The Mac Arthur Competence Assessment Tool Criminal Adjudication

1564 words - 6 pages

Research and Evaluation
Forensic Evaluation
Competence to stand trial. The MacArthur Competence Assessment Tool- Criminal Adjudication is used to assess for competency to stand trial. The tool shows understanding, appreciation, and ability to reason (Acklin, 2012). Bobby showed ability to reason when he explained his life history; and gave example of how parents are to protect you not, hurt you. He understood that the abuse and neglect were not signs of protection from a parent. He realized his parents showed no sign of concern for him or his siblings well being.
Risk of Dangerousness. MMPI-2 and PAI show signs of dangerousness in an individual; if violence is accompanied by mental disorder, examples: schizophrenia and antisocial personality disorder (Sinclair, Antonius, Shiva, Siefert, & Kehl-fie, 2010). Bobby only showed signs of violence when he was in ninth grade; and a few times he considered suicide. He was going through puberty when the volatile behavior was active; and suicide was only a passing thought, but never found worth doing. Bobby is not considered a danger to himself or others in a natural state. When the PTSD is under control and Bobby is no longer abusing drugs and alcohol, he should be able to start a new life a part of society, not just in society.
Insanity. Criminal responsibility or not guilty by reason of insanity can be evaluated through the MMPI-2. The validity scales that show if an individual is responsible by responding; knows the difference between right and wrong; or determines if the individual cannot respond to an incident the individual is accused (Walters, 2011). Bobby was aware of what he was doing, knows right and wrong; but Bobby still suffered from a mental illness. The reason for this statement is because Bobby did not steal for financial gain. He took risks climbing in and out of multiple story complexes, not for financial gain. This behavior shows not a sign of sanity.
Treatment Recommendations and Empirical Support
Bobby has been four weeks sober, and appears to be logical. The only issue is Bobby does not see what is wrong with the taking drugs and using alcohol. Growing up he was encouraged by his parents to take drugs to deal with his emotions. As a 20 year old man, this is the only life he has known since he was ten. He was sober for two weeks as a teen, and in past four weeks. His treatment for the drug and alcohol abuse should include therapy for the PTSD and monitored treatment to insure his sobriety.
Substance abuse. Maltreatment is noted as source of substance abuse: for Bobby the physical and emotional abuse, followed by neglect from parents. Environmental enhanced substance abuse encouraged by Bobby’s mother. Bobby desired his mother’s attention and approval. Generally with maltreatment clients have an understanding of the substance abuse. Bobby does not see an issue with his substance use. Substance use was common in his family and encouraged. Part of the...

Find Another Essay On The MacArthur Competence Assessment Tool- Criminal Adjudication

The Goals of Criminal Justice: Doing justice, controlling crime, and preventing crime

695 words - 3 pages Criminal justice is the branch of law that deals with disputes or actions involving criminal penalties. It regulates the conduct of individuals, defines crimes, and provides punishment for criminal acts. More so, it means activities relating to the detection, apprehension, detention, pretrial release, post trial release, prosecution, adjudication, correctional supervision or rehabilitation of accused persons or criminal offenders. Also, the

Cultural Competency Assesssment of Team Members

785 words - 3 pages Self assessment of cultural competency is a means of realizing how a person reacts to other cultures he or she encounters every day. Team A chose a cultural competency assessment tool from the Alameda County Public Health Department website (see Appendix A) to evaluate themselves concerning their cultural awareness. This paper will evaluate those assessments to come to a better understanding of each member's level of cultural competency. Each

Understanding the Meaning of Rhetoric

2417 words - 10 pages speech has changed since when Socrates was using rhetoric. There was no Truth. Rhetoric has been shown to change due to the situations and conditions that are around it. No rhetorical tool will withstand the trials of time due to the fact that rhetoric must constantly be changing. If rhetoric does not change then the use of rhetoric would become unneeded and unused. However, General MacArthur did have a great rhetorical piece of work. He

Juvenile Recidivism

3227 words - 13 pages referrals to intake, most serious prior adjudication, prior assaults, runaways, known use of alcohol or illegal drugs during the past 12 months, school behavior problems during the prior 12 months, peer relationships (association with delinquent peers), and parental supervision (Schwalbe 2004)”. Court counselors are instructed to complete each assessment item using the best available information. “Information is gathered from case files

week 2 cja

760 words - 3 pages precedent have helped in the shaping of today's Americancourt systems and also the criminal justice system.The role of the courts in criminal justice today is very important, especiallyto the study of criminal justice for two important reasons, adjudication andoversight. Adjudication means dispute resolution and the adjudication ofcomplaints, it means most often that courts decide who is going to answerfor an alleged criminal act. Without

