This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Meiji Constitution Was A Blend Of Many Conflicting Ideas

1010 words - 4 pages

The Meiji Constitution was a Blend of Many Conflicting Ideas

It has been said that “the Meiji Constitution of 1889 was a blend of
many conflicting ideas.” This statement is true to a great extent as
the Constitution contained a number of inconsistency and ambiguities.
As a matter of fact, it was proclaimed with the intention of solving
certain existing problems rather than giving Japan a liberal and
democratic institution. It served as a symbol of progress: appeasement
of those discontented and politically conscious; consolidation of
power of Meiji oligarchs; a cover of democracy; stimulus of Japan’s
nationalism as well as a typical example of imitation of the West, all
of which were conflicting in meaning to each other. The Meiji leaders
adopted a utilitarian approach in drafting the Constitution and they
tried to balance and reconcile these conflicting forces. In short, the
Meiji Constitution was made with the aim of killing several birds with
one stone.

The first blend of conflicting ideas was appeasement versus
symbolization, which led to the birth of the Constitution in 1889. As
early as Meiji Restoration, there was a clamor for parliamentary
government from the aggrieved and the politically conscious. The
discontented included the idle ex-samurai and indebted peasants. The
politically-conscious were merchants and educated class. The clamor
came to head the ‘People’s Right Movement’ in the 1870s. Consequently,
the Meiji Government decided to promulgate a constitution to calm down
the unrest.

However, this idea of appeasement was opposed to the idea of
necessity. Democratic institutions were considered the inevitable
course of progress. Strong and advanced countries like Britain,
France, and the United States all had a Constitution and this
convinced the Meiji leaders that Japan with a constitution would be
recognized eventually as an advanced country. It was with this blend
of these conflicting ideas that the Constitution was made.

The second blend of conflicting ideas was democracy versus oligarchy.
On the surface, there were many democratic features like the diet, the
cabinet and a prime minister. However, oligarchy formed a greater
proportion in the blend as it was the underlying idea of the
constitution. For the diet, though the House of Representatives were
to be elected, the election was restricted to adults who paid national
taxes of 15 yen or more, thus limiting to 1% of the population.
Furthermore, the House of Peers and conservative check over the Lower
House. The House of Peers was actually dominated by a few men and the
idea of oligarchy was obvious.

Again the cabinet was devised by Ito to replace...

Find Another Essay On The Meiji Constitution was a Blend of Many Conflicting Ideas

Why was it that a great many of Americans opposed US involvement in the Vietnam War?

989 words - 4 pages The Vietnam War was one of the most time-consuming, energy, money and manpower consuming wars to the US. There were many reasons why a lot of Americans oppose their country's involvement in this war in the late 1960s and early 70s. Ranging from military to social and economic factors, and the propaganda in America also played a significant role in influencing the general public's opinion of the war.Militarily, many US citizens were disillusioned

The Constitution of a State Essay

2582 words - 10 pages , which establish and regulate or govern the government. (Barnett, P7) An older definition, that of Thomas Paine, reveals a more complex set of ideas: A constitution is not the act of a government, but of a people constituting a government, and a government without a constitution is a power without right…A constitution is a thing antecedent to a government; and a government is the only creature of a constitution

The Military Events of the Meiji Restoration

1736 words - 7 pages In this investigation I will look at the major historical and military events of the transition of the Edo period to the Meiji Period and the Meiji Restoration and look at how they relate to the freedom of Japanese people. Japan during the periods of 1600 – 1868 A.D. was a land of seclusion, military power and oppression. This was known as the Edo period. This however was one of the most peaceful times in Japan’s history. This peace was

The Conflicting Roles of Teachers

1509 words - 6 pages told him that he should have better classroom management because the incident could have been fatal and it would reflect badly on the school. Although this was the experience of one teacher, several teachers have experienced this conflicting expectation. The same parents in the community, whose children attend these schools, support the idea that despite his recurring misconduct, "The youth must get a chance." They then blame the teachers, who

Romare Bearden: A Blend of Music and Culture

1650 words - 7 pages closely related to the evolution of Louis Armstrong's music and many suggest that it was essential to the development of jazz. In the foreground the viewer sees a "working woman" being fixed up and primped by her pimp. In the background, one can see through a doorway into the scene of a ragtime musician playing a piano. Romare Bearden "captured the intensity of jazz musicians in the midst of creation". This piece was not a collage, as many of

