This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Legal And Ethical Aspects Of Drug Screening In The Workplace

771 words - 3 pages

The Legal and Ethical Aspects of Drug Screening in the WorkplaceIntroductionWorkplace drug screening policies in America revolve around the risk management views of corporate accountants and lawyers, and do not consider the individual rights of employees. Risk management can be defined as the process of analyzing exposure to risk and determining how to best handle that exposure ( Since companies are concerned with profitability, the risk can further be defined as what is the financial cost vs. the financial benefit of implementing a drug screening policy.In the article "Employer Drug Testing Has Pitfalls" by Lee Fletcher (Fletcher, 2000, 1-2), he interviews 5 different companies about the downside to drug screening. Company policy makers are asked about their considerations. Each company’s answers were all about consistent implementation in order to minimize liability. The liability had to do with poor performance at work, and the costs of increased injury. One company interviewed was against drug screening, but not because of the ethical implication, but because of the financial risk of litigation making it too expensive.Few would argue that drug use in the workplace affects a company's profitability, but the question as to whether this should be the only concern remains. What about the majority of a company's employees that do not use drugs? Do these companies have the right to ignore the rights of individuals not under suspicion, and the rights of those individuals that practice their drug use on occasion without any affect to their performance?"The process is a waste of resources and a violation of civil liberties, according to the ACLU. They contend that a decade of drug testing has failed to produce evidence that testing curbs workplace problems and drug abuse. "The evidence shows that [drug testing] is not only morally wrong but a colossal waste of money," said Lewis Maltby, director of the ACLU's Workplace Rights Project. Maltby argues that people "shouldn't be fired for what they do in their off time unless it affects their job performance." Greenberg agrees that there is not enough evidence to show if testing cuts down on overall drug use, but he says it does let the company identify specific drug users. Though he supports drug testing, Eric Wish, PhD, director of the Center for Substance Abuse Research at the University of Maryland, said, "Still, I don't know of any evidence that someone who casually uses marijuana . . .has more accidents than anyone else."( testing of millions of workers doesn't enhance labor productivity...

Find Another Essay On The Legal and Ethical Aspects of Drug Screening in the Workplace

Drug Testing in the Workplace Essay

3716 words - 15 pages considered. Furthermore, they argue that this government was partially created because of King George?s treatment of the settlers, treatment which included unreasonable, indiscriminate searches. As a result, the ACLU thinks it is completely irrational for the government to allow such searches (?Drug Testing in the Workplace?).      There are numerous different ethical issues that can also be tied in with the legal issues. First, there is the

Drug Testing in the Workplace Essay

1885 words - 8 pages medical costs and benefits, are absent up to 16 times more often, and are 1/3 less productive (Drug Screening 1). Another study shows that workers who are under the influence of drugs are 3.6 times more likely to injure themselves or another person in a workplace accident. In addition, they are 2.5 times more likely to have absences of eight days or more, and five times more likely to file a workers compensation claim (Drug Test 1). ). For this

The Legal and Ethical Environment of Business

601 words - 2 pages employees and customers, the situation must be immediately addressed. Although businesses such as DWI must comply with legal standards such as Civil Rights laws and other labor laws we must also consider the ethical issues. The case of Katzenbach v. McClung, 379 U.S. 294 was heard by the U.S. Supreme Court in 1964. The case included arguments against a restaurant that provided in store service to Caucasian customers, but take out to African

Legal Issues In The Workplace

1486 words - 6 pages Case for Human Resources as a Strategic Partner In an era of organizational flux due to competition and globalization, companies and employees are faced with constant change. Leaders must be able to adapt to change as the environment shifts. HR has been known as the organizational change agent, administrative expert, and employee advocate. More recently they have been regarded as business strategic partners for many organizations. In order

Ethical Dilemmas in the Workplace

660 words - 3 pages In Module 1, Kindred Todd faced quite a few ethical dilemmas that included her values and technical ineptness. The first predicament was tested her personal morals and ethics. According to, Cumming and Worley, OD practitioners are dealing more and more with value conflicts with powerful outside groups (Cummings & Worley, 2008). Kindred was immediately faced with the issue of knowing what was ethically correct but being told the unethical

