The Need For Electoral College Reform

1170 words - 5 pages

The Need for Electoral College Reform

During the horse-and-buggy era of 1789, travel to neighboring states was nearly impossible. A distance of even forty miles could require hours. Therefore journeys to non-bordering states were an extremely rare occurrence. These obstacles and the lack of communication between voters in one state and candidates in another was the constitutional framers’ main impetus for instituting an electoral college for presidential elections. This system ideally elects the most qualified candidate as deemed by educated voters: persons designated to keep abreast of current social issues and activities of political office holders and seekers. These specially selected voters would be chosen according to the will of the people. From the eighteenth (18th) century to today, this is how we elect our president.

Known as the melting pot, the United States’ diverse constituents reflect the diversity of the states themselves and elucidate the complications of change on a national level to this system. Direct election would be one option but it’s major disadvantage is that candidates may ignore smaller states because their campaign stops’ value is proportional to the concentration of people there. The electoral college, then, can be seen as a compromise between large and small states very much like the “Great Compromise” which gave smaller states equal representation in the Senate and larger (i.e. more populous) states representation by population in the House.

Third parties were another concern of the framers because they could eliminate a potential candidate if numerous third party candidates attracted even minimal votes such as those from people’s hometowns. This invite to corruption was discerned by the framers and ameliorated by the electoral college because scandals’ effects were limited to the potential votes in one state. In order to dispose of a candidate, similar operations must be executed in multiple states which is much more difficult to perform without raising awareness.

The framers’ fears were sensible and valid during that time. However, today in the computer age and the era of instant information their validity has diminished. While the basic principles of democracy remain steadfast, the methods are overdue for revision. We are at the dawn of the twenty first (21st ) century and times have changed. But that is how life is: times change. In fact, the people who implemented the electoral college are the same people who decided that slaves would only count as 3/5 of a person!

Perhaps it is the system’s reluctance to change that has produced the disappointing turnouts at the polls (a 20% decrease in turnout in the past forty years). Surveys consistently show that often an overwhelming majority favors change in the electoral college, yet it has continued in virtually the same manner for over two hundred years. Why isn’t America listening to its people? At the same time, polls show that 82% of Americans...

Find Another Essay On The Need for Electoral College Reform

Should Britain reform the existing electoral system for general elections?

1099 words - 4 pages part of democracy, and coalitions often result in the smaller parties gaining undue influence (a good example is Israel). Also if reform were to take place, the electorate may not understand the new system. The Single Transferable Vote system for example is very complicated, and could result in people not turning out to vote. Therefore I would conclude that Britain should not reform its existing electoral system for general elections.

The Need for Health Care Reform

1140 words - 5 pages Abstract It is time for our government to take a step away from war and look to meeting the needs of their own citizens. The need for health care reform is more evident than ever. The recession of America has caused many people hardship due to many lay-offs and the fact that insurance premiums have risen drastically. Many families are not receiving the health care that they require due to these circumstances. It affects not only the young

The Electoral College.

946 words - 4 pages The Electoral CollegeThe Electoral College process is part of the original design of the U.S. constitution. The Electoral College was devised by theFounding Fathers to elect the president and vice president. In this essay I will asses whether the system is democratic. I shall dothis by discussing its strengths, weaknesses and attempts to reform it.The Electoral College system has been criticised many times since its establishment. It is seen to

Elimintating the Electoral College

1661 words - 7 pages more. Work Cited American Enterprise Institute for Public Policy Research. Proposals for Revision of the Electoral College System. Washington: 1969. Longley, Lawrence D. The Politics of Electoral College Reform. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1972. Pierce, Neal R. and Longley, Lawrence D. The People's President: The Electoral College in American History and the Direct-Vote Alternative. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1981

