This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Limbic System Theory Essay

1283 words - 6 pages

-Why does the limbic system theory still persist?
While the concept of the “triune brain” is, as a whole, wrong, MacLean in 1970 did propose some interesting ideas about the evolution of the brain. He proposed that there are three main layers of evolutionary progress in the human brain. It starts in the middle with the most basic, the reptilian brain. The reptilian brain is the brainstem itself, and is responsible for the most basic of survival behaviors. The next layer out is what he called the paleomammilian brain, which is where MacLean says we find the limbic system. This part of the brain deals with social and emotions, and MacLean argues that most mammals have this. The third and most complex layer is the neomammilian or neocortex that deals with the highest of cognitive functions. LeDoux argues that while MacLean was fundamentally wrong about the physical layers of the brain, he was not far from the truth about the evolutionary brain. Emotions at the core are in part for survival, and so therefore the more complex the emotion, the more complex the functions needed.
-What remains relevant in limbic system theory?
Emotions are (in part) for survival, and the more complex the emotion, the more complex the system to process it must be (both in theory and in context). If an emotion or mood is as simple as fight or flight, then this is something that is instilled in reptiles, mammals, and humans alike. These emotions are more easily figured out in the human brain, and seem to be easier to experiment with as well as find out about. There has been a large amount of research on the amygdala and fight or flight response, which as was stated above, is a basic emotion that reptiles, mammals, and humans all seem to have alike. The more complex emotions that not all animals would have seem to be harder to research, harder to find the root of, and also seem to be the most complex emotions in terms of processing and regulating. While MacLean’s triune brain theory was mainly thought to be because of the size of animals’ brains, it is ultimately too simplistic of a theory to be correct.
-What is wrong with limbic system theory?
There are many things wrong with MacLean’s theory that have led most people to believing that there is no such thing as a limbic system, with some professionals even wanting the term to be banned altogether from textbooks and from the biological world. One of the main pieces of evidence against MacLean is that he was much too simplistic in his theories. MacLean believed that there was only one system for regulating emotions, while it is clear that it is much more complex than that. There has been very little evidence and findings to suggest that all of the parts of his limbic system work together, and over the years there has been so much disagreement on what structures should even be included in the limbic system.
Many of the various structures that MacLean originally proposed to be a part of the limbic system do in fact deal...

Find Another Essay On The Limbic System Theory

Brain Development in Victims of Child Abuse

1547 words - 6 pages of the limbic system, and the cerebellar vermis (6). The hippocampus is in charge of creating and retrieving memories, working together with the other parts of the limbic system, such as the amygdala, which records the emotions for each memory. The vermis controls the production and release of two of the catecholamine neurotransmitters, dopamine and norepinephrine (6). Both the vermis and the limbic system have higher concentrations of receptors

Cracks On Glass Essay

973 words - 4 pages emotion-regulating limbic system1. The group concluded that people with autism have a distorted salience landscape. In other words, the connections of the amygdala input and the structures of the limbic system that regulate behavior is altered and therefore, cause extreme emotional responses1. Researchers have found that 1 in 3 autistic children had temporal lobe epilepsy during infancy1. It was caused by repeated passing of nerve impulses crossing

Exploring Emotion

3644 words - 15 pages body on the appropriate course of action (do Amaral). Therefore, if the hippocampus is damaged, the individual has problems learning from past experiences and remembering how to react. The thalamus, the structure on which the Canon-Bard theory focused, does play a significant role in the limbic system. It relays sensory information to the brain where the message can be processed and evaluated (Anatomy of the Brain). It includes

Self Destructive Behavior and Role of the I function

1588 words - 6 pages -harm. In the case of the alcoholic, the increase in dopamine acts as a pleasurable sensation. Perhaps the Lesch-Nyhan patient only feels a sense of pleasure when he is in pain and to please himself he has to continue to inflict pain never being satiated. Is this desire a function of the self or in opposition to it? In the case of harmful behaviors the primitive brain is overriding the I function. The limbic system is the predominate structure

Limbic System

696 words - 3 pages Description: The limbic system is a sophisticated set of brain structures found above the brainstem and below the cerebrum while lying on both sides of the thalamus. It includes a group of brain structures that surround the brainstem such as the amygdala, hypothalamus, thalamus and hippocampus. These are the main structures, but there are also some minor related areas such as the cingulate gyrus, ventral tegmental area, basal ganglia, and the

