This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Jack Kevorkian Trial Essay

1549 words - 7 pages

Hero or villain? Murderous or merciful? The jury in Jack Kevorkian, “the Suicide Doctor’s”, trial had to answer this question (Morganthau). Kevorkian was tried for the assisted suicide of Thomas Youk. The jurors had to decide whether to declare Kevorkian responsible for Youk’s death, make Youk responsible for his own fate, or find a compromise of the two. In Reginald Rose’s play Twelve Angry Men, a conflicted jury had to decide the verdict of an equally difficult murder case. Any member of the jury for Twelve Angry Men would find the Jack Kevorkian case full of conflicting ideas and would find it difficult to arrive a verdict.
Jack Kevorkian, who called himself the “intellectual heir of Einstein,” assisted in countless suicides; therefore, the Youk suicide was not his first case of euthanasia, assisted suicide, or his first time in court for his actions (Hosenball). According to Crimes and Trials of the Century, “His first trial was for Thomas Hyde- a landscape designer and construction worker with Lou Gehrigs disease which was terminal at age 29” (Chermak). Although Youk’s case was not Kevorkian’s first, it certainly was his most well known. Biography.com states “Kevorkian was prosecuted four times in Michigan for assisted suicides: he was acquitted in three cases and the fourth was declared a mistrial” (“Jack Kevorkian”). Clearly, the possible consequences of his crimes did not affect Kevorkian and he kept assisting people. Although he had many different federal offenses, Kevorkian was not severely punished for his actions until the court case involving Youk.
On May 26th 1999 twelve people of the jury found Jack Kevorkian guilty of murder in the second-degree. Dirk Johnson, a writer for the New York Times stated, “His widow, Melody Youk, gave a statement to the court today that bitterly criticized prosecutors and cast Dr. Kevorkian as someone who was merely carrying out the wishes of her husband” (Johnson). This shows that she did not want the jury and prosecutors to give the obvious decision of guilty, because her husband wanted Jack to do this to him (Johnson 2). He also said, “Every member of the jury had compassion and empathy for Thomas Youk” (Johnson). Since the jury showed compassion and empathy towards Youk, they would be biased in their vote, which would drastically change Jack Kevorkian’s life. The jury should’ve had an easy decision when it came to his trial: “More than 30 states have banned assisted suicide-the act of helping a person take his own life- including Michigan” (McHugh). However, the jury’s verdict wasn’t so easy.
These jurors’ verdict of the court case didn’t come easily or quickly. The verdict stood with a sentence of “25 years in prison with the possibility of parole” (“Jack Kevorkian”). The decision was that of a second-degree murder and Kevorkian was guilty. “There are twelve people on the jury,” explained Johnson, “and only one of them decided to talk to the press after the verdict” (Johnson). Only a well...

Find Another Essay On The Jack Kevorkian Trial

Physician-Assisted Suicide is Morally and Ethically Acceptable

1162 words - 5 pages     The long time debate over medically assisted suicide, the presence of a doctor at a patient’s suicide, resurfaced again with the conviction of doctor Jack Kevorkian.  Kevorkian was convicted of second degree murder when he euthanized, or administered the injection himself, Thomas Youk on September 17, 1998.  Dr. Kevorkian, an advocate and practitioner of medically assisted suicides, has many opponents on the issue. Opponents say that it is

Physician Assisted Suicide Essay

2539 words - 11 pages constitution of the United States of America to end their lives so long as they do not directly affect others in the process. ​A renowned physician challenged this very issue many years back in the mid 1990's. The physicians name was Dr. Jack Kevorkian. Dr. Kevorkian was known as Dr. death because of his extremely liberal view on physician assisted suicide, which led him to conduct the assisted suicide to over 130 patients in the United States

Should We Go Gentle Into the Night?

985 words - 4 pages and are in extreme physical pain. Would you want the right to ask your doctor to end your suffering, or is that going too far? This is euthanasia: a topic that has been the subject of debate for many years.Euthanasia, also known as "assisted suicide," is an issue that was brought to light by Dr. Jack Kevorkian. Dr. Kevorkian was a controversial activist who had tried to make euthanasia legal under the argument that everyone deserved to die humanely

The Faults in Dr. Death

863 words - 4 pages Jack Kevorkian was a doctor who assisted terminally ill patients to commit suicide. He believed that they had the right to die in an appropriate way; to die with dignity. He therefore invented a machine (called thanatron—a Greek word for death machine) which could take away his patients’ lives painlessly and efficiently, all they had to do was to push a button and their lives would be ended by either deadly injection or carbon monoxide poisoning

