This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Main Characteristics And Basic Differences Of Generative Grammar And Usage Based Approaches

551 words - 3 pages

Through the years, linguists have produced many models of grammar, however, two models have proven to be most controversial. They are Chomsky's generative grammar of formal syntax and functional, usage-based approaches. These two fields, formalists and functionalist, are divided into two divisions of linguistic theories without cooperation. While one field focuses on cognitive abilities, the other directs their attention to syntax and universal grammar (henceforth UG). This essay investigates the main characteristics and basic differences of generative grammar and usage-based approaches.
In short, Chomsky's generative grammar involves the human innate ability to learn a language, termed UG, and the fundamental role of syntax. This genetically encoded ability (UG) as well as exposure to language (environment) answers Chomsky's question "how is language generated in the speaker?". His earlier theory of parameters, ...view middle of the document...

First, the usage-based theory is associated with cognitive linguistics and their focus on meaning (lexical semantics). They emphasize on identifying phraseological units and the memory of pre-constructed forms and patterns in the mental lexicon. Higher frequency of forms or patterns increases accessibility to them, whereas lower frequency words are soon forgotten. With children, early exposure to forms or patterns is entrenched in their lexicon. These forms are categorized and mentally represented in the mental lexicon and thus memorized. Moreover, due to the importance of the multicultural aspects of language, the usage-based approaches take into account the social dimension of contrasting usage both synchronically and diachronically.
In view of the main characteristics between Chomsky's generative grammar and the usage-based approaches, there are considerable basic differences. In particular, Chomsky and generative grammar makes a clear distinction between syntax and the lexicon, whereas usage-based theories make none at all. While generative grammar takes no interest in language change due to its external properties (E-language), usage-based focuses on diachronic as well as synchronic issues of language because, to them, historical linguistics and sociolinguistics are not regarded separate disciplines. Another difference, is the importance of phraseology within the discipline of cognitive linguistics and the usage-based approach, however, generative grammar has limited interest except for the grammar, structure, and irregularities of phrases.
Overall, Chomsky's universal grammar is a principle of the language faculty embedded in the human mind and generative grammar is based on the principles of syntactic rules. However, usage-based approaches build upon the theory of language learning with input, mental representation, frequency, and categorization. Due to their dissimilar theories and approaches towards language acquisition, they have sided against each other rather than to work together.

Works Cited

Herbst, Thomas (2010). English Linguistics: A Coursebook for Students of English. Berlin: De Gruyter Mouton.

Find Another Essay On The Main Characteristics and Basic Differences of Generative Grammar and Usage-Based Approaches

What are the main differences between authoritarian and democratic regimes?

1693 words - 7 pages Democratic and authoritarian are two very different and contradicting forms of political regimes. They differ in the way a country or a state is managed. In attempting to identify and discuss the differences between the two regimes, we should think what implications do the two regimes have on the political system. How are they different in terms of the institutions they inherent? How are rulers elected and which one provides the more

The Development and Usage of Gas Warfare

1820 words - 8 pages the effort to increase the effectiveness of gas. Phosgene was commonly mixed with other substances to create more lethal components (Background and Development of Chemical Weapons”). Gas was also a main component of World War II. However, there were some restrictions for certain countries and the usage of gas. For example, Germany was not allowed to have any type of gas weaponry. This was stated in the Treaty of Versailles. Even though other

Cultivation and Usage of the Date Palm

1495 words - 6 pages Introduction Date cultivation has had a very important effect on the history of the Middle East. Without dates, no large human population could have been supported in the desert regions. The group routes existed for centuries, mainly for the transportation of dates. Early on, date cultivation became a sanctified symbol of productiveness and fertility. Dates had great spiritual and cultural significance to the people of the Middle East. Date

Explain the main differences between Common and Civil Legal Systems; Discuss the feasibility of the convergence between these legal systems

1463 words - 6 pages laws can be divided for convenience into three main legal systems of the world; which are civil law, common law and religious law. The main purpose of this work is to clarify the principal distinction between Common and Civil Legal Systems. Consequently, the knowledge of these distinctions will make it possible to discuss the feasibility of the convergence and unification of these legal systems. According to Winterton (1975) legal system in

Grammar and Writing in the Classroom

767 words - 3 pages In the article entitled “How to Teach Grammar, Analytical Thinking, and Writing”, Lynn Sams (2003) voiced and suggested methods on how grammar and writing should be taught in the classroom. This article was published in the English Journal by the National Council of Teachers of English. Sams based her research on her 16 years of experience as a high school teacher and the instructional approaches she used with her sixth, seventh, eighth and

