This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Juvenile Court System Is Distinct From Adult Courts

2010 words - 8 pages

July 15, 1999, was an ordinary night for Kristopher Lohrmeyer as he left work at the Colorado City Creamer, a popular ice cream parlor. Kristopher had no idea that his life was about to end. When Michael Brown, 17, Derrick Miller and Andrew (Andy) Medina, 15, approached Kristopher and demanded his money and his car keys. Before the boys knew it shots had been fired and Kristopher was dead. About an hour after the fatal shooting of Kristopher Lohrmeyer, all three men were in custody and telling their version of the night’s events. Michael and Derrick who had run away after the shooting confessed to police and named Andy as the shooter. According to the three boy’s testimony, they had only recently met and needed away to get some quick cash, so they developed a carjacking scheme and headed to Andy’s house to pick up 2 stolen handguns. The three boys were uneducated and had spent most of their time on the streets in search of drugs. The judge ruled that they would be held without bail and there was probable cause to charge them all with first-degree murder (Thrown Away, 2005).
Michael and Derrick both struck a deal in exchange for implicating Andy as the one who fired the fatal shots. Under Colorado’s felony murder rule, Andy could be found guilty of first-degree murder just for simply participating in a violent felony. Of the three boys, Andy would be the only one to stand trial for first-degree murder, which could carry a mandatory sentence of life without parole. In May 2001, Andy went to trial, after a brief deliberation, the jury found Andy guilty of robbery and murder in the first-degree. Andy has been serving his sentence in a Colorado State Penitentiary, the state’s “supermax” high-security prison for the past 9 years and is in the process of requesting an appeal based on ineffective assistance of counsel (Thrown Away, 2005). Medina’s story was featured in the 2005 series “Thrown Away” published by Human Rights Watch.
The Juvenile Court System is Distinct from Adult Courts
How can a 15 year old boy be sent to an adult prison for the rest of his life? In order to answer that question we must first understand the history of the Juvenile Justice System. Social conditions during the progressive era, 1890-1920, were characterized by large waves of immigration and an increase in children left wandering in the streets (Reuters, 2011). According to Reuters, hundreds of indigent children were left to find ways to survive in a new place with little to no assistance, from family or government, many typically ended up getting involved in criminal activity. This led to a large increase of children in the adult court systems, as children were treated and punished like adults many were sent to adult institutions. For instance, under English common law, children who were under the age of 7 were considered to lack the cognitive capacity to know and understand the aftermath of their actions. Therefore, without criminal intent, or mens rea,...

Find Another Essay On The Juvenile Court System is Distinct from Adult Courts

Report of Downing Court (local, civil and district courts) and the Roles and Responsibilities in the Court System

2098 words - 8 pages 1. On arrival at the downing courts on Liverpool St, the court officer Richard took the commerce II students on a tour. The students were provided with a brief history on the building before they were taken to courtroom 2 on level one. Here Richard explained the role and jurisdiction of both the local and district courts as well as the layout of the court room. He also explained that the Australian court system is arranged in a hierarchy.The

Justice system in the USA: Should Juvenile be tried as adult

1562 words - 6 pages , both juvenile and adult system has changed over the years (Simmons 2002). The death penalty is a conservational issue in the criminal justice system today. Capital punishment is allowed in 35 states. Over the past years some of those that were executed were seventeen years old when they committed the crime of murder. The Supreme Court ruled in the case of Thompson v. Oklahoma 1988 that it is unconstitutional to execute juveniles who commit a

The Puritan Court System

1211 words - 5 pages system, it is necessary to learn about the structure of the courts. The General Court was the highest body in the Puritan Court System. The General Court of Massachusetts was a legislative, administrative, and judicial body (Breen 1). An important change came when Puritan leaders shifted the government to New England from London. This caused the locals in New England to start running the government, instead of Men in England (Breen 1). The General

The Canadian Juvenile Justice System

1131 words - 5 pages , Canada government practised a new juvenile justice system, the Youth Criminal Justice Act, which had taken about 7 years for the government to adjust and modify over the previous law YOA. This new law covers the 12-17 year-old juvenile delinquency. Children under the age of 12 are exempted from criminal prosecution. As Makarenko said, the Youth Criminal Justice Act is "contemporary reforms of youth justice in Canada" (2007, p.5). The act clarifies

