The New York Police Department’s Stop And Frisk Policy: A Time Series Analysis

3605 words - 14 pages

At the core of the stop and frisk policy as utilized by the New York Police Department is racial profiling. Racial profiling has a significant and often controversial place in the history of policing in the United States. Racial profiling can be loosely defined as the use of race as a key determinant in law enforcement decisions to stop, interrogate, and/or detain citizens (Weitzer & Tuch, 2002). Laws in the United States have helped to procure and ensure race based decisions in law enforcement. Historically, the Supreme Court has handed down decisions which increase the scope of discretion of a law enforcement officer. For example, traffic stops can be used to look for evidence even though the officer has not observed any criminal violation (Harris, 2003). Proponent's for racial profiling reason that racial profiling is a crime fighting tool that does treat racial/ethnic groups as potential criminal suspects based on the assumption that by doing so increases the chances of catching criminals (Harris, 2003). Also, it is important to note, law enforcement officers only need reasonable suspicion to stop and frisk, probable cause is not required as in other circumstances (Harris, 2003). It is because of this assumption that the New York Police Department’s stop and frisk policy is still a relevant issue.
When police officers are perceived as being racially motivated, where certain groups of people are being targeted, it undermines the social goals of policing, weakens residents’ cooperation with police and raises questions about the legitimacy of law (Fagan & Davies, 2000). Supporters also back up this claim with statistics that show an association between racial/ethnic groups and crime (Harris, 2003). The argument continues that the disproportionately large numbers of minorities reflected in arrest and incarceration rates is further proof to keep targeting these groups (Harris, 2003). To the supporters, racial profiling makes perfect sense and is a rational law enforcement strategy (Harris, 2003). Furthermore, supporters do not acknowledge the effects racial profiling has not only on people who belong to these groups, but on the relations between police and the communities they serve. Today policing strategies which center on community policing and racial profiling only alienates people from the police and causes deep seeded mistrust. Failure to acknowledge the racial context of the law and its enforcement will only increase the racial disparities that already exist in all aspects of criminal justice (Johnson, 2003).
Harris (1999) has suggested that racial profiling was practically put into place during the Reagan administration with the implementation of Operation Pipeline by the Drug Enforcement Agency (DEA). In this operation conducted across the nation's highways, local and state officials cooperated with DEA officials to target private cars based on a profile of potential drug...

Find Another Essay On The New York Police Department’s Stop and Frisk Policy: A Time Series Analysis

The Erie Canal And Impacts That It Had On Commerce, Trade, And Development Of New York And The US At That Time

1522 words - 7 pages American history." (Harness, 36).Taking a lot of time and labor, the Erie Canal was not an easy job to complete. Workers dug through solid rock, marshes, rivers and valleys to build the canal. From hard work of men and horses, they managed to build 83 locks that allowed the waterway to run smoothly with the altering elevation levels of New York State. When it was complete, the canal was over 363 miles long, 28 feet wide at the bottom, 40 feet wide at

Stop Question and Frisk Essay

1131 words - 5 pages The stop, question and frisk policy is one of the most widely known controversy in the whole of New York City for the past years. Since its creation, the ongoing conflict between the New York Police Department and the citizens has never been resolved. There were several attempts to prevent the use of this policy, but all were unsuccessful. The main idea of this paper is to show how stop, question and frisk became a conflict between the New York

Stop-and-Frisk Essay

782 words - 4 pages On August 12th 2013, a New York City judge, Shira A. Scheindlin, ruled that the New York City Police Department’s (NYPD) policy, stop-and-frisk, is unconstitutional. Stop-and-frisk is a policy that allows police officers to stop people they deem suspicious. They are permitted to frisk them in search for illegal items such as weapons and/or drugs. Since Mayor Bloomberg introduced stop-and-frisk to the city it has been very controversial. The

Stop And Frisk

1885 words - 8 pages these sources prove that the NYPD is promoting intuitional racism by carrying out Stop and Frisk. The NYPD, an institution, is implementing a policy, Stop and Frisk, which essentially has a negative effect on racial minorities because they are constantly targeted and treated unequally than everyone else who does not fit the criminal quota, which essentially denies them equal service from their police. Furthermore, when racial profiling does result

Furthur's Two Night Run at Time Square's Nokia Theater in New York City

1413 words - 6 pages "Feels like I've been here before..." Well, one could certainly use that to represent Furthur's two night run at Time Square's Nokia Theater in New York City July 28 and 29th. While not attending the first night of Furthur's eventful two night stay at the small theater, it was apparent that the whole crowd knew what happened the previous, whether being there or not. Bob Weir had lost his stability and overall control onstage for reasons not

stop and frisk

3171 words - 13 pages individuals rights. As well as inadequate training of police officers, this law has become one that is viewed as being biased and racist. The enforcement of Stop and Frisk serves as a catalyst for class and race division within the city of New York and as long as it continues to be enforce the way that it is, minorities will always be at a disadvantage. “If the courts force policy to obey the law, then the legislature should give the

What is Stop and Frisk?

