This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Only Badge Needed Is Your Patriotic Fervor: Vigilance, Coercion And The Law In World War I America

1440 words - 6 pages

Vigilantism in World War I America was a perversion of the law that in the eyes of the perpetrator was a just action no matter how gruesome or violent. The obligation of vigilance during the war time was seen as patriotic duty but somewhere along the way the thought of it became distorted. Christopher Capozzola writes in his article The Only Badge Needed is Your Patriotic Fervor: Vigilance, Coercion and the Law in World War I America about vigilance taking three forms: Defending the home front and in particular in Connecticut, labor disputes and social and moral disputes. During this article one sees that vigilantism was not a clear cut defiance of the American law or system it was a theory that put the power in the hands of the people but did not separate it from those that created it and those that could act upon it.
The first section Mr. Capozzola discusses in his article is the idea of defending the home front during the war. His argument is that the people of the United States found it their duty to step in and take control when the citizens felt that the government was not doing their job. In a quote from Woodrow Wilson the reader is able to see what the government was trying to fix. "No man who loves America, no man who really cares for her fame and honor and character…can justify mob action while the courts of justice are open and the governments of the States and the Nations are ready and able to do their duty. The point here in the article is that it was just not the American people that would look bad from this vigilantly justice but, the society and nation as a whole was being scrutinized.
He continues this argument by examining America's past, one that is very much violent. He states that, "…violence is as American as apple pie, a point that would not have been lost on the crowd that strung up Robert Prager…and then dropped him three times in the words of one participant ‘one for the red, one for the white, and one for the blue." Mr. Capozzola shows that the people that committed these acts were not anti American, they thought they were the pro-America at its finest.
Woodrow Wilson as the article points out, government sought out to clarify the nations "standards of law and right." This article in the first section shows that when it came down to vigilantism in the World War I era the line is a little grey. He points out that the same officials that spoke out against lawless vigilantism stood up for the idea of vigilance organizations' policing. The idea behind this that Christopher speaks of is that uncontrolled physical violence was politically illegitimate because it went against the nation and the spirit of their laws.
The problem Capozzola sees in his article is that the American people were used to policing themselves and for that to work many people saw coercion and mob violence to fit under that category of self policing. The other grey area in all this is the fact that mob violence was never...

Find Another Essay On The Only Badge Needed is Your Patriotic Fervor: Vigilance, Coercion and the Law in World War I America

America and The First World War

498 words - 2 pages right to vote, because they “had shown that their strength and independence was equal to men” and had proven themselves worthy during the devastating war (McCrae). The League of Nations came into being after the end of WWI. The League of Nation's mission was to ensure that war never broke out again (Smikin). The country as a whole was appalled by the carnage that had taken place in what was intended to be a civilized part of the world. The only

America and the First World War

652 words - 3 pages America and the First World WarWhen war erupted in 1914, the United States attempted to remain neutral and was a proponent for the rights of neutral states. Isolationist foreign policy was encouraged by Congress's apprehensions about giving other countries a political door into US policies and the cultural melting pot of the United States' population. In spite of these factors, the United States did enter World War I, as a result of several

World War I: The West in Despair

1186 words - 5 pages "The Great War" as it came to be known was supposed to be the war to end all wars. World War I left an unforgettable mark in history as it shook the elitist governments of Europe and Asia to the core, scarred the face of Europe, saw the appearance of the greatest nation, the United States, and set the stage for a global economic crisis and the next world war. I will be discussing and explaining the main factors that led to the war. The cause of

Race Discrimination and The World War I

1090 words - 5 pages World War I was a life-changing moment in African-American history. It impacted all African Americans, no matter gender, class, or origin. Although the it had a larger impact on those who lived in the South. African-American soldiers actually served in the army for the United States way before the Great War. But World War I marked a turning point for colored soldiers, not only on the battlefield but when they returned home as well. It was

Brief Analysis of industrial work, politics, law, and foreign relations from the Civil War to World War I

1874 words - 7 pages In the decades after the Civil War, an "Engine of Change" spread across America (LN 9/11). This engine had five chief causes: government assistance, availability of resources, human capital, foreign capital, and technology. From the second Industrial Revolution to World War I, America witnessed a period of reaction that shaped the twentieth century. The Engine of Change affected the worlds of industrial work, politics, law, and foreign

