The Model Minority Essay

1682 words - 7 pages

Have you ever wondered where the term "Model Minority" came from? Do you know what it means, and what it applies to? "Model Minority" refers to a minority ethnic, racial, or religious group whose members achieve a higher degree of success than the population average. The term Model Minority was coined in the Mid-1960's by William Peterson, a social demographer who believed through hard work and determination that this minority group has risen above the ranks of "problem minority." The term Model Minority mostly applies to Asian Americans that portray the hard working, musically talented, and mathematically brilliant Model Minority. Even though it's meant to be a good thing, the Model Minority has created a false perception of Asian American success that is different in reality and has negatively affected the Asian Americans.After all the Model Minority in the eyes of Americans is seen as a good thing, but many Asian Americans resent the label of Model Minority and see it as another attempt to stereotype a minority group. The Model Minority causes an identity problem with other Asian ethnic groups; the label homogenizes all Asian American and hides their differences. The label also causes everyone to think all Asian Americans are college educated and a wealthy middleclass citizen of America. The Model Minority label also causes a big problem with Asian Americans. It often pits them against other minority groups. I think The Model Minority is just a myth in which there is a good side of it and also a bad side of it. The myth was made with good intentions however, not every Asian American is what it describes as and Asian Americans should be treated like any other group.In "The Harmful Myth of Asian Superiority," he talks about the difference between the myth and reality of Asian American success. The example of high earnings of the Asian American compared to Caucasians are misleading, because most Asian Americans live in California, Hawaii, and New York-states with higher incomes and higher cost of living than the national average. When comparing family incomes it is deceptive because Asian Americans have more workers per family than Caucasians. Another issue Takaki brought up in his article was that the Model Minority categorized all Americans as the same, not every Asian American is successfully portrayed by the Model Minority such as Chinese, Japanese, and Asian Indians. Takaki said that although many Asian Americans are getting good jobs and earning high salaries, most of them hit the "glass ceiling" and never reach the positions of officials or managers. Only eight percent of Asians have held this title, compared to twelve percent of all other groups. Most Asian American know their success is largely a myth with regard to the theory of the Model Minority that it makes other people think they are successful; however, in reality, a lot of Asian Americans are poor and uneducated.In "The Myth of the Model Minority," Philip Chiu talks about how the...

Find Another Essay On The Model Minority

New Latino Diaspora Essay

1196 words - 5 pages “model minority” stereotype. Wortham et al define the “model minority” as “‘the good’ minority that seeks advancement through quiet diligence in study and work and by not making waves; the minority that other American minorities should seek to emulate” (Wortham et al, 6). While Mexican immigrants might be depicted in a positive light through the “model minority” stereotype, this stereotype only furthers white supremacy and leaves minorities

Midterm Paper

1307 words - 6 pages Tomorrow, a crime-drama film made in 2002, parodied almost the exact opposite, specifically the “model minority” theme. The term “model minority” referred to minority groups that were perceived as achieving high success in education, income, and general stability. Lastly, Chan is Missing, a movie made in 1982 consisting of an amalgam of different genres, such as detective and drama, explored the identity crisis that Chinese Americans faced in the


872 words - 4 pages It was evident that these teachers affirmed their students’ native languages. The teachers focused on the content that the students were learning and allowed students to respond in whatever language they preferred. The teachers’ affirmation of the students’ native languages ended up affirming the students themselves. This maximized student involvement, participation and understanding. The traditional schooling model is not meeting the needs

New Latino Diaspora

1056 words - 5 pages Wortham Mortimer and Allard aim to summarize their study and findings exploring the Mexican model minority model and the impact of this on a growing Latino community, an area called the New Latin Diaspora. The New Latin Diaspora refers to a region not preciously related to a Latino population but in the past 15 years has become home to a large recently grown and continuing to grow Latino community. The city used in this particular research is

Short overview of Asians as a Super Minority-class presentation from notes.

