This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Significance For Economic Anthropology Of The Work Of Marx And Durkheim

1669 words - 7 pages

What is the significance for economic anthropology of the work of Marx and Durkheim?
Introduction
The works of Karl Marx and Emile Durkheim have proved that they were indeed the finding fathers of modern social theory during the late 19th to the early 20th century. Along with others (i.e. Weber, Simmel, Veblen etc.) they had laid down the foundations of our understanding of the relationships that are held between culture and society on one hand, and economic activity on the other hand. Marx saw economics in terms of conflicts between different interest groups, which he referred to as ‘classes’, over rights to various facets of the processes of production, and the effect that those conflicts had on determining other areas of culture. Durkheim for his part, was more interested in the division of labour, classifications organised around social distinctions and how economic activity might be understood in terms of various forms of social solidarity.
Karl Marx’s significance
Karl Marx lived from 1818 – 1883, during which he wrote on history, philosophy, politics and economics. His work is usually recognised through his several publications, including The Communist Manifesto (1848) and Das Kapital (Capital) (1867-1894). Marx’s work in economics laid the foundation for the recent understanding of labour and its relations to capitalist system, and previous economists and academics (Schumpeter, 1952; Hicks, 1974) believe that his work has influenced much of the consequent economic thought, as well as more recent academics (Unger, 2007). Marx’s theories about society, politics as well as economics encourage the notion that human societies progress through a conflict between an ownership of class that controls production and a dispossessed labouring class that provides the labour for production, often termed as the class struggle. The amalgamation of society, politics and economics is better known as Marxism, as he was of the first to appropriate such arenas into one Marx did not see these as progressive steps that each and every culture must progress through, but as being the advancement of historically dependent communities and their modes of production.
The modes of production mould the foundation or structure of a society. This foundation governs the superstructure (governments, laws and other political and legal apparatus), from which both determine the ideology (including religions, philosophies, and the ideals which conquer in a society at any given time). Class struggle is the crucial mover for such a scheme to progress in stages. Change is inevitable, which means that changes would occur and that the classes will be realigned. Although, the ruling classes have an assigned interest in continuing their power and will look to repel such change, though in the long run, by any means necessary. A key tool of the upper classes is to amplify mystification in ideology, which consequences in the false consciousness of the working class. Consequently,...

Find Another Essay On The Significance for Economic Anthropology of the Work of Marx and Durkheim

The Contributions of Emile Durkheim Essay

2386 words - 10 pages results and individual motivations. Durkheim separated functional analysis from two other analytical methods, the search for historical origins and sources and the examination of individual purposes and motives. The second appeared to be of only minor significance to him, because men often participate in deeds when their unable to foresee the consequences of sociological investigation. The search for sources and historical origins, nevertheless, was to

The Life of Emile Durkheim Essay

1521 words - 6 pages transferred to one of the greatest French high schools in Paris, Lycee Louis-le-Grand. While in Paris he began to prepare for the grueling acceptance exam for the prestigious school, Ecole Normale Superieur. During his time in Paris his father had became very ill and Durkheim became utterly miserable. The sickness was a great distraction to his studies and he was not able to pass the exam his first two attempts. Finally in 1879, after his third

A Comparison of the Economic Philosophies of Adam Smith, John Stuart Mill, and Karl Marx

1811 words - 7 pages land, an equal obligation of all to work and free education for all the children. Among other ideas, Marx Communist government is one of total control, but preaches equality that transcends through the current classes that have developed through capitalism. Most items would be state owned, including land, factories, schools and a heavy progressive income tax would be established. The true meaning of this is to diminish political character

A Comparison of the Economic Theories of Adam Smith and Karl Marx

2467 words - 10 pages There is perhaps not a more famous ongoing dialectic argument in the field of political economy than the one between Adam Smith and Karl Marx in regards to capitalism. The two thinkers, although coming to radically different conclusions about the outcomes of the capitalist system for all parties involved, agree on a surprising number of ideas such as labor being the source of commodities’ value, as well as the fact that the division of labor

The Study of Anthropology and the Humanities

1375 words - 6 pages culture that is used to describe what humans do. Anthropology explores what culture is, how it influences society, and why the idea of culture is important. Studying anthropology also looks into the various cultures around the world and the diversity that makes the human race. A basic concern for anthropologists is what defines human life and its origins. How has the evolutionary past of humans influenced the contemporary culture? Reading R

