The Legal Issues Surrounding Packet Sniffing

995 words - 4 pages

During a conversation last year with a Houston-based network administrator, I asked, “Is wire sniffing at some random public WiFi hotspot illegal?” “No, not at all. It’s just passive…and besides, anyone stupid enough to pass their sensitive information over an unsecure network gets what they deserve.” As it turns out, he was wrong, but he’s not alone in his confusion.
A quick search shows that many other people are curious about the legality of packet sniffing, but that the advice they get is contradictory. According to Ohm, Sicker, and Grunwald (2007), some of the top justifications for sniffing without consent include:
• “It’s my network, so I can do whatever I want.”
• “The network wiretapping laws have an exception for academic research.”
• “Packet sniffing is legal so long as you filter out data after the 48th (or 96th or 128th byte)”
• “Capturing content may be illegal, but capturing non-content is fine”
• “We’re not breaking the law because we’ve anonymized the data”
• “Data sent over a wireless network is available to the public, so capturing it is legal.” (Ohm, 2007 p. 1)
Ultimately, the court of law, not the court of public opinion, is the deciding factor in legality. So why isn’t the issue clear cut and widely known? The laws that govern packet sniffing, the Federal Wiretap Act and the Pen Register and Trap and Trace Act, were written more than 50 years ago and were meant to apply to the wire tapping of phones. Later, in 1986, packet transmissions were added to the list of covered communications. The Patriot Act of 2001 also amended the body of law. Between this patchwork of jury rigged laws and the legitimate exceptions to the law, it is often unclear what restrictions apply to which activities.
It is fairly simply to see that gathering content, such as chat communications and emails, is unethical; its pure illegality is defined by the Federal Wiretap Act of 1968. However, some believe that there are no laws covering non-content such as headers of HTTP requests and emails, and prior to 2001 this was in fact the case. After the Patriot Act of 2001 amended the Pen Register and Trap and Trace Act, that loophole was closed. Exceptions to this can be made for network administrators (via the Electronic Communications Privacy Act) that use packet sniffing solely for monitoring purposes and for law enforcement officials.
How, then, can one legally sniff a network? Only by the consent of all users being monitored. In some states, such as Texas, implicit consent may be obtained when the law only requires one party of a communication to be notified. However, it would be best to assume that explicit consent of both parties is required from at least an ethical standpoint.
It is easy to assume that in this day and age, most reputable websites would engage in some form of secure transmissions of sensitive data. Indeed, when I used WireShark to view network traffic during the login procedures at major websites such...

Find Another Essay On The Legal Issues Surrounding Packet Sniffing

Legal and Geographic Issues on the Internet

2086 words - 8 pages Legal and Geographic Issues on the Internet   Abstract    Many states and nations have conflicting laws regarding what type of digital content is legal.  When content is legal at its place of origin but illegal where it is downloaded the laws become unenforceable because no single jurisdiction applies.  International cooperation and Internet fragmentation are potential solutions, but neither is currently viable.  This paper discusses how

Medical Ethics - The essay primarily discusses autonomy and legal issues as they relate to medical ethics issues.

1071 words - 4 pages Medical Ethics and AutonomyThe term autonomy is derived from the Greek autos, which means self and from the term nomos meaning rule, governance or law. To be autonomous is to be self-determined and to be in control of one's life. In regards to medical care, being autonomous refers to one making a decision regarding personal medical care issues for his or her self.Autonomy focuses on respecting the ability of a person to make health care

Legal and Ethecal Issues that impacted on the delivery of mental health care.

2214 words - 9 pages This essay explore the ethical, legal, and professional issues that impact upon the delivery of mental health care delivered to a client, it will also refer to recommendation for change in practice regarding the delivery of such care. The rational for choosing this client was because of issues relating to the fragmentation of his coping mechanism; perception; and support, which led to his crisis situation, which resulted in him threatening to

Legal and Ethical Issues of Reporting Abuse in Both Children and the Elderly

779 words - 4 pages Reporting abuse has been a legal and ethical dilemma for years in the healthcare system. Some physicians, nurses, and other healthcare workers are quick to report abuse while others are more reluctant to report abuse in fear of overreacting to an occurrence. This leaves children and the elderly in unknown state of protection from their abusers. While these medical personnel are reluctant to report abuse, there are approximately 2,000

Assisted Suicide Paper-The need to have an understanding of the moral, legal and ethical issues facing clinicians dealing with end of life issues. . .