1653 words - 7 pages down to Manhattan’s Fifth Avenue from lower Harlem to Mayor Michael Bloomberg’s Upper East Side townhouse in protest of the stop-question-and-frisk policy (New York City Stop-question-frisk program). They wanted the mayor to band the policy but he protested that it reduces crime and saves lives. People who took video of a stop and frisk were targeted as activist by the New York Police Department. This shows that what the New York Police Department

Terry vs. Ohio – Stop Question and Frisk

912 words - 4 pages The Stop and Frisk program, set by Terry vs. Ohio, is presently executed by the New York Police Department and it grant police officers the ability to stop a person, ask them question and frisk if necessary. The ruling has been a NYPD instrument for a long time. However, recently it has produced a lot of controversy regarding the exasperating rate in which minorities, who regularly fell under assault and irritated by the police. The Stop

Stop and Frisk/Racial Profiling Should Be Made Illegal

1653 words - 7 pages down to Manhattan’s Fifth Avenue from lower Harlem to Mayor Michael Bloomberg’s Upper East Side townhouse in protest of the stop-question-and-frisk policy (New York City Stop-question-frisk program). They wanted the mayor to band the policy but he protested that it reduces crime and saves lives. People who took video of a stop and frisk were targeted as activist by the New York Police Department. This shows that what the New York Police Department

New York Times and the Republican Party

1303 words - 6 pages In 1884, the New York Times was under the direction of a new publisher, George Jones, Jones was disgusted with the way the Grant administration was governed and allowed for constant scandal to plague its effectiveness. Previously the paper had a strong connection to the Republican party, under their new direction the paper choose to endorse the Democratic party. Those who were running on the Republican ticket were not qualified to fix the issues

Commentary On A Police Series Episode

1026 words - 4 pages Commentary On A Police Series Episode The commentary I am going to write about is on a police series called the Bill. The Bill first started in 1983 and quickly came a national institution, renowned for its real life feel, likeable characters and accessible short story format but things have changed since then. It is heading in a new direction bidding for larger audiences by making the Bill an all out serial with

Similar Essays

The Stop And Frisk Program Within New York City Police Department

1848 words - 8 pages Bloomberg’s seat as the mayor of New York City, has the right idea when it comes to New York City’s Police Department’s stop and frisk program. He plans not only to redevelop the stop and frisk program altogether, but he plans on focusing on making the program “racially color-blind”. While making any program in the criminal justice system “color-blind” is not an easy concept, many regulations can be enacted to help ensure equality when finding a

The Stop And Frisk Policy Analysis

1498 words - 6 pages protect the people of New York City but all it has done is cause problems; distrust between the minority communities and the police, fear, and hatred. Stop and Frisk has created wounds that are not only physical but mental as well, what good is a policy meant to protect people if it is hurting them? How does this make our society a just and equal one? It doesn’t, Stop and Frisk is just another example of Institutional Racism and how it has oppressed

Restaurant Industry: The Doha Quick Stop In New York

2402 words - 10 pages methods for success 2.0 Company Summary Doha Quick Stop shops will be makers of, "New York style Pizza". We offer a comfortable, friendly ambience, with a new "Modern Pizzeria" design. The menu features pizzas with a variety selection of toppings, delicious Buffalo Wings and fresh tossed salads. The pizza dough is made fresh everyday on site. Food ingredients will be the finest available. 2.1 Start-up Summary Our start-up costs cover the renovation of

"Police Brutality In The United States." Lots Of Details, Deals Primarily With New York City And The Abner Louima Case And Racial Motivation

2580 words - 10 pages the judicial system, often because policies within police departments restrict officers from being punished or even questioned about their actions made during an arrest. If the officer named in a complaint doesn't have to give his account of what occurred, vital evidence is kept from investigators. The policy in New York, for example, allows officers to remain silent about an incident for 48 hours, allowing ample time for a "cover-up" to be