The Insanity Of Hamlet Can Be Portrayed As An Act Of Will To Revenge His Father's Death. William Shakespeare Captures This Through Madness Vs. Melancholia

1067 words - 4 pages

Sane, or Insane? That is the Question

Madness vs. Melancholia

One of the most controversial questions surrounding William Shakespeare's tragedy, Hamlet, is whether or not the character was in fact haunted by madness or just acting it. His continuous use of melancholia leaves us as the audience, to ponder upon the true madness of Hamlet.

"Hamlet" is a story about fratricide, madness, melancholia and a constant change of attitudes and emotions.

His madness and melancholia range to different heights through the use of actions, movement and language. But this cannot prove whether or not Hamlet was mad, sane or suffering from a profound emotional depression. Hamlet's idea of assembling a staged play to defy the guilt set inside his uncle Claudius was an intelligent act. Further more, Hamlet's executed madness is shown to be none the less played with lines such as "I am but mad north-north-west. When the wind is southerly, I know a hawk from a handsaw."(Hamlet, Prince of Denmark, 2.2.340).

Madness vs. Melancholia can be defined as two different emotions. Madness is the quality or condition of being insane. Melancholia, however, is diametrically opposed to that of Madness, where it is characterised by severe depression which is shown through the emotion displayed at the death of Hamlet's father. Thus it rests upon the apprehension of the two directors to illustrate these emotions in a suitable way that best portrays Hamlet. "It will be your and the director's responsibility to decide the quantity and quality of personality characteristics necessary for the development of character."

(Acting In Person and In Style, Pg 162)

Two examples of the different notions that can be portrayed, is that of Franco Zeffirelli's and Laurence Olivier's Hamlet where madness and melancholia compete against one another with one achieving much stronger dramatic meaning then the other.

The two interpretations from Olivier and Zeffirelli's Hamlet are completely different in contrast to the emotions, and the way they have portrayed the character. The madness and melancholia of both films have been used effectively, but are incomparable to one another. Zeffirelli has shown a more evidential use of madness throughout his production. He has managed to portray a realistic conflicted struggle within Hamlet as he tries to revenge his father's death. An example of this conflict is Zeffirelli's idea in amongst Hamlet's monologue at the beginning of the assigned scene. The constant demand of heightened language displays this inner struggle which portrays the madness. "The audience must be stirred by the...

Find Another Essay On The insanity of Hamlet can be portrayed as an act of will to revenge his father's death. William Shakespeare captures this through Madness vs. Melancholia

Act 1 as an Effective Opening to Hamlet by William Shakespeare

1538 words - 6 pages Act 1 as an Effective Opening to Hamlet by William Shakespeare The play Hamlet is a dramatic love story written by William Shakespeare. It is set in the late sixteenth century. Most scenes take place in the grounds of the Danish castle at Elsinore. The play has many characters, and the main ones are members of the royal family or were close to them. It is a very long, complicated story that twists into a tragic end. ...

A Method to Madness - Hamlet - by William Shakespeare

731 words - 3 pages Ankita Mitra 8A #12Mrs CastagnaMarch 20, 2014A Method to MadnessPolonius's words, "Th8ough this be madness, yet there is method in't." (1) clearly show the reader that Hamlet simply feigned his insanity. William Shakespeare's parents gave birth to him in Stratford-upon-Avon in the sixteenth century. His son, Hamnet, died at the tender age of eleven years. This influenced the writing of Hamlet - one of the greatest...

Madness in Hamlet by William Shakespeare

1779 words - 7 pages Madness in Hamlet by William Shakespeare At first glance, William Shakespeare's tragedy Hamlet appears to be an obvious story of a man who goes mad over the murder of his father, the king. Madness is a common theme throughout Hamlet, but often times Hamlet himself is the only character seen as mad. An explanation for this is that a first time reader does not carry the perception that any other characters are mad, simply Hamlet. When in...

Antony & Cleopatra, by William Shakespeare "Explore Shakespeare's presentation of Cleopatra through her death - Act 5, Scene 2 - from "What poor an instrument," and Act 1, Scene 5."

2412 words - 10 pages As Act 5, Scene 2 is the scene where Cleopatra dies; Shakespeare needed to make this scene dramatic in order for one of his eponymous characters to truly reflect the grand life she led. He does this by providing characters for her to interact with so that the audience can know her thoughts, but also by setting aside large chunks for her to soliloquise, so that the change in her personality can be noted since Antony's death.The passage...

Insanity in Shakespeare's Hamlet - Madness in Hamlet

801 words - 3 pages Madness in Hamlet        Hamlet's choice to put on an "antic disposition" leads to his downfall; it is a tragic error in judgement (hamartia) which destroys his relationship with Ophelia and Gertrude. It is Hamlet's hubris. Another result from Hamlet's peculiar actions, is that in his own mind he begins to believe that he is mad.  It is unfortunate that Hamlet's plan did not succeed; not only did it lead to his own downfall but he had to...

