This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Insanity Plea And Mental Illness

1165 words - 5 pages

The insanity plea, or the “irresistible impulse” defense, described by Martin (1998) as “a plea that defendants are not guilty because they lacked the mental capacity to realize that they committed a wrong or appreciate why it was wrong.” Remains a very controversial within the judicial system, with many believing that the defense attempts to fake a purportedly guilty man’s insanity, more often to make sure the defendant gets a less harsh conviction or the possibility of an acquittal. While the plea is truly helpful to many who suffer from mental illness, many who do not suffer from illness try to use it as a get-out of-jail-free card.
The insanity plea’s first successful use occurred in England by a man named Daniel M’Naghten. M’Naghten believed falsely that the Prime Minister of England established a plot against him, M’Naghten decided to take action, attempted to ambush the Prime Minister, and unfortunately shot and killed his press secretary in the confusion. Established psychologists in England testified to the mental instability of M’Naghten. The jury eventually reached a verdict of not guilty by reason of insanity and was held in a mental institution for the remainder of his life. This ruling was then brought to The House of Lords, and 15 judges met to determine the judicial standard of the insanity plea. They established a test under the so called “M’Naghten Rule”, which Douglas states:
“Under the M'Naghten test of insanity, also called the "right-wrong test," a person was not criminally responsible if at the time of the crime, he did not know the nature of the act or that it was wrong. The jury was required to answer two questions: (1) did the defendant know what he was doing when he committed the crime? Or (2) did the defendant understand that his actions were wrong? This test allowed a prosecutor to prove sanity easily by simply showing a defendant understood the moral consequences of an action; mental illness did not matter.”
A study conducted in 2002 discovered that 25 states still utilize the M'Naghten test to determine the eligibility of the insanity defense.
I do agree with the principles of the insanity plea, as it seems to be a very ethical and logical thing in society, as there are numerous valid examples of mental illness and their effects on the mental balance of the person they inhabit. These illnesses can render the person unable to claim full responsibility for their actions. Take Ed Gein for example, one of the most famous serial killers and grave-robbers in American history was one of the only serial killers to ever successfully win an insanity verdict, and rightfully so. Gein had schizophrenia, and found solace in a perverse obsession of his mother, his most infamous trademark included taking body parts of his victims and displaying them as trophies around his house. Do I believe the heinous and exasperating crimes he committed deserved punishment for a sane man? Absolutely, but Gein could not be considered a sane...

Find Another Essay On The Insanity Plea and Mental Illness

The Insanity Defense Part I When is the insanity plea a reasonable and

866 words - 3 pages The Insanity Defense Part IOutlineWhen is the insanity plea a reasonable and ethical tool?Thesis: Although some criminals abuse the insanity plea by invoking it to escape being punished for their crimes, the insanity plea should nevertheless still be allowed for those with a documented record of mental illness.I. Background information on the insanity plea [the M'Naughten case]II. Abusing the insanity pleaIII. Importance of the insanity plea in

The Ponzi Scheme and Mental Illness

1420 words - 6 pages The Ponzi Scheme and Mental Illness December 26 1919 Charles Ponzi borrowed $200 to buy some office furniture. By January 1920 he then began telling the people of Boston how he could buy stamps and sell them overseas and give them a 50% return on their investment in 45 days and 100% return in just 90 days. The people came so fast he was able to pay returns of 100% in just 45 days. The word spread quickly and more investors came. Soon Charles

Mental Illness and Mental Health

2797 words - 11 pages what is abnormal and normal in our society at any given period? The use of the terms abnormal and normal seems archaic when dealing with symptoms of mental illness given the mathematical origin of the terms. More appropriately, the terms adaptive and nonadaptive speak to the transient nature of the relativity in our thoughts, behavior, physical symptoms, and psychosocial interactions. Several individuals I work with have been

Mental Illness and Facilities

2220 words - 9 pages Madhouses, loony bins, insane asylums, monsters, witches, and lunatics. These are the terms that haunt both the mentally ill and the facilities that provide their treatment. The stigma of mental illness prevents persons in need of treatment from seeking help for their mental illnesses. Stigma has been reduced throughout the years due to mental health support groups and out-patient care; however, stigma is still a very prominent issue today

