This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Life You Can Save Essay

1212 words - 5 pages

In this paper I will begin by explaining Singer’s utilitarian argument in “The Life You Can Save” regarding the obligation of affluent nations to give in order to alleviate global poverty. Secondly, I will analyze one objection to Singer’s argument that opposes charity. Thirdly, after examining the objection to Singer’s argument, I will present Singer’s noteworthy reply. Finally, after offering both an objection to Singer’s argument, as well as Singer’s rebuttal, I will offer my own view on whether or not Singer’s refutation is convincing.
In discussing Singer’s argument, it is important to explain his definition of global poverty. Singer clearly states that extreme poverty is “not only a condition of unsatisfied material needs” but also a “degrading state of powerlessness” (6). Singer’s argument asserts that citizens of affluent nations are behaving erroneously because they fail to contribute to the end of poverty they know to exist in impoverished countries. He postulates that the common person has the ability to point fingers at others, while he or she nevertheless ought to do as much as they can. Singer's argument is a direct criticism of a capitalistic system where extreme wealth exists next to extreme poverty. For Singer, the ethical call to assist in eradicating poverty rests in a person’s ability to help another. In his full argument, Singer considers three premises. The first is common knowledge that suffering and death is inherently bad. Singer’s argument for the Golden Rule is encapsulated in this premise: “doing unto others, as you would have them do unto you” (16). No sane person would like to suffer; therefore, it is only moral to help those who are suffering. Singer contends in the next premise that individuals have the obligation to alleviate global poverty by sacrificing small commodities such as bottled water, clothes, etc. He articulates that with having the power to prevent poverty, it is our duty to do so. Finally, he believes it is a moral imperative to give to a reliable charity as most people in the developed world live admittedly better than King Louis XIV of France and can afford such an expense without sacrificing anything “nearly as important” (Singer 15). Singer proposes that “nearly as important” is a vague statement. It connotes that a person cannot say, for example, saving one’s child is more important than saving the lives of multiple children in another country, as a hardened fact. It is perceptibly more important for someone to save his or her child, while to a third party observer more lives saved is morally more important. Therefore, “nearly as important” allows some wiggle room in order to allow people to be honest with themselves about right and wrong. Essentially, Singer says that if an individual has the ability to give, there is no substantial reason not to do so. It is not a question of whether or not to give, but how much.
Singer offers many objections to his argument, but I will focus on the most...

Find Another Essay On The Life You Can Save

The life you save may be your own - math - homework

758 words - 4 pages Lilly Moreland Branson 4 11/26/17 Symbolism in Literature In literature, symbolism is used to give something qualities and meaning much deeper than shown. Many people overlook symbols when reading literature because the symbols aren’t always obvious, but recognizing symbolism can give readers a whole new understanding of the story. Flannery O’Connor’s use of symbolism and imagery in her story “The Life You Save May be Your Own” helps portray the

Your Body is trying to Destroy You! Genetic Mapping can help Save You

1625 words - 7 pages treatment that has shown to have a higher chance of succeeding provided by genetic mapping. Now, there is an option to have tumors genetically mapped so that cancer treatments can be more personalized. Also, because of genetic mapping doctors are making connections and have a greater understanding on how cancers are formed and how different types of cancers relate to each other. Now, a person can have a treatment that works in their favor on the

How Sleep Can Save Your Life

854 words - 4 pages How Sleeping Can Save Your Life Without sleep humans would struggle more than a teenager in high school. Sleep is a fundamental part of human life. Sleep helps the human body remain in homeostasis, or maintaining stability. Highschoolers are notorious for falling asleep in class, right? Well actually teenagers have different sleep schedule than other adults. In fact, if the groups are aggregated into ages, not all of the groups are not

Fire Safety Program Can Save A Life

947 words - 4 pages During the fire safety program I learn a lot of important things like fire safety should know. The fire triangle has oxygen, heat, fuel and there has to be one missing for it to go out. Arson is intentionally set fire malius and you also want to cause harm and the possible consequences you can get is restitution, probation, house arrest, community service, out of the home placement, juvenile detention. A first degree arson can be a structure

May be your own Life you Save

966 words - 4 pages One small act can change a person’s life forever. This should have a big effect on you because one kind act can change the attitude of a person in an instant. This effect could be good or it could be bad depending on your attitude towards them. If you do a good deed you will have the good and I like that person vibe and you could have them go from suicidal to making them feel like they are important and worth something in life. Or you could be a

