This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Innocence Of The Paxton Boys

916 words - 4 pages

The Innocence of the Paxton Boys

I am here today to prove to you that Lazarus Stewart and Matthew Smith are not guilty of the murder of Conestoga Indians. While both men agree that they did kill the Conestogas, what they did is justified by the aggressive behavior shown by the Indians.
I will now present evidence to prove this conclusion.
My first piece of evidence is from a speech made by Little Abraham, a Mohawk sachem, to colonial Pennsylvania officials and Indian Leaders:
"You [...] made Plantations there and spoiled their hunting grounds, they [French-allied Delawares] then complained to us [...] and [we] found their complaints to be true. [...] [...] Our advice to you is, that you send for the Senecas [and Delawares], treat them kindly."(Mombert 172-174)
From this quote, one can clearly see the fellowship amongst the Indian Tribes. Not only does Little Abraham advise the Colonials to cease settling, but also he has checked up on our doings. As I go over the next few pieces of evidence, I want you to keep in mind this fellowship.
From the "Narrative of Matthew Smith":
'[...] I cautiously crawled where I could get a view; I saw Indians armed; they were strangers; they outnumbered us by the dozens. [...] The moment we were perceived, an Indian fired at us and rushed forward [...]. [...] For no murder of our defenseless [sic] inhabitants has since happened" (Mombert 187-188)
This is eyewitness testimony stating that Captain Smith seen armed and foreign Indians in a substantial number. Now, why would there be armed Indians in a peaceful Indian village? Obviously, the Indians are not peaceful. This answer is also backed up by what happened right before the village was razed; as soon as the Indians seen a white man perceiving the activity in the Village, the Indians attacked, unprovoked. As for the final sentence in the quote, we can see that with no safe house with which to operate out of, the Indian attacks ceased.
From Lt. Governor Robert Morris's Proclamation of War:
"[...] I do hereby declare the said Delaware Indians and all others who, in conjunction with them, have committed hostilities against his Majesty's subjects within this Province, to be enemies, rebels and traitors [...]; and I do hereby require all his Majesty's subjects of this Province [...] to embrace all opportunities of pursuing, taking, killing and destroying the said Delaware Indians and all others confederated with them [...]." (Mombert 166-168)
I call this piece of evidence to show direct orders for His Majesty's subjects to kill, maim, or otherwise destroy Delaware Indians and those who help them. If these orders were followed during the first attack on the Conestoga's village, there would have never been a second attack. However, the Captains were not sure...

Find Another Essay On The Innocence of the Paxton Boys

The Innocence of Eve Essay

758 words - 4 pages Imagine how life in the Garden of Eden is beautiful. Adam and Eve have the perfect life, of living luxuriously and eating all the fruit without the efforts of hard labor. However; the serpent had to come around and persuade Eve and manipulate her into eating a fruit from the tree of knowledge and good and evil. Yet, Eve may have taken the first bite, which no argument can be disagreed upon, but Adam, who was so in love with her and would forget

The Lost Boys of Sudan Essay

866 words - 4 pages The Lost Boys of Sudan The lost boys of Sudan did not only show courage but also perseverance when they were forced to flee their home, leaving everything behind to find safety, after their village and all their loved ones were destroyed by the war. In 1983 the Second Sudanese Civil War took place; Arabic Muslims from the North of Sudan attacked southern villages killing more than one million civilians and leaving more than twenty thousand of

The Concept of Childhood Innocence

2210 words - 9 pages construction of childhood innocence. In the UK case of the killing of two-year-old James Bulger, the two ten-year-old boys who admitted to his killing were tried in an adult court, even though they were classified as children by UNCRC (1989). They were seen by the British court as fully aware and knowing of their actions and the consequences. They were proven guilty and sent to jail, without any of the privileges children get. They were not given any

The Innocence of a Lamb

946 words - 4 pages Songs of Innocence by William Blake collocates the naïve lives of children and loss of innocence of adults, with moral Christian values and how religion has the capacity to promote cruelty and prejudice. Blake was born in 1757, up to and after the French Revolution he wrote many works criticizing enlightened rationalism and instead focused on intellectual ideas that avoided institutionalization and propelled ethical and moral order. Blake’s

The Innocence of a child

866 words - 4 pages There comes a time when everyone must grow up and lose their innocence. Unfortunately for some, that time comes sooner than others due to the obstacles and difficult situations that life brings our way. Maji is the perfect example of a child who is stuck in a feud and is robbed of a normal childhood. Most children grow up being able to go out and play whenever they can. They don’t ever worry about any sort of revolution. In her narrative

