This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Nacirema: Another Look Essay

933 words - 4 pages

The Nacirema: Another Look

Written by Horace Miner, this essay of the people group Nacirema is an interesting look at their everyday functions. The tribe Miner describes is seemingly primal and uncivilized, and yet somewhat familiar. The entire account of these mysterious people describes unusual and strange behaviors and activities. The brief overview on the Nacirema is graphic from Miner’s point of view. When the meaning of the story becomes clear, the purpose for writing it becomes either humor or disdain.

In this article written by Miner, he describes the tribe of the Nacirema vividly and descriptively. The Nacirema are a tribe known for only twenty years. When they were discovered there was almost no information on them. They are a North American tribe that exists between the Canadian Cree, the Yaqui and Tarahumare of Mexico, and the Carib and Arawak of the Antilles (Miner). This area, with further investigation, is the area of the United States of America. The location alone causes the reader to be alert for Miner’s motives.

The Nacirema are unique followers of the market system, and live in a rich natural habitat. This primitive market system takes up much of the inhabitant’s time. However the people spend a large block of time in daily ritual activity. This tribe does not worship the soul like prominent religions but they worship the body. They believe the body is ugly and prone to injury and sickness. So to alleviate the problem they perform many rituals and ceremonies. In each home there is a ritual center where these actions take place. These centers are so important that all wealthier tribesmen have more than one. The shrines are located in the family home but the performance of the ritual itself is personal and practiced behind closed doors.

The shrine rooms contain small boxes built into the wall. The chest holds many charms and magical potions that are the basis for these people’s lives. At the bottom of each box is a small font. These fonts play a significant part in the rituals. Sometimes they sprinkle holy water over the font. This holy water is distributed from the regional Water Temple.

After medicine men there are “holy-mouth-men” who do barbaric and painful rituals on the tribes-people’s mouths. These rituals are continued in the home involving hog hair on sticks and certain powders in a ritual done by the tribe every day.

This tribe has many sadistic health related rituals along with the tooth check-up. Many are far more painful, and happen on scheduled dates...

Find Another Essay On The Nacirema: Another Look

Nacerima Reaction paper

809 words - 4 pages by the maidens can be related to modern day hospitals. Even though the technology is worlds apart, nurses, doctors, and physical therapists all do the similar procedures to their patients. Another concern of the Nacirema is the devils lodged in their heads. The "listener" witchdoctor will exorcise the devils from bewitched natives. I find it amazing that mothers could actually curse their own children. The witchdoctor is used to apply counter

Forging Elite Fitness Essay

1063 words - 5 pages Once again the Nacirema culture has been brought back to life. The discovery of an unknown, existing subspecies of Naciremians has captured the attention of many anthropologists. Questions about the culture left unanswered by the formerly extinct people can now be answered. (“The Mysterious Fall of the Nacirema” written by Neil B. Thompson first described the extinction of the Naciremian people.) This exclusive subspecies originate in the

The Concept of Cultural Relativism

856 words - 4 pages can move up but if we don’t then we can never advance in our life. This paper aims to talk about the relation of the body ritual among the Nacirema to the concepts of cultural relativism and cultural invisibility, to post materialism and culture of consumption. Cultural relativism is a concept that refers to the fact that what is regarded as true, valued, or expected in one social system may not be so in another (Sociology. About.com, n.d

The Nacirema Way

723 words - 3 pages thought an ethnic tribe would be. I heard the tribal music and saw the tribal dancing. I wasn't surprised about any of the tribal rituals I was reading about. Then I went back to the top to reread "Nacirema" to take a more in depth look at what was going on. I read that they were a North American group, so I began to wonder. Then I read where they were located, and thought wait a minute. Since the locations had unfamiliar names, I just kept reading on

The Nacirema Way

723 words - 3 pages thought an ethnic tribe would be. I heard the tribal music and saw the tribal dancing. I wasn't surprised about any of the tribal rituals I was reading about. Then I went back to the top to reread "Nacirema" to take a more in depth look at what was going on. I read that they were a North American group, so I began to wonder. Then I read where they were located, and thought wait a minute. Since the locations had unfamiliar names, I just kept reading on

