The Motivational Self Fear Of A Poe Narrator

1271 words - 5 pages

Poe has given his narrator in “The Tell Tale Heart” multiple currently diagnosable psychological disorders: bipolarity, obsessive compulsive disorder, psychopathy, paranoia. Although he is a psychopath by Hare’s definition, among the disorders, the narrator’s sense of fear is overwhelmingly the most motivating. On a first reading, it might seem that the narrator committed murder because of his unjustified hatred towards the victim, or more specifically, the victim’s “evil eye.” And later, he confesses to his crime because of the overwhelming guilt he feels which causes him to hear the beating of the dead man’s heart. However, as a psychopath, the narrator is incapable of feeling guilt. I will demonstrate that it is not hatred toward what is outside of the self that drove the narrator to murder and confession but the hatred and the immense fear of the insane side of himself that drove him to such irrational actions.
After the burying the corpse beneath the floorboards, the narrator, being proud of his work, states that “no human eye – not even his – could have detected anything wrong.” To the narrator, the old man is able to see beyond what the average person can see. One might assume that it was the fear of the eye’s judgement that caused the narrator to resort to murder. Although this is true, a stronger motivation was the fear of his own insanity. The fact that he feared the eye made him see the irrational side of himself. In refusal to acknowledge his mental disorder, the narrator gives an alternative name to his paranoia, characterized by an oversensitivity to sound: “nervousness.” The phrase “I have nothing to fear” right after the murder as well as in the presence of the police is repeated because he’s trying to convince himself that he should not be paranoid, which he associates with insanity.
The obsession with the old man’s eye was due to an obsession with asserting his own sanity.
The eye is described as “the eye of a vulture” and an “Evil Eye.” Little does the narrator know, the same description can be given to his own eyes. In a play on words, the “eye” represents the “I” in the narration. Seeing the eye is like seeing himself in a mirror. The way he sees the eye “with perfect distinctness” on the eighth night can also be said about how he sees his insanity: the “I.” The narrator has projected his fear and self-hatred of his insanity onto the old man’s eye. The “evil eye” like a mirror, reflects to him the “evil” and “vulture” like part of himself that he knows others would consider insane. Vultures as scavengers that prey on the dead and the near dead are similar to the narrator when he preys on an aging man who is approaching natural death. This fear of his own mental disorder gave the narrator the need to purge the insane part of himself by eradicating the eye of the old man.
The old man’s eye has a “film over it” probably because of a medical condition but when the narrator’s eyes that parallel the old man’s can also be...

Find Another Essay On The Motivational Self Fear of a Poe Narrator

Shattered Perception: The Narrator of “The Sandman” as a Schizophrenic

1832 words - 7 pages manifested a nurse that could bring to reality all of the darkest recesses of his imagination and explain to him what the Sand-man truly was, a horrific beast that ripped eyes from children (a repressed fear that may be an insight into the nature of his family’s death). At this point in the story, reality breaks down and becomes totally unintelligible from the real world. The narrator begins to hallucinate sounds of the Sand-man visiting his

The Role of the Narrator Essay

1141 words - 5 pages the invention of a narrator,” Diane Middlebook said, “who serves as a contemporary guide to the materials of the book…” (Middlebrook). The narrator of a story is fundamental to the reader’s understanding and, any changes to the narration can change the stories understanding entirely. “Snow” “Snow” is a short story in first person narration, told by the main character. Set during a time when people lived in fear of nuclear fallout

Poe as More Than Fiction: The Man, The Narrator and Real Life

947 words - 4 pages how he killed his wife and attempted to kill his cat. The unnamed narrator reveals that “From my infancy I was noted for the docility and humanity of my disposition” (Poe, n.d., 3); Poe’s temperament was the opposite; from a child, he had a sharp intellect and in his teen years, he developed a sharp sense of superiority and pride as he united with the Southern slave owners of his day (Quinn 24-27). However, similar to the narrator, Poe endured

Comparing and Contrasting Self-Awareness in the Works of Emerson, Whitman and Poe

2241 words - 9 pages Defining Self-Awareness in the works of Emerson, Whitman and Poe Literature in the American Renaissance influenced the Romantic sentiment that prevailed during this period: the emergence of the individual. This materialization evolved out of the Age of Reason, when the question of using reason (a conscious state) or faith (an unconscious state) as a basis for establishing a set of beliefs divided people into secular and non-secular groups

A Night of Fear

982 words - 4 pages A Night of Fear Have you ever been in a situation, where you have to choose a spiritual path, the good way or the bad way? Well I was in that situation quite a few years ago and the way I chose was dire…. The old preacher used to say to me, 'let Jesus come into your heart' but I wouldn't listen I always used to think that, that was for the older people. I used to think, why not enjoy my youth, why should I

