This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Ongoing Debate Over The Division Of Powers Between The National Government And The States

888 words - 4 pages

The ongoing debate on the division of powers between the national government and the states began with the founding of the republic in 1787 and still continues today. In 1787 the debate over the division of power began with the federalists and the anti-federalists. More recently, the Republicans started an effort to slow the growth of the federal government by returning many of the functions back to the state, called the Devolution Revolution. The U.S. Supreme court continues to make decisions that have a direct impact on the power given to the states in relation to the federal government.Although the political process has the final decision in how the power is divided between the national and state governments, the Supreme Court is often the final say in the debate about which level of government should do what, for whom, and to whom. This role was claimed for the Courts because of the outcome of McCulloch v. Maryland case, in which the state of Maryland levied a tax against the Baltimore branch of the Bank of the United States and was then challenged in court by James McCulloch. McCulloch was a cashier of the bank who refused to pay the tax levied against the bank on the grounds that a state could not tax an instrument of the national government. In this case, it was decided by Chief Justice John Marshall to set forth the doctrine of National Supremacy, which states that in cases of conflict between the constitutionally authorized actions of the national government and those of the state or local governments, the actions of the federal government is supreme. In this decision, the Supreme Court dealt a great blow to a claim of states rights by rejecting a states attempt to interfere with a legitimate federal activity. As a result, this decision transferred power away from the states toward the national government.Another way in which Supreme Court decisions have impacted the issue of state power in relation to federal power is that federal judges, under the leadership of the Supreme Court, have recently been given the authority to review the activities of state and local governments. This is due to the modern judicial interpretations of the Fourteenth Amendment, which prohibits the states to deprive any person of life, liberty, and property without due process of law and prohibits the states to deny any person the equal protection of the laws and congressional legislation enacted to implement this amendment. Because of this authority, every action by state and local officials is now subject to challenge before a federal judge as a violation of the Constitution or...

Find Another Essay On The Ongoing Debate Over the Division of Powers Between the National Government and the States

A Search for Truth - United States Healthcare Debate: Government vs. the People

1741 words - 7 pages Paletta PAGE 1 A Search for TruthU.S. Healthcare Debate: Government vs. the PeopleIn 1965 Lyndon B. Johnson amended the Social Security Act to provide American citizens with two health insurance programs: Medicare and Medicaid. Since then the United States' healthcare system has been questionable, unreliable, and immoral. The existence of these programs goes against the very principles this country was founded upon. To this day, forty-five

Centralization vs. Decentralization in America. Federalism. Is most of the power of America given to the states, or to the national government?

551 words - 2 pages Federalism has always been an issue for the USA since the 228 years ago we were declared a nation. Federalism is having two or more governments rule over the citizens of a country. A decentralized government is where the states govern the people, and a centralized government is where there is a national government to rule all the states. Each one leaves little power for the other.The Articles of Confederation left many examples of how the USA

The Powers of the Government

1388 words - 6 pages branch are further divided between the Senate and the House of Representative. The Senate has several powers which include: the power to trial a government official who has committed a crime against the United States, approve or disapprove the presidents recommendations to appoint a government official, and approve or disapprove treaties negotiated by the president with other countries. The House of Representatives has the power to decide if a

The Powers of the Government

1388 words - 6 pages branch are further divided between the Senate and the House of Representative. The Senate has several powers which include: the power to trial a government official who has committed a crime against the United States, approve or disapprove the presidents recommendations to appoint a government official, and approve or disapprove treaties negotiated by the president with other countries. The House of Representatives has the power to decide if a

United States National Government Current Top Issues

1517 words - 6 pages To begin with, it should be noted that many people in United States are frustrated and disappointed with their current political system and government actions. It should be highlighted that some organizations and individuals have an unfair and disproportionate influence over what the government does instead of a democratic idea that all citizens have an equal opinion in the governing process (Massey, 2007). The result is that the greed and power

