The Mind Body Problem Continued: Functionalism Takes A Stab

1021 words - 4 pages

The mind-body problem is an issue that yields various philosophical ideas. Functionalism is one such view that proposes a solution. The ideals of functionalism define mental events as brain states, and that mental states are created through a relationship with each other as well as with physical stimuli (such as the senses) teamed with a physical or behavioral result or response.Functionalism holds that the knowledge of the physical (or the functional methods) are not the complete picture. It is more concerned with the relation to similar and their opposite reaction, and how they relate to other functions. According to this view, mental states can only be seen through their relations with an input, the brain state that results or is created, and after the physical or observable affects of behavior (seen from an outside perspective). It sometimes helps to look at the situation in reverse to see the specificity of it all. For example, we know that a certain mental state, though mostly identifiable, cannot reveal the physical process or component that creates it, so a mental state must contain an element that is not reducible completely to the physical.Functionalism is often argued and compared against behaviorism and identity theories in the philosophical realm. Mainly, functionalism can be contrasted to the two theories by it's description of mental events. Both theories focus mainly on the sensory stimuli and behavioral result relationship, however, functionalism also takes into account other mental states (with little or no direct input), most arguably states like depression or stress. A major difference between Functionalism and identity theories is that with identity theory, mental states are confined to brain activity. Behaviorism on the other hand, reduces mental events and activity entirely based on an input/output relationship. But therein lies a problem in behaviorism's simplistic view. For example, according to this theory if I am feeling terribly sad and law, I am inclined to cry, instead of me being sad simply causing my behavior. In my opinion, functionalism takes it a step further than identity and behavior theories. Functionalism aims at relationships between input, mental states, and output in trying to decipher mental states. It looks at the causes and relationships of mental states, brain activity, and what is physically observed through a person's behavior. It is the middle steps (the focus on relation of mental states), that add to functionalism, and make it different from other theories.Another major flaw in identity theory is the view that it is too chauvinistic or narrow. Functionalism too, faces similar charges. The problem of chauvinism (in dealing with functionalism) is how it effects classification of stimulus and response. Chauvinism warns that philosophers should be wary of defining and characterizing reactions and mental states solely to the human body, because in doing so, philosophers would be stating that we (as...

Find Another Essay On The Mind-Body Problem Continued: Functionalism Takes a Stab

Exploring the Different Theories Involved in the Mind and Body Problem

2580 words - 10 pages identity of mind and brain a position that may be considered related to materialism and physicalism. Another theory is functionalism which is if an object is created under the style of functionalism that means that its artistic beauty cannot be separated from its function. Functionalism is the dominant theory of mental states in modern philosophy. Functionalism was developed as an answer to the mind-body problem

Comparing Thomas Reid and David Hume on the topic of the mind-body problem

851 words - 3 pages nothing that has perfect identity; everything is constantly changing. The body and mind are different from day to day, as is everything else. There is no impression of the self that is constant, and does not change. Hume called the self "a bundle or collection of different perceptions, which succeed each other with an inconceivable rapidity and are in a perpetual flux and movement". There is nothing consistent and permanent to base the self off of

Discuss the mind-body problem, its origin in Descartes' philosophy, Descartes' solution and other relevant reactions, including you own?

524 words - 3 pages 1641.Further works, Principles and then Passions, supplemented Meditations with a more ordered approach and a clearer study of feelings.The mind holds no spatial qualities, being a concern of the physical, yet connected with the body. Where did the immaterial and material meet though? Interactionism and Cartesian Substance Dualism in Meditations 4 explain the pineal gland as a "weather vane" sort that allows the mind to affect the body. However

The Mind-Body Connection

1674 words - 7 pages emotions and thoughts on physical health.History of the Mind-Body ConnectionThe concept of the interconnection between the brain and body has been around for quite a while. Ancient healing practices, such as Traditional Chinese Medicine and Ayurvedic medicine emphasized important links between the mind and body. Hippocrates once wrote: "The natural healing force within each one of us is the greatest force in getting well." This statement reflects

X vs Stab. The story of a rivalry - RLA - assignment

647 words - 3 pages . Well welcome to the beautiful Asia. Just in case you ever see yourself doubting someone. Stab is a very rich man, he usually wears his gold armor on him and usually has his hair braided back into a bun. He is also a very young looking man. If you ever do encounter him don’t show off anything, don’t befriend him, just come back straight to me and let me know 1 week later… Mike: *casually walking down the street with his girlfriend, sees Stab* Man

