This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Morphing Of Child Pornography Essay

766 words - 3 pages

Morphing of Child Porn

 
   At issue before the Circuit Courts has been the constitutionality of the 1996 Child Pornography Prevention Act (CPPA) in which Congress sought to modernize federal law by enhancing its ability to combat child pornography in the cyberspace era(Free Speech). There is a split in the circuit courts regarding this bill, and this essay will address the discrepancy.

 

This piece of legislation classifies an image that "appears to be" or "conveys the impression" of a minor engaging in sexually explicit acts as "virtual" child pornography. Such images include a photograph of a real child that may be scanned, replicated and manipulated by computer to create a sexually-oriented photo, or a wholly fake child that may be generated solely by computer graphics.

 

Congress recognized a loophole in the child pornography law, in that technological improvements have made it possible for child pornographers to use computers to "morph" or alter innocent images of actual children to create a composite image showing them in sexually explicit poses.

With this in mind Congress intended to (1) ban computer-generated images that are "virtually indistinguishable" from those of real children, (2) to protect the privacy of actual children whose innocuous images are altered to create sexually explicit images and (3) to deprive child abusers of a "criminal tool" frequently used to facilitate the sexual abuse of children.

 

On December 17, 1999, in Free Speech Coalition v. Reno, the Ninth Circuit struck down the law as a content-based restriction on protected speech not in furtherance of any compelling governmental interest because the prohibited images are not of actual children. According to that Court "Because the 1996 Act attempts to criminalize disavowed impulses of the mind, manifested in illicit creative acts, we determine that censorship through the enactment of criminal laws intended to control an evil idea cannot satisfy the constitutional requirements of the First Amendment."(Ibid.)

 

This ruling created a split with the First Circuit which held in United States v. Hilton, that the CPPA's definition of child pornography withstands constitutional scrutiny. The First Circuit found itself "firmly satisfied that it is well within Congress's power to regulate virtual pornography of minors of all ages."(United)

 

The Ninth Circuit recognized there is a compelling interest in banning child pornography but stated that the U.S. Supreme Court in Ferber "implicitly rejected the regulation of...

Find Another Essay On The Morphing of Child Pornography

Excerpt of "The Morphing of Whiteness" in America

680 words - 3 pages Critical Summary of “The ‘Morphing’ Properties of Whiteness” Within the definitions and perceptions of race exists a dichotomy that Duster illuminates as inconsistent, transforming, and historically erratic depictions of what represents the racial categorization of “white”. Vacillating between racial portrayals of “whiteness”, embodying a divergence between the fluidity of historic and social transformation and a disingenuous reflection of

Child Pornography: The Fuel for Pedophiles

1202 words - 5 pages According to the American Heritage Dictionary the word pornography means: Sexually explicit pictures, writing, or other material whose primary purpose is to cause sexual arousal. The term child pornography applies for the sexual explicit material who involves minors of eighteen years of age. The human being as part of a civilized society it is meant to evolve and eradicate some kind of behaviors that make us go back as society and

Child Pornography and the Supreme Court

611 words - 2 pages In this paper we shall present an important case involving the governments attempt to defend a child-protection law designed to guard minors against internet pornography. In Ashcroft v. Free Speech Coalition, 00-795, the court heard arguments over the Child Pornography Protection Act of 1996 (CPPA).(Ashcroft)   The production or possession of actual child pornography was illegal prior to 1996; the CPPA broadened the definition of

The Benefits of Pornography

936 words - 4 pages Many people have many ideas and opinions on different things in society. One of these things that come up frequently is a person's opinion on pornography whether it is good or bad for society. My opinion is that porn is good for the society with limitations. Limitations that I believe in are that all persons in the pornography must be or the age of eighteen or older and animal pornography should be banned from print. These limitations could be

The Benefits of Pornography

1384 words - 6 pages The history of pornography is as old as time. The word “pornography” derives from the Greek words for “sexual slave”, “harlot”, and “description of”. Originally, it was a mean for describing scenarios of sexual slavery or the purchase of sex from women, both of which involve an imbalance of power, mostly between men and women. (Carse) In the earlier times, pornography focused on standards of abuse and degradation rather than on the goal of

