This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Second Red Scare Essay

2857 words - 11 pages

The Second Red Scare

The McCarthy era, which generally spanned from 1947 to 1957, brought to the forefront of American politics the question of civil rights. At issue were controversies about both First Amendment rights to assembly and free speech and Fifth Amendment rights to due process and freedom from self-incrimination. Anti-Communist actions often involved restrictions on these rights, and heading the anti-Communist movement was the House Committee on Un-American Activities (HUAC). This committee, which consisted of government officials from Congress, was formed to investigate the threat of Communism in America. In doing so, the committee brought in witnesses, usually individuals thought to have, or to have had, Communist affiliations. The overzealous tendencies of HUAC, however, resulted in the use of bullying and smear tactics in its quest to expose a supposed Communist conspiracy. Coming to the defense of individuals under attack by anti-Communists was the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU). The ACLU’s aim was to champion civil rights, regardless of the ideologies of the groups it defended. Its activities have ranged, for example, from defending the rights of Nazis to protest during the seventies to espousing the abolition of segregated schools in the South during the fifties. In the McCarthy era, the ACLU had its hands full dealing with threats to civil rights that stemmed from anti-Communism. The ACLU, however, was not without its own anti-Communistic sentiments. Indeed, within the ACLU was a cadre of anti-Communist members that made it difficult at times for the ACLU to take a strong stance for the civil liberties of suspected Communists.

This side of the ACLU often gets overlooked, as do the original intentions of HUAC. Both, in theory, held similar principles in regard to civil rights and Communism. HUAC aimed to protect American ideals of democracy. It violated, however, the civil rights necessary for democracy. While the ACLU proposed to protect civil rights no matter the cause, it refused at times to extend those civil rights to Communists or Communist sympathizers on the grounds that Communists sought to suppress civil rights. Thus, although the ACLU and HUAC are generally perceived as diametrically opposed groups, the ambivalence of both groups makes it difficult to paint the former as the archetypal protector of civil rights and the latter as the archetypal suppressor of civil rights.

While HUAC’s actions were not laudable, it paradoxically had the best interests of the American public in mind, including protecting American civil rights. Insofar as Communism seemed to threaten the American way of life, HUAC’s attempts to root out Communists reflected a concern for American civil rights. The authoritarian nature of the Communist Party, as described by some, seems to support the idea of a Communist threat to American ideals. As a friendly witness before HUAC, for example, former Communist Party member Elia Kazan...

Find Another Essay On The Second Red Scare

The Red Witch Scare Essay

867 words - 4 pages of innocent and few not so innocent government employees of being communist spies. The Crucible written in the early 1950’s during the reign of Senator Joseph McCarthy reflects strongly the anti-communist movement occurring at the time, spearheaded by Joseph McCarthy. Events and characters in Millers play reveal the dramatic, anxious, and hysterical actions and allegations that came with The Red Scare. A parallel between McCarthys world

The Red Scare: Truman's Cold War

1200 words - 5 pages ", Online Submission, 2012-Feb-12." ERIC - The Legacy of "A Nation at Risk", Online Submission, 2012-Feb-12. N.p., 12 Feb. 2012. Web. 15 Apr. 2014. "Red Scare." History.com. A&E Television Networks, n.d. Web. 14 Apr. 2014 "Second Red Scare: A Cold Era: The Story of US." Second Red Scare: A Cold Era: The Story of US. N.p., n.d. Web. 14 Apr. 2014.

Joseph McCarthy and the Red Scare

696 words - 3 pages Joseph McCarthy, senator of Wisconsin during 1947 to 1957 was the man behind the mask of the red scare in the mid fifties. While still in office as a senator Joseph McCarthy talked himself and many others into the fact that communists where trying to infiltrate the country. He soon began to accuse completely innocent people of being in the communist party, many completely innocent people were charged, held in prison, or put on trial just because

Red Scare Describes the causes and consequences of the Red Scare of 1919

1128 words - 5 pages Red ScareThe Red Scare of 1919 was the first of two major periods in American History when fear of radicalism culminated in the persecution and deportation of Americans thought to be radicals (communists, anarchists, or socialists). An unprecedented event, the Red Scare of 1919 exhibits how popular suppression and fear of radicalism can have disastrous consequences.The causes of the Red Scare are numerous and varied, however, one of the most

Did Joseph McCarthy create a “red scare” or did the “red scare” create Joseph McCarthy?