Barchester Towers; Role of a Narrator

1401 words - 6 pages impression that the author talks too much in the novel. He digresses at length on women, tradesman, farmers' etc. Some of this chattiness is richly informative as Victorian Morses and manners. It reflects Trollope's great observation but on other hand it also tends to get bore at times and the reader is dejected. Trollope is also considered as a subjective narrator. He reveals his characters through telling and describing every thing him self

Reliability of a Narrator in Literature

733 words - 3 pages Stories are often told by a narrator giving his/her point of view, by using omniscient, limited omniscient, or first person. The purpose of the narrator is to give facts and details, being reliable or not. Three stories we have read in class are "The Body," by Stephen King, "Defender of the Faith," by Philip Roth, and "Everyday Use," by Alice Walker; which give examples of a reliable narrator. Each narrator was a reliable source of

The Narrator of The Yellow Wallpaper

833 words - 3 pages The Narrator of The Yellow Wallpaper In “The Yellow Wallpaper” the narrator becomes more depressed throughout the story because of the recommendation of isolation that was made to her. In this short story the narrator is detained in a lonesome, drab room in an attempt to free herself of a nervous disorder. The narrator’s husband, a physician, adheres to this belief and forces his wife into a treatment of solitude. Rather than heal the

The Mystery of the Rose and the Narrator in A Rose for Emily by Faulkner

1187 words - 5 pages an unknown secret, Faulkner also keeps us on the edge to who’s voice the narrator represents. Thomas Klein argues many widespread points but in the end he concludes that the author’s voice takes on a group voice but “indicating what he or she [the narrator], as an individual, thought or did” (Klein 230). I agree with Klein’s analysis of the supposed voice taking on a “we” approach. Klein first states that the narrator fails to identify his or her

Views on the role of Nick as a narrator in the Great Gatsby have

2241 words - 9 pages Views on the role of Nick as a narrator in the Great Gatsby have varied greatly. How do the views of Arthur Mizener and Gary J. Scrimgeour relate to your own view of Nick's function in the novel? Published in 1925, and written by F. Scott Fitzgerald, 'The Great Gatsby' is a brilliant and scathing illustration of life among the new rich during the 1920s; people who had recently amassed a great deal of wealth but had no corresponding

The Definition Of Fear

1263 words - 5 pages Fear can be defined as the personal sensation of being in great danger, or that something terrible is going to happen. A fear can also be considered a phobia. A phobia is a fear which isn't justified by the presence of real danger or threat, or by any rational cause. It is also a systematic avoidance of a situation which lead to it. Phobia is a type of panic reaction caused by specific stimuli or situations. Six of every ten people who suffer

Similar Essays

The Unreliability Of The Narrator In Ms. Found In A Bottle By Edgard Allan Poe

911 words - 4 pages Edgar Allan Poe, one of the most important writers of 19th Century literature, used to see himself as primarily a poet. However, his reputation as a writer is in great part due to his tales and short stories. These involved from the gothic, the grotesque and the dark side of life, to the detective stories and to those which originated modern science fiction. Poe's unique style has been the subject of criticism and of studies for a long time, and

Analysis Of The Narrator Of The "The Fall Of The House Of Usher" By Edgar Allan Poe

588 words - 2 pages The Truth Behind The NarratorAlthough it is widely believed that "The Fall of The House of Usher" is about Usher and his disease, the truth is that the story is really about the narrator. In a sense, the narrator generally symbolizes humans and basic human actions and desires. When people first read the story "The Fall of The House of Usher" they tend to believe that the story is about Usher, his sickness, his legacy, and his sister; but if the

A Fear Of The Ocean Essay

1305 words - 5 pages Amy Jo JohnsonProfessor David Tomas MartinezEnglish 1301July 28, 2014A Fear of the OceanEarly this morning, his alarm is the one that woke us up. Usually, my alarm is the one to let me know that it is time to get up and get ready for school. Today is Sunday though, and the wave report is showing a prediction of good conditions at Surfside. So, his plan is to wake up before sunrise, go pick up Trey, and hit the beach. I have plenty of homework

Fear In The Fall Of The House Of Usher By Edgar Allan Poe

1152 words - 5 pages fear to the characters in order to reveal the importance of facing and overcoming fear. Poe suggested in the story that the denial of fears can lead to madness and insanity. This has clearly shown through the weakening of Roderick Usher's mind and the resulting impact on the narrator of the story. In the beginning of the story, Poe used images and descriptions to create a gothic picture of the Usher mansion and to set up a sense of fear and