This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Main Controversies Of Medieval Thought In The 12th And 13th Centuries

1212 words - 5 pages

The Main Controversies of Medieval Thought in the 12th and 13th Centuries

The twelfth and thirteenth centuries were a time of great controversy for medieval scholars. New systems of thought were being developed and implemented that challenged the accepted teachings of the church. Some fought to preserve tradition, others fought to destroy it, while still others sought to find a common ground between the two. The greatest controversy of the times, it can be said, was that of faith and reason. Most philosophical debate revolved around these and to a lesser extent the opposition of realists and nominalists on the question of universals. The type of philosophy that was being taught in the Christian schools of the time has been given the name of scholasticism. Scholastics shared a common respect for the ideas of Aristotle, Plato, Boethius, Pseudo-Dionysius, and Avicenna. These were referred to by scholastics as the "authorities". The views of the time were mainly Augustinian and Platonic although certain developments brought radical new ideas into contact with a fixed Christian dogma that was bound to oppose them. Whether a synthesis between them was possible remained to be seen.
Possibly the single-most important event of the twelfth and thirteenth centuries for medieval thinkers was the introduction of new translations of Aristotle's works. The new translations were the products of work done by Arabic scholars. Up to that point Christendom knew only of Aristotle's Logic. It had been widely accepted and was widely respected which meant the new works held great weight. The new translations provided a coherent view of the world that now challenged traditional views. On top of the controversy aroused by the works themselves, they were accompanied by the commentaries of non-Christian Arabic scholars holding unorthodox opinions. The excitement incited by the works was accompanied by a deep concern within the church over the effects of their assimilation.
Among the Arabic commentators was Averroës. The multi-talented Islamic philosopher would become known as the commentator and interpreter of Aristotle. Averroës had written the commentaries in response to a request from his ruler. His commentaries are very numerous and their effect on the Christian philosophical world immeasurable. In his personal philosophies he arrived at the conclusion that the two truths of faith and reason were irreconcilable.
Maimonides was at the same time an orthodox Jew and a firm adherent to Aristotelian philosophy. He was therefore in the same position as his Christian counterparts, particularly Thomas Aquinas, and faced the problem of combining the two. The result of his meditations on the issue is expressed in his Guide of the Perplexed, which appeared in approximately 1190. Maimonides stated that since God was responsible for the existence of both faith and reason the two must never be contradictory. Any semblance of contradiction between the two is therefore the...

Find Another Essay On The Main Controversies of Medieval Thought in the 12th and 13th Centuries

Ethical Controversies Involved in the Use of Germ-line and Somatic Gene Therapies

1559 words - 6 pages Ethical Controversies Involved in the Use of Germ-line and Somatic Gene Therapies Abstract There are many sides to the issue of using germ-line and somatic germ therapies. Many people argue that it should be stopped completely, whereas others argue that both germ therapies should continue for the benefit of all people. There are other arguments that lie somewhere in between. Most of the controversy is caused by germ-line gene therapy

Education in 12th Century Medieval Times

1518 words - 6 pages Paris and the School of Chartres," in Renaissance and Renewal in the 12th Century, ed. by Robert L. Benson and Giles Constable (Cambridge, Mass., 1982), pp. 118. Peter Abelard, Historia Calamitatum, trans. by Henry Adams Bellows (Medieval Sourcebook), chapter II.

The role of the English monarchs in the English Reformation in the 15th and 16th centuries

2194 words - 9 pages that was customarily preached to a heretic before execution. "My hand has offended in writing contrary to my heart. Therefore, my hand shall be first punished, for if I may come to the fire it shall be first burned," Cranmer said (Haack). Without waiting any longer, Cranmer ran outside of the church and thrust his right hand into the flames. The rest of his body followed afterwards. "Lord Jesus, receive my spirit," were his last words.The Anglican

Function of the English Exchequer in the 12th century

1001 words - 4 pages The English exchequer was the central board responsible for all in comings and out goings into the royal treasury. It arrived with the Normans and was the first system of centralized revenue extraction to appear that although crude was a direct predecessor to the modern one.The information on how the Exchequer functioned as a method of institutionalised revenue extraction is from the OeThe course of the Exchequer¹ written by Richard son of

Controversies around the use of Monosodium glutamate in food

1168 words - 5 pages syndrome complex usually involves the symptoms of: headache, nausea, numbness, weakness, and facial pressure (Zeratsky, 2012, Para. 2). Despite the controversies around the use of MSG, U.S Food and Drug Administration continues to approve the use of MSG in food as scientists are unable to consistently trigger the allergic reactions experienced by some (FDA, 2012, Para. 3). MSG breaks down into glutamate and sodium ions inside the body. Glutamate is a