Euthanasia: The Strange Case of Dr. Kevorkian

704 words - 3 pages Euthanasia: The Strange Case of Dr. Kevorkian Physicians face an ethical dilemma when confronting their patients who are suffering. Many have to choose between abiding by the law or ignoring the law and acting on their own beliefs by assisting in a patient’s suicide. Dr. Jack Kevorkian is certainly one doctor who has taken the illegal route in assisting in many of his patients suicides. In “Killer Doc,” William F. Buckley provides a

Euthanasia is the Wrong Way to Go

1525 words - 6 pages from a murderer. Assisting in ones death is immoral, unethical and should not only be a crime, but it should be viewed as premeditated murder rather than assisted suicide. Euthanasia is a shrouded killer and the physician that assist in the practice of it is no more then its sidekick.For instance, if you follow the work of Dr. Jack Kevorkian and those in which he helped to execute you will understand my theory. Kevorkian's role in assisting

Voluntary Euthanasia: What's Right and Wrong?

2065 words - 8 pages Pratchett could face up to 14 years in prison (BBC Films). Years before, the nation learned of another man with opinions like Sir Terry Pratchett. One of the strongest, controversial, and known followers of euthanasia is Dr. Jack Kevorkian. Dr. Jack Kevorkian believed it was his job as a doctor to end patient's suffering. Kevorkian claims he has assisted in at least 130 assisted suicides. Quoting Wikipedia, “He famously said that dying is not a crime

Euthanasia: The controversy over assisted suicide

936 words - 4 pages most well known of all the doctors ever tried in a court of law is Dr. Jack Kevorkian. A Michigan native, Kevorkian, the physician who has become famous for his willingness to aid terminally ill patients in ending their lives, assisted in around 130 suicides of gravely ill citizens. He used euthanasia on only one patient who suffered from Lou Gehrig's disease. In March of 1999, Dr. Kevorkian was convicted of second degree murder. On April 13, 1999

Euthanasia

671 words - 3 pages never consider being euthanized because people were created by God for a reason and should not be taken away until natural death occurs. No human being has the right to take another individuals life. However, from the opposing viewpoint, other people argue that a human should be able allowed to eliminate his/her pain rather than be left to suffer. Jack Kevorkian, a pathologist from Michigan was sentenced to prison for euthanizing individuals

Euthanasia: A Good Thing

899 words - 4 pages it to be wrong because of their views, not because it is beneficial for the ill person. One of the extremely well-known doctors whom had experience in Euthanasia was Doctor Jack Kevorkian, or known by his rather popular name “Doctor Death”. Doctor Kevorkian created a machine known as the thanatron, a device that had a trigger so the patient could press the button themselves. The contraption was made out of household items, toys, magnets, and

Assisted Suicide and Euthanasia - No Human Life Should End by Unnatural Means

880 words - 4 pages thanks to high-profile court cases, like the trial of Dr. Jack Kevorkian. Some claim that the terminally ill have a “right to die”, but no human life should end by unnatural means. As medical technology continues to expand at an astounding rate, doctors are finding treatment for diseases and ailments that would have been untreatable a mere five years ago. The main selling point of euthanasia seems to be to put terminally ill patients out of their

Similar Essays

Jack Kevorkian Essay

1163 words - 5 pages Jack Kevorkian Jack Kevorkian was born in 1928 in Pontiac, Michigan, to Armenian immigrants. He grew up in Pontiac and went on to college and medical school at the University of Michigan, where he received his medical degree in 1952. Dr Kevorkian chose pathology as his specialty, which involves trying to determine causes of disease and death. He served in Korea as an Army medical officer, then came back to Michigan and began residency

Twelve Angry Men And The Jurors Of The Kevorkian Trials

2347 words - 9 pages doesn’t want to admit it. Therefore, for these reasons, one can see that he would’ve used the same mindset throughout the Kevorkian trials. If one would examine Juror Eight’s thoughts and opinions, they would find it clear that Juror Eight would give Jack Kevorkian a chance and a shot at a fair trial. “There were eleven votes for guilty,” Juror Eight said in Twelve Angry Men, “It’s not so easy for me to raise my hand and send a boy off to die without

Euthanasia: The Right Choice Essay

2430 words - 10 pages remains in jail today because the Michigan court of appeals does not agree with his statement. During his trial, Kevorkian asked the judge if he could call Youk’s wife and brother to confirm the suffering Youk was undermining. The judge denied his request. Even Youk’s family knew how much he was suffering. Youk’s wife states, “Heartbroken, that in spite of all our efforts we had come so near the end, yet respectful of his wish not to go further, we

Should Physician Assisted Suicide Be Legal? Essay

1717 words - 7 pages dash their passing with pharmaceutical recommended by their medical practitioners (Richards III, 1995). The decision in the Quill and Glucksberg does not mean the campaign is in favor of assisted suicide. The failed attempt in November 1998 election to legalize it in Michigan and Dr. Jack Kevorkian attempt for television euthanizing. The Supreme Court put a no bar against state legislation giving physician’s licenses to honor patients request