The Invalidity Of Utilitarianism Uof T: Phl Philosophy Paper

1312 words - 6 pages

The Invalidity of Utilitarianism: Persaud 1
The Invalidity of Utilitarianism
Utilitarianism is implausible because it fails to realize that happiness is not the only intrinsically valuable thing and because quantifying happiness is a very difficult task to complete in real life. Utilitarianism may seem plausible in theory but it is not applicable in real life. Section one aims to explain the doctrine of utilitariansim whilst Section 2 will object to it and explain its implausibility.
Section 1: “Argument for Utilitarianism: why they believe in the Utilitarian theory”
Utilitarianism, a form of consequentialism, claims that the morality of actions depends on their effects. This doctrine is unconcerned with the process of what occurs whilst the action is being carried out or any other relative specifics. It is solely concerned about the consequences/ outcome of that action and the net amount of happiness/ pleasure it contains (the usefulness of these consequences). A core principle it follows is the Greatest Happiness Principle, which says actions are right if happiness is produced and wrong if unhappiness is produced- happiness being pleasure and the absence of pain: unhappiness being pain and absence of pleasure. You may ask “Why is happiness the focal point/ goal of utilitariansim? What does happiness have to do with morality or vice versa?”
According to utilitarians, utility (happiness) is intrinsically valuable, i.e. it is of value in itself or in its own right. Its value does not lead to something else but its own sake alone, attributing a sense of divinity to happiness. In contrast, things of instrumental value lead to other things, making those other things of intrinsic value. The utilitarian doctrine argues that our instrumental actions are only a means to an end- that end being happiness. With regards to coexisting relationship between happiness and morality, Utilitarians believe that the intention of morality is to make life better by increasing the good and decreasing the bad. Explicitly, morality exists in order for us to achieve happiness/pleasure.
The notion of instrumental and intrinsic values and the relationship they share is plausible. We do complete many activities or go through many things in our lives only as a means to something else greater. E.g. John dislikes going to the gym early in the morning but is the only time available in his busy schedule to work out. Due to health concerns, he must exercise consistently lest his health quickly worsens. Consequently, he remains consistent with exercising although he dislikes it.
Section 2: Utilitarianism is implausible because…
The underlying issue within this doctrine that I would like to point out is that utilitarianism argues that utility is the only thing that can have intrinsic value. To believe that happiness/pleasure has an exclusive and universal intrinsic value is a blatant disregard to other worthy things that people consider intrinsic, such as love, liberty, knowledge,...

Find Another Essay On The Invalidity of Utilitarianism - UofT: PHL - Philosophy Paper

The Flaws of Act-Utilitarianism Essay

1775 words - 7 pages In this paper I will argue that John Stuart Mill, the presenter of the most compelling theory of act-utilitarianism (AU), ultimately falls short in addressing the moral complexities which factor into man’s virtues and its effect on his motives for certain actions. John Stuart Mill’s core arguments follow and contrast many theories established by Jeremy Bentham. Combining the idea of consequentialism, that consequences of actions are the

explain the main forms of utilitarianism

989 words - 4 pages Carys Jones 26th March 2014EXPLAIN THE MAIN PRINCIPLES OF CLASSICAL FORMS OF UTILITARIANISMUtilitarianism is the idea that the greatest good for the greatest number, so the action that causes the most number of people, pleasure or happiness. It is a teleological theory of ethics, as it is more concerned with the outcome rather than the act. It is also relative and subjective. Utilitarianism is a consequentialist theory as it decides whether an

euthansia- utilitarianism is the best approach - criminal justice - research paper

1168 words - 5 pages “Utilitarianism is the best approach to euthanasia.” Discuss. (10) Utilitarianism is traditionally the principle “the greatest good for the greatest number”. Euthanasia deals with issues to do with whether or not the soul exists and whether or not this decides whether we view someone as a person. As well as this, during a decision about euthanasia, we must find out what importance we place on the autonomy of the person that is planned to die, as

The implications of a Social Institution - Philosophy Paper 1 - Oresteia Paper

1611 words - 7 pages 3942729 Social Philosophy Paper 1 Athenian Court as a Positive Institution In this paper I will argue that the court invented by Athena does put an end to the cycle of violence as retribution. I will do this by introducing and discussing the principles of the Athenian court that idealize justice over vengeance. Then I will discuss the rule of law argument that is introduced as an institution and argue how it is better than using emotions and