886 words - 4 pages The question Did Joseph McCarthy create a “red scare” or did the “red scare” create Joseph McCarthy suggests if Joseph McCarthy started the red scare or if he was trying to show others he isn’t a communist because of other people’s fears of communism in the US. In other words, McCarthy’s policy in the United States stimulated everyone to fear and watch out for Communists leading to a massive witch hunt for the Communists within the country. In

Arthur Miller’s The Crucible vs The Red Scare

1072 words - 4 pages In life, there are a lot of historical events people learn about, but not many people can relate to them. The Crucible, by Arthur Miller is based on The Salem Witch Trials, many people can relate to it, it has drama. Drama is a key element in helping people understand things, because we all have drama in our lives. The Salem Witch Trials and The Red Scare both had a lot of drama in them. Miller’s story of The Salem Witch Trials closely

Comparing the Salem Witch Trials and the Red Scare

1294 words - 5 pages Inspired by the Red Scare, which was fuled by use of the either-or ( black and white) fallacy of thinking, Arthur Miller’s The Crucible depicts the village of Salem undergoing its own period of black and white thinking along with the suspicion and hysteria which followed. Miller exploits the literary element of setting to support the portrayal of the effects of black and white thinking in Salem Witch Trials of 1692. The

The 1920's and 1950's Red Scare

2178 words - 9 pages In the 1950’s the U.S government black listed artists, playwright and other intellectuals as Communists and unfairly destroyed many careers. The Red Scare in the 1950’s was actually America’s second red scare. The 1920’s red scare was what helped start suspicion over Communists, but was put off during World War 2. It was no coincidence that what many people called the second red scare ignited after World War 2, during the Cold War, in the 1950

How the Red scare influence Arthur Miller's Book on the Salem Witch Trial

826 words - 4 pages . Although “The anti communist hysteria of the early 1950s was actually the second Red Scare of the United States.”(Fitzgerald 16), “the first occurred after a revolution in Russia in October of 1917”(Fitzgerald 16), the country reacted in greater fear than the the first time as proved “In New York City, 11,000 police and detectives were kept on twenty-four-hour duty, guarding all federal, state, city, and county buildings, as well as the Stock

McCarthyism: The Manipulation of Fear in America During the Red Scare

816 words - 4 pages McCarthyism: The Manipulation of Fear in America During the Red Scare Is war the greatest weapon that political leaders can use? The answer is no because the manipulation of the minds of citizens can be used to enforce almost any demand imaginable. During the Red Scare, Senator Joseph McCarthy used this tactic to exploit the fear of Communists in ordinary United States citizens. The Red Scare was the most influential event on America in the

The House of Un-American Activities Committee, Hollywood and the Red Scare

1991 words - 8 pages , the controversies of the 1940s and 1950s have left an impression on the current entertainment industry. Before the “Red Scare”, the United States was a huge world power and was thriving in every facet possible. Its people could do as they pleased for the most part, and did not have to fear persecution for their beliefs or associations. The entertainment was reaching its prime with celebrities creating the greatest films and writings the

Similar Essays

To What Extent Did Film Propaganda During The Second Red Scare Influence Anti Communist Hysteria?

2075 words - 9 pages Section A: Plan of Investigation The focus of this investigation is the ability of leaders to appeal to human emotion through propaganda. Propaganda became especially prevalent in the United States of America during the Second Red Scare between 1947 and 1954. Propaganda assisted in the infiltration of anti-communist ideals. This examination specifically focuses on the extent to which film propaganda during this time period influenced anti

The Red Scare Essay

1146 words - 5 pages The First and Second Red Scare of the United States paved the way for a long standing fear of communism and proved to be one of America’s largest periods of mass hysteria. Throughout the years authors and analysts have studied and formed expository albeit argumentative books and articles in an attempt to further understand this period of time; the mindset held during this period however is shown to be completely different compared to now

The Red Scare Essay

1441 words - 6 pages , 1920. Of course, when no revolution (or even attempted revolution) occurred, the people began to become skeptical of Palmer, suspicious of his blatant disregard for Civil Rights, and accusations that his Raids and the Red Scare were nothing more than tactics to boost him into a Democratic nomination for President.Another capitalizing anti-communist was Wisconsin Senator Joseph McCarthy. An unimpressive politician, McCarthy took up many different

The Red Scare Essay

1000 words - 4 pages In the long years between 1947 and around 1957, fear of communism froze the very voices of America into unison. A supposedly enlightened country, the United States of America succumbed to the mass hysteria of the Red Scare with shockingly little resistance. Communist “Reds” and Communist sympathizing “Pinks” were seen everywhere and were often persecuted by the House Committee on Un-American Activities (also known by the inaccurate acronym HUAC