The Limitations Of Porter’s Six Forces Model In Industry

1734 words - 7 pages

Managers and strategists are often faced with a dilemma while trying to understand the determinants of profitability of industries they compete in as well as potential industries they may wish to compete. To this effect, several analytical frameworks are employed; the most widely used being the Porter’s Six Forces model. This paper seeks to bring to light the shortcomings of using the Porter’s Six Forces model as an analytical framework to determine which industries are profitable or not.
Until the introduction of a “sixth force” in the mid-nineties, the “Porter’s Five Forces Model” as it was originally developed by Michael E. Porter in 1979 explained how “five competitive forces” determine industry attractiveness. Porter opined that in the fight to sustain long-term profitability, a firm must be strategic towards competition, and beyond competition, keep tabs on a broader set of competitive forces; customers who can drive prices down, suppliers who exercise some level of power, new entrants who might come in to compete for profits and substitute products and services that essentially place constraints on the profitability and growth on any industry. With the extension of this model, the sixth force (as shown in exhibit 1) included showed the impact of complimentary products and services on the attractiveness and overall profitability of an industry. In general, the Six Forces model proposes that the underlying structural drivers of any industry determine the performance of the players.
To buttress the implication of the model, Porter explained why the airline industry is the least profitable amongst industries owing to the high threat of the competitive forces. The airline industry players compete heavily on price. Most customers are looking for best deals irrespective of the brand name or carrier. It is difficult to differentiate or get customers to wait one or two extra hours for a flight if they can get a cheaper flight that takes them to their destinations. Suppliers (i.e. airplane and engine producers) coupled with syndicated labor forces erode away the airline’s profit. Constant stream of new entrants coming into airline industry due to low barriers of entry (i.e. a new airline operator can rent a plane, lease a gate, start with one flight between two city pairs, generic technology, etc.). There is a substitute of getting on the train, taking a bus, driving your car or sailing on a ship. Also there are no clear differentiating complements that could change the game in the industry.
Furthermore, he explains that the alignment of the competitive forces changes by industry however, the most salient competitive force or forces are of the greatest value to strategy formulation. That is; there are zero-star industries like the airline industry, there are six-star industries where all the forces are relatively benign and there are industries that have a mix of low, medium and high forces. To this effect, the model gives insights to how...

Find Another Essay On The Limitations of Porter’s Six Forces Model in Industry

Five Forces Model for Industry Analysis

1623 words - 6 pages Five Forces Model for Industry AnalysisNew EntrantsThe online bookstore industry that has pioneered in was, at first, very hard to penetrate. There were different barriers such as distributing capabilities and the variety of the selection offered that are supposed to be hurdled. Amazon successfully solved the tricky parameters as being the first one to get into the whole idea of online retail. With being the first, they had the luxury

Choose the airlines as an industry to apply the Michael Porter's 'five forces' model and discuss how one established airline like SIA should respond to the competitive environment

2109 words - 8 pages QUESTION:The industry analysis is necessary in the strategic marketing planning in order to identify the opportunities and threats in the competitive environment. Choose the airlines as an industry to apply the Michael Porter's 'five forces' model and discuss how one established airline like SIA should respond to the competitive environment, after analyzing the industry.SIA is internationally recognised as one of the world's leading carriers

Analysis of Using Porter’s Five Forces

1567 words - 6 pages music device. The firm uses its Audible manager software in downloading, scheduling, managing and playing audio selections. The manager software also allows customers to listen and download spoken content and transfer to Audible Ready players. The firm is the exclusive provider of digital content. This essay analyzes Porter’s five forces assist to evaluate where the firm’s power lie in a given market and the attractiveness of the

The Strengths and Limitations of the Biological Model of Abnormality

796 words - 3 pages The Strengths and Limitations of the Biological Model of Abnormality This model uses physical illness as a model for psychological disorder, suggesting that like physical illness, mental illness has an underlying bodily cause. It proposes that genetic, organic or chemical disorders cause metal illnesses which give rise to

Criticism of Porter’s Model of National Competitive Advantage

1325 words - 5 pages This study focuses on to discuss the criticism of Porter’s model of national competitive advantage. In order to fully discuss the limitations of Porter’s model of national competitive advantage, the determinants in Porter’s diamond model should be explained. Therefore Porter’s diamond model and its elements are analyzed in the first part of the study while rest of the study is explaining the limitations of the Porter’s diamond model that are

