This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The "Mommy Track" Debate Essay

2248 words - 9 pages

The "Mommy Track" Debate

As more and more women continue to move into the workplace, hot debate has arisen surrounding the issues of work and family balance. Many female managers and professionals with young families are leaving the fast track for what has become known as the “mommy track.” Today, as young people are applying for jobs, many now take into consideration a company’s values of a work and life balance. Some say that the pressures of maternity are becoming an obstacle for many women who wish to continue their climb up the corporate ladder. Often times when women become pregnant, they are forced to abandon their careers. Therefore, the following question has aroused many controversial arguments: can women obtain high standards of success in their careers and maintain the best possible home life?

These debates have generated a new term referred to as the “mommy track.” The “mommy track” is a new option many employers have for working women to consider. It involves making the switch from working full time to a career path calling for part-time employment, allowing for more time to be spent at home with the children. Today, many large corporations are considering implementing “mommy track” option.

There are conflicting viewpoints involving the “mommy track.” Supporters of the track claim that women cannot make it to the top of their prospective career fields and be the primary focus in their children’s lives. They say a “mommy track” would allow these women to maintain their careers while playing a vitally important role at home. Those opposed to the creation of a “mommy track” claim that it is separate and unequal, permanently derailing women’s careers, making them like “second-class citizens at work”. Implementing this policy would only give male executives more opportunity to deny women promotion. They question whether or not this choice is really necessary and they state that a variety of other possibilities exist for creating a healthy work and family balance.

In order for both sides of the “mommy track” debate to convey their messages to their intended audiences, the utilization of specific persuasive techniques and rhetorical strategies becomes key. Both the supporters and non-supporters of a “mommy track” put these techniques and strategies to use. Ultimately it is the opponents of a “mommy track” that compose the more persuasive argument by employing the most effective rhetorical methods.

In her essay “Management Women and the New Facts of Life,” Felice Schwartz makes her message of implementing an effective two-track career path very clear, but she neglects the audience to which she is appealing, thus lessening the persuasiveness of her argument. Schwartz’s essay appeared in the Harvard Business Review. The Harvard Business Review publishes articles that advocate the theory and practice of management. It is published by the Harvard...

Find Another Essay On The "Mommy Track" Debate

Gender Inequality in the Accounting Profession

2344 words - 9 pages : Gender Inequality in the Accounting Profession From my extensive research, I have found that there is gender inequality in the accounting field. Research suggests a few reasons for this, such as the “mommy track”, and the idea that a successful accounting executive have what society considers masculine attributes. The “mommy track” is the idea that women will put family life in high priority, therefore work like and success may suffer. It is a

Legal Workplace: Women Overcoming Obstacles Essay

1653 words - 7 pages and consideration to their female-specific needs have high job satisfaction and performance among the female employees. The ultimatum female attorneys face when choosing between partner track and ‘mommy track’ is something that law firms are trying to decrease. Firms are trying to implement policies that help female attorneys with their work-life balance issues. Studies have found that 30 percent of the lawyers are female, but only 8 percent of

Gender Inequality

862 words - 3 pages tied to low paying careers such as servants, childcare workers,receptionist, preschool teachers and nurses. " It is generally accepted that inequalitybetween men and women stems from attitudes, prejudices and assumptionsconcerning the different roles assigned to men and women in society"(Overholt et al.,1984). 'Mommy Track' is the key reason for women to be limited in jobs. Themommy track is an expectation that women grow up to become housewife

Use of Cellular Phones While Driving

2534 words - 10 pages station to check for reports of a hit-and-run incident. Late last year, when Ald. Burton Natarus (42nd) proposed a partial ban on use of cellular phones in moving vehicles, I was one of those who spoke out against the idea, telling Natarus during a televised debate that catching up on telephone calls while driving was an important and benign form of multi-tasking.... But ever since he brought it up, I've been paying increased attention to

Should genetic engineering be banned?