The Problem of Pornography

732 words - 3 pages  In the United States someone has to be eighteen years old before they can buy pornography, but just because they have to be eighteen to buy it doesn't mean they have to be eighteen to look at it. Everywhere around the Internet one may stumble upon pornography where anyone, including children, may look at it. Pornography is not something to be proud of and is not something that our children should be able to see randomly on the Internet or in a

The Economics of Pornography

1920 words - 8 pages compare Steven Hirsch to F. Scott Fitzgerald's fictional Jay Gatsby. They believe entrepreneurs who enter the sex industry pursue the "American Dream" the wrong way. Society devotes a lot attention to the harmful effects of pornography and to the issue of the First Amendment. We hear much less discussion about the economic aspect of porn. In fact, pornography represents the product of an industry that has grown immensely since its emergence

The Benefits of Internet Pornography

2224 words - 9 pages supports freedom of choice and fetishes, it does not mean that certain fixations like child pornography, bestiality, and rape pornography are justified. These types of pornography are illegal and prove to be more detrimental than beneficial since they infringe upon rights, lack consent from the opposite parties, and above all, cause physical harm. Like any other form of artistic or literary expression, pornography reflects values that people share in

The Harmful Effects of Pornography

1699 words - 7 pages Whether pornography is an excuse to make acts of violence public? A big number of famous scholars, no matter men or women, have given their opinions. Each of them has their own view, but we can sort them into two groups, which are against to serious censorship and willing to convict and uproot pornography. Because of pornography, women’s status can never be equal to men’s. Recently, a revolution about the perception of moral values comes out

The Consequential Pleasures of Pornography

812 words - 4 pages would use this study to promote the use of mandatory caution labels that are displayed on pornographic sources from all media platforms. Essentially, it will be the same as the warning labels on cigarette packs. Rather, in this case it is for pornography. I believe this is an appropriate step to take because there is a legal age requirement to view pornographic content, however that alone is not enough because it is easy to bypass. Supplementing

Overview of the Issue of Pornography

2902 words - 12 pages A life in erotic cinematic film also known as skinematography can become a rewarding career and punishing career. An example in pornography could be a camera and two people having sex it can sometimes be over a dozen people having sex. However people in today’s time keep in the shadows and say that pornography is something they hold equal to a painting of some of the greats, on the other side of the scale non-viewers of erotic films will say

Similar Essays

The Wrongs Of Child Pornography From A Christian Perspective

3183 words - 13 pages Pornography/Child Pornography I am a Christian theist due to a few reasons. A few of these reasons include the bibliographical, teleological, and Christological evidence and my own personal beliefs. The bibliographical evidence has to do with prophecies of the bible that have been made which are being filled. This has strong conviction for me because I grew up reading the bible and listening to what it has to say. As I grow older I see more and

The Fight Against Child Pornography Essay

2341 words - 9 pages is finding a way to regulate the Internet in a way that doesn't limit adults but still provides protection for children. The second real issue is finding a way to regulate and enforce the removal of material that is agreed upon as being inappropriate for anyone to have on the Internet. I am specifically touching on the issue of child pornography. While it is illegal in the United States, as it is in many countries, government and law enforcement

Are The Dangers Of Internet Child Pornography Exaggerated?

734 words - 3 pages The idea of child Pornography on the internet is very well alive and well. There are people who rummage around the black holes of the internet looking for Child Pornography or some call “Kiddy Porn”. Child Molesters are everywhere; the internet is a virtual playground for them to pry and hunt out children for their satisfaction. These reviews are both very opinionated views.The first thing that stood out to me was that Julia Wilkins

Critical Summary Of "The 'morphing ' Properties Of Whiteness"

931 words - 4 pages Critical Summary of “The ‘Morphing’ Properties of Whiteness” Within the definitions and perceptions of race exists a dichotomy that Duster illuminates as inconsistent, transforming, and historically erratic depictions of what represents the racial categorization of “white”. Vacillating between racial portrayals of “whiteness”, embodying a divergence between the fluidity of historic and social transformation and a disingenuous reflection of