Publix Super Markets: The Five Forces Model of Competition

1358 words - 5 pages competitors is the Five Forces Model of Competition. The five aspects that will be discussed are the threat of new entrants into the market, the bargaining power of suppliers and buyers, threat of substitute products and rivalry among competing firms. Striving for the optimal position in each of these categories has given Publix Super Markets the reputation it has pride towards earning. It is important to every company to keep a balance between these five

The Limitations of Statistics in Crime Solving

1282 words - 6 pages the use of crime statistics when measuring criminal activity there are also some criticisms. Two of the main criticisms include the limitations of statistics in general and the dark figure of crime, which can be described as the undetected or unreported act of crime. The first criticism for using statistics to measure criminal activity is the fact that statistics can be very limiting as there is no way of gaining a complete number of crimes or

The Major Components, Strengths, and Limitations of Urie Bronfenbrenner’s Ecological Systems Model

875 words - 4 pages addition of the chronosystem that Bronfenbrenner highlighted the processes and roles of the person. The Process-Person-Context-Time Model became the underlying principle of the ecological systems theory. Process or proximal processes is the interaction between the developing person and people in their environment to assist in developing skills and knowledge, for example, children interacting with other children. The person aspect acknowledges the

The Statute of Limitations

810 words - 3 pages liabilities, with injuries may take time to manifest, many courts adapted different rules such as postponing the running of the statute until the injury has been reasonably discovered. The length of time differs among states and branches of law (Danzon, 1985). The long and deferred statutes of limitations lead to long tail of claims and contributed majority of medical malpractice and product liability (Danzon, 1985). In this section, statutes of

Limitations of the Paparazzi

1424 words - 6 pages concerned that the cars behind her were paparazzi stalking her. Which in most cases was true, considering the paparazzi were following her most of the time (Simmons). “The paparazzi of Europe are hungry, relentless, fearless, and generally merciless celebrity stalkers, armed with cameras and driven by the thrill of the chase and the desire to bag that single exclusive shot that will sell to a tabloid for five or six figures and makes weeks or months

Limitations of the Gods

833 words - 4 pages In many myth’s the gods seem to be able to everything, and nothing can stop them. As figures who are personifications of things humans cannot understand, they are powerful beings, but even they may have times of struggle. As some stories tell, the gods themselves had weaknesses, and things that they could not achieve. The gods do have human traits or tendencies that often lead to them being unable to do things. Sometimes it was the fact that

Similar Essays

Application Of Porter’s Five Forces Model In The Bpm Industry

1908 words - 8 pages . • There were regulatory concerns against outsourcing. • Sentiments of nationalism. Xara Inc. preferred to opt the Porter’s Model to cope up with the boosting competition in the industry, other issues and challenges confronted by the company. They analysed the five forces and constructed a draft model for implementation. Summary of five competitive forces analysis is mentioned below: 5.1. Threat of New Entrants  Entry barriers: Low The resources

Porter’s Five Forces On The Weight Loss Industry

1116 words - 5 pages combinations, rigid menus, or have no need or advise against exercise (Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics, 2012). WebMD also gives advice to avoid dieting that met much of the same criteria (WebMD LLC, 2012). So with many reliable sources advising against diets like Medifast, what is the profit potential for new entrants into the weight loss industry? A Marketdata Enterprises study estimates $61.6 billion in revenues were generated for the weight

Porter’s Five Forces Of The Government Contracting Industry Umuc Mgmt Org Theory & Behavior Research Paper

1133 words - 5 pages Running Head: Porter’s Five Forces Analysis of The Government Contracting & Procurement Industry Porter’s Five Forces Analysis of the Government Contracting Industry Porter’s Five Forces of the Government Contracting Industry Introduction & Background The U.S government is the world’s largest buyer of products and services. According to the National Contract Management Association, the federal government entered into nearly $450 billion of

Definition And Limitations Of Swot Analysis, Porter’s Five Forces Analysis And Ratio Analysis

1275 words - 6 pages ). Porter’s five forces analysis “Competitive Strategy: Techniques for Analyzing Industries and Competitors” (Porter, 1980), a book by Michael E. Porter where he has explained how certain five competitive forces can help an organisation change its position in industry positively (Recklies, 2001). These five forces are: bargaining power of suppliers, bargaining power of customers, competitive rivalry within the industry, threat of new substitutes and