Excessively Negative Views of America and World War II in Adams' The Best War Ever

815 words - 3 pages primarily correct information, however, it is overly negative in order to create an audience that questions and contradicts the popular belief of utter glory and success. Adams argues that Americans have an intriguing way on which they view certain aspects of history; people tend to often only remember the good and to evade the bad. “To make World War Two into the best war ever, we must leave out the area bombings and other questionable aspects while

World War I Weapons and Their Impact on the War

796 words - 4 pages Throughout World War One, the way the war was fought was changing drastically over time. The weapons being used were constantly advancing based on what the soldiers needed to help them defeat the enemy. Each country was trying to outdo the others. Throughout World War One, several new weapons were released to the soldiers such as rifles and machine guns. The weapons manufactured during World War One, such as the rifles and machine guns, forever

The Patriot Act is Not so Patriotic

832 words - 3 pages The USA Patriot Act was designed and passed by Congress six weeks after the World Trade Center terrorist attacks on September 11, 2001 in New York. The USA Patriot Act (Uniting and Strengthening America by Providing Appropriate Tools Required to Intercept and Obstruct Terrorism Act of 2001) drastically increases the surveillance, and investigative powers of law enforcement agencies. It also increases the discretion of law enforcement and

World War I Results in Liberty and Free Enterprise in America

832 words - 4 pages Throughout the 1920’s,traditional American values such as liberty and free enterprise became significantly more present in certain groups of society as a result of World War 1. The traditional American value of liberty was significantly present in the group of rich industrialists, which was led by Henry Ford in the 1920’s. In the 1920’s rich industrialists were greatly benefited by free enterprise policies of the republican government. As

Gun Control Is needed in America

682 words - 3 pages Now a day, owning a gun is simply viewed as apart of the American culture and heritage. And with all the youngsters praising and itching to get a firearm in their hands, it's even more tempting and fashionable for one to show off their shooter around their friends and dangling it off in their hands. The streets of America have become known for the most dangerous and the most shooting homicides. People want guns because they simply fear guns

Why isn't America Patriotic?(Includes quotes from numerous groups and dicusses the USA Patriot)

1519 words - 6 pages Why isn't America Patriotic?There is a day America lost its freedom that many Americans have fought to keep sacred. This day was on October 26, 2001. George W. Bush signed the USA Patriot Act, which broadly expands the powers of federal law enforcement agencies investigating cases involving foreign intelligence and international terrorism. This act was passed to help prevent terrorism in the United States of America. It was intended to protect

Similar Essays

The Patriotic America This Is A Research Paper About The History, Changes, And Effects Of Partiotism In America

1788 words - 7 pages In times of war, the patriotic fervor of the United States increases dramatically. Somehow patriotism holds the people of a country together, but all the while it seems to separate humans across the globe with the idea that supporting one's country means despising the rest. The suggestion that one country ranks the best of all countries promotes a type of monolithic and narrow-minded society that should have disappeared ages ago. However

Why The Allies Needed Canada In World War Two

1535 words - 7 pages protecting its allies from U-Boats. Protecting the Allies from U-Boats was crucial because U-Boats were a major threat that threatened the preparedness and effectiveness of the Allied countries. “‘The only necessity in war,’ argued Marder, ‘ is to stop submarines [from] sinking ships...to keep [them] out of the way.’ Canadian escort and support groups in the North Atlantic, supported by the RCAF… achieved that aim… Canadian Naval Board policy

Coercion, The State, And Anarchy Essay

2982 words - 12 pages , surely it could be mitigated, but how much ‘good’ is enough? And can we really ever justify the indefinite use of coercion based solely upon favorable outcomes that have occurred in the past? If we cannot, then the only option that may be justified could be anarchy. Begin by examining the laws of different countries: we find that the ways in which these laws vary depends largely upon lawmakers in said countries. Often, these lawmakers propose

The Great Patriotic War: Conflicts In The Air

1258 words - 6 pages and well equipped, having flown hundreds of sorties during the Spanish Civil War in the then-advanced Messerschmitt Bf-109, and fully prepared for the invasion. In contrast, the Soviets, most with little combat experience and equipped with inferior aircraft, like the Polikarpov I-153 Chaika & the Polikarpov I-16, were caught off guard with little time to react, resulting in more than 300 aircraft shot down and 1400 destroyed on the ground, all in