The Impossibility Of Female Desire In Pygmalion And The Awakening

2062 words - 8 pages

In “The Power of Discourse and the Subordination of the Feminine,” Luce Irigaray argues that, because society uses a patriarchal language that privileges male-gendered logic over female-gender emotion, there is no adequate language to represent female desire. She writes that “feminine pleasure has to remain inarticulate in language, in its own language, if it is not to threaten the underpinnings of logical operations” and, because of this, “what is most strictly forbidden to women today is that they should attempt to express their own pleasure” (796). This inability to articulate female desire means that female desire becomes unutterable, something that cannot be expressed. According to Irigaray, this unutterable-ness of female desire in patriarchal language leaves only one option for women to attempt to express their desire and that is the act of mimicry or mimesis. Mimesis is not an attempt to represent female desire in patriarchal language; instead, mimesis is in attempt through the use of patriarchal language to reveal that female desire cannot be presented, a way to “make ‘visible,’ by an effect of playful repetition, what was supposed to remain invisible – the cover-up of a possible operation of the feminine in language” (795). Mimesis exposes how patriarchal language disallows or denies female desire by circling around the absence of that female desire, by making its absence perfectly clear in a patriarchal discourse.
The concept of a patriarchal discourse, necessary to Irigaray’s argument, is an example of a shared interpretive community, a term coined by Stanley Fish that refers to a discursively-created set of ideas, beliefs, and interpretations that belong to a community or multiple communities. The most important aspect of a shared interpretive community is that it names and interprets the objects and events in a person’s life. Fish argues that no object has an innate meaning because human interaction with any object necessitates language and interpretation and so every object is culturally-constructed through the language and interpretations of the person who encounters it. In the same way, humans are also culturally-constructed. Fish writes:
“No one of us wakes up in the morning and (in French fashion) reinvents poetry or thinks up a new educational system or decides to reject seriality in favor of some other, wholly original, form of organization. We do not do these things because we could not do them, because the mental operations we can perform are limited by the institutions in which we are already embedded. These institutions precede us, and it is only by inhabiting them, or being inhabited by them, that we have access to the public and conventional senses they make. Thus while it is true to say that we create poetry (and assignments and lists), we create it through interpretive strategies that are finally not our own but have their source in a publicly available system of intelligibility. Insofar as the system (in this case...

Find Another Essay On The Impossibility of Female Desire in Pygmalion and The Awakening

Essay on Female Companions in The Awakening and A Doll's House

653 words - 3 pages Importance of Female Companions in The Awakening and A Doll's House       Female companions are very important to the development of the main characters in Kate Chopin's The Awakening and in Henrik Ibsen's A Doll House. Mademoiselle Reisz and Madame Ratignolle, in The Awakening, and Kristine Linde, in A Doll House, help Edna Pontellier and Nora Helmer discover their inner selves.   Mademoiselle Reisz, Madame Ratignolle, and

The Character of Henry Higgins in Pygmalion

1575 words - 6 pages Shaw has often been criticized for his inability to create well- developed round characters. His characters are usually seen as mere puppets propelled by the crisis of the plot or as mouthpieces for his socialist viewpoint. However in Pygmalion,, Shaw vindicates himself of these charges by the creation of rounded and life-like characters such as Higgins and Eliza. Clearly they are not authorial stooges. They have a peculiar quality that leaves

The Working Poor's Impossibility of Survival

1186 words - 5 pages they will most likely encounter. Rather, as millions of Americans work in full-time minimum wage jobs, several of them discover that their wages are insufficient to survive in today's society. In the book Nickel and Dimed, the author Barbara Ehrenreich, a journalist with a PH.D, does undercover reporting about low wage workers by obtaining minimum wage jobs in three areas of the United States--Florida, Maine, and Minnesota. As she journeys

Representations of Female Sexual Desire and Faithfulness

990 words - 4 pages controlling women's behaviour. Further, it introduces the concept of female sexual desire, in suggesting that women ultimately avoid affairs due to the societal repercussions. Montagu's “Epistle” also discusses female sexual desire, claiming that “Nature with equal fire our souls endued” (Montagu ll. 26). Female desire is constructed as natural and equivalent to male desire. This emphasizes the speaker's view of women as equals to men, with the same

Evaluation of the text- "Pygmalion"