The Two Camps of Modern Art is about the two main schools of thought in art history from 1945 - current

1993 words - 8 pages item and decided to call it art. Of course it was not just an everyday item, it was something that no one who saw it would really consider it art. The thought process of these two authors was quite different in their workings of art. Mondrian worked so hard on ridding his paintings from any meanings within the artwork. He was trying to stress the importance of each line painted, and the aesthetic appeal of the bright primary colors next to the

Medical Technology and the Controversies Associated With Prolongation of Life

3168 words - 13 pages Medical Technology and the Controversies of Prolonging LifeIn 1900, the average life expectancy was 47 years, by 1998 life expectancy had risen to 76.7 years (Kleespies, P., 2004). Prior to the advent of Penicillin, pneumonia carried a mortality rate of 30%, Penicillin lowered this to 6%. (Leach, J., 2005). Infant mortality rates have fallen from 16.5 per 100 in 1900 to 0.77 per 100 in 1997. Many of the childhood diseases which took young lives

Expressionism Expressionism was one of the main movements in the later 19th and 20th centuries. No other artistic style has had as much an impact on 20th century art as expressionism has

971 words - 4 pages Expressionism was one of the main movements in the later 19th and 20th centuries.No other artistic style has had as much an impact on 20th century art as expressionism has.Expressionism not only has influenced the art movement, it has influenced other expressive, creative areas such as literature, theatre and cinema.One of the two Expressionist movements was Die Brucke (The Bridge), which emerged in Germany early in the 20th century.The artists

To Kill a Mockingbird. This essay is about prejusice that has caused pain and suffering to others for many centuries. Racism is the main issue in this essay

699 words - 3 pages Prejudice has caused the pain and suffering of others for manycenturies.Some examples of this include the Holocaust and slavery in the UnitedStates. In to Kill a Mockingbird, by Harper Lee racism was the cause ofmuch agony to the blacks of a segregated South. Along with blacks, othergroups of people are judged unfairly just because of their difference fromothers. The prejudice and bigotry of society causes the victimization ofpeople with

The Effects of Mercantilism During the 16th to 18th Centuries in Great Britain and America

542 words - 2 pages Mercantilism during the 16th through 18th century played a major part in the relationship between Britain and the colonists of America. Mercantilism was one of many factors that caused the separation of America and Great Britain. You must first know how mercantilism benefitted both parties in order to understand why the separation took place. Mercantilism is an unfair practice. The main objective of mercantilism was to increase a nation’s

Skepticism and the Philosophy of Language in Early Modern Thought

3259 words - 13 pages scene well into the XVIIIth century. However, the importance of the discussion of the nature and role of language in this process and its relation to skeptical arguments has scarcely been examined. My objective in this paper is to extend Popkin's analysis of the role of skepticism in the formation of modern thought to the consideration, in general lines, of some of the main features of early modern theories about the nature and function of

Similar Essays

European History In The 13th And 14th Centuries

1080 words - 4 pages war in 1415, and were supported by the Burgundians in their claim to the French throne. In Italy, the country was divided into city-states. These city-states often quarreled with each other and caused a power struggle over Italy. Religion played a big role in the devastation in the 13th and 14th centuries. One of the main conflicts that existed was between the Church and the Monarchy. Pope Boniface VIII issued Unam Sanctum in 1302. It was a

How Legal Identity Of Women In Medieval Europe During The Twelfth And Thirteen Centuries Reflect And Influence Other Aspects Of Their Identity.

2124 words - 8 pages medieval society. However, analysis of laws and legal rights through court cases, personal accounts, and scholarly authors can offer valid arguments. The secular and ecclesiastical laws of western Europe during the twelfth and thirteenth centuries, influenced by Roman law, show women’s legal identities to be that of a child and secondary to man. As a result, women identified themselves as powerless, and inferior. It also showed how reputation in the

The Art Of War In The 17th And 18th Centuries

1116 words - 4 pages The Art of War in the 17th and 18th Centuries The Art of War in the 17th and 18th Centuries is a history course book whose author's are United States Military Academy history instructors Lieutenant Colonel Dave Richard Palmer and Major Albert Sidney Britt III. The textbook gives an insight into the military tactics and the political reasons when they were brought about in the 17th and 18th centuries. The text was published in West Point

Cathedrals Of The 12th Century Essay

1108 words - 4 pages aroundParis, including Saint-Denis and Chartres, to the region of the Champagne in the east andsouthward to Bourges. Within this restricted area, in the series of cathedrals built in the course ofthe 12th and 13th centuries, the major innovations of Gothic architecture took place.2The supernatural character of medieval religious architecture was given a special form inthe Gothic church. 'Medieval man considered himself but an imperfect