The Morality Of Lying In Contrast To The Philosophies Of Kant

2329 words - 9 pages

The young girl gazes at you helplessly from within the tangled wreckage. You witnessed the crash – a massive truck careened into a minivan as it passed on the highway, killing the driver on impact, and virtually tearing the girl in half. Now she hangs from the car, held together by the seatbelt. Her nervous system critically damaged, she can’t feel much pain, but she knows that her situation is not optimal, to say the least. She is six years old – she probably doesn’t understand the concept of death. As you stare equally helplessly into her fear stricken eyes, the only words that you can muster are: “Don’t worry, everything will be okay.”
This is obviously a lie – there is absolutely no chance that the dying girl will indeed survive and have no cause for worry – but this lie contains ideas to sooth her fear, allowing a comparatively peaceful passage out of this life. Surely few would argue that the little girl did not deserve to be comforted, as the alternative seems somewhat heartless – “Why should I help you? You’re not worth my time, you’ll be dead in a minute.” Indeed, telling the truth, in this case, appears even less moral than the lie. There is, however, at least one who would disagree with this scenario: a certain Immanuel Kant, whose philosophy insists that lying is wrong in every circumstance. But despite Kant’s fervent belief, it is not hard to see how lying can be a beneficial, mutually advantageous, and in fact moral act that still consistently complies with Kant’s own moral imperatives.
Because Kant’s philosophy does not specifically define what a “lie” is, we are led to believe that speaking an untruth, no matter what the context, is strictly immoral. But speaking untruth does not necessitate the negative connotation that has become associated with the idea of lying. Omitting unintentional lying (i.e. expressing a misconception, or otherwise unwittingly speaking an untruth), deliberate lying takes many different forms. For this paper, it is necessary to distinguish several of those forms, which vary in severity. First, there is the simple white lie, which is defined as “a trivial lie that is told for diplomatic or well-intentioned reasons.” These are typically inconsequential responses made in an effort to preserve one’s feelings, such as in the cliché case of a spouse asking, “Do these jeans make me look fat?” They rarely have any lasting effect, and are, for this argument, considered moot. On the other side of the scale is the outright lie, also known as deception, which is “a sender intentionally trying to get someone to believe something that the sender knows to be false” (Gass & Seiter, 1999). These lies are the sort that have most often garnered scorn, as they are typically malevolent (or at the very least, selfish), and utilized to serve a personal end. We will see that this is not always the case, but for the sake of argument, the “outright lie” will begin as an evil. Lying, as a whole, is perceived negatively, because...

Find Another Essay On The Morality of Lying in Contrast to the Philosophies of Kant

The Philosophies of Friedrich Nietzsche Essay

1002 words - 4 pages Philosophies of Friedrich Nietzsche Friedrich Nietzsche was a 19th-century German philosopher and held in regard amongst the greatest philosophers of the early part century. He sharpened his philosophical skills through reading the works of the earlier philosophers of the 18th century such as Immanuel Kant, John Stuart Mill, Arthur Schopenhauer and African Spir; however, their works and beliefs were opposite to his own. His primary mentor was

Compare and Contrast the Philosophies of John Locke, Thomas Hobbes, and Karl Marx

772 words - 3 pages In the idea of human nature; origin of state, the nature of government, the rights of regulation can be drawn as the reflection of insightful philosophies of John Locke, Thomas Hobbes and Karl Marx. By understanding this within the context of human nature, we can see their ideas play to how they perceive a modern philosophy. Karl Marx's Communist Manifesto illustrates the desire to build "a society without economic classes". John Locke's

Using example to analyse the five philosophies of marketing.

1865 words - 7 pages J. Baker, a critical decision is the selection of target market segments. (Baker, 2000, p188). The management of Delixi noticed that organization buyers tend to purchase the lights of special function and high quality. In contrast, consumers usually enjoy the beautiful and quality lights. Especially the family buyers, they often focus on the appearance, quality, and coordination with the environment. To combine their producing implements and

Compare and contrast the concepts of eudaimonia and happiness, and their respective roles in the ethical philosophies of Aristotle and Mill

2188 words - 9 pages flourishing of the individual is by far the most important thing, and help is given to others only as it helps the giver become eudaimon.So in conclusion, the concepts of eudaimonia and happiness share a number of similarities, such as an elitist belief in the distinction between higher and lower pleasures and the belief that all action aims at some greater end which is the good. Both doctrines try to be consistent with the common-sense morality, and