695 words - 3 pages . As a part of the middle class you are always asked for money and certain behavior is expected of you.What I liked as well is the difference between the play and the Greek myth on which the story is based. In this myth, as already described, the creator and his creation fall in love and he marries her, but in Pygmalion by Bernard Shaw, the end is left open so that I had to think about the question whether the creator loves his creation or merely

symbolaw Use of Symbols and Symbolism in The Awakening

1293 words - 5 pages entrapment of women (the two birds in cages; the desire for flight; the pigeon house). Flight is another symbol associated with birds, and acts as a stand in for awakening. The ability to spread your wings and fly is a symbolic theme that occurs often in the novel. Edna escapes her home, her husband, her life, by leaving for the pigeon house. Mlle. Reisz lectures Edna on the need for strong wings in artistic endeavors. Clothing is also

Characterization of Women as Empowering Figures in The Country Wife and Pygmalion

2125 words - 9 pages man’s side. In Sir Jasper’s description of women, there is no mutual love between a husband and wife, but rather there is one-sided compliance where the wife must please her husband as he wishes. Like the men of The Country Wife, Mr. Higgins from Pygmalion treats women as if they are not people. Higgins bullies Eliza and treats her without respect because he only views her as an experiment. In the scene where Eliza arrives to Higgins’ house to

The Importance of Setting in The Awakening

2249 words - 9 pages home in New Orleans, and in just about every other environment that she inhabits. In fact, Edna seems to drift from setting to setting in the novel, never really finding her true self - until the end of the novel.        Chopin seems highly concerned with this question throughout her narrative. On a larger scale, the author seems to be probing even more deeply into the essence of the female experience: Do women in general have a place in

Edna and Conformity in Chopin’s The Awakening

615 words - 2 pages Edna and Conformity in Chopin’s The Awakening The passage of The Awakening which truly marks Edna Pontellier’s new manner of thought regarding her life revolves around her remembrance of a day of her childhood in Kentucky. She describes the scene to Madame Ratigonelle as the two women sit on the beach one summer day. The passage opens with a description of the sea and the sky on that particular day. This day and its components are expressed

Themes and Images in The Awakening

1599 words - 6 pages swoops through the air for a while, but she flies too high, into turbulent currents, breaking her bones and her spirit. Details from this novel by Kate Chopin demonstrate how this quote aptly captures the theme and spirit of The Awakening, as well as the situation of women in the nineteenth century and even today. First, one most look to the "white beach," Edna has trod on her entire life. This beach is the safe and sturdy ground that Adele

Use of Symbolism in Chopin’s The Awakening

744 words - 3 pages Use of Symbolism in Chopin’s The Awakening --Passage from Chapter X, pgs. 49-50 “But that night she was like the little tottering, stumbling, clutching child, who all of a sudden realizes its powers, and walks for the first time alone, boldly and with over-confidence. She could have shouted for joy. She did shout for joy, as with a sweeping stroke or two she lifted her body to the surface of the water. A feeling of exultation overtook her

Similar Essays

Utopia The Impossibility Of Perfection

1669 words - 7 pages Utopia - The Impossibility of Perfection "The latter end of [this] commonwealth forgets the beginning." ?William Shakespeare, The Tempest From Plato's The Republic to Karl Marx's Communist Manifesto, the search for a perfect social state has never stopped; its ultimate goal of achieving a human society that exists in absolute harmony with all due social justice, however, has proved to be woefully elusive. The pure concept of a utopia

The Impossibility Of The Angel And The Monster

2076 words - 8 pages standards set for women in a patriarchal society by their male precursors. The book examines the notion that female writers are confined in the literature they write by the male literary precursors of their patriarchal cultures to create their female characters in such a way that they are perceived as either angelic or monstrous. The Countess possesses both angelic and monstrous traits and her vampiric nature influences her to feed on the

The Impossibility Of Reducing Global Warming And Environmental Hypocrisy

1280 words - 5 pages have crossed the threshold, and going back is an impossibility. The Impossibility It is difficult to imagine that the snowcaps of Mt. Everest and the Himalayas are gradually disappearing. From 1921 to the present, 40% of the snow that covered these majestic mountains has melted. (Smith). At this rate, it would seem that in 100 years, 80% of the snow will be gone. Many, experts or not, are quick to tell society what to do to stop global warming

Cultural Diversity And The Impossibility Of A True Melting Pot

2536 words - 10 pages Cultural Diversity and the Impossibility of a True Melting Pot The core standards of America are founded, in principle, on the basis of its diversity and equality among citizens. Begin- ning with its Declaration of Independence, the United States distinguished itself from other modern nation-states by establishing a country of men who were different but equal. Yet, despite the unifying images America projects within and beyond its borders