The Implications Of Quasi Democracy In China

933 words - 4 pages

Muhlberger notes that the definition of democracy has historically been restricted to nations that are adhere to the Western conception of democracy (25). Yet, Muhlberger claims that even within authoritarian regimes, there are components of democracy at the grassroots level. He defines “quasi-democratic” as “any group willing to submit to decisions arrived at by discussion and voting (formal or informal) or abides judgment of elected representatives” (Muhlberger 27). In this essay, I argue that there have been quasi-democratic elements even within the Chinese Communist tradition. These elements at the local level signal the potential for China to fully transition into a democracy in the future.
Muhlberger notes the historical tradition of quasi-democracy within Chinese political development. Under most emperors, village administration was the responsibility of the villagers themselves (Muhlberger 30). Village temples typically provided services on behalf of community. In areas of weaker clan and temple organization, cooperative organizations fulfilled role of providing services (Muhlberger 31). Thus, the Chinese villages enjoyed a certain level of autonomy. Furthermore, this local organization to provide needed goods and services is characteristic of self-governance. Although encapsulated within an authoritarian regime, these beginnings of village self-government revealed quasi-democracy.
This autonomy has considerably increased with the introduction of competitive village elections through the 1982 China constitution (Horsley 44). Village committee elections give hope to the possibility of liberal democratization of the rest of China. Horsley claims that the introduction of competitive elections has opened the path to the rule of law and the spread of democracy in China even through Communism (40). The elections are a result of the destruction by the decade long Cultural Revolution (Horsley 40). Party leaders hoped to re-establish political and economic stability by allowing villagers to choose leaders and making leaders accountable to their constituents (Horsley 40). This also served as a political maneuver of the Party; by improving the relationship between the villagers and state, the government could pass unpopular but necessary central policies (Horsley 40). Thus, the Chinese government is beginning to embrace the liberal notion that effective governance can be made to work if based on consent of the governed. In this way, the Chinese government accepts, to a degree, the necessity of official accountability and democratic appeal.
The village communities are organized as a dual power structure: (1) the village committee works as a democratic executive apparatus to manage day-to-day politics; (2) the Party branch is responsible for general policy and intervenes “if necessary” by using ties to township or county governments (Horsley). This organization is strikingly similar to federalism, regarding the division of power. Similarly,...

Find Another Essay On The Implications of Quasi-Democracy in China

Democracy in Russia and China Essay

1404 words - 6 pages and has been one of the major obstacles of democratization for Russia. However in China, only economic reform took place under a total political dictatorship. Without political reform, there would be no democracy, even if economic modernization booms rapidly. Both nations ceased to let go of the communist bureaucratic regime, instead they incorporated market economy with heavy bureaucratic control. This persistence of bureaucratic control over the

The Implications of Expressed Emotion in Schizophrenia

1936 words - 8 pages illness of the dependent (Whittick, 1993). When a Schizophrenic patient goes into convalescence, they are required to be in a stable environment which is low in expressed emotion, otherwise implications, including relapse, are more likely to occur (Vaughn and Leff, 1976). Schizophrenia is a complex psychological disorder in which the sufferer experiences severe disturbances is cognitive ability, speech, perception, emotion and behaviour (Herz and

Implications of Catcher in the Rye

695 words - 3 pages The Catcher in the Rye has been prevalent in some of the most traumatic and earth-shattering moments in contemporary history, and may have even contributed to them. Before the police arrived and after the gun was fired, Mark David Chapman (John Lennon’s assassin) started reading lines from Salinger’s work. He recited the passage: “ I keep picturing all these little kids...I’d just be the catcher in the rye and all” (Salinger 224-25). Author

Social Protests in China and Its Implications on The Autocratic Chinese Communist Party

2931 words - 12 pages Topic: How do social protests emerge in China and what are their implications on the autocratic rule of the Chinese Communist Party? 1. Introduction Social protest has been increasingly prevalent in China since the early 1980s despite the restrictions on the freedom of speech and association. Groups of Chinese citizens, from unsophisticated villagers to state-owned enterprise workers and students, have been staging protests across the

China and the Invasion, Implications and Intervention of the Korean War

2844 words - 11 pages Max Hastings, an author of several novels dealing with numerous war events including The Korean War stated that, "[t]here is no evidence that China played a significant role in the North Korean decision to go to war. ". This paper will clash with Max Hastings' scholarly statement because the Chinese must have been intimately involved in the process of creating the Korean War in order to be able to defeat American, South Korean, and United