The Electoral College

1192 words - 5 pages favor the Electoral College. The reasoning for this is part of the original plan of the forefathers to increase the influence the smaller states have on an election. Also a small percentage of a popular vote could elect a president (Grolier). The next proposal would be to split a state's electoral votes into districts. Each district would have at least one electoral vote and the presidential candidate would be awarded electoral votes form that

The Electoral College

834 words - 3 pages representatives in the Senate for each state and The House of Representatives. This means that the number of electors that each state receives can change each decade according to the census and how many representatives each state receives for the house.(Unknown, How The Electoral College Works) The popular vote is then taken for each state, and whatever party or representative receives the most popular votes, receives all the electoral votes for that

The Electoral College

2395 words - 10 pages States are indirect popular elections. Even though voters cast their ballots for the presidential candidate, they are really voting for a group of electors who pledge to vote for a particular candidate. (Project Vote Smart) This group known as the Electoral College is made up of 538 citizens who are responsible for voting on behalf of their states and it is this group that actually chooses the president. The number of electoral votes is based on

The Electoral College - 1010 words

1010 words - 4 pages select the president (Wikipedia The Free Encyclopedia n.d.). The compromise was to set up an Electoral College system that allowed voters to vote for electors, who would then cast their votes for candidates, a system destined to change our beloved America forever.The Electoral College came to be at the Constitutional Convention in 1787. Our founding fathers wanted to create a system that consisted of checks and balances for two main reasons. Firstly

The Electoral College - 2080 words

2080 words - 8 pages The Electoral College The framer's intent of setting up the American government will never be known for sure, but it is gathered that they preferred a republic to a democracy. In the constitutional convention the drafters had to decide how much power they would entrust with the people of the United States, and how much should be controlled by representatives. They chose to have Congress make the laws, and congress would be selected

The Electoral College - 2474 words

2474 words - 10 pages the American public? The founding fathers created the Electoral College for many reasons. One of the reasons was to give the people the right to have a say on who becomes president and another reason was to give congress the right to choose as well. At the time of the 1787 Constitutional Convention this was a topic that aroused many opposing ideas and opinions. They had three choices, to allow the public

The Electoral College - 733 words

733 words - 3 pages of representatives that state has in Congress. Arizona, for example, has eight electors because it has six representatives in the House of Representatives and two in the Senate. This guarantees that every state has at least three electors. A popular election in each state determines which party the electors will be chosen from, and all electoral votes from the state will go to that party. The electoral college is the best way to elect the

Similar Essays

Electoral College Reform. Essay

1355 words - 5 pages republic. The only means by which this is legitimate is by use of direct election. Direct election of the President and Vice President is the only valid expression of democracy in determining the Presidential election. The need for reform is not in question, it is the method by which we reform system which has puzzled policy-makers since the archaic nature of the institution became apparent. The use of direct popular election would define the essence of

Time For Reform? Considering The Failures Of The Electoral College In The Us

1882 words - 8 pages TIME FOR REFORM? CONSIDERING THE FAILURES OF THE ELECTORAL COLLEGEDescription: This paper discusses the many shortcomings of the ElectoralCollege, and posits possible alternative electoral processes which likely bemore democratic.Time for Reform?Considering the failures of the Electoral CollegeA common misconception among American is that when they vote they elect the President. The truth is notnearly this simple. What in fact happens when a

The Need For Constitutional Reform Essay

2391 words - 10 pages The Need For Constitutional Reform No government in modern times has ever been elected with such a commitment to reforming the constitution as the Labour administration that won office in May 1997. Within months of its election, Scotland and Wales were on the road to devolution. Within a year, although in a very different context, the framework had been set for a devolved, power sharing government in Northern Ireland. A

Examining Case For Electoral Reform Essay

1700 words - 7 pages Examining Case for Electoral Reform The electoral system; the ways and means of electing a party or candidate to power. Elections are at the forefront of democracy being that they represent the peoples choice over indifference and dictatorship, put crudely a consensus of the majority view. But how fair are the different systems of voting, of which there are over three hundred, either actually in existence or potentially