630 words - 3 pages neighborhood. It's easier for the comparisons to be made between Asians that are successful and other minority groups while ignoring the very fact that both groups still show signs of discrimination, economically, anyway, late into the 20th century.Lee, Thea. (1990). "Trapped on a Pedestal: Asian Americans confront model-minority stereotype." From Dollars & Sense, p. 12-15. In Annual Editions: Race and Ethnic Relations 00/01. (2000) Ed by John

"Using Assessment in Higher Education to Improve Success for Minority Students"

1811 words - 7 pages entitled, Involvement in Learning shifted the focus from K-12 to post-secondary education, citing that higher education was in no better shape than the "sub-standard" conditions found in the nations elementary and secondary school systems. This report challenged higher education institutions to improve quality by strengthening student learning through a model which included student involvement in learning, communicating high expectations, and

Delegate model with the truste model of representation.

631 words - 3 pages , delegates if you will, to put in our vote. If that elected official were to decide that his representative public was wrong, and consequently vote according to his personal opinions, he has not fulfilled his duty as a REPRESENTATIVE. The very meaning of the word "representative" denotes that his vote should symbolize the wills of the public. That said, there are also some problems with a "delegate" model for representation as well, namely, minority

UK Institutions Promoting Health of Ethnic Minority Women

2539 words - 10 pages model of health, cannot treat. The social model of health is a most suitable alternative to the medical model for dealing with domestic violence in minority communities because it considers how “the complex and interacting social, economic, environmental and personal factors” impact on people’s health (Taylor and Field 2007). Interagency working According to Lloyd et al (2001) interagency working is defined as “more than one agency working

DeTocqueville and Mill, and the tyranny of the majority

991 words - 4 pages political philosophers. Alexis de Tocqueville and John Stuart Mill existed among those most apprehensive of the democratic experiment. To each of these men, democracy certainly possessed certain positive attributes, but at the same time, represented a potential threat to the individual freedoms of man, through a much feared 'tyranny of the majority'.De Tocqueville and Mill both cite the possible oppression of minority groups as a significant

Wygant v. Jackson Board of Education

2280 words - 9 pages court decision on multiple accounts. First, the Court rejected the lower courts rationale that the racially-based layoff provision was justified in effectuating the Board’s interest in providing minority role model for its minority students, as an attempt to alleviate the effects of societal discrimination. The Court reaffirmed its insistence on some showing of prior discrimination by governmental unit involved before allowing limited use of

Background of ESL

1328 words - 5 pages opportunity, but not by slowing the learning process of the English proficient for the English deficient.ConclusionI believe the ESL pullout model is the best model available. It will not hinder the mainstream classes. It will provide opportunity for minority language students to succeed in mainstream classes. Historically, our nation's educational goals have gone from Protestant and religious based to a secular view where religion has been

Similar Essays

The Model Minority Theory: The Cause Of An Overlooked Culture?

2401 words - 10 pages The Model Minority theory is a concept that puts the assumption in the minds of people that all persons who are from Asian or of Asian decent are successful, smart, hard working, and model citizens who respect the authority of their country. The Model Minority theory became very apparent in 1966 when two major magazines, New York Times Magazine and U.S. New and World Report, each published articles that gave praise to the great achievements of

The Minority Predicament: An Analysis Of Asian American Success And The Model Minority Paradigm

2053 words - 8 pages The Minority Predicament: An Analysis of Asian American Success and the Model Minority Paradigm My grandmother sent me a letter from home, telling the success story of her old Chinese tenants who, through hard work, had become very wealthy in the 9 short years they lived in America. My grandmother embraces the belief that "with hard work, patience and a little help from the model minority stereotype, someday Asians will gain full approval of

Model Minority Essay

1252 words - 5 pages in the US. In order to catch up along with the rest of the world, the government created an example for their own people, known as the model minority. The model minority is a stereotype suggests that Asian Americans are “more academically, economically, and socially successful than any other racial minority groups.” (Yoo) In today’s world, Asian Americans are known to be “culturally — even genetically — endowed with the characteristics that

Model Minority Stereotype Essay

1253 words - 6 pages , Americans associate “smart” with “Asian”. Many Americans assume that the “Asian” race is more successful than other racial minorities in the United States. This stereotype is known as the model minority stereotype. Success, in this essay, is measured by academics, occupation, relations, and economics. Racial minorities include African Americans, Native Americans, Asian Americans, and Hawaiians. The cause of this stereotype was the Immigration