From Communism to Democracy: This essay is about the advancment from Communism to Democracy in China and Russia

898 words - 4 pages From Communism to DemocracyGradualism is naturally the most feasible approach to any situation. Since the fall of the iron curtain, these two Communist power houses have chose to move towards democracy. China has chosen to take the natural, more gradual approach to democracy where as Russia has chosen the fast-paced, more dangerous approach. These twonations have chosen to change their economies from a collectivized command one to a market

What are the Implications of China as an Emerging Nuclear Power

4736 words - 19 pages powerful nuclear power on its own. Much strength, determination and intense efforts were devoted to successfully conduct their first nuclear test on the 16th of October 1964 on the test grounds at Lop Nor in Sinkiang province. The Chinese had finally implemented the first step toward changing the status of the international system, triggering widespread international concerns over the implications of China as a nuclear power.China's Nuclear

The Rise of Democracy in Chile

938 words - 4 pages The Rise of Democracy in Chile General Augusto Pinochet gained power during a blood-filled coup during 1973 when his militaristic, authoritarian rule began. He continued to rule in a brutal regime of repression and human rights abuse until 1989 when his regime was lifted in favor of a more democratic system. Since 1990, Chile seems to be on the right track to re-establishing a once strong democracy that will continue to strengthen in the

The Rise of Democracy in Britain

1711 words - 7 pages The Rise of Democracy in Britain The dynamic course of the nineteenth century set off a revolution within the realm of British politics. Foreign influence and domestic transformation created a situation where individual interests were forced into the public sphere for political reconciliation. The shift towards democratic government was largely unscripted because Britain had no written constitution to guide its path

The Rise of Democracy in Great Britain

1183 words - 5 pages Greece was once at the pinnacle of the world. Its philosophy, sculptures, paintings, theater, and architectures have been some of the great gifts it has left for us, but the most important one is democracy. It is believed that democracy was created in a city of ancient Greece; this city is known as Athens. The success Athens had as a city is credited to the way they ran their government. In this city everyone had an equal say on what they wanted

The Evolution of Democracy in Georgia

4979 words - 20 pages The Georgian people made its choice on 26 May 1918, when it voted for democracy and pluralism in the conditions of a free Georgia. 26 May was destroyed by Bolshevik bayonets, but the idea of freedom and democracy remain undefeated in the Georgian - Statement of the National Democratic Party, 1988.1 In the late 1980s and early 1990s, the Caucasian country of Georgia (map below) was among the vanguard of forces seeking the dissolution of the

Similar Essays

Implications Of China Essay

1539 words - 7 pages China currently lacks a highly survivable strategic nuclear force. The US has anticipated for years that China would modernize its nuclear force with the goal of making it larger and more survivable, thereby providing a robust assured destruction capability. China has now begun such a program -- building mobile ICMBS and ballistic missile submarines -- that will take many years to complete. According to the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists in

The Struggle For Democracy In China

1891 words - 8 pages against Confucian beliefs, "which stresses harmony and obedience. But neither is democracy a concept that has just recently taken hold in the minds of Chinese youth who have seen the wonders of democracy in Western-style discos and fast food" (Barme par. 2). The youths' concluded that these luxuries were achieved through democracy and if China converted, then they too will get the amenities that western countries have. But more importantly, they

The Environmental Implications Of Political And Economic Reform In Communist China

2477 words - 10 pages a role model for cleaner energy production. After awakening to the massive environmental degradation it had undertaken at the hands of a poorly focused regime, China must realize that it still has a long way to go in terms of environmental restoration. Also, China has started to realize that with their enormous population comes the reassurance that environmental crisis's affect not only them, but have implications for the rest of the world as

The Quasi Legislative Effect Of The Supreme Court Of Canada

2636 words - 11 pages the political sphere. Though Parliament remains supreme, the Charter of Rights and Freedoms has empowered the judiciary with the ability to interpret it broadly and settle major questions of public policy, something the Bill of Rights, 1960 could never really achieve. The charter has in effect, given the judiciary a quasi-legislative authority. The Quasi-Legislator This paper will argue that the Supreme Court of Canada has adopted a quasi