The Creation of a Serial Killer: Nature vs. Nurture

1481 words - 6 pages . Damage to the temporal lobe can result in hair-trigger violent reactions and increased aggressive responses. Damage to the limbic system can also be a cause of serial killers’ ‘dysfunction’. The limbic system controls emotional responses and motivation. MRI scans of known serial killers show damage to the limbic system, or inactivity. When the limbic brain is damaged, it may account for uncontrollable aggression. In 2000 an article was published in

The Brain

592 words - 2 pages The brain is made of three main parts: the forebrain, midbrain, and the hindbrain. The forebrain is divided into two subdivisions: the telencephalon and the diencephalon. The primary structures of the telencephalon include the cerebral cortex, basal ganglia, and the limbic system. Here the brain is divided between the left and right hemispheres of the cerebral cortex. The left hemisphere controls linguistic consciousness, the right half ofthe

Schizophrenia, a basic definition and description of the illness

1683 words - 7 pages and will blunt their emotions (Torrey, 1983).The part of the brain thought to be affected by schizophrenia is the limbic system. It was realized that the limbic system might be the source of the malfunction when it was discovered that all information and incoming stimuli must pass through the limbic system before being sorted out. Previously the limbic system was disregarded, and considered simply a remnant of our primitive pass. At that time

Psychology; Importance of Sleep

628 words - 3 pages ), the pons, the ascending reticular activating system (ARAS), the basal forebrain, the medulla, the thalamus, the hypothalamus, and the limbic system.No one knows precisely what functions sleep serves, but there are two prominent theories on the subject; the repair/restoration theory and the evolutionary/circadian theory. The repair/restoration theory believes that sleep is a tile for our recuperation, when physical, emotional and intellectual

Procrastination: A Student’s Worst Enemy

1256 words - 6 pages , whether it is peer pressure or a lack of self control, but it all stems from a single point of origin, a battle between two parts of your brain. The first contender is the limbic system. According to an article, “The Science Behind Procrastination” by Amy Spencer, she describes the limbic system as “one of the oldest and most dominant portions of the brain. It tells you to, say, pull your hand away from a flame—and also to flee from unpleasant

New Age of Medicine: Complementary and Alternative Medicine

902 words - 4 pages essential oils that come from the different plants are mixed with a medium like: sunflower oil. The aromatherapy theory states that when you smell an essential oil, it goes to the olfactory system that is found in the nose. Then after it is in the olfactory system it then mingles with limbic system in the brain. The limbic system controls: hormones, memory, breathing and heart rate (Billitterl 35). A few more of the common forms are homeopathy and

Similar Essays

Review The Functions Of The Limbic System. Explain Its Role In The Control Of Major Affective Activities.

1647 words - 7 pages The Limbic system compromises of detailed structures which control and regulate major affective activities such as fright, anxiety, and happiness. Further functions of the limbic system are motor functions, sensory systems, hormones and memory which all contribute to the control of affective states. These factors are controlled and regulated by different structures of the limbic system and work inter-relatedly. The central components of the

Karl Marx’s Theory Of The Capitalist Economic System

1122 words - 4 pages Karl Marx’s was a German philosopher, economist and evolutionary socialist born in Germany on May 5th 1818. His theories mostly consisted of the capitalist economic system. Marx’s attended the University of Bonn and University of Berlin. He is widely recognized for his theory of on the class system which included the concepts of base and super-structure. Marx’s theory of the class system is well exhibited by the documentary film, Class Dismissed

Karl Marx’s Theory Of The Capitalist Economic System

1036 words - 5 pages Karl Marx was born in Trier, Germany in 1818. He was a Economist, Philosopher and a Sociologist. Marx attained his PhD in Philosophy from the University of Berlin in 1841. Among the various theories and concepts developed by Marx, his theory on the capitalist economic system along with the concept of the base and superstructure is what he widely recognized by. Although Marx was born in a fairly wealthy middle class family, Marx has always

Schizophrenia Essay

558 words - 2 pages frightening to others.Schizophrenia affects the normal functioning of the brain that help us to tell the difference between fact and fiction, to think logically, to perceive reality correctly, to have normal emotional responses, and to act appropriately in social situations. The part of the brain thought to be affected by schizophrenia is the limbic system. It was realized that the limbic system might be the source of the malfunction when it was