The Topic Of Guilt In Margaret Laurence's "Stone Angel" And Davies Robertson's "Fifth Business"

1514 words - 6 pages

Every piece of literature that has been written uses words, which have concrete meaningin everyday life. As a result of that it cannot ever be completely abstract. Theme is what sustains its link with living, by giving it a topic or idea that extends it beyond the aesthetic, and unites it with the preoccupation of humanity. A work can have one theme or many, and Margaret Laurence's and Davies Robertson's essential humanism makes it very inevitable that in this respect their novels are multifaceted. In their novels The Stone Angel and The Fifth Business the main characters Hagar Shipley and Dunny Ramsay through the birth, lack of feelings and escape from the family have undergone similar feelings of guilt through their whole lives.First of all, Dunny the main character of The Fifth Business, for whom the snowball was intended, feels extremely guilty because he knew that Percy Staunton with whom he had earlier a fight, would throw one final snowball at him before he goes into the house for supper. To avoid the coming snowball he dodges around pregnant Mrs. Dempster who at the same time gets hit on the head, causing her great pain. Dunny is just reaching puberty and listening to his mother's reports on the premature birth of Paul Dempster gave him the sense that he is directly involved in it. Furthermore, he has been raised in a strict Presbyterian household that has encouraged him to feel guilty about almost every lapse of duty.So at the beginning of the two novels the reader learns that the first feeling of guilt that the two main characters share is a birth of one of the characters presented in the novels. In The Stone Angel Hagar blamed herself for being born, because it was she that caused her mother's death. She felt that it should be her who should die not her mother. In The Fifth Business the main character Dunny felt really guilty for dodging a snowball that hit pregnant Mrs. Dempster. He knew that the snowball was thrown by Percy Staunton at him. 'I was perfectly sure, you see, that the birth of Paul Dempster, so small, so feeble and troublesome, was my fault' (Davies 22) Ramsay blamed himself for not letting it hit him and a reader can receive the message in this quote said by him, 'I was contrite and guilty, for what I knew that the snowball had been meant for me' (Davies 11) Maybe this incident didn't have any similarity to Hagar's birth yet, but later on in this novel it is known that it was the cause to Mrs. Dempster's son premature birth. Dunny's guilt got even greater that it had been. Now he feels obliged to take care of Mrs. Dempster and her son, he decides to play with him and even teach him his magic tricks. He was not able to get over the snowball incident as Hagar couldn't stand the fact she was the cause of her mother's death. Hagar didn't like mentioning that subject and when she did she quickly changed to another, 'Auntie Doll...had been with us since my birth.' (Davies 4) She didn't like to tell anyone about her mom's...

Find Another Essay On The topic of guilt in Margaret Laurence's "Stone Angel" and Davies Robertson's "Fifth Business"

Discussing Imagery in Margaret Laurence's novel "The Stone Angel"

1136 words - 5 pages Discuss Laurence's use of three of the following images to develop characters/ themes in The Stone Angel.-flowers/earth -stone -animals -water -journey(physical/spiritual) -Scottish lineage______________________________As in any literary work, imagery is an essential element in accenting characters, and giving a better understanding of events as they progress. Of course, the novel "The Stone Angel" by Margaret Laurence is no exception. Imagery

Thomas Hardy's "Tess of the d'Urbervilles", and Margaret Laurence's "The Stone Angel"

1805 words - 7 pages problems that can create, not only depression but death in one's life. Throughout both Thomas Hardy's Tess of the d'Urbervilles, and Margaret Laurence's The Stone Angel, comparisons are made between the varied incidents that send both Tess and Hagar's life into isolation and the similar causes for both of the women's tragic life.The fist incident that is introduced is how both Tess's and Hagar's deaths are similarly caused by the deceitfulness of their

Guilt in Robertson Davies' "Fifth Business"

1097 words - 4 pages Guilt in Fifth BusinessOne feeling that may cause mixed emotions such as anger, hate, or fear, a feeling that can also cripple one's mind, is guilt. Robertson Davies' "Fifth Business" demonstrates how guilt is able to corrupt the young minds of children through the characters of Paul and Dunstan. On the other hand, he also shows how a child will suppress an incident into their unconscious mind if it makes him feel uncomfortable, or guilty

"Gainsay who dare" Hagar's lack of Emotional growth in Margaret Lawrence's "The Stone Angel"

1121 words - 4 pages Hagar, the protagonist of Margaret Lawrence's The Stone Angel, has the emotional maturity of a child. Throughout the novel, Hagar is portrayed as someone who never fully developed emotionally. Her impulsive actions and inability to make connections with others are the causes of her immaturity. Hagar's past allowed her to build an emotional mask, which prevents others from getting close to her. Hagar uses these techniques as defence mechanisms to

In "The Great Gatsby" by F. Scott Fitzgerald and "The Stone Angel" by Margaret Laurence both main characters are tragic heroes

