The Myths Of Cultural Globalization Essay

3841 words - 15 pages

"Globalization, both as an ideology and process, has become the dominant political, economical and cultural force in the 21st century." Quote from "Globalism: The New Market Ideology" by Manfred D.Steger Two powerful scenarios dominate the public discourse about the cultural consequences of globalization. The one very common scenario represents globalization as cultural homogenization (for example Benjamin Barbers McWorld vs. Jihad). In this scenario the culturally distinct societies of the world are being overrun by globally available goods, media, ideas and institutions. In a world where people from Vienna to Sidney eat BigMacs, drink Starbucks coffee, talk about human rights and work on their Apple computers, cultural characteristics are endangered. As these commodities and ideas are mostly of western origin, globalization is perceived as westernization in disguise. The other scenario is that of cultural fragmentation and intercultural conflict (encapsulated in Huntington's Clash of civilizations and most recently "confirmed" by the ethnocides in Africa).

But can we really reduce the processes of cultural globalization (i.e.
the process of world-wide interconnections) to these two stereotypes?
What about the meaning that local people attach to globally
distributed goods and ideas? Why do people drink Coca-Cola and what
sense do they make of the soap operas they watch? Do they really trade
in their century-old lifeworlds for the kinds of Madonna and Bill
Gates? And how does the homogenization scenario fit with its rival,
the imminent cultural fragmentation?

In order to gain a clearer picture of contemporary global cultural
changes, we have to study cultural practices worldwide. Objectively
measurable figures concerning death rates, intercultural marriages and
market-shares have to be understood in their wider social context.
They have to be related to specific worldviews, gender relations and
the local meaning of death and wealth.

An ethnographic approach to globalization

But how does one study these intersubjective aspects of life? Many of
the writings on the cultural aspects of globalization generalize from
experiences gained in the West to other parts of the world. What we
need instead are decentralized perspectives, ethnographic "deep
descriptions" (Geertz) from local communities all over the world and
combine them with the predominantly quantitative data obtained through
the perspectives of economists, political scientists and others. What
people say and what they actually do or mean is often a very different

Good ethnography...

Find Another Essay On The Myths of Cultural Globalization

Globalization: Disjuncture in the Global Cultural Economy

1359 words - 5 pages who work for a wage exist. Throughout a development of cooperative resist on the part of groups of people with similar economic situations, they argue that capitalism brings optimistic and pessimistic impacts into our modern society. Correspondingly, in the article “Disjuncture and Difference in the Global Cultural Economy,” Arjun Appadurai agrees with Marx and Engels’ argument on the cause of globalization, yet somewhat disagrees on a process

Seven Myths of the Spanish Conquest

927 words - 4 pages Chip BothmannHIST 1052Book ReviewMatthew Restall, Seven Myths of the Spanish ConquestNew York, Oxford University Press, 20033 pages, 889 wordsMyths of the Spanish Conquest is broken into seven chapters, each dedicated to a different myth or mis-conception regarding the Spanish conquest. In debunking these myths, Matthew Restall works with three themes regarding the conquest. First, that the European discovery of the Americas was one of the

Tracing the Notion of Japanese Myths

2498 words - 10 pages Tracing the notion of ‘Japanese myths’ As my thesis deals with the interpretations and commentaries on Japanese myths from Western scholars one would expect me to start with the beginnings of Mythological research in the 19th century Europe, but the more urgent topic in my opinion is the positioning of the Japanese myths at the time the first Japanologist came to the contact with them, a very complex subject reaching as far as the 8th century

Achieving Immortality through the Telling of Myths

1331 words - 6 pages by William, Edward turns into the Big Fish that has alluded him for so many years. The concept of metamorphoses is prevalent through mythology. In Nordic myths the trickster god Loki could turn into a fish. Countless, Greek and Roman tails depict this phenomenon, examples include: Zeus changing into different animals to woo unsuspecting women, Daphne turning into a tree to escape Apollo and people transforming into horrifying monsters because they

Manga and the Retelling of Myths

4135 words - 17 pages movies, however, are not the only place that these creatures can find a new life but also in manga. Manga artists are also re-inventing these mythical creatures like the kitsune which is a creature of Japanese folklore. These creatures are no longer bound strictly to their original story. In this essay I will be discussing how the kitsune is being re-invented in manga and the cultural ambiguity present in all of them. In Zilia Papp’s work called

How Does Globalization Affect Cultural Traditions in the Arabic Communities?