The Moral, Legal, and Economical Aspects of Capital Punishment

1552 words - 6 pages Capital punishment has long been a topic for heated debate throughout the United States of America and the civilized world. For many politicians, the death penalty has been a key pillar to winning a state or election; and, to some extent, politics have been a key influence in America’s justice system. Many nations have outlawed capital punishment, with the United States included between 1972 and 1976. In the United States, there has been a

Legal, Safety and Requlatorly Requirement in the Workplace

714 words - 3 pages rights just but a few. Over time there has been change of behaviour. The workforce has embraced ligation in order to reduce disputes and turnovers .There by replacing common sense and compassion. In the workplace you find that it is now more leaning towards legal and regulatory requirements .The human resource department is in charge of training, educating, enforcing legal and regulatory requirements. . Regulatory requirements are enforced to

Legal Aspects of "The French Lieutenant's Woman"

786 words - 3 pages matter to court it may be indicative of a slightly lower social status. In the Victorian Age (1850-1900) breach of promise actions were considered vulgar by the upper classes. Sarah's disappearance can be attributed to her resentment as she felt there was no remedy for the bias in society in looking down on people who are not of the same social class and break the "moral code of laws." Some of the legal issues in this novel referring to marriage

Against Drug Testing In The Workplace

1736 words - 7 pages Abstract The issue of drug testing in the workplace has sparked an ongoing debate among management. There are many who feel that it is essential to prevent risks to the greater public caused by substance abuse while on the job. However, others believe that the costs far outweigh the benefits and that it is an invasion of privacy. Putting all ethical issues aside, evidence presented in this paper supports the latter. The costs of drug testing

No Drug Testing in the Workplace

1214 words - 5 pages law enforcement function. The term 'drug testing' refers to the analysis of biological material to detect drugs or their metabolites in the body. The issue of drug testing is complex and has scientific, ethical, economic, legal and social dimensions.(Durham) However, the questions that it raises are not simply technical ones for the relevant experts. They include questions about the rapidly changing nature of work and leisure in the modern world

Ethical Issue in the Workplace and Its Moral Implication

1347 words - 5 pages include these individuals raising the issue of ethical practice in the workplace. The GM used the low revenue generated by those individuals as a justification to their termination and by explaining that lowering the amount of sales professionals would raise the sales of those still employed. The moral of the workplace is mixed in emotions for those who still are employed and reflected a weak ethical stand from the GM.Moral implications. Moral values

Similar Essays

Workplace Drug Screening Option Paper

1772 words - 7 pages . Santa ClaraUniversity. Retrieved September 14, 2009, from, Lena. (2005-2008). The Ethics of Drug Testing in the Workplace. Articlesbase. RetrievedSeptember 14, 2009, from Scope. (2003). Drug Testing at Work: Legal and Ethical Issues. Retrieved September 16, 2009, from http

Psy 425 Workplace Drug Screening Opinion Paper

1143 words - 5 pages Job Redesign and Workplace Rewards Assessment PaperAccording to the Business Dictionary, an employee is "an individual who works part time or full time under a contract of employment, whether oral or written, express or implied, and has recognized rights and duties. Also called a worker" (2008). To classify employee position, "job analysts needs to collect information and then develop a job description. This is a way of determining the

Legal And Ethical Responsibilities Toward Drug Abuse

1806 words - 7 pages Role in Identifying and Responding toMethamphetamine Use and the Drug Endangered Child. ADHA Access, March:24-27.American Dental Hygienists Assoc (2007). Bylaws Code of Ethics, Retreived March 11,2009, from, P., Odom, J., (2001). Ethical Principles in Clinical DecisionMaking. Journal of the California Dental Hygienists’ Association, Volume 17,No. 1, Fall.Ethics and Law in Dental Hygiene, Phyllis L Beemsterboer, RDH, MS, EdD Saunders,2002.(One more resource coming soon!)

Ethical Standards And Technology In The Workplace

997 words - 4 pages There are many areas in which technology affects our lives in the workplace. The high-level of ethical standards at Delta Airlines goes hand-in-hand with technology. In order for Delta to maintain a high-level of ethical standards Delta relies on technology to assist them in their goal. The use of the internet is mandatory for a company that is as large and diverse as Delta but what is available to be viewed is regulated by technology. The use