The Analysis of the Characters in “The Life You Save May Be Your Own”

795 words - 3 pages sins that taunt the human mind to do as it pleases not as it should. Flannery O’Connor, the author of “The Life You Save May Be Your Own”, knew the idea of human life beyond just existing. Three of her characters; Tom Shiftlet, Mrs. Lucynell Crater, and the daughter also named Lucynell Crater, show the true meaning of human life. Tom Shiftlet, the traveler, exposes the meaning of life by his turning back to get Lucynell after he leaves her at

Tone and attitude of "The Life You Save may be Your Own, " Flannery O'Connor

526 words - 2 pages In "The Life You Save may be Your Own," Flannery O'Connor descriptively characterizes the battles within oneself with the characters of Mrs. Crater, Tom Shiftlet, and Lucynell Crater. The realistic and truthful tones of their actions suggest that through personal obstacles and flaws, triumph can be obtain by being truthful. All three characters of the story are realistic and truthful in a different way.Mrs. Crater could be considered the most

can solar energy save the world?

687 words - 3 pages , inexhaustible and clean solar energy technologies will have huge longer-term benefits. So knowing that once this technology is accepted then you can enjoy the benefits for a long time also the life of the equipment being at least 20 years. Apart from this there are several subsidies/rebates like 40% off the cost of a solar energy system by some state and city programs and businesses receive a 30% investment tax credit from the federal government as a

how can i save the planet

1541 words - 7 pages , recycling and just cutting down on all the harmful products we buy we can really make a difference. This isn’t going to change overnight but we need to make steps in the right direction before its too late. If I live an optimal life the way I want to and help save the environment it will help the generations to come live their lives the way they want too. I do not want to be the generation that sat around while our Earth died I want to be the generation that did something about it and by doing something about it I will be living my optimal life.

Can Solar Energy Save the World?

676 words - 3 pages Now the current situation the world is experiencing the ‘go green’ movements. This movement was started by environmentalist with the aim to enlighten the damage we are causing on the Earth. In order to save the earth we need to look for alternative sources of energy in order to avoid the fossil fuels resources from being completely depleted. Presently, fossil fuels provide us with heat and electricity. The most commonly used fossil fuels are


2540 words - 10 pages . In addition, let us say that there is really one God who created us, who gave us brain to think and become geniuses, can we consider that maybe God gave us such talent to develop medical tools to help cure the sick people, and to have a better longer life? Therefore, we should not decide to make an action if not all the people are acknowledging it. On the other hand, just like in- vitro fertilization, anonymous sperm donation, and other

Similar Essays

At What Cost Would You Save The Life Of Another?

814 words - 3 pages the world they would not let them live like this, not let other humans be treated so monstrously. Throughout the Holocaust between 11 million and 17 million died. “I was taught that if you see a person drowning you must jump into the water to save them, whether you can swim or not.” (Woo) It is vital that we remember the lessons and history of the Holocaust to prevent such atrocities from happening in the future. You should never be

Duality In "The Life You Save May Be Your Own."

1374 words - 6 pages lupus, and she lived with this disease most of her life (“Flannery” 1050). “The Life You Save May Be Your Own” is a story about a traveler, Mr. Shiftlet, who marries a mentally challenged girl to get an automobile and money from the mother of the girl. In the end, Mr. Shiftlet ends up abandoning the girl. In “The Life You Save May Be Your Own,” O’Connor uses duality to show that people and things can have two sides. In the story, O’Connor

The Life You Save May Be Your Own

683 words - 3 pages Flannery O'Connor's style of southern gothic writing, with her background of Christianity, collaborate for some controversial and unorthodox symbolism. In her short story The Life You Save May Be Your Own, O'Connor incorporates numerous symbols to emphasize her theme. O'Connor's use of symbolism filters into the names and traits of her characters, the dimensions of her setting, and the events of her plot.Mr. Shiftlet is a man who doesn't know

The Life You Save May Be Your Own

800 words - 3 pages OwensThe inability to overcome physical or emotional temptation flaws all humans to some extent, but what make an individual morally reprehensible? In O'Connor's story "The Life You Save May Be Your Own" she paints a complex and elegant answer to the question. Every character in the story has a physical impairment lending to the idea of outward deformities being metaphors for emotional inadequacy. Mr. Tom T. Shiflet lacks the most physically