1110 words - 4 pages Argumentative EssayIn "The Great Gatsby" by F. Scott Fitzgerald and "The Stone Angel" by Margaret Laurence both main characters are tragic heroes and have a strong sense of dignity (pride) . You may ask yourself what is a tragic hero? A tragic hero is someone who has the potential for greatness but yet he or she is doomed to fail because of a certain situation they are put in. Tragic heroes become tragic heroes by decision he or she have made in

Hagar as a Holy Terror, "The Stone Angel" by Margaret Laurence

789 words - 3 pages the world knowing that she is self sufficient and freeing herself of any help that she was given.Hagar resembles the character King Lear, from the play "King Lear" by William Shakespeare; she denied her son Marvin the love that he deserved, just as King Lear denied Cordelia the love that she deserved. As well as both characters isolate themselves from the real world once they realize their mistakes, they both end up lonely, and in the end the child that they had cast aside is the child that they confess their fear too."The Stone Ange"l truly is a tragedy as Hagar loses the ones the loves, and cannot even mourn their deaths.

The Theme of Saints in Robertson Davies' Fifth Business

523 words - 2 pages The marvelous story of saints is one of the leading themes in Fifth Business. As the author Robertson Davies develops this theme through Dunstan’s journey into hagiology, he often uses certain saints such as Saint Dunstan, as allusions. Among the Saints that the novel refers to, Saint Paul is the perfect allusion that portrays the character of Paul Dempster since the two share strong similarities in their lives. Additionally, Saint Paul

Comparing Robertson Davies' Fifth Business and Aleksandr Soltzhenitsyn's One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich

2379 words - 10 pages Two Roads; One Bode Many different journeys in life can result in people learning about their true inner being and the truth of others in their life. In fact, the story of a man spending his life contemplating over the guilt from his childhood can have the same common lessons as the story of a man enslaved in a Russian concentration camp. When compared, the two novels, Fifth Business by Robertson Davies and One Day in the Life of Ivan

Theme of guilt in Hamlet and Fifth Business

1521 words - 7 pages causes for why people behave a certain way. They mask their identities, hide their realities, contain themselves in ambiguous world, and only think about their personal selves. In the texts, Fifth Business by Robertson Davies and Hamlet by William Shakespeare, a multitude of emotions are seen among the characters. However, there is one dominant emotion that affects our conscience, and leads us to behave and act irrationally. It is this strong

Guilt in Fifth Business

756 words - 3 pages Guilt is the regret one experiences when they realise their action was not appropriate according to a lawful or moral standard. In Fifth Business, by Robertson Davies, guilt was a major theme and was essential throughout the novel. Davies used the three main characters, Dunstan Ramsay, Boy Staunton, and Paul Dempster to illustrate the different effects of Mrs. Dempster’s incident. The way one is raised, the key disciplines they have developed

Changes in Identity In Robertson Davies' novel Fifth Business, the

1075 words - 4 pages Changes in Identity In Robertson Davies' novel Fifth Business, the author uses the events that took place in Deptford to reveal character identity. Three characters in the novel from Deptford: Boy Staunton, Dunstan Ramsay and Paul Dempster, leave Deptford to look for a new identity to get rid of their past one. Though for some, the journey was a difficult one, it ends up turning out for the best overall. The three main characters of the novel

Similar Essays

Margaret Laurence's "Stone Angel" And Fifth Business "Fifth Business"

1514 words - 6 pages inevitable that in this respect their novels are multifaceted. In their novels The Stone Angel and The Fifth Business the main characters Hagar Shipley and Dunny Ramsay through the birth, lack of feelings and escape from the family have undergone similar feelings of guilt through their whole lives.First of all, Dunny the main character of The Fifth Business, for whom the snowball was intended, feels extremely guilty because he knew that Percy Staunton

Margaret Laurence's "The Stone Angel" Essay

1185 words - 5 pages In Margaret Laurence's The Stone Angel the main character Hagar Shipley refuses to compromise which ultimately shapes the outcome of her life as well as those around her. As an older woman faced with death, Hagar comments that, "pride was my wilderness and the demon that led me there was fear... [I was] never free, for I carried my chains within me, and they spread out from me and shackled all I touched."(292) Hagar's stubbornness and pride are

The Use Of Symbolism In Margaret Laurence's Stone Angel

815 words - 3 pages The Use of Symbolism in Margaret Laurence's Stone Angel The statue of the stone angel is symbolic of the Currie family pride, Hagar's inability to relate and share her emotions, and the blindness and ignorance that comes from constantly refusing to see things from another point of view other than your own. The Stone angel is symbolic of the Currie family pride because it does not seem to serve it's purpose, which is to honour Hagar's

"The Stone Angel" By Margaret Laurence's

942 words - 4 pages In Margaret Laurence's The Stone Angel, the main character Hagar Shipley refused to compromise which shaped the outcome of her life as well as the lives of those around her. 'Pride was my wilderness and the demon that led me there was fear... [I was] never free, for I carried my chains within me, and they spread out from me and shackled all I touched.' (Laurence, 292). Hagar's pride and stubbornness were the causes of her failed relationships