The Outsider In Don Quixote And Frankenstein

1497 words - 6 pages

Regarding the seeds of creativity that produced her Frankenstein, Mary Shelley
paraphrases Sancho Panza, explaining that “everything must have a beginning.” She and
Percy Shelley had been reading Don Quixote, as well as German horror novels, during
the “wet, ungenial summer” and “incessant rain” of their stay with Lord Byron at Villa
Diodati in Geneva in 1816. In his introduction, Maurice Hindle notes the connection
between the two fictional madmen:

Both Don Quixote and Frankenstein start out with the noble intention of
helping their fellow creatures, but their aspirations are doomed by their
pursuit of a „single vision,. one that takes them further and further away
from satisfying the moderate needs of the community, and nearer and
nearer to a personally tragic denouement. (Frankenstein xxxviii)

Society, too, must have had its beginning, but theorists from Hume to Marx to Darwin
and writers such as Shelley and Dostoevsky may never solve the question of whom or
what came first: the individual or the community? One thing seems clear: whether via
sensational impressions, inductive reasoning, or common sense, the individual cannot
long survive without meaningful inclusion within the larger group of humanity. From
childhood, we recognize the profound hurt that comes from exclusion from the majority,

and this alienation, in Marxian parlance, can lead to an antagonistic position toward
society, as dramatized in both Frankenstein.s “monster” and Dostoevsky.s Underground
Man. The monster proclaims in his agony that he is “malicious because I am miserable,”
and he is miserable, no doubt, because he is not merely alone but shunned from society
(147). Shelly.s creation is in part derived from her father.s philosophy, who, in resisting a
“Hobbesian view of nature as essentially self-interested, held that virtue and happiness
could only spring from socially considered and constituted aims: „the true solitaire cannot
be considered as a moral being…His conduct is vicious because it has a tendency to
render him miserable.” (Frankenstein xxxii). This would seem evident in the
Underground Man who rails against society because he is an outcast and is
hyperconscious of this state because he is highly educated, but Godwin would argue, via
Rousseau.s Confessions, that the creature begins in an unadulterated, unfallen state of
innocence and is subsequently corrupted by an unlearned, un-enlightened society and
suffers additionally because he is a tabula rasa, uneducated. The chicken and the egg
conundrum continues to revolve. Nearly a century earlier, David Hume, despite his
refusal to accept cause and effect as having a “necessary” connection, writes in the
conclusion to Book I of A Treatise of Human Nature of his own equally morbid and
pitiable existence as a direct consequence of social alienation:

I am first affrighted and confounded with that forelorn solitude, in which I

Find Another Essay On The Outsider in Don Quixote and Frankenstein

Sancho Panza as Governor in Don Quixote

2600 words - 10 pages Sancho Panza as Governor in Don Quixote While reading Don Quixote, I am sure that many people wonder whether or not Sancho Panza will get his island to govern. The main reason that Sancho agrees to be the squire of Don Quixote is because he is promised riches and an isle to govern. As the book progresses it appears that Sancho's dream will not come true and he will not become a governor. Many times in the book, Sancho asks his master

Cervantes’ Don Quixote and St. Augustine’s Confessions

1042 words - 4 pages Cervantes’ Don Quixote and St. Augustine’s Confessions Christianity teaches that in order to be able to truly serve God, one must give up worldly pleasures, which are deemed selfish. Throughout literature, many authors touch on this subject, some in very direct manners. Such is the case in Cervantes’ Don Quixote and St. Augustine’s Confessions. In excerpts from each, the narrator describes how he had undergone a change from relishing in

Don quixote and le morte d art

680 words - 3 pages In Malory's literature, men were knights, ladies were damsels, and magic was preponderant. By the time that Cervantes wrote Don Quixote, men got real jobs, the innocent damsel had become a myth, and magic was reduced to superstition.These works both examine the chivalric ideal: "physical prowess, courtesy, truth in love and friendship, tenderness, humility, gentleness" (The Legend of Arthur in British & American Literature, p. 65) and remark

"Don Quixote": The Book that Revolutionized Literature

1030 words - 4 pages Literature is a very diverse and interesting subject today, with many different kinds of stories that all echo different ideas. Although, this was not always the case, because in the Elizabethan Era, almost all novels consisted of a boring theme and a chivalrous knight that would save his love. When Miguel de Cervantes wrote The Ingenious Gentelman Don Quixote de la Mancha, it shattered the concept of what was that literature. It did this with

Don Quixote: The Writings of Cervantes

863 words - 4 pages The writings of Cervantes may have been influenced by the writings of Shakespeare, Petrarch, etc. regarding concepts such as the story-within-a-story and the tyrannical female image, giving them a spot in the classical genre. However, Don Quixote has received multiple criticism for its style of writing and ambiguity, but of course, like many other authors, Cervantes had a clear reason why there were mini-narratives surrounding the main one

Comparing Alice's Adventures in Wonderland, by Lewis Carroll and Don Quixote, by Miguel de Cervantes

1974 words - 8 pages and Lewis Carroll in their texts, Don Quixote and Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland. While the texts follow two contrasting characters, they are brought together by the theme of fantasy. Cervantes’ Don Quixