This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Impact Immigrants Have On The Economy

1760 words - 7 pages

The world is becoming an increasingly interconnected place and this trend is continuing. As a result, countries are facing new problems that are requiring policy changes in many highly contentious fields. Of major concern are the immigration and citizenship policies of many western nations that are receiving a majority of the immigrants. This is a highly salient issue because people are concerned about the effect immigrant populations will have on voting trends and the jobs that they could take from citizens. Rarely discussed, though of vital importance, is the immense impact that immigrants have on the economy, as they take low paying jobs that the average citizen would scoff at. If these immigrants are willing to take such low paying positions and be disadvantaged in some of the world’s largest economies, it calls to question what the grounds for excluding them from the political process are. I will argue that the elitist theories of Schumpeter and the early writings of Dahl have contributed to the marginalization of these groups and are not democratic at all. Only Dahl’s later work, Democracy and Its Critics, presents a state that can be viewed as truly democratic and applicable in a real political system.
Dahl’s work is a synthesis of his learnings, an understand that his original ideas about democracy and the ideals of others left out some key democratic ideals that leave the consumer looking for more, certainly wondering what is democratic about the system proposed. This becomes very apparent in Schumpeter’s work Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy as he suggests that as long as there is competition in a system it may consider democratic. “And we define: the democratic method is that institutional arrangement for arriving at political decisions in which individuals acquire the power to decide by means of a competitive struggle for the people’s vote”(Schumpeter, Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy, page 260). This implies that the only requirement of a democracy is competition, and that if there is sufficient competition the result is one that the people should accept.
The issue with this concept is that it allows for a small minority, which is unlikely to be representative of the general population, to create policies that may affect huge populations. It gives the control of the government to the most powerful man in the competition but this competition may be rigged. In a nation of millions, ten men could be the entirety of the competition (potential leaders and electors), which makes it outside the accepted view of democracy. The system is not required to have proportional representation and will not if it does not stand to benefit the elites who have created the institutions of government to work in their favor. This does not create equality among the people and does not provide equal opportunity to the general population.
This kind of theory cannot be applied to the current immigration issues that we are plagued with because it is...

Find Another Essay On The Impact Immigrants have on the Economy

The Impact of Minorities on the United States Economy

1865 words - 7 pages shouldn't they receive the same benefits?The purpose of this report is to illustrate many issues dealing with the impact minorities have on the United States economy and decide the positive and negative aspects.Minority BusinessesThere are many misperceptions indicating that minorities have a negative affect on the United States economy. One misperception is that minorities are only viewed as consumers rather than both consumers and entrepreneurs

The Euro And Its Impact On The U.S. Economy

1293 words - 5 pages euro in the long-term impact the growth of our economy.Generally there have been a few schools of thought on how the American economy will be impacted by the euro. The first one supports that the United States can only benefit as the euro is established as an international currency. U.S. administrations have long been supporters of global cooperation, believing that whatever is good for Europe is good for the U.S. Bill Clinton even stated, "A

The impact of the global financial crisis on Chinese economy

3304 words - 14 pages The impact of the global financial crisis on Chinese economy In the past two decades, China has enjoyed the one of the world’s fastest growing speeds. And for right now, China has been the most major contributor to the world economic growth. But in the recent years, the global financial crisis already did a huge damage to the Chinese growing economy. Especially in the aspect of exporting sector, China has been hit hardly by this crisis. The

The Impact of Dual Income Families on the Economy

2049 words - 8 pages The Impact of Dual Income Families on the Economy An important impact of the current economic conditions upon today's American family is that of the dual-income family. Currently many families, my own included, need both partners to provide economic support in order secure quality housing, childcare and living conditions. I intend to examine the conditions that create the need for two income families, the effects, good and bad upon the

The Impact on America of Turkish, Greek and Italian Immigrants and Their Respective Cultures

1591 words - 6 pages The Impact on America of Turkish, Greek and Italian Immigrants and Their Respective Cultures My Big Fat Greek Wedding, The Godfather, The Italian Job, Roberto Benigni, Mario Andretti, Frank Capra, spaghetti, gelato, Turkish baths.? What do all of these have in common?? All of them are well known parts of American culture, yet they have all been influenced and inspired by Italian, Greek, and Turkish immigrants and their respective

Immigrants Flock to the Netherlands Due to Booming Economy

756 words - 4 pages booming economy at that time, many people came to work in the Netherlands and many also stayed. Nowadays, there are a lot of discussions going on about this large number of immigrants in our country. The PVV (Partij Voor de Vrijheid) is an extreme right winged conservative political party established by Geert Wilders in 2006. This party wants to limit the immigration to the Netherlands. It’s populist and negative remarks mainly concern Moroccan

The Impact Divorce May Have on an Individual

604 words - 3 pages With reference to literature, critically discuss the impact that a particular life stage transition may have on an individual. INTRODUCTION The essay will aim to critically discuss the impact of divorce may have on an individual focusing on prior, present and post-divorce and how the impact can differ between them. It is of importance to note the difference between change and transitions. It is suggested that change is a situational process

What Impact does Jasper Jones have on the Reader?

1954 words - 8 pages people that are closest to him. The most important ideas and issues that Craig Silvey portrays in Jasper Jones are: coming of age and identity, injustice and racism. These themes have a great impact on the reader. While discovering and facing these new issues, Charlie and his best friend Jeffrey Lu gain a greater awareness of human nature and how to deal with the challenges that life can throw at you. One of Silvey’s major ideas in Jasper Jones is

The impact video games have on children and teens

884 words - 4 pages Did you know playing video games helps children with their education? A good video game will teach problem solving, math, history, or anything else a parent wants their children to learn. Children that play video games are more educational than those that do not play video games. In this paper you will experience the positive and negative impact video games have on children and teens. Even though playing video games can sometimes be educational

What Impact did the Seed Plow have on Mesopotamia?

708 words - 3 pages were right above the slaves, but yet their civilization depended on them. They would not have a civilization today without farmers. (“Mesopotamia: Science & Inventions.". 07 Nov. 2013.) To work the seed plow was not that difficult at all. Almost anyone could work the plow. The farmers were more advanced in using the plow than the Pharaoh would be. To work the plow you have a animal, usually a horse, Ox, or Bull in front of the plow pulling and

The Impact of the Central Bank and Long run Economic Growth on the Economy

2173 words - 9 pages for a government to recognise that changes in revenue and expenditure can have an alternative impact on the government revenue & budget, however it may have different effects on economic growth in the long run. This shows true in the example of japan, whilst the £3.4bn stimulus package cost the government greatly it helped to boost japan out of a recession. By doing this, the Japanese government were ignoring the short-term growth of the economy

Similar Essays

Impact Of Foreclosure Crisis On The Economy

1412 words - 6 pages dream to own their own homes. I have heard people on TV and on the national stage debate the reasons and the impact of the foreclosure crisis on the economy. This debate has been frustrating because people focus too much on arguing who is right or who was wrong; some people claim the foreclosure crisis is from a lack of oversight over mortgage companies that should have been regulated more by the government in how they make their loans. Other

Illegal Immigrants Threaten The American Economy

2133 words - 9 pages , to these illegals, the benefits of successfully migrating outweigh the costs. (www.fairus.org/site/news2) An interesting law has passed merely a few weeks ago within the state of Arizona. With our government cracking down on the illegal flow by increasing more stadium lights, fences, and man power throughout Southern California, and Texas, it has “forced a shift in the flow of illegal immigrants that have now turned Arizona into the single

The Impact Families Have On Individual Lifestyles

1397 words - 6 pages is really what you make of it. A family can affect someone either positively or negatively. How a person decides to live their life depends on individual goals and perspectives on life. Just because you are born into a family that is rich or poor, nice or mean, etc., does not mean you have to be the same way. Perry, Dick, and Nancy all had different family experience and based off of those experiences they created a life style in which they wanted to live. Just because they shared the same blood as their families, they were able to decide to stick with family or create their own path.

The Impact Of The Oil Crisis On The American Economy

5691 words - 23 pages The Impact of the Oil Crisis on the American Economy With the current spike in oil prices, many American consumers have asked, 'what is going on?' In order to fully understand the current situation and how it is affecting the economy one must look at a variety of factors including: the history of oil crisis in the United States, causes of the current situation, and possible outcomes for the future. It is only after meticulous research in