World Hunger - Philosophy of ethics paper - Philosophy 120

1796 words - 8 pages happiness of the entire world. They place the value on objects that they do not need, rather than place them on the lives of children in need. Similarly, to Hardin he is using utilitarianism to defend his argument. By saying that in order to maximize the amount of happiness the people of the rich countries need to help those that are poor. In order to increase overall happiness for both sides this must be done. . The consequences of the action of

Developing a Coaching Philosophy - SCCC/Philosophy of Sport - Research Paper

2580 words - 11 pages Quinn Jackson Philosophy of Sport Research Paper The great Vince Lombardi (1970) once said “Winning is not a sometime thing; it’s an all-time thing.  You don’t win once in a while, you don’t do things right once in a while, you do them right all the time.  Winning is habit.  Unfortunately, so is losing”. Playing for Vince Lombardi was much more then just showing up and going through the motions. His personal philosophy on coaching and leadership

The Importance of Philosophy

2018 words - 8 pages The Importance of Philosophy ‘Philosophy is to be studied, not for the sake of any definite answers to its questions, since no definite answers can, as a rule, be known to be true, but rather for the sake of the questions themselves.’ (Bertrand Russell, Problem of Philosophy, pp. 93-94). Discuss the usefulness (or

The Value of Philosophy

1533 words - 7 pages To understand the value of philosophy, one must look at its origins. Linguistically the word philosophy comes from the Greek term philosophia, meaning “the love of wisdom.” Wisdom can be defined as the quality of having experience, knowledge, and good judgment. Ultimately philosophy can be defined as the love of having experience, knowledge, and good judgment. When one hears the term philosophy questions such as “what is the purpose of life

The Value of Philosophy

745 words - 3 pages "The Value of Philosophy?"Question 5: Some students feel that philosophy is worthless because it does not yield definite results. How would Russell respond? Russell says the value of philosophy is in its uncertainty. What does he mean? Do you agree?Often times before I had attended college, I felt that philosophy was a useless study. I did not see the point of asking sometimes ridicules questions and arguing over them. You know the questions I

The Value of Philosophy

1121 words - 4 pages The Value of Philosophy Consider a man that looks to material needs as the necessities of life. He moves through his world in a twenty-four hour cycle of the mundane, never reaching for a less ignorant existence. Bertrand Russell believes that these "practical men", as society deems them, are wrongly named. A meaningful life to this "practical man", certainly does not include the understanding of a need for knowledge. Russell states

The Value of Philosophy - 880 words

880 words - 4 pages As a concluding thought in his book entitled, The Problems of Philosophy, Bertrand Russell wrestles with the value of philosophy and why philosophy should continue to be studied. Philosophy’s value must be sought after, he states, in order to truly understand its importance. In order to do so, one must rid his or her mind, first, of any practical prejudices such as material needs like food only being for the body’s nourishment

Similar Essays

Philosophy: Two Differetn Types Of Utilitarianism

1826 words - 7 pages seen as “pleasure absent of pain” (Feinberg, 597). There are two different types of utilitarianism: act and rule. As talked about in lecture act utilitarianism is the “right action to perform on a particular occasion is the action which, on that occasion will result in the greatest sum of happiness. Rule utilitarianism is “the right action to perform on a particular occasion is the action which conforms with the rule such that, if the rule is

The Flaw Of Utilitarianism Essay

837 words - 3 pages Philosophers Bentham and James Mill developed an ethical theory, utilitarianism, proposing that all action should be directed toward achieving the greatest happiness for the greatest number of people. Utilitarians further argue that achieving the greatest happiness overall is not only the right thing to do for society but also moral. Although this theory is applicable in many situations, when one takes a closer look it is clear to see that

The Effect Of Utilitarianism Essay

1412 words - 6 pages who experienced near-death, or people who attained freedom after long periods of hardship and torture. These people would definitely view their lives, and those who went through the same experiences, in a different light. If we were to analyze Utilitarianism closely, we would realize that they do not put any values on human life. In the Utilitarian point of view, every human life is worth the same. No matter what the status of the entity. Even if

Explain The Forms Of Utilitarianism Essay

726 words - 3 pages decision procedure.Some Weaknesses of Utilitarianism.It allows us to do evil so that good might come. For example, in a time of crisis, innocent people may be imprisoned or executed if it calms down the population (if say they are believed to be responsible for terrorist acts). The British police were guilty of this during the Northern Irish troubles.The no-rest objection: act utilitarianism, if followed to the letter, could prevent us from doing