The Road to a Healthy Body and Mind

703 words - 3 pages The Road to a Healthy Body and Mind Having a healthy body and mind is not keep on dieting or starving ourselves. The purpose of the journey is how we balancing our body and mind positively. Anna Damitru (2013) explained that adding a consistent and balancing daily workout routine will contribute overall health improvement. She listed several steps in order to keep body and mind healthy. One of the steps is set our mindset in positive area which

“Good humor is a tonic for the mind and body

970 words - 4 pages "Good humor is a tonic for the mind and body. It is the best anecdote for anxiety and depression. It is a business asset. It attracts and keeps friends. It lightens human burdens. It is the direct routine to serenity and contentment." -Greenville Kleiser. Comedy as mentioned is that of a necessary entity in one's everyday life and undertakings. The use of comedy can brighten one's day or simply provide the humor that people desire. When able to

How to Manage a Body to Improve the Mind

1110 words - 5 pages How to Manage a Body to Improve the Mind Throughout academia and higher education, in general advice can be found on how to learn or how to more effectively absorb the knowledge that is being presented. While there is plenty of information to be found on how to take notes or how to review for a test, there is the equally important but much less talked about impact of the body and mind connection. The impact of having a body that is

The Mind and the Body

906 words - 4 pages there is a man who would give his life to keep a life you love beside you” (145-148). Carton continued to put off his affections until he could no longer keep the magnitude of his emotions inside, while Darnay was sure of his affections and calmly addressed them. Carton and Darnay acted as the mind that can repress thoughts and emotions and the body that is forced to handle things calmly and composedly. The body deals with physicality and

The Distinction Between the Mind and Body

647 words - 3 pages "outer" are construed as metaphors, the problem of how one's mind and body can influence one another is well-known charged with abstract difficulties. Therefore there is a popular conflict between mind and matter. A conflict which is often brought out as follows. Material objects are categorized as "space" and what happens to one body in one part of a space is mechanically combined with what happens to other bodies in other parts of space. On

The Smell of Disappointment: A Study of the Mind, the Body, and the Building

2085 words - 8 pages greater significance for the scent. He almost reverently refers to the odour in the office building as “the smell of disappointment,” attaching an emotional meaning—and a story of origin—to something that everyone else understands to be a mere problem (Fitzgerald 677). According to the Manager, Singlebury is uncharacteristically vocal about this opinion. One only other instance of Singlebury making a firm contention is when he claims that the body

Similar Essays

The Mind/Body Problem Essay

1589 words - 6 pages The mind/body problem is a fundamental philosophical problem that even the greatest thinkers have pondered throughout our history, but still have yet to provide an adequate solution for. The problem lies specifically in the philosophical realm of metaphysics, which involves the examination of the nature of our reality. According to metaphysics, reality consists of two things: the physical, and the mental. The 'physical' are things that exist in

Mind Body Problem Essay

6819 words - 27 pages some of the questions regarding this issue.The mind-body problem is the problem of determining the relationship between the human body and its mind. Are our minds something different from our physical bodies? Suppose we think that the mind is a substance of some sort -- a mental substance. We might still ask: Is there some way to explain what the mind, a mental substance, is, in terms of physical substance? Or will we maintain that the mind is

The Mind Body Problem In Descartes Meditations

1402 words - 6 pages , whether it be imagining, sensing, feeling, or reasoning, that he exists. Since he can only be certain of the existence of himself insofar as he is a thinking thing, then he has knowledge of his existence of only a thinking thing.After he has established himself as a thinking thing, he then goes on to argue that the mind is more certainly known than the body. He goes on to say that it is possible that all knowledge of external objects, including his

Androids And The Mind/Body Problem By Rebecca King

840 words - 4 pages The Star Trek: The Next Generation episode “The Measure of a Man” makes a compelling argument on androids and the mind/body problem. The episode is about Lt. Commander Data who is an android who acts identically to human behavior. Data is put on trial to find out if he should have human rights or if he is considered property of Starfleet. The episode makes interesting points as to what qualifies a person of having a mind and soul. William Hasker