The Issue Of Bad Math In Court Discussion

1148 words - 5 pages

Bad math in court is something that happens over and over again and because of it, many innocent victims have been jailed and punished unjustly over the years. The problem is not some sort of miscalculation, but the refusal of the court to recalculate. More than often enough, the judge refuses to reexamine the collected DNA in an investigation case. What the people of the court fail to realize at times is that probability is not a one off thing, it is something that should be repeated at least more than once and can even be repeated over and over again. The flipping of a coin is frequently used to explain this logic and will be explained in following paragraphs. Sometimes statistician will state that there is only a one in a million chance (or some other ludicrously large number) that the defendant is innocent; but then they fail to examine: what is that 1, what are the chances that the accused that that one in a million? In this paper, I will be discussing the issue of ‘bad math in court,’ why it happens and how something as simple as probability can get innocent people out of jail.

I chose to explore the idea of bad math in court’ because ever since I was a child, my mother always said to me: “No matter what you choose to do in life, it’ll always require mathematics.” She said this as a way to encourage me to take my math classes more seriously (and it worked!) When watching an episode of criminal minds, my mom’s saying came into mind and I was left wondering if what my mom said was true. Once my teacher introduced this Math IA project, I took it as the perfect opportunity for me to explore an issue that had been bugging me for a while, which was: Math in Court. However, when I was doing a little but of background information on the topic to see if it had enough information for me to write a paper on it I was struck by what I found. Coming from an actively based political family, I make it a responsibility of mine to keep up with World Wide news. I have watched and kept up with numerous court cases and trials. A few that stuck out to me over the last few years was Sally Clark’s and Amanda Knox’s court cases. What was so intriguing about theirs was the fact that although they were accused and eventually jailed for murder, after a couple of years they were let free by the court because of incorrect statistics that had been used during their trial. I found it quite odd that something as simple as statistics could be misused and ultimately, disregarded. Soon enough I forgot about these cases, but imagine my surprise, a few years later, when the very subject I am researching, is directly connected to those fascinating and mind-boggling cases.

The first case that I will be exploring is one that took the world by storm back in 2007: Amanda Knox.
“A British exchange student, Meredith Kercher, was found stabbed to death at the house she shared in Perugia, Italy, in November 2007. Kercher's housemate, Amanda Knox, and her boyfriend, Raffaele...

Find Another Essay On The Issue of Bad Math in Court Discussion

Necessity of Math in Business Essay

882 words - 4 pages business. One should have some knowledge in different areas such as business math or hire the right people with the experience and the know. Knowing mathematics will only enhance your work, in a person’s reasoning, problem - solving skills, and in the capability of thought. Tools in math such as the use of accounting can help with the expenses coming in and out of business. Market trends can be mapped by using the theory of chaos formula. Statistics

Women in the Math World Essay

1540 words - 6 pages Women in the Math World Works Cited Not Included Math is commonly known as the man’s major. Many college math professors are men and the same goes for their students. "One study revealed that women accounted for 15% of students in computer science, 16% in electrical engineering,. . . Gender splits in the faculty were similar" (Cukier). There are few women that have made an impact on the math

The Controversial Issue of Religion In Schools

2151 words - 9 pages age, we could help prevent children from being made fun of because we will have a better understanding of their beliefs.Religion is a very controversial issue, especially when it comes to religion and prayer in public schools. In the case of Engel v. Vitale in 1962, it was decided that school prayer was unconstitutional. With this case, it was pointed out that the students were to voluntarily recite a prayer. The court ruled that "...state

The Issue of Race in Othello

3275 words - 13 pages The Issue of Race in Othello   In his production of Othello for BBC television (1981), Jonathan Miller asserted that Othello's race does not greatly impact his downfall in the play.  He maintains that while Shakespeare touches upon the issue of race, the cause of Othello's demise lies elsewhere.1  However, the implications of race in the play directly lead to its tragic ending; it is this issue that impels the characters to set the tragedy

The Issue of Immigration in America

1083 words - 4 pages provides for racial profiling be in effect. The law is so vague that it can be loosely interpreted. SB1070 was recently taken to the Supreme Court for a federal decision, after a federal judge in Arizona blocked 8 out of the laws 12 provisions (Rojas). The main one being the right of a local police officer to check anyone they suspect to be an illegal immigrant. The Supreme Court is mainly focusing on the Obama administrations appeal on the law