The Case of Gertrude’s Innocence

871 words - 4 pages In William Shakespeare’s tragedy Hamlet, we see the conflicts between the titled Danish prince and his uncle Cornelius; who killed the previous king (his brother) and married Hamlet’s mother in order to take control of Denmark’s throne. Upon finding out his Uncle’s crimes, the rest of the play centers on Hamlet’s plot for revenge against Cornelius. During all of this, the loyalty Gertrude (the mother of hamlet and the Queen) is placed into

The Innocence Of Arthur Dimmesdale

572 words - 2 pages Reverend Arthur Dimmesdale, whose name and status repels any trace of ignominy, shares the sin of adultery with Hester Prynne. Even though he did commit this sin, he constantly repented and punished himself. He was tortured continually by his physician and supposed friend so that he suffered more. When there was the hope of freedom from his sin ahead of him, he decided instead, to share the news of what he had done with the people of Boston

At the end of the novel, 'The Lord of the Flies', Ralph weeps not just for the death of Piggy, but for the loss of innocence in the boys. Discuss

805 words - 3 pages In William Golding's 'Lord of the Flies', Ralph weeps not just for the death of Piggy, but for the loss of innocence of the boys as well. The lack of adult influence on the island leaves the boys' superegos venerable and the incantation of fear that manifests itself in the minds of the boys destroys them. The truth about human nature is revealed, as the boys separate from Ralph and the moral of civilization, and migrate to a world of killing

The Tragedy of the Scottsboro Boys

2390 words - 10 pages During the Great Depression jobs were hard to come by for whites but for blacks it was practically impossible. Several individuals jumped trains to get from city to city in search for work. On March 25, 1931, numerous people were hoboing on a freight train traveling from Chattanooga to Memphis, Tennessee. A number of white and black teenagers on the train got in a fight which resulted in the white boys getting thrown off the train. They told a

Oedipus the King: The Innocence of Oedipus

1457 words - 6 pages idea behind Oedipus' innocence is this "royalty." Regardless of either of their class standings a fight occurred and the one to start had been King Laius? men, or group, the fact that they lost is not the fault of Oedipus. In other words, King Laius and his men wanted to discipline Oedipus for not showing honor towards a king. Yet, in return, Oedipus wanted respect in return from King Laius and his men. They were both rightfully due the same

Mark Bixler's The Lost Boys of Sudan

1278 words - 5 pages villagers being killed by government militias . These boys fled, not knowing what they would encounter on the journey to escape the violence in their own country. Hungry, frightened, and weak from their long and hellish journey, the boys reached refugee camps outside of Sudan. Even though many young men were killed on their journeys to and from refugee camps in Kenya and Ethiopia, many remained at these camps for numerous years. While in the camps

Similar Essays

The Fall Of Innocence Essay

841 words - 4 pages It’s one of the most famous stories to ever exist, the story of how two people changed what defines us as humans. It’s the story of Adam, Eve, a serpent, and the unbecoming of mankind, the Fall of Man. This iconic account has been the premise for many works over the centuries. Today, Lord of the Flies by William Golding is considered one of the most influential novels of our time, not only for its adventurous story of stranded boys on a lost

The Voice Of Innocence Essay

963 words - 4 pages people so it would be a sin to kill it. In the novel To Kill A Mockingbird, by Harper Lee, Jem Finch is the voice of innocence while Boo Radley doesn’t bother anybody and Tom Robinson is an innocent person, therefore they all represent Mockingbirds. Boo Radley lives alone and doesn’t do anything to anyone, and doesn’t bother anybody. He minds his own business and it would be "a sin" to do anything that would disturb him. He is not the bad, mean

The Innocence Of Love Essay

906 words - 4 pages A first date, a tender touch, a gentle kiss, can all be described as expressions of affection. Innocence often has to do with the fondness and adoration displayed in relationships. The movie, Love Actually, starring Hugh Grant, focuses on different ways of making love work by showing the lives of different people. The film, from time to time, shows a little boy who is falling in love with a girl in his school. He thinks that the best way to win

The Age Of Innocence Essay

1465 words - 6 pages determinism, Americans were not as “free” as they believed. The Age of Innocence presents a representation of the constant social trap that forced people to mask their true feelings because of the ever-imposing desire to always seem at their best. One of the main subjects of the story is the lack of morality in Old New York. The city is renown for its “rigidities about form, family, and financial problems” and is the “epitome of rectitude” (Kozloff