Mental Illness and Homelessness

773 words - 4 pages (Montgomery et al). Environmental factors include a poor family structure and a change in social surroundings. While the exact source of a majority of mental illnesses is unknown, through extensive research, it has been discovered that there are in fact biological, psychological, and environmental factors, such as those aforementioned, involved in originating a mental illness (“Causes of Mental Illness”). A mental disorder can also be the cause of a

mental illness and society

1837 words - 8 pages This essay will focus completely on Mental illness in the UK. To gather my research I used various resources such as websites and books. I have also viewed YouTube videos in order to expand my knowledge. The statistics gathered may not be totally accurate in discussing mental health within the UK for the sources are secondary but it is reliable for giving a view of what the distribution is like amongst gender, age, class as well as ethnicity

Summarizes "Insanity Plea" by William J.Winslade and Judith Wilson Ross. Speaks also about different ways people have used and abused the Criminal Justice System using The Insanity Plea

991 words - 4 pages wasthenbrought to court on the charges of 1st degree murder where he wasfound not guilty due to the plea of Insanity. On Thanksgiving Day,1976, Torsney had to work and was unhappy about it. At thirty-fourhe had been on the force for about 8 years and he was sick andtired ofthe conditions he had to work through. He would rather be athomewith his wife and kids at Thanksgiving, just like the average personinAmerica was doing. He made a note of the

Poverty and Mental Illness

2487 words - 10 pages The concept of poverty is complex and has many indicators across different disciplines. The prevalence of poverty is growing and the effects of poverty impacts individuals, families and communities across the lifespan. One area of focus is on poverty in relation to mental illness. The impact of poverty on mental health has been shown to affect those of all ages. Many people are unaware of the widespread poverty and its effects on mental

Homelessness and Mental Illness

1227 words - 5 pages Imagine a man on the streets, who society has forgotten. This man emits the smell of garbage; he has not bathed in months. This man sits quietly mumbling to himself. To the outer world he is just one of the many homeless, but little does society know that this man has a mental illness as well. Homelessness and mental illness are linked. These two happenings have similar beginnings. Homelessness is influenced by drug and alcohol disuse, being

Mental Illness and Environment

874 words - 3 pages Introduction The number of people suffering from mental illness has been on the rise in the recent times. It is vital to acknowledge that there are differences as to the levels of mental illness in different individuals. However, research shows that more often than not, mental illness results from a specific relationship between an individual and the environment. The psychological stress comes about as an individual perceives the environment

Mental Illness and POWs

1330 words - 5 pages Any member of the Armed Forces who is held in captivity as a POW or as a hostage is more likely to be at a higher risk of mental illness like PTSD. This assumption goes against everything that was thought to be known during WWI, it was noted time and time again that both English and German POWs were somehow immune to war neuroses and only susceptible to the newly identified barbed wire disease which is the prisoner’s reaction to his environment

Similar Essays

History And Effectiveness Of The Insanity Plea

1089 words - 4 pages , his illogical state of mind has come into question. Diagnosed with a mental illness would have satisfied the insanity plea, yet Loughner’s premeditation defies McNaughtan’s law of insanity. When the United States adopted and interpreted the insanity, it did not account for trail cases such Jarrod Loughner’s. Where the defendant is insane but had also premeditated the crime. In addition to its ambiguous interpretations, there is a clear danger to

The Insanity Plea Essay

2371 words - 9 pages ) When the judge accepted his plea, they sentenced him to a get a mental evaluation to see if he was actually mentally ill when he committed the crime. (Elliot 2013) This plea would be Holmes last chance to escape the death penalty which everyone thinks he deserves and the only way to escape this would be to get the mental evaluation but then only the jurors will decide his punishment. (Elliot 2013) If they find him not guilty by reason of insanity

The Insanity Plea Essay

1072 words - 5 pages illness, but are exaggerating rather than faking the symptoms in order to escape criminal responsibility where it would have been assigned otherwise, and only a few of them feign a mental illness entirely (Gagliardi & Kramer, 2008). Perception   Research has found that perception of the insanity defense can be predicted through other factors, such as feelings towards the death penalty, authoritarianism, liberalism, fear of crime, philosophical

The Insanity Plea Essay

1101 words - 5 pages Prime Minister because he was suffering from paranoid delusions and believed he was being persecuted. The M’Naghten’s trial was also the first incidence in which the M’Naghten Rule was played into effect. This rule states that an individual must be diagnosed with a mental disorder before they commit a crime in order for insanity to be a plausible plea. The M’Naghten Rule was not used in the Daniel Sickles trial, because Sickle’s defense had