2. Assess the main threats of IS/IT outsourcing and put these possible threats in order based on its importance.

1011 words - 5 pages Commonly use outsourcing and managed services for their company. Outsourcing of information technology is not new for those who work in the technology and banking sectors. Although this area is new on the IT areas, it is one that may be more prevalent in the workplace, especially when it comes to data security. This is because many banks do not have the expertise to gather all the information effectively. 2.1 Quality control In some cases, these

English Grammar: The Subjunctive And The Conditionals

799 words - 4 pages in set phrases which have to be considered as wholes:God save the Queen!Come what may...Be that as it may...Heaven forbid...Suffice it to say...The ConditionalsThe conditionals combine the meaning of tense and modality: the main clause expresses modality and it usually contains a modal verb, the if-clause however expresses tense.1. Real Present Conditional: Present + Future:If you do that I'll kill you!This type of conditional sentence relates a

Grammar of Spoken and Written English

3041 words - 12 pages the grammatical form of this discourse. Biber, Johansson, Leech, Condrad & Finegan (1999) states that the same English grammar can be applied to both spoken and written language however research shows that the two use these grammatical features differently. This essay will be referring to a conversation between two friends in a restaurant, whose main objective is to order food for lunch, together. Their conversation also includes a waitress who is

Define the four main approaches to staffing within International Human Resource Management.What are the advantages and disadvantages of each approach to international management

1236 words - 5 pages Human Resource Management. The term IHRM refers to the development and deployment of human resource capabilities within an international framework. Companies have several techniques at their disposal when faced with staffing decisions.The first approach is called ethnocentric. It is based on the occupation of a key position by employees from headquarters (i.e. expatriates or parent country nationals PCN). It is assumed that subsidiaries can be

The Characteristics and Culture of Bangladesh

2935 words - 12 pages noticeable cooling to 43 degrees or less at night. The rainy season usually start in April and ends in October. The rainfall is of critical importance for agriculture in Bangladesh. In case of the absence of the April rain, which softens the ground, it becomes necessary to postpone rice crops and jute, the main market culture crop. Tidal waves, hurricanes and tropical cyclones terrorize the coastal districts of Bangladesh, especially adjacent to the

Outline the main differences between Civil and Criminal Law in Scotland and describe how these differences operate

899 words - 4 pages Introduction It is relatively often that people can find it difficult to differentiate between the two main divisions of the Scottish legal system and fully understand their characteristics. This assignment will explore the key differences between criminal and civil law in Scotland by delivering insight into the complexities of the court systems, procedures and disputes considered in both branches of Scots Law. The Basic Distinction Civil law

Similar Essays

This Essay Will Aim To Explain The Main Differences Between Marxian, Durkheimian, And Weberian Approaches To Social Inequality

1492 words - 6 pages This essay will aim to explain the main differences between Marxian, Durkheimian, and Weberian approaches to social inequality. It will begin with each Marx's approach to social inequality, which he believed economic factors to be the sole cause of this social phenomenon. Marx was born in the aftermath of the French revolution where the governing elite was overthrown by the bourgeoisie allowing capitalism to develop. This in turn gave rise to a

Characteristics Of Protein Based Biopolymer And Its Application

893 words - 4 pages protein sequences, shapes, and functions found in nature [47]. Interaction phenomenon between natural and/or synthetic polymer with side chain groups of peptide allows to develop natural polymer based film with enhanced properties such as elasticity and toughness, etc. [48-50].The different reinforcement approaches that are used for development of protein based polymer can categorized into several ways that are chemical agents and radiation

Characteristics Of Protein Based Biopolymer And Its Application

834 words - 4 pages Protein Characteristics and Its Suitability for Polymer Development Proteins are prepared by basic unit called amino acids. The protein’s structure is broadly classified into four major categories which are called primary, secondary, tertiary and quaternary structure. The primary structure of a protein is a linear polymer with a string of amino acids coupled by peptide bonds. Secondary structures of proteins are usually very regular in their

Three Of The Main Counselling Approaches

1771 words - 7 pages understand fully we need to know how each develop and work. According to Freud we are born with the id this is the oral stage of development. The id is an important part of us as it gets our basic needs met he believed that it was based on the pleasure principle it does not care about reality or the needs of others only its own satisfaction and desires. As we grow and interact with the world the second part of our personality grows and is known by