The issue of Fukushima Daiichi in Japan

2062 words - 8 pages since it gets an attention of the world in many different ways. The issue can be considered through idealistic approach and institutional approach. First, it can be an idea issue since people share the environment and there is a norm to keep the clean environment. Although humans interact with many different cultures, there is one environment we all live in. So it is important to respect and practice the norm for sharing and keeping the

The Issue of Experiment in Mathematics

2305 words - 9 pages The Issue of Experiment in Mathematics ABSTRACT: The issue of the status of mathematical knowledge a priori or a posteriori has been repeatedly considered by the philosophy of mathematics. At present, the development of computer technology and their enhancement of the everyday work of mathematicians have set a new light on the problem. It seems that a computer performs two main functions in mathematics: it carries out numerical calculations

The Issue of Casinos in South Florida

2354 words - 9 pages Casinos on the 2014 ballot? Political committee lays the groundwork “After failing to persuade the Florida Legislature to pass a bill to open South Florida to mega resort casinos, gambling interests have taken the first steps to bring the issue directly to voters in 2014. A political committee under the name of “New Jobs and Revenues for Florida” was created April 10 with the purpose of promoting a “statewide constitutional initiative re gaming

Issue of Poverty in the World

1749 words - 7 pages services to related nations. Overall, poverty is a pervasive problem in developing countries. To my opinion, this issue is getting more severe and may not be solved completely. We United Nations celebrate holidays with tremendous amount of food most every month while more than half of the population in the developing world lives on an income less than 2-dollar a day. I wish that American and people in developed countries or even rich people in

Issue of Privacy in the Workplace

1201 words - 5 pages that these policies be enforced throughout the company. Only with complete compliance can the security of the company and its employees be assured. Everyone has the right to privacy but when it comes to business and the privacy issue, there's a risk people are going to have to take. It is already evident that e-mail and internet monitoring is mandatory, even if businesses don't want to participate in it. Therefore, to prevent any future problems concerning privacy in the workplace people should review and think over the contents of their electronic communication before sending them.

The Issue of Ethics in Writing Fiction

2698 words - 11 pages issue of ethics in writing fiction is a responsibility of the writer who has to understand his/her own personal ethical standards. A writer writes what they know and in writing fiction a distance is created between the author and the creative piece, I want to explore the Nigerian female’s existence and my goal in writing fiction is to create empathy and understanding in my reader’s mind through storytelling. American novelist, Jon Hansen in his

Similar Essays

Critically Discussion Of The Issue Of Stop And Search

1884 words - 8 pages evidence. In spite of that, police officers are simply members of society, therefore, it is argued there should be an acceptance that they may be as prejudiced as other members of the community (Ainswoth, 2002: 30). However, there are complaints that these prejudices have impacted police effectiveness. There is concern that police biases become influential on other members of staff, primarily within new recruits, and thus creates a bad relationship

The Importance Of Arithmetic In Math

764 words - 3 pages Arithmetic is the ABC of math. Addition, subtraction, multiplication, and division are the basics of math and every math operation known to humankind. In one way or another, every equation, graph, and an enormous amount of other things can be broken down into the ABC's of math, the four basic operations. As people say, math is a language, and addition subtraction, multiplication, and division are its alphabet, along with the number line as well

The History Of Math Essay

4801 words - 19 pages The History of Math Mathematics, study of relationships among quantities, magnitudes, and properties and of logical operations by which unknown quantities, magnitudes, and properties may be deduced. In the past, mathematics was regarded as the science of quantity, whether of magnitudes, as in geometry, or of numbers, as in arithmetic, or of the generalization of these two fields, as in algebra. Toward the middle of the 19th century

What Was The Consitutional Issue In Brandy V Hreoc, What Did The Court Decide? What Broader Implications Does It Have?

1445 words - 6 pages consideration in human rights issue resulted the victim suffering the consequence of racial abuse without any legal action being acted upon because it could not be enforced by HREOC. So the question remains, can the separation of power really act as safeguard to individual rights or is it merely legal fiction?Apart from resolving the Constitutional issue and finalized the dispute. The decision made by High Court also invalidated the amendments of