The Main Argument Of The Phaedo For The Theory Of Recollection And The Immortality Of The Soul

771 words - 3 pages

The main argument Plato expressed in Phaedo (through Socrates) regarding the Theory of Recollection and his philosophy on the Immortality of the Soul can be explained as follows:"That our ability to judge objects of experience whether they are more or less perfect *presupposes* that we already have a concept of perfect objects in our minds, Therefore, we cannot gain these concepts of perfect objects from any experience, but had to have them before all experiences. Since our experiences began with our birth, we had to have them before birth. A priori knowledge, which is based on our having these concepts, is prenatal. (Theory of Recollection) Our soul had to have these concepts before birth, so it had to exist before birth. The soul is capable of existing without the body, and so it is immortal."Socrates discusses in his second speech (245d) "The soul through all her being is immortal, for that which is ever in motion is immortal; but that which moves another and is moved by another, in ceasing to move ceases also to live. Only the self-moving, never leaving self, never ceases to move, and is the fountain and beginning of motion to all that moves besides."Socrates goes on to explain how he 'proves' this theory of recollection "But if unbegotten, it must also be indestructible; for if beginning were destroyed, there could be no beginning out of anything, nor anything out of a beginning; and all things must have a beginning. And therefore the self-moving is the beginning of motion; and this can neither be destroyed nor begotten, else the whole heavens and all creation would collapse and stand still, and never again have motion or birth".(245 e)He further clarifies and then dismisses this point (as proven) as follows "But if the self-moving is proved to be immortal, he who affirms that self-motion is the very idea and essence of the soul will not be put to confusion. For the body which is moved from without is soulless; but that which is moved from within has a soul, for such is the nature of the soul. But if this be true, must not the soul be the self-moving, and therefore of necessity unbegotten and immortal? Enough of the soul's immortality."(246)Plato argued for the immateriality of the human soul in the Phaedo primarily on two grounds, each...

Find Another Essay On The main argument of the Phaedo for the Theory of Recollection and the Immortality of the Soul

The Doctrine of Recollection Essay

1256 words - 5 pages everything. Overall, the Doctrine of Recollection is based on two premises. The first is the immortality of the soul, along with its incarnations, and the second is the kinship of all nature (Ionescu). To demonstrate Socrates’ theory, a slave boy was brought in. Knowing that this slave boy never had any training in geometry, Socrates asks him a geometric problem. In answering every questions Socrates asked, the slave boy eventually reached the correct

Essays on Suicide and the Immortality of the Soul: The Complete 1783 Edition David Hume

10622 words - 42 pages Essays on Suicide and the Immortality of the Soul: The Complete 1783 Edition David Hume 2/10/96Copyright 1995, James Fieser ( See end note for details on copyright and editing conventions. This is a working draft; please report errors.1Links to Sections: Essay I: On Suicide [Not assigned] Essay II: On the Immortality of the SoulMetaphysical Arguments [Required]Moral Arguments [Optional]Physical Arguments

Courage, Virtue, and the Immortality of the Soul: According to Socrates

2174 words - 9 pages Socrates talks extensively about the arguments of immortality and he lays out three separate arguments for the immortality of the soul. The three arguments are the cyclical argument, the argument from recollection, and the affinity argument. I will be focusing on examining the “affinity argument.” This argument is based on the idea that the soul has a likeness in a higher level of reality. In order to properly examine this argument some

The Belief of Immortality

1216 words - 5 pages hallucination or a dream (Clark Web). Recent research ''shows that different parts of the brain are more likely responsible for out-of-body experience and near-death experiences''(Clark Web). Many philosophers will disapprove immortality. One of the philosophers, David Hume, explain his theory about miracles. In his argument, he explains with an example of a balance in which one pan represent with the most strongest signs of miracles

The Physics of Immortality.