918 words - 4 pages The modern phenomena of globalization is having effects on Arab cultural traditions in Arab communities in many ways, like in language, education, media and customs. Globalization is making the world becoming a "global village" and the result is Arab communities cultural traditions are changing and are threaten to be lost . Globalization is not easy to define, but we can say it is process of integrating the world's economies, trade, business

The Meaning of Globalization

1806 words - 7 pages in the 1980’s and it grew so popular that the economic, political and cultural background of today is now described as “The Era of Globalization.” However, this term needs to be thoroughly clarified as it means different things to different people. To some, it is a natural phenomenon of wide-spreading economic, social, and political activities of different countries beyond their physical borders. In these people’s view, the increase in free trade

The Disadvantages of Globalization

1573 words - 6 pages Globalization is a term that is difficult to define, as it covers many broad topics in the global arena. However, it can typically be attributed to the advancement of economic, social, and cultural interactions among the companies, citizens, organizations, and governments of nations; globalization also focuses on the interactions and integration of countries (The Levin Institute 2012). Many in the Western world promote globalization as a

The Benefits of Globalization

894 words - 4 pages .) However, although culture has the ability to spread throughout all nations, some countries are less likely to see increased availability of cultural exports from different parts of the world. Even though there are less cultural innovations in these countries, the lowest ratio is still over 6 to 10 (Taylor.) Globalization allows countries to have an insight on different cultural lifestyles through movies, sports, and music. For example, basketball, one

Blurred Lines of Cultural Identities Due to Globalization

2467 words - 10 pages Globalization has resulted in blurred lines of cultural identities. More people are moving across borders due to labor, immigration, and forming new spaces in their host countries. The heterogeneity created by this globalization features the already existing culture or cultures of the host country, people who fight to maintain and preserve their cultural identity by rejecting the influences of other cultures, and others who readily adopt new

The Effects of Globalization

747 words - 3 pages In the book Globalization: A Very Short Introduction by Manfred Steger and the reprint Globalization and the Impact of American Popular Culture Abroad by Carl Guarneri, the point is made how recognized globalization has become and how much it has affected citizens around the world. Some of the debates over the effects of cultural globalization are: the West and its multinational corporations after World War II, what it promotes to the world’s

Similar Essays

The Phenomenon Of Cultural Globalization Essay

921 words - 4 pages just a passing trend, but also rather a worldwide phenomenon that has replaced the Cold War system. Concerning "cultural globalization," the two main dimensions that make up this social state are media and communications, as well as religious responses, such as the ideology of fundamentalism. This specific literary work will concentrate on the significant dimension of the media. The media is acknowledged as one of the most influential

The Globalization Of Culture: Cultural Homogenization

1918 words - 8 pages Cultural individuality and distinctiveness is the pride of every nation. All communities rejoice in the richness and exoticness of their own cultural symbols, be it dressing, architecture, language or way-of-life. With the dawn of globalization, however, cultural variety and distinguishing characteristics are vanishing; giving rise to a monoculture common to all. While this may be a harbinger of unity and relatedness among all people of the

The Myths Of Families Essay

2137 words - 9 pages Question 1: In The Way We Never Were, Stephanie Coontz suggests that society romanticizes past generations of family life and points out that these memories are merely myths that prevent us from “dealing more effectively with the problems facing today’s families” (Coontz x). Coontz proposes that researchers can take empirical data and create misleading causality for that data, thus feeding cultural myth and/or experience. Coontz believes that

The Myths Of Vietnam Essay

5552 words - 22 pages versions of the war and the antiwar movement as they have come down to us are better termed myths than versions of history because they function less as explanations of reality than as new justifications of old positions and the emotional investments that attended them (Garfinkle, 7). Pro-war or Anti- war. In the generation alive during the 1960s and 1970s, few, if any, Americans could avoid taking a position on the United States' role in