2100 words - 8 pages Assisted Suicide PaperFebruary 26, 2004AbstractThe need to have an understanding of the moral, legal and ethical issues facing clinicians dealing with end of life issues. Those who treat patients approaching the end of life often face moral, ethical, and legal issues involving shared decision-making, futility, the right to refuse medical treatment, euthanasia, and physician-assisted suicide. This paper will address the following; An overview of

Legal Issues In The Workplace

1486 words - 6 pages people related business issues” (Noe et al., 2002, 59) which is the primary function of HR. “Once the strategy has been determined, HRM has a profound impact on the implementation of the plan by developing and aligning HRM practices that ensure that the company has motivated employees with the necessary skills” (Noe et al., 2002, 83). HR must enact its own strategies which can aid the organization in meeting its goals and mission. They are

The Issues Surrounding the Possibility of Modern Day Artificial Cloning

1673 words - 7 pages With the invention of cloning, several important questions have arisen. There are many incorrect ideas of what human cloning is. Cloning is the creation of an organism that is an exact genetic copy of another. This means that every single part of DNA is the same between the two. Because of this definition, any identical twin could also be considered a clone. However, it is artificial cloning that has sparked the interest of scientists in

A Report on the issues surrounding the Green Revolution

1127 words - 5 pages benefited one group of people and has resulted in the majority of wealth being concentrated into the hands of only a select few. The effects of the revolution have created an even greater gap between the rich and poor, have caused massive environmental damage, and has above all else, failed to solve the problems of world starvation. Many believe that a second Green Revolution will occur in the next few years, in an effort to correct the mistakes of 60's and 70's, perhaps by addressing theses issues, the next revolution with benefit the majority of people instead of just a select few.

What are the Economic Issues Surrounding Divorce or Relational Split?

1782 words - 8 pages ; money issues. It puts its place into economics due to the supply and demand for divorce today. While divorce could have its benefits to economics, it also has several issues. The economic issues that occur are the amount of settlements and income tax; the amount one must pay in court and lawyer fees; and problems with children of divorce and child support the other separated parents must pay to one another. Those issues can put problems into their

Cost of Glory: The Issues Surrounding Football Injuries

1000 words - 4 pages emotional issues such as anger and depression, rapid memory deterioration, and lack of emotional ties. The ex-players have trouble functioning in normal society because of a game they played for 9 nine years. In the worst case scenarios, players have committed suicide, which can be linked with the postconcussion symptom. There is no reason for someone to participate in something that will greatly affect their well being just for money and to

Write an essay of 1000 words stating whether Australia will become a Republic within 20 years & some of the legal issues that relate.

1486 words - 6 pages document. Simply 'excising' the Crown from such a rigid document would in itself prove a legal minefield.Australia is already an independent and sovereign nation so there is no real sense of urgency in dealing with the issue. Without that sense of urgency, taking into account the ramifications and issues surrounding such a move, as well as the current sociographics and demographics, it is unlikely Australia will become a republic within the next

Similar Essays

Legal Issues Surrounding First Aid Essay

1657 words - 7 pages a victim, a survey of the area is necessary to determine if conditions surrounding the incident may place the victim and the rescuer in danger. Next, the primary survey will determine if lifesaving procedures must be immediately performed to save the victim's life. The primary survey involves checking the ABC's: A: Is the airway opened and the victim's neck stabilized? B: Is the patient breathing? C: Is the victim's blood circulating? Is

[Legal Studies]Discuss The Issues Surrounding Ivf Surrogacy And Cloning, Showing Both Sides Of The Argument And Also At The Same Time, Give Your Opinion

1818 words - 7 pages twin...only a but younger.There for who is the parent of the clone? The cloned person, the egg provider, the surrogate mother or is it the doctors and scientists? If human cloning ever does become legal these issues must be addressed.It is true that no two people are the same, cloning is the only thing that could ever really change this. Research could be done as to how personalities are developed by studying what affects the child. Two children

The Legal And Social Issues Surrounding Dna Databanking

1914 words - 8 pages unprocessed DNA samples increase, the statutes of limitations to convict offenders are growing nearer. CODIS is an effective method of comparing a suspect’s DNA sample with samples collected from the crime scene, as well as registered samples from prior criminal investigations. For judicial and legislative personnel involved in the legal proceedings, this can provide a form of evidentiary support against the suspect that may be difficult to argue

Issues Surrounding The Death Penalty Essay

1189 words - 5 pages Issues Surrounding the Death Penalty Does executing murderers really stop violent crime in the U.S.? Our government seems to think so. In many states the death penalty still exists or is being reinstated. Many people contend that the death penalty should be used in cases of heinous crime where guilt is obvious. Bill Clinton signed a bill adding 58 more crimes that are punishable by death. For example, if you see a murder