1611 words - 6 pages debate on genetic engineering. First I will summarise the history of genetic science, and look at the origins of the debate. Then I will discuss the manipulation of plant, animal and human genes in turn, and consider the possible benefits and dangers of each. Finally, I will suggest that, for all its potential dangers, it is better for research to go ahead openly than for governments to try to ban such research altogether.GE is quite a recent science

Community Service

841 words - 3 pages about themselves. When the day would end, most of the children were almost tear struck because they loved to be around their environment. I remember my 4th day one of the kids said to his mom "mommy can Chris be our new daddy because he is the best!" Wow did that change me, I achieved an important trust within those kids and in doing so became a part of their environment.The final day was a hard one indeed. My mind was set to not say goodbye to

5 inexpensive baby shower ideas

706 words - 3 pages speaking about children and inexpensive baby showers. So look for free printables of Mickey or Minnie Mouse or both together if baby's gender is unknown. Use the printables for creating the invitations and keep the same track for room decorations, cake and so on. Some strawberry and bananna drinks will lighten up the atmosphere and match your Disney theme. Styilish up the environment with some lovely red and white dotted ribbons and use personalized

Where I Will be in Ten Years

728 words - 3 pages see myself having many of my goal accomplished, if not accomplished, I will be working on accomplishing those goals to fulfill my life. I live with my mommy and daddy in La Cresta along with my brother. I have many friends in my life right now, but i don’t want to drag on this paper with all of their names, but I hang with the guys on the weekends. I do not currently have a girlfriend but I am seeing a very beautiful lady by the name of

A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Internet Forums

2311 words - 10 pages actual debate, and rather than merely providing society a mirror to see its faults, people can discuss those faults without needing to sacrifice reputation or invoke persecution. A good example of what one can discuss with this newfound obscurity are topics like what is found in Malcolm Gladwell’s “The Sports Taboo” when he says “What you’re not supposed to say is what we were saying in my track days – that we were better because we were black


3538 words - 15 pages before, with images of dismemberment and mutilation becoming commonplace in many movies. Not only has it become more violent, it is ubiquitous. Violence in the mass media has been a topic of much debate in recent years. One of the main concerns about media violence is the effect that it has on children. The effects of media violence on children have been studied for over forty years, with researchers repeatedly finding correlations between

History of the Nürburgring

1256 words - 6 pages The Nürburgring is a race track located around the village of Nürburg, in the Rhineland-Palatinate, of Germany. The track today has a total of three circuit configurations the GP-Strecke, Nordschleife, and the Combined Circuit with there being four total closed circuits. The GP-Strecke is a 3.199 mile asphalt circuit with a total of 16 turns. The Nordschleife is a 12.93 mile asphalt and concrete circuit with a total of 154 turns. The longest of

Similar Essays

The Family Medical And Leave Act

1914 words - 8 pages was being fully funded by the company. Conclusion: Even an act that is 198 pages long can be interpreted as vague. Seven years after its implementation, there remains a lot to be discussed and discovered. The Mommy Track What comes first, a family or a career? The career track VS. the parent track. Do you build a family once you have securely established yourself in the workplace, knowing that you will be able to finance such a task

Flexibility In The Workplace Essay

996 words - 4 pages mothers. (Williams, 2010) Congress needs to wake up and join the rest of the civilized world when it comes to protecting families. Professional working mothers who cannot work 50 or more house a week are often barred from the fast track and put on the mommy track.(Willams, 2010) On the mommy track they might receive more flexibility but they lose chances for advancement. Professional who uses flexible work arrangements may be seen as less valuable

Chimpanzee's And Tool Use Essay

1568 words - 7 pages forever. The question now at hand is if having the chimpanzees that we study in captivity makes a difference between studying wild chimps. These interesting creatures can be found naturally in the rainforests of Africa. Development of tool use: “Tool use is rare in animals, and the chimpanzees stand out as the most proficient tool users besides humans” (Boesh, Boesch-Achermann18). Some debate has taken place between researchers regarding how these

Over Parenting Essay

827 words - 4 pages of over-parenting”), mother Bethany Young Hardy ponders about her own frustration with Mommy and me classes. She got frustrated when her son did not fit in in a Mommy and me class until she real-ized that we should not push our children into being a certain way. o In text 3 (“Over-parenting is the curse of our time”) author Johann Hari discusses the new GPS device for ‘helicopter parents’. It is a device that allows parents to track a child’s