624 words - 2 pages The Physics of ImmortalityHere it is at last, just what we've all been waiting for! Modern science proves everything you have always wanted: resurrection after death, eternal life, and idyllic sex forever! The abstruse topics of quantum cosmology and computer complexity theory prove it all true: "If any reader has lost a loved one or is afraid of death, modern physics says: 'be comforted, you and they shall live again"! Not only that, but you no

The Main Properties of the Cosmological Argument

1220 words - 5 pages theory as a strong one. Therefore, the cosmological argument, although able to be understood easily and useful in some cases, is not sustainable argument and cannot be regarded as a logical explanation for the existence of God.

The Main Strengths of the Cosmological Argument

871 words - 3 pages because everything has a beginning and an end. One criticism of the Cosmological Argument asks why cannot God not be the originator and now no longer exist? On the other hand Copleston replied with his “In Esse” theory that God has to be there for everything to exist. Without God we would not be here, because he is non-contingent being and outside of time he will always be there (whom created the universe). Like the

Characterise and assess Plato's theory of forms/essences in the first half of the Phaedo (up to 95e).

2848 words - 11 pages the admiration of the jailor for Socrates beautifully illustrates, what is, a moving and extremely touching work. (2) That it is a wonderful piece of pure literature is beyond doubt, yet it also contains a wealth of philosophical material. The central theme in the Phaedo is the immortality of the soul. Subordinate to this claim yet ubiquitous throughout the text is Plato's theory of Forms and it is in this dialogue that they are given their

Immortality and the study of Grimus

1943 words - 8 pages the answers contradict each other making it hard to figure out. "Belief in life after death is a source of personal security, optimism, and spiritual betterment" (1 John 3:2). Nothing offers more courage than the confidence that there is a better life for those who use the present to prepare for eternity. While some believe it's impossible to know whether there is life after death, belief in immortality is a timeless phenomenon. During our lives

The immortality of Skyy Vodka

757 words - 4 pages It happens to be spring break and I decided to take a road trip to visit an out of state relative in Florida. While I am driving I happen to see advertisements on bill boards of Skyy Vodka at nearly every stop or city I pass. While I’m driving on the interstate about every ad I perceive almost symbolizes sex or some sort of representation of a high economic status. For instance Skyy Vodka commercial and magazine covers usually

The Soul of Dell

1058 words - 4 pages culture and recapture a stronghold on the industry. Dell’s philosophy statement was created in hopes that it would transform the existing incentive-oriented culture to one which adhered to the newly established key standards and principles of the company. Unfortunately, as Dell would find, the company’s vision for improvement failed to make an impression on employees. Establishing Standards The intention of The Soul of Dell was to provide

Similar Essays

"The Immortality Of The Soul" By Phaedo

1843 words - 7 pages an instrument for the soul to use. A person should not fear or run from death, but rather look at it as a chance for the soul to move on to something else and to another chance to learn more based on what was already learned.To prove his statement that the soul continues to live even after the death of the body, Socrates offers four arguments in support the immortality of the soul: the recycling of the souls, the recollection theory, the

The Immortality Of The Soul Essay

1558 words - 6 pages is not the dying of body and soul collectively, but when the body dies the soul continues to live on. Socrates offers readers four main arguments: The Cyclical Argument, which is the idea that forms are fixed and external. The soul is the sole purpose of life in this argument, and therefore cannot die and it is also to be seen as virtually never-ending. Next is The Theory of Recollection, which insists that at birth everyone has knowledge that

Meno And The Theory Of Recollection

1274 words - 5 pages Meno?s Paradox and The Theory of Recollection Meno?s paradox is an argument in the form of a question. As it is written Meno asks, ?How will you look for something when you don?t know what it is.. or even if you come right up on it, how will you know that what you have found is the thing that you didn?t know?? Socrates states it more simply, ?A man cannot try to discover either what he knows or what he does not know.? This is the matter for

Theory Of The Soul Essay

673 words - 3 pages PLATOAccording to Plato, the body is merely a holding cell for the soul here on Earth. The soul exists prior to life on Earth, and it will continue to exist following the death of the body. Prior to life, the soul has all knowledge, but at the moment of birth, this knowledge is concealed.Plato's theory of the soul states that the soul embarks on a journey the moment it is formed. When the soul is created, it enters a preexistent state until the