The Body Ritual of the Nacirema

648 words - 3 pages The Body Ritual of the Nacirema It is human nature to describe one's own culture as the most advanced and most intellectual. Unfortunately, it is also common practice to look down upon the practices of another culture because they are not similar to one's own traditions. The ability to do this can sometimes be a damaging characteristic for society as a whole. Horace Miner realized the implications of egocentric views and wrote a

Truth Exposed in Body Rituals among the Nacirema

946 words - 4 pages Truth Exposed in Body Rituals among the Nacirema “Body Rituals among the Nacirema” is a document written by Mr. Horace Miner. Miner was a graduate of the University of Chicago, with a degree in anthropology. Throughout his life, Miner was dedicated to his studies ranging in anthropology to sociology. He was very interested in the study of anthropology, but Miner disagreed with the way that other cultures were represented. He thought

Witchcraft, Magic and Rationality

2353 words - 9 pages believes that the difference is not a question of rationality but rather ‘…our differing construction of what reality is.’ ; the self evident truths we hold, and it would seem these are not as objective as we like to think they are. It is also important to look at the language we use when describing certain things. As I mentioned before there is little difference between magic and religion however by us labelling one ‘magic’ we are already

Why are women less successful in business

852 words - 3 pages mean that they are not able to pay their debts. If I was I functionalist theorist I would look to the purpose of discrimination of women. They are the new Afro Americans in today's business. May be men benefit from this but just at first sight. Men and women may have different values, attitudes to life etc. but as for their business they have a common goal-profit.Women do not believe that some day the will be regarded as equal to men. Men prefer and

Kung Bushman

1031 words - 4 pages are so unrivaled due to factors such as time and the wrong sense of view many people have on them. Another reason that we cannot compare the !Kung of today to the people of the past is because they are now advancing in society with the use of technology. I believe that the !Kung tribe is not comparable to the early people of their culture and that they are just the same as us minus our technology, which in no way makes them ‘primitive’ people

Varieties of bodily experiences

1353 words - 5 pages medical establishment Horace Miner's Body Ritual among the Nacirema (ref) reveals the extent to which medicine is revered in the West. Yet I believe medical practice exerts a huge degree of control over our bodies, even in universal experiences such as pregnancy. A friend of mine has been vilified by doctors by choosing a home birth even though she smokes - although no medical evidence exists to suggest that smoking affects the safety of the birth

Similar Essays

Religion Reaction Essay: “Body Ritual Among The Nacirmea”

845 words - 4 pages Religion Reaction Essay: “Body Ritual Among The Nacirmea” The reaction essay is based upon Horace Miner’s article “Body Ritual Among the Nacirema,” published in Wiley-Blackwell’s, in conjunction with the American Anthropological Association, journal American Anthropologist. The essay will consist of two sections: an article summary and a reaction discussion. Article Summary Horace Miner wrote the article “Body Ritual among the Nacirema”, in

Power Of Perspectives Essay

1405 words - 6 pages way the present themselves (260). Miner successfully persuades his audience of the danger of assuming one's biased view of an alien culture and the importance of treating unfamiliar concepts objectively by allowing them to examine American rituals from an outsider's perspective. If one were to look at the Nacirema cultural behaviors regarding physical appearance and health without any knowledge of their specific beliefs, the rituals are

Body Rituals Among The Nacirema Essay

604 words - 2 pages to do every day. It could not be considered as a ritual or ceremonies, but she described it as a ceremony because she is lack of knowledge in the Nacirema culture. Another example could be found in paragraph 4, she states "The medicine women do not give out the potions though, but decide what the ingredients should be..." As you can see, her country is not developed because we could clearly see that she compares her culture's medicine women with

Socialization Of The Nacirema Tribe Essay

1126 words - 5 pages perspective of another and responding from that imagined viewpoint” (Schaefer, 2012). Although I couldn’t actually practice any of the Nacirema ritual without physically or mentally harming myself, I can apply reasoning to their motives for behaving in certain situations. Miner (1956) states that “Nacirema people teach their children the secret body rituals, but mothers often do not breast feed their infants” (Miner, 1956). In all, the Nacirema