English Law - The Court System

657 words - 3 pages court system is the doctrine president, this plays a very important part of the English judicial system. The doctrine president means that courts are "bound by an earlier decision on the same point made by the same court or a higher court." For this reason lawyers who argue in courts started publishing collections of important decisions, to remind the courts of its previous decisions .The doctrine president is one of the main reasons as to why the

The United States Juvenile Justice System

868 words - 3 pages juvenile delinquents. The juvenile justice system applies criminal law to persons not old enough to be held responsible for criminal acts. The age for criminal culpability is usually 18. The goal of the juvenile justice system is still to rehabilitate, but if juveniles commit serious enough crimes they can be transferred into adult court if juvenile court waives or relinquishes jurisdiction.The characteristics of the modern juvenile court have

History of the Juvenile Justice System

3102 words - 12 pages .334). Law enforcement agencies send around two-thirds of all detained children to a court with juvenile authority for further evaluation (Johnson, 2011). With law enforcement, the court can make a decision to redirect various juveniles away from the recognized justice system to other agencies for examination. Prosecutors may direct some juvenile cases straight to adult criminal court. The end effect is that juvenile courts formally process over

Little Justice in The Juvenile Justice System

808 words - 4 pages juvenile court was created to handle juvenile offenders on the basis of their youth rather than their crimes” (cliffs notes). This is unfair because they base their decisions on how old the child is. What do they think this is, school? In school, they basically teach children based on their age, not on how much they know already. The court system shouldn’t be like school. Kids know what they are doing. If they are able to do these heinous

Future of the Juvenile Justice System

2125 words - 9 pages our efforts on "nipping the problem in the bud" or attempt to save the apple from spoiling while it's still young and on the tree, we will be able to positively affect crime in the juvenile and adult justice systems.The Juvenile Justice SystemJuvenile justice first received help in the Supreme Court in the 1960's in a case called Kent v. United States; this case started the due process for juveniles. The Supreme Court stated that "…the

Girls in the juvenile justice system

1311 words - 6 pages justice system, girls are more likely than boys to suffer from PTSD and other internalizing emotional disorders such as depression, anxiety, and suicidal ideation” (p.2). Given the high rates of mental health disorders of female offenders, it is imperative that services be offered. However, girls with conduct disorders are far less likely than their male colleagues to find, receive, or complete treatment. Girls in the juvenile justice system

Girls in The Juvenile Justice System

1464 words - 6 pages system, girls are more likely than boys to suffer from PTSD and other internalizing emotional disorders such as depression, anxiety, and suicidal ideation” (p.2). Given the high rates of mental health disorders of female offenders, it is imperative that services be offered. However, girls with conduct disorders are far less likely than their male colleagues to find, receive, or complete treatment. Girls in the juvenile justice system are at a

Similar Essays

The Juvenile Court System Essay

784 words - 3 pages trial is to keep the public from branding the minor a criminal. The court system still has to work out more rights violations. Females are treated differently in the juvenile court system. Parents tend to tolerate misbehavior in a boy, but are more strict with girls. A result of these actions show an increasing number of females entering the juvenile court system at a growing, and alarming rate. Once in the court system they are handed

Juvenile And Adult Courts A Comparative Analysis

1522 words - 6 pages brought to a juvenile court and if the crime is more severe, an adult court may be more appropriate. The author will discuss the differences between adult and juvenile courts. Finally, it will discuss what can happen if juvenile courts are abolished and implications for young offenders.Compare and ContrastThe juvenile court system has been in existence since 1899 (Kerbs, n.d.). Although this does not show how long juvenile crimes have been taking

Juvenile And Adult Courts: A Comparative Analysis

1833 words - 7 pages execution of juveniles. In the present day the increasing violence, both juvenile and adult system has changed over the years (Simmons 2002).The juvenile philosophy in juvenile courts was to offer the youth an individualized justice and treatment instead of imparting justice and punishment. The juvenile court is different then adult court and from earlier periods of American history was the idea of protecting the children.The focus is treatment and

Waiver To Adult Courts Impact For Juvenile Offenders

1266 words - 6 pages waived to adult court each year. Mechanisms of waiver to adult court. According to Mears (2003) in 1999, juvenile courts waved less than 1 % of the 1.7 million cases that were referred to the juvenile courts. According to Griffin (2008) ever since the initial installment of the juvenile court system judges were able to designate cases that met certain criteria to adult court. This process is described as the “jurisdictional transfer”. According