This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Moral, Legal, And Economical Aspects Of Capital Punishment

1552 words - 6 pages

Capital punishment has long been a topic for heated debate throughout the United States of America and the civilized world. For many politicians, the death penalty has been a key pillar to winning a state or election; and, to some extent, politics have been a key influence in America’s justice system. Many nations have outlawed capital punishment, with the United States included between 1972 and 1976. In the United States, there has been a renewed movement for this “eye for an eye” method, citing such arguments as “deterrence” and “victims’ rights.” This movement begs a single question – is there any economical, legal, or statistical support for the ultimate punishment? This article will strive to answer that question by evaluating several key issues (be they supporting or otherwise) concerning capital punishment – the legitimacy of ‘deterrence,’ the legality of capital punishment under the Eighth Amendment’s “cruel and unusual punishment” clause, and the cost associated with putting a man to death in relation to the cost associated with life imprisonment.

The Eighth Amendment to the United States Constitution states, “Excessive bail shall not be required, nor excessive fines imposed, nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted.” The key phrase to examine when determining the constitutionality of capital punishment is “cruel and unusual punishments.” The question that must be answered are ‘what makes a punishment cruel and unusual’ and if or how these standards apply to capital punishment. According to Supreme Court Associate Justice William Brennan “the Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause ‘must draw its meaning from the evolving standards of decency that mark the progress of a maturing society” (Brennan 32). Judging from this definition, a definition set forth by the entire Court and not just those Justices with dissenting opinions in the case of Gregg v. Georgia, one can easily make the statement that the taking of a human life in return for another does not agree with the standards of decency of our maturing society. Justice Brennan goes further to state that “death is not only an unusually severe punishment, unusual in its pain, in its finality…” (Brennan 32). This argument is one of the major summarizing points of Brennan’s argument – the death penalty is incredibly severe and irreversibly final. According to an article in the USA Today by columnist Jacqueline Blais, 117 people have been freed from death row on account of innocence (Blais). This figure is astonishing when one considers the innocents who slip through the cracks in states like Texas, where the average death row inmate has just ten years to prove his or her innocence from behind bars.

Opponents might argue that the death penalty provides closure to the victim’s family. However, this view makes an assumption about the U.S. Justice system that should never be made – that the system is about retribution and not about justice. Interestingly, in a survey conducted in a...

Find Another Essay On The Moral, Legal, and Economical Aspects of Capital Punishment

Capital Punishment is Moral and Ethical

2280 words - 9 pages victim, he has the potential and incentive to murder again, and he must return to a foreign way of life. This is not to mention how society might react to an ex-convict. After he leaves prison he will be treated like not as a free person but as a murderer. In the end everyone is arguably unhappy. The idea of institutionalization should be look at more closely before life in prison is considered as the more “moral” punishment. I do not think

Capital Punishment: Moral Or Immoral? Essay

1373 words - 6 pages apital Punishment, also known as the death penalty is a very controversial issue in today's society. Capital Punishment is the legal infliction of death as a penalty for violating criminal law. Methods of Capital Punishment have ranged from crucifixion, stoning, to impaling, to modern time Capitol Punishment that generally consists of lethal gas or injection, electrocution, hanging, or at times shooting over the years. About 90 nations all over

Capital Punishment is Not Moral

1782 words - 7 pages controversial topic with many different views. Many supporters of the death penalty believe that it is more ethical to carry out capital punishment since those who are receiving it have committed the most heinous and unforgivable crimes. The evidence and research shows that capital punishment is not morally permissible. Many studies show that the death penalty costs much more than life without parole for the max punishment (Dieter 6). There is also

Capital Punishment: Main Aspects of this Controversial Topic

1258 words - 5 pages mean legally killing, executing or taking someone’s life as a punishment for a crime that constitutes such punishment. However, which crimes are considered punishable by death? And what controversies arise over such punishments? These are some of many questions being discussed today over the subject of capital punishment. This research discusses the main aspects of

"Capital Punishment Cannot Prevent Murder" talks about the negative aspects of the death penalty

1396 words - 6 pages Capital Punishment Cannot Prevent MurderCapital punishment has always been a controversial topic. Applied already in the ancient times, executions have always been a part of our lives. Nevertheless, more and more countries abolished this kind of penalty because they started to doubt its fairness and reliability. Amnesty International states on its website that" an average of three countries per year have abolished the death penalty since 1976

Should Capital Punishment Be Legal?