Criminal Profiling

570 words - 2 pages IntroductionIn order to identify the unique characteristics of the criminal's personality a process is followed which is known as criminal profiling. Criminal profiling plays a crucial and significant role in deterring and combating criminal behavior and activity. This process is used to evaluate and investigate criminal activity by adopting a proactive and dynamic approach. Criminal profiling provides a valuable tool for law enforcement

Providing Culturally Competent Care

998 words - 4 pages The National Center for Cultural Competence developed a validated assessment tool “at the request of the Bureau of Primary Health Care (BPHC), Health Resources and Services Administration (HRSA), U.S. Department of Health and Human Service (DHHS)” (National Center for Cultural Competence (NCCC), 2004). The intent of the assessment tool is to “to enhance the delivery of high quality services to culturally and linguistically diverse individuals

Most Common Dementia: Alzheimer's Disease

1238 words - 5 pages , so clinicians must perform various tests to determine the cause of dementia in order to rule out Alzheimer’s (Alzheimer’s Stages & Behaviors, 2014). Capacity Assessments In 1988, the MacArthur Treatment Competence Study was designed to provide clinicians and policy makers with information to address questions about decision-making capacities of patients with mental impairment (Applebaum, 2007). This test takes about 20 minutes and

Rossett's Model

1225 words - 5 pages problem or task or competence related to it. Causes - Why is there a problem? What is causing it? This should focus on the various sources that may be contributing to the problem. Solutions - What are some ways of ending or diminishing the identified problem? Solutions should be considered based on the identified causes for performance problems. Five Steps of the Needs Assessment Process Rossett (1987, 1995) outlines the

Judicial Precedent

2214 words - 9 pages Judicial Precedent Setting a precedent is providing an example for others to follow. Legal precedent is however slightly more complicated. It is the term given to a previous decision, a particular stance or view, judge's Statement, or the effect of certain fact(s) present within a past case; which dictates or influences the adjudication or verdict of a later case. Or put simply 'a reason for deciding a particular issue as

Are lie detectors an accurate method of determining truthful statements relating to crimes?

1802 words - 8 pages Introduction Nowadays, in certain countries like the USA, Belgium, Turkey and others, lie detectors or polygraph is commonly used in lawsuits or criminal trials as an extra tool for solving crime cases. Lie detector tests used to figure trustworthiness of witnesses, bolster evidence or simply decide whether a suspect is innocent or guilty. However, accuracy of polygraph is highly debatable. Whereas one part of scientific world considers

Similar Essays

Criminal Profiling Should Become A Common Tool In Criminal Investigations Because It Provides A Plethora Of Critical Information That Has Led To The Arrest Of Elusive And Dangerous Criminals In The...

3241 words - 13 pages profiling in the United States. Criminal profiling should become a common tool in criminal investigations because it provides a plethora of critical information that has led to the arrest of elusive and dangerous criminals in the past. Used on rare occasions, and almost exclusively on serial murder cases, criminal profiling analyzes all aspects of a crime. A criminal profiler examines the different phases of a crime, the key elements involved, and

Psychologists And Forensic Assesment Essay

3619 words - 14 pages , 2008). There is also the Standardized personality tests which can include: “Adolescent psychopathology Scale- This instrument is used to identify psychological disorders and emotional problems in adolescents; MMPI-Adolescent and Psychological testing such as the MacArthur Competence Assessment tool-Criminal Adjudication (MacCAT-CA)” (Ackerman, 1999). These tests are useful in helping experts make diagnosis about their clients can come to

Variables Affecting Competency And Restoration Decisions

3102 words - 13 pages outcome of the trial. Certain assessments administered by psychologists evaluating competency have been developed to specifically identify a defendant’s current legal knowledge or their ability to learn about the legal proceedings well enough to aid in their own defense. Two such assessments are the MacArthur Competence Assessment Test - Criminal Adjudication (MacCAT-CA) and a revised version of the Georgia Court Competency Test (GCCT-MSH). The

Forensic Essay

1079 words - 4 pages assess the suspect, in the mental ability of a witness, comment on the defendant's competency in court. The Macarthur Adjunctive Competency Assessment is a very significant psychological judgment that forensic psychologists make use of in cases such as this. It amounts realizing (a person's factual understanding of legal proceedings), thinking (the defendant's ability to assist the counsel in his defense) and admiration (a rational understanding