Why Hamlet Delays in Avenging his Father's Death

982 words - 4 pages Why Hamlet Delays in Avenging his Father's Death The tragic play 'Hamlet' by William Shakespeare, tells the story of the enigmatic Prince Hamlet who is set the task of avenging the murder of his father at the hand of his uncle, King Claudius. Though it is clear that Hamlet harbours deep resentment towards his uncle and is eventually certain of his mission, Hamlet is seen to consistently delay in completing his task for...

Madness and Insanity in Shakespeare's Hamlet - Insanity within Hamlet

1956 words - 8 pages Insanity within Hamlet         Let us explore in this essay the real or feigned madness of the hero in William Shakespeare’s dramatic tragedy Hamlet.   Critical opinion is divided on this question. A.C. Bradley in Shakespearean Tragedy staunchly adheres to the belief that Hamlet would cease to be a tragic character if he were really mad at any time in the play (30). On the other hand, W. Thomas MacCary in Hamlet: A Guide to the...

Madness and Insanity in Shakespeare's Hamlet - Hamlet and Insanity

1967 words - 8 pages Hamlet and Insanity          William Shakespeare’s supreme tragic drama Hamlet does not answer fully for many in the audience the pivotal question concerning the sanity of Hamlet – whether it is totally feigned or not. Let us treat this topic in detail, along with critical comment.   George Lyman Kittredge in the Introduction to The Tragedy of Hamlet, Prince of Denmark, explains the prince’s rationale behind the entirely pretended...

Hamlet         Even in the first act of Hamlet one can

577 words - 2 pages Hamlet Even in the first act of Hamlet one can see that the relationships of the characters will play a major role in the outcome of this famous Shakespearean play. The development of these associations is played out as early as scene IV and will be evident throughout the story until the final tragic moments. One of the most compelling relationships described in the story is that which occurs between

Madness and Insanity in Shakespeare's Hamlet

1395 words - 6 pages        In Shakespeare's Hamlet, there are two characters that display qualities of insanity.  They are Hamlet and Ophelia.  Although they both appear to be mad at times, their downfall (or supposed downfall) is quite different.  Ophelia's crazed characteristics show up and intensify quite rapidly, until she is ultimately led to suicide.  Her madness seems definite, and it is never questioned.  The insanity or sanity of the main character is an...

Madness and Insanity in Shakespeare's Hamlet

3220 words - 13 pages Hamlet and Insanity       William Shakespeare’s creation of the character of Hamlet within the tragedy of that name left open the question of whether the madness of the protagonist is entirely feigned or not. This essay will treat this aspect of the drama.   George Lyman Kittredge in the Introduction to The Tragedy of Hamlet, Prince of Denmark, explains the lack of success with Hamlet’s pretended insanity, and in so doing he implies...

Similar Essays

"Revenge his foul and most unnatural murder." Hamlet seeks for the revenge of his father's death throughout the play. However in the end, does revenge actually pay? Discuss.

1384 words - 6 pages Shakespeare's Hamlet is a complex play where many themes are intertwined - themes that are essential to the development of the play. The issue of death and disease, both physical and emotional is very prevalent throughout the duration of the play, as well as fate and divine intervention. The play also questions madness and whether it can be feigned, as well as corruption and its moral implications. Also the 'To be or not to be' soliloquy,...

An Exploration of the Way Shakespeare Presents Madness in Hamlet

3145 words - 13 pages An Exploration of the Way Shakespeare Presents Madness in Hamlet Does Shakespeare intend to present Hamlet and Ophelia as insane? This is a question which has baffled English literary critics for more than 400 years. There is still no definite answer, and throughout the play there are numerous points where you stop and wonder whether Hamlet and Ophelia are sane or not. They both change dramatically from one scene to...

Use of Insanity and Madness in Hamlet

1160 words - 5 pages It is or is it not true that Hamlet was faking his insanity? I’m not saying Hamlet was faking the whole thing. The meaning for insanity on Dictionary.com is “a permanent disorder of the mind.” I don't think Hamlet had a permanent disorder of the mind he knew what he was doing and even planned the majority of the events that happened. Most of the time anyway. Having your father die is bad enough, but to have your mother marry your uncle,...

Motif of Madness in Hamlet by William Shakespeare

1116 words - 4 pages Motif of Madness in Hamlet by William Shakespeare It is the driving force of mankind that has delivered man from the age of stone to that of industry. This force is also the essential ingredient that produces the inescapable prison of the mind, a frightful disease that may be viewed as the greatest irony of life. Pain is a dreadful disease in which every individual has felt the everlasting effects. The grief of pain can become a crashing...