The Birth of Religions and Philosophies in the Ancient World

1315 words - 5 pages The Birth of Religions and Philosophies in the Ancient World From the beginning of time, people all over the world have wondered where we come from, what our divine purpose in life is, and what we can expect after death. Questions about right and wrong, society and government, and nature and the cosmos, are some of the few wonders that ultimately created some of the earliest philosophies and religions, helping people find peace and explanation

The Critical Philosophy of Immanuel Kant

2526 words - 10 pages The Critical Philosophy of Immanuel Kant Criticism is Kant's original achievement; it identifies him as one of the greatest thinkers of mankind and as one of the most influential authors in contemporary philosophy. But it is important to understand what Kant means by'criticism', or 'critique'. In a general sense the term refers to a general cultivation of reason 'by way of the secure path of science' (Bxxx). More particularly, its use is not

Lying is Story Telling (The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn)

1698 words - 7 pages Courtney ArisonEnglish 11 HMr. SmithApril 21, 2014The Truth Behind Good and Bad StorytellingLying is story telling. One cannot make up a story without there being some deal of truth and experience to create the situation. In The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn by Mark Twain, lying is a predominant theme. Many of the characters are found to lie quite often through the novel. When knowing a story being told is a lie, it is easy to automatically

The Bitter Tears of Petra von Kant

1380 words - 6 pages Have you ever loved somebody so much that you would give anything to be with them even if they didn’t even realize your existence? What lengths would you go to in order to keep them in your life? In the movie The Bitter Tears of Petra von Kant directed by famous German film director Rainer Werner Fassbinder, we explore the manipulation inherent in every relationship and the lengths to which people will go to stay with the ones they love. The

The Morality of Money.

1187 words - 5 pages morality." His reason is that one makes money through production and trade. And that is the noblest way to live: as a producer who creates value and then gains values from others through voluntary exchange.That is just what people normally do in a free market. Money does not itself create anything, but because it is the medium of exchange it makes possible the specialized production and long-distance commerce that are the basis of our advanced and

The morality of abortion

1398 words - 6 pages in the question of the morality of abortion. When parents decide to keep or not keep a baby the issue of adoption does not play into this. The reason for this is that once the baby is born that the parents may change their mind if they want to keep it. Parents must decide at the onset of the pregnancy to decide if they can in good conscience bring a child into the world, if the answer is yes, then people should proceed with the pregnancy and

The Morality of Torture

1348 words - 5 pages The Morality of Torture The moral issue of torture is one that has come under scrutiny by many national and international organizations as of late. To talk about torture one must really understand what torture is. As taken from “1.a. Infliction or severe physical pain as a means of punishment or coercion. b. An instrument or a method for inflicting such pain. 2. Excruciating physical or mental pain; agony. 3. Something

Similar Essays

Kant And The Morality Of Anger

4129 words - 17 pages Kant and the Morality of Anger Introduction This essay does not comprise a defence of retributive punishment, neither does it imply a rejection of deterrent punishment. The writer suggests that one possible reason for the tendency to advocate punishment of offenders with ever increasing severity can be discovered in the concept of the 'morality of anger'. It is this explanation of the phenomenon that forms the principal burden of the

The Decay Of Lying Essay

11227 words - 45 pages either the lawyer or the journalist. Besides what I am pleading for is Lying in art. Shall I read you what I have written? It might do you a great deal of good. CYRIL. Certainly, if you give, me a cigarette. Thanks. By the way, what magazine do you intend it for? VIVIAN. For the Retrospective Review. I think I told you that the elect had revived it. CYRIL. Whom do you mean by "the elect"? VIVIAN. Oh, The Tired Hedonists of course. It is a club to

Lying From The Tip Of Our Tongues

2320 words - 9 pages Lying from the Tip of Our Tongues Tell the truth, live the truth, do the truth, or there will be terrible consequences. -Gwen Rice Clark You come through the door and you see that look in their eyes, they know. All this time, all those lies; all of it just to make sure that they didn’t have to know, all so they didn’t get that look in their eyes. Now you enter further into the room and there’s no stopping the inevitable, one

The Essay Deals With Kant And How His View On Rationailty Determine's His View On Morality, Referring To His Idea Of Duty

761 words - 3 pages For Kant, the best way to live is the morally good way. This is not because of morality's bestowal to happiness, but because of the intrinsic value and significance of morality.The basic principles of morality are principles of practical reason; and these basic principles of practical rationality are 'a priori': our wisdom of these principles is not based on empirical observation or experience. On the contrary, these principles are in some sense