The Manciple's Tale: The Journey The Placement Of The Manciple's Tale Before The Parson's Tale Is Intentional On Chaucers Part.

1957 words - 8 pages

The Manciple's Tale:The JourneyMany critics have argued the meaning of placement and order of each tale in Geoffrey Chaucer's The Canterbury Tales. Accordingly, the arrangement of The Manciple's Tale, next to last and before The Parson's Tale, has been supported by both the Ellesmere and Chaucer Society (Storm 2). Chaucer's decision to place a tale teaching sin and silence just before a tale preaching truth and repentance surely has a meaning far beyond chance. A tale of evil followed by a tale of good matches the overall theme of The Canterbury Tales: a pilgrimage leaving sin (the inn) and traveling toward redemption (the cathedral.) Likewise, The Manciple's Tale is saturated with contradictions and contrasts that are common to The Canterbury Tales as a whole.Chaucer's main source for The Manciple's Tale, Ovid's Metamorphoses, and its hero, Apollo, is the first of many ironic twists that Chaucer incorporates in this tale. Chaucer reverses Apollo's traditional qualities and shows his unsuccessful attempt as a human lover. Michael Kensak in his essay Apollo exterminans: The God of Poetry in Chaucer's Manciple's Tale agrees that Phebus in The Manciple's Tale bears all the traits of Apollo, "the classical god of music and medicine, art and eloquence." The Manciple describes Phebus as "Pleyen he doude on every mynstralcie" and "Was wont to beren in his hand a bowe" (lines 113,129). Also, like Apollo, Phebus is the height of male attractiveness. No less than three times in the first twenty lines Phebus' manliness (lusty baccilar) and good looks ("seemliest man" and "noon so faire enslave") are mentioned (107,119,122). However, Chaucer's Phebus reduces these attributes and contradicts the "illumination, healing and truth" that constitutes this Olympian deity. By the end of the tale, there is little resemblance to the traditional Apollo and proof that gods cannot successfully master human love. Trevor Whittock in The Manciple's Tale and the Parson's Tale says, "Apollo, who is traditionally the god of civilization, of law, of high moral and religious principles, is presented in the Manciple's story as a spoilt nobleman" (285). Like the Metamorphoses, Chaucer implements a religious tone by showing the fate of Phebus while portraying a pagan god. Marc M. Pelen in his essay The Manciple's "Cosyn" to the "Dede," explains,From Plato and Boethius we learnt that language must be carefully chosen to guide us toward the important truths in texts (for example, Consolation III, prose 12) concerning the goodness of God and its influence over human affairs (349).Not only does Chaucer portray an Apollo that "brings darkness rather than light, lies rather than truth, and silence rather than music," he implies that the mythological Apollo can not compete with Christian ethics (Kensak 1,2). That good will be destroyed and words will be silenced. Kensak says, "the Apollonian poetry of natural man fails to adequately represent not only the highest Christian mysteries, but...

Find Another Essay On The Manciple's Tale: The Journey The placement of the Manciple's Tale before the Parson's Tale is intentional on Chaucers part.

The Knight’s tale and The Miller’s tale

1136 words - 5 pages lead to the occurrence of the incident. With all these techniques used it will give readers an intriguing and insightful taste in reading the works of any authors. On one hand, The Knight’s Tale is about King Theseus a duke of Athens, who imprisons two knights from Thebes, Arcite and Palamon. From their prison window, the knights see and fall in love with Theseus’s sister-in-law, Emily. Through the intervention of a friend, Arcite is freed, but he

The Tale of the Heike Essay

1055 words - 4 pages sides. The group went to bed that evening agreeing to switch. The following day, Sanemori inquired on the subject, the warriors rationalized that it would be “demeaning” to switch sides. Sanemori then reveals that he was just testing their loyalty and clarifies that has prepared to die in the next battle. Sanemori’s loyalty is also reflected when the tale reveals that he was over the age of seventy, he died is hair and beard black so that

The Tale of the Heike

1075 words - 5 pages orchestrate the complete destruction of the Taira and establish themselves as the dominant house. In contextualizing this work’s importance, Heike is regarded as a “seminal masterpiece of Japanese culture” on the level of The Tale of Genji. Since the epic has a history of being performed as well as read, the physical structure of the passages can vary significantly. Royall Tyler, the translator, chose to incorporate three formats into the text

commentry on the handsmaid tale

1150 words - 5 pages conditions in the novel. The Handmaid'sTale is a warning to young women of the 'post-feminist' 1980s and after,who began taking for granted the rights that had been secured for womenby the women before them. The environmental danger of pollution and radiation run off from powerplants is commented on in the novel. Atwood is voicing her concernsabout the destruction of the environment here, and warns us of thepossibilities if the destruction