1323 words - 5 pages Capital punishment is a very controversial issue today. There are good statements made on both sides of the argument. A couple of questions should be asked before deciding which side to take in the never ending debate of capital punishment. Is capital punishment a cruel and unusual way of punishing serious offenders? Should the mentally ill be susceptible to capital punishment? A lot of states made capital punishment legal, but not all of them

Should Capital Punishment be Legal?

606 words - 2 pages been reversed and more and more states are resorting to capital punishment for serious offenses such as murder. If America continues these outrageous acts then America is nothing better than the criminals on death row. Capital punishment is given to prisoners who are convicted of committing unspeakable acts and after years in prison some welcome their demise. However the question remains, should capital punishment be legal? Capital punishment should

Legal Studies Essay– Capital Punishment

1873 words - 7 pages October 2008, <http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_rights_in_Australia>Death Penalty Abolition Act 1973, viewed 27th October 2008, <http://www.austlii.edu.au/au/legis/cth/consol_act/dpaa1973228/>The Bible and Capital Punishment, viewed 27th October 2008, <http://www.tektonics.org/af/cappun.html>Revolution: The Bible for Teen Guys; New International Version, 2003, The Zondervan Corporation, Grand Rapids, Michigan Page PAGE 5 of NUMPAGES 5 Legal Studies Essay - Capital Punishment

Capital Punishment: California's Financial Burden and Legal Nightmare

1719 words - 7 pages a mistake is made a life is wrongfully lost. In addition to the legal and financial criticisms of capital punishment in California, there exists profound moral arguments against the idea of capital punishment in general. Helen Prejean, a longstanding member of the Order of the Sisters of St. Joseph of Medaille, has insight from her experiences counseling death row inmates in Lousiana. Prejean claims that executions come with too high a moral

Capital Punishment: Should it be Legal?

1045 words - 4 pages Capital Punishment: Should it be Legal? After the Timothy McVeigh execution over 80 percent of viewers polled supported the decision the courts made to put McVeigh to death, and even a handful of the people who supported the execution thought it was preformed in a way that was too humane. Some people say that the death penalty is the most effective way to control serious crimes such as murder, while others say that it is extremely unethical

The Pros and Cons of Capital Punishment

906 words - 4 pages down and hopefully continue to decrease over the years. Opponents believe that the capital punishment laws are unnecessary and should not stay in place. They dislike spending millions of dollars a year to execute their own citizens. Hence, opponents find it a disgrace when citizens of other countries come view the executions of Americans because it shows that Americans do not value human life enough or are moral. It’s also a shame that there are many innocent inmates on death row that are forced to plead guilty or wait for their death sentence. Capital punishment will continue to have its good value and it’s con.

Similar Essays

Social, Moral And Historical Aspects Of Capital Punishment

1392 words - 6 pages face the fact that you know you are going to die and how much painful some punishments can be ; we saw how , still in 2014 , a lot of counties approve the use of the capital punishment. However, the debate is still open and hopefully, the next few years something will change. Bibliography William W. Wilkins (2007) University of Richmond Law Review Available at: http://lawreview.richmond.edu/the-legal-political-and-social-implications-of-the

Capital Punishment: The Social, Moral, And Historical Aspects Of This Controversial Topic

1621 words - 6 pages items as capital punishment is now a routine act – killers are killed. Supporters of capital punishment defend their arguments by making it clear that society has a moral duty to look after the wellbeing and interests of its people. Those who commit murders threaten these wellbeing and interests of the people. The only alternative is to rid the society of these murderers so that they do not kill again. Similarly, there are those who are of the

Is Capital Punishment Moral? Essay

2012 words - 8 pages Is capital punishment an equal consequence for the death and killing of another person? Should we even consider this an option, or should we make the senseless individual rot behind the walls of a prison, where they are treated like the criminal they are. Even though every action deserves the consequence equal to the level of crime, capital punishment should be considered before we use it to take another persons’ life because in our judicial

Capital Punishment, The Legal Infliction Of The Death Penalty

1337 words - 5 pages Capital punishment is the legal infliction the death penalty. It is obviously the most severe form of criminal punishment. (Bedau1) Capital punishment is a controversial way of dealing with violent criminals. The main alternative to the death penalty is life in prison. Capital punishment has been around for thousands of years as a means of eradicating criminals. A giant debate started between supporters and opposers of execution, over the