The Division Of Law-making Powers In Australia

1266 words - 5 pages States, such as Education and Health. Gaining financial dominance also meant that the Commonwealth had de facto control over residual areas, as it could determine how much money was to be spent on education etc.High Court interpretations of the Constitution have also played a vital role in the change of the division of lawmaking power. One example is the Franklin River Dam Case where the Tasmanian Government challenged the Commonwealth Parliament in

The Powers of the United States President

1055 words - 4 pages States for at least 14 years” (History.com:U.S. Presidents). The powers of the U.S, President are outlined in Article II of the Constitution. This states that executive power shall be vested in a President of the United States making the President the head of the Executive Branch of the Federal Government. Presidential powers include: authority to appoint judges and ambassadors as well as other high ranking officials, foreign policy powers

Separation of Powers in the US Government

1014 words - 4 pages issue. The U.S. government is separated into three main branches, the executive, the legislative, and the judicial. Each branch has its own powers and weaknesses and they must all work together to govern the country (Bernstein 24). The United States system of government is largely credited to James Madison. People who opposed the ratification of the constitution thought it did not secure the proper degree of separation (separation of powers press

Hip-Hop and Politics: Attacking The Political Powers of Government

1747 words - 7 pages African Americans” and Public Enemy wanted to make a statement. They attacked the political powers of the government not through violence and weapons but through music and words. There hit song “Fight the Power” talked about racism and civil rights leaders. Public Enemy was not like the rappers today singing only about women, money, and drugs. Public Enemy focuses on the political aspects and emphasizing their black community. This was the start

The Debate Over Abortion

2024 words - 8 pages With the ongoing debate and the advancement of technology in determining the viability of a fetus, abortion, the ending of a pregnancy by removing a fertilized egg, has become increasingly controversial. The morality of abortion has caused many to separate into opposite sides of the spectrum, pro-life and pro-choice. The arguments over abortion has stirred a continuous debate between a pro-choice stance such as that presented by the analogical

The Debate over Homeschooling

2331 words - 10 pages able to shape their children’s education without interference from the government. Because LaE and homeschooling are interwoven and people believe homeschooling regulations are unjustifiable intrusions of the home. The belief that states should have no authority to regulate schooling is opposed by the liberal democratic theory. These theorists acknowledge that parents are the primary role of LaE and child rearing, but when formal schooling and

Similar Essays

How Can The Division Of Law Making Powers Between Commonwealth And States Be Altered? (Australian Legal System)

1238 words - 5 pages Australians are 'non-thinkers' and 'negative'. Generally, referenda do not succeed because the process of changing the Constitution is instilled in politics.Co-operative measures between the two tiers of government can also be seen as a medium in changing the balance of law-making powers within Australia. Firstly, with the co-operation of the states, the concurrent powers of the Commonwealth may be extended under s.51 (xxxvi), whereby the states (either

The Debate Over Stem Cell Research In The United States

1595 words - 7 pages Some people believe that stem cell research should be allowed in the United States because over sixty percent of scientists think that ES (embryonic) cells—pluripotent stem cells that come from the inner cell mass of a blastocyst; an early stage embryo – could be the solution to curing a multitude of diseases, others believe that experimenting with these cells could destroy an embryo and kill a possible human fetus (a developing body after the

Revenue Sharing Between The States And The Federal Government

572 words - 2 pages Federal grants have become more common over the last 60years, due to the expansion and retraction of the size of thefederal government. The federal government began expanding inthe 1930s to deal with the Depression. It used federal agenciesto directly deal with problems. As time went on, the tasks wereturned over to the states, but the federal government stillremained involved through the use of federal grants to statesand localities. In the

The Debate In The United States Over Immigration

1300 words - 5 pages The Debate in the United States over Immigration      Immigration plays a huge role in the population of the United States. The U.S. is looked at as a place for a new start and a place to begin a new life. This country gives people the opportunity to make their own choices and have their own freedom, who are we to decide who can have these rights or not. Should Americans really have to right to deny another human being the right to live in