Miller's Tale and the Reeve's Tale

845 words - 3 pages merriest fit in all her life" (116).The Miller and the Reeve through their tales are trying to embarrass each other. Their stories include an unlucky character who takes on the other's occupation. The Reeve becomes angry when the Miller first presents his story which might suggest that the tale is in fact about the Reeve. His reaction to the Miller's story is shown when he says, "It is a sin and foolishness to slander any man or bring a scandal on

The Winner's Tale

1066 words - 5 pages Does a morally sound tale become less morally sound based on the teller’s morals? A tale is a tale, and to base a story’s morals off of the teller rather than the message is absurd. This is why The Pardoner’s Tale should win The Host’s contest in the Canterbury Tales over The Wife of Bath’s Tale. When choosing a winner between these two tales, one must first consider the rules on the contest. The Host set the rules that the story must be morally

The Miller's Tale-Chaucer

1913 words - 8 pages wol telle a legende and a lyf Bothe of a carpenter and of his wyf, How that a clerf hath set the wrights cappe." (The Canterbury Tales, line 3141) The Miller is saying that his tale will relate to how a clerk deceived a carpenter. This immediately arouses the ire of that carpenter, the Reeve, who on moralistic grounds asserts that the Miller should not defame wives, although the other carpenter, one of the five Guildsmen, has no word of

The Miller's Tale

1313 words - 5 pages The Miller's Tale The Miller’s Tale is in the form of fabliaux, which is part of the oral tradition of storytelling, which was very popular among the lower classes in the medieval times. Prominently bawdy and satirizing in content, fabliaux commonly told the story of a bourgeois husband who is cuckolded by his young wife. Fabliaux brings a great contrast to the likes of the courtly love tales such as the Knight’s Tale

The Pardoners Tale

1448 words - 6 pages these sins. Overall, The Pardoners Tale is a miraculous story in which it underlines the main theme “greed is the root of all evil”, and sets the tone for all upcoming stories. Works Cited Chaucer, Geoffrey, and Nevill Coghill. "The Pardoner's Tale." The Canterbury Tales. London: Penguin, 2003. 103-06. Print. Dean, James. "'The Pardoner's Tale'." In Sauer, Michelle M. The Facts On File Companion to British Poetry before 1600. New York: Facts On

The Wife of Bath’s Tale and The Clerk’s Tale

1858 words - 7 pages objects and offers that the knight’s life is spared if he can find the answer to what women really want. The knight embarks on his journey to discover the answer (“The Wife of Bath’s Tale” 167-68). Similarly, “The Clerk’s Tale” takes place in the kingdom of Saluzzo, Italy under the control of Walter, the marquis. The people of Saluzzo eagerly advised Walter to find a wife to ensure an heir to the throne. Walter finally finds the standard

Interpreting The Handmaid's Tale

625 words - 3 pages with her life before the Revolution, the gross corruption and injustice of the Gileadean period becomes increasingly evident. Offred's narrative is noteworthy for several reasons. For one thing, it is an act of defiance; by telling her story, Offred refuses to forget the past or reconcile herself to the present. In a society in which women are forbidden to read or write or to speak freely, her tale becomes a protest. In fact, it becomes her

Similar Essays

Chaucers: The Pardoner's Corruption Tale Essay

861 words - 3 pages hypnotize the Host; that he is a glutton and a typical tavern reveler is revealed by the fact that he calls for cakes and ale before he can properly relate a moral tale. (Curry) This small detail of the Pardoner desiring cake and ale is a significant clue that, despite his outwardly appearance of caring for the sinful, his first concerns are only for himself. One of the more unsympathetic characters in Chaucer's tales is the Pardoner, who

The Tale Of Genji Essay

2145 words - 9 pages The Tale of Genji is seen as many things, whether it is the first novel written or the world’s first psychological novel. In this book, Murasaki Shikibu tells the story of Hikaru Genji and his experiences. The Tale of Genji is considered the world’s first novel; the story takes us through the birth and death of Genji, a smart, attractive, and talented boy. Genji, is the second son of Emperor Kiritsubo and as the son of an emperor Genji’s life is

The Tale Of Boudicca Essay

1555 words - 7 pages … calling them by the names of slaves and captives’ this allows present day readers to understand that his entire tale was not based complete bias. Though this was known there is a predominant focus on her vengeful actions Tacitus is able to sway the readers to regard Boudicca as a violent, alien like barbarian. With remarking on the Iceni beginning as allies to the Romans, it brings outrage to the readers whom have been made to believe that the Celts

The Tale Of Genji Essay

1791 words - 7 pages In the “The Broom Tree,” the main characters Genji, Tō no Chūjō and two acquaintances find themselves in a friendly debate regarding the various vices and virtue of women of the court. The story has only begun, but the narrator is already introducing the concept of an ideal woman and as the story progresses, an image of the ideal man emerges as well. The chapter opens with Genji and his friend in his room on a rainy day, and spotting some