The significance of the 'Cogito' for Cartesian and modern philosophy

2186 words - 9 pages phenomenon in terms of a nature like a mechanical machine. Descartes interest in the project of establishing a method for this new advancing science is one of the core motivations towards his work in epistemology and why he was orientated towards the rationalistic view that knowledge should have mathematical certainty.In the scholastic tradition Descartes reacted against it is assumed that the world is as we perceive it. Aristotelian-scholasticism

David Emil Durkheim and the Social Causes of Suicide

1945 words - 8 pages David Emil Durkheim is a renowned sociologist and also France’s first professor of sociology. Born on 15th, April in France, he successfully advocated for sociology to be recognized as an academic discipline. He did his first recognizable work titled ‘The division of labor in society’ in 1893 and then started the first European department sociology in a university in his homeland of France. David Durkheim's main concern was to try and

The Moral and Ethical Dilemmas of Anthropology

1146 words - 5 pages Anthropological researchers have considerable moral and ethical standards by which their work must be conducted in order to preserve the accuracy and the posterity of the information gathered during the study and also to the persons or cultures of which they study. These two important parts of anthropology – the research and those being researched – can be conflicting. The Code of Ethics of the American Anthropological Association presents

The Meaning and Significance of Hajj for a Muslim

1732 words - 7 pages The Meaning and Significance of Hajj for a Muslim When Muslims do Hajj they are following the example of the Prophet Muhammad and the peoples of his time. People have always done Hajj in Makkah but Muhammad brought Islam back to it and made Hajj how god intended it (like it was in the times of Ibrahim, Adam and Eve). Muhammad had set a perfect example for all Muslims and today they will do the same as Muhammad did

Significance of memory for Paulina in Death and the Maiden

1045 words - 5 pages Maiden’ by the renewed Austrian composer Franz Peter Schubert whenever he would force himself on her. The memory of being sexually exploited is something which has been permanently engrained in the mind of Paulina Escobar. And this memory serves as the foundation for the entire play, as the rest of the play is focusing on the effect of this memory on Paulina. Paulina seems to be suffering from long-term mental damages which have completely ruined

Marx And The Historic Evolution Of Communism

1016 words - 5 pages organized framework and plan of action to propel it. Nearer the end of his life Marx even spent ten years writing the three volume thick economic plan for his state. One which Marx didn't finish before his death and was taken over and finished by his partner Engels. But very few of his ideas were original, whether taken from classical literature or socialist thinkers of the past.

Similar Essays

This Essay Will Aim To Discuss Durkheim And Marx In The Context Of Sociology Of Religion

1967 words - 8 pages and unknowable being called a god. Religion is meant to create illusory fantasies for the poor.Durkheim challenged this view as he believed that would help people to cooperate better and be more willing to work with each other in a harmonious manner. This would give them a sense of solidarity, as they all have a common interest. Durkheim believes that religion is seen as binding and holding people together. He also suggested that many organs of

Mexican Society In The Eyes Of Karl Marx And Emile Durkheim

1259 words - 5 pages In the article titled “Mexican official's daughter gets restaurant closed after she didn't get table she wanted” gives us the opportunity to explore a current event in Mexican society and the influence of social media which we attempt to view through the eyes of both Karl Marx and Emile Durkheim. We will focus on Karl Marx’s conflict theory of capitalism and Emile Durkheim’s structural functionalism theory of dynamic density. Both theories

Durkheim, Weber And Marx Essay

1228 words - 5 pages structural-functionalist, Durkheim believed that harmony, rather than conflict, defined society, and studied the division of labor, religion and suicide from this perspective. Karl Marx, on the other hand focuses his theories on the relationship between human lives and a capitalist economy. The theory of historical materialism provides a framework for analyzing human society and the laws of its development. Marx identifies a capitalist society by

Comte Durkheim And Marx Essay

1509 words - 6 pages Kapital was published in his lifetime. Marx died in Britain in 1883.As can be seen the development of social thought occurred gradually over time and although August Comte was clearly important in its history many of the modern sociologists today disregard his work. Emile Durkheim built on the work of Comte taking it further with his rules of methodology. However both made early pioneering statements of a sociological nature and Karl Marx gave an