Modernisation of Japan during the Meiji Restoration

1415 words - 6 pages "Enriching the country; strengthening the military" became the goal of the Meiji Government so that Japan "could find a place among the aggressors instead of among the victims of aggression" and they adopted an "all or nothing" style of modernisation based upon Western Examples.One aspect of Japan which was modernised based on Western examples and enforced using their own initiative was the economic development which took place during the Meiji

Yoga - This essay is about the art of Yoga as a blend of stretching poses, breathing patterns, and meditation

612 words - 2 pages Although it has deep roots in India, yoga has become very well know in the Western World. The word 'yoga' translates to mean the union of mind and body, and yoga is exactly that. Yoga uses a different approach to exercise that can benefit almost anyone. With it's low impact on joints and aide in stress reduction, yoga can be found everywhere from large studios to your local YMCA's. Yoga is a blend of stretching poses, breathing patterns and

How was your understanding of the ideas in a prescribed text shaped by the use of character?

1536 words - 6 pages If you have read the novel 'Of Mice and Men' then you would have been captivated. The novel is set, during the 1930s the Depression. It is very difficult to find a job at this time, because of it. Some of the many ideas John Steinbeck examines in his novel are friendship, loneliness and dreams. Each of the ideas has their own different meanings as demonstrated through the characters of the book.The dream is one of the ideas used in the text

Conflicting Desires in A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man

794 words - 3 pages doctrines ofreligion. When Stephen makes this decision, another girl is influential inmaking this happen. Stephen sees a girl on the beach and he is taken by herphysically beauty but also compares her to an "...angel of mortal youth andbeauty." She was what all the girls before her were except more. This girltells Stephen to go towards art and so that is how he finally decides tolead his life.Stephen has experienced many different feelings that

"To a great extent the Constitution is a document with as many checks upon the power of the people and majority rule as upon the power of the government." Assess the validity of this statement

745 words - 3 pages people as well. The authors of the constitution believed that most of the people of America were incompetent in the matters of running the government, and therefore they created many checks upon their power. The national government under the constitution became one in which checks and balances were placed among all people, so that no entity became too powerful.The national government was created in three branches, the executive, the judicial and

A CRITIQUE OF THE SERVICE MANAGEMENT IDEAS

2031 words - 9 pages scientific discipline. Foreign experts have developed a number of concepts for practical applications, including the management of quality of service (Berry 1991) (Gronroos 1988) (Gummesson 1995) (Parasuraman, Berry & Zeithaml 1985). Different schools of thought offer a wide variety of approaches to quality management services. Many of them take the correlation of consumer expectations and perceptions of service received as a "starting point." This

Similar Essays

The Rise And Development Of Nationalism In Meiji, Japan Was A Result Of Government Modernization Efforts

724 words - 3 pages The Rise and Development of Nationalism in Meiji, Japan was a Result of Government Modernization Efforts The rise and development of nationalism in Meiji Japan was a result of government modernization efforts. The ban on Christianity was lifted and the Meiji government practiced religion toleration. Foreign missionaries were allowed to propagate Christianity and carry out educational and medical work. However

Indian Culture: A Blend Of Various Culture

2265 words - 9 pages As a humble student when I sit down to think and write about Indian culture my mind goes back to 3000 or 2500 B.C. As I make a study of history and read some of the scriptures a question confronts me. How did the oldest Indian culture survive so long when so many great ancient cultures of Greece and Rome became museum pieces? What was the vitality of Indian culture that continued through the ages despite so many historical vicissitudes?To start

How Successful Was Japan In Establishing A New Style Of Economy, Government And Armed Forces In The Period Of The Meiji Emperor (1868 1912)?

2749 words - 11 pages study in Europe and USA. They admired the French legal system and army, The Prussian state constitution, police force and army, the USA's education system, the German army and their navy was almost a copy of the British navy.The Meiji Emperor was also well aware and desirous of change: only four years after ascending the throne in 1868, the nineteen-year- old made the first trip by train from Shimbashi Station in Tokyo to Yokohama. This showed the

The Meiji Restoration Of Japan Essay

2028 words - 8 pages foundation of imperial rule. By this reformation, Meiji Constitution was created by the government and all of the laws were renewed. Emperor gained control of the government and shogun and daimyos lost their power. Also, emperor were seen became the commander of the military and head of shintoism. He was seen as a god-figure. Due process was introduced for punishing the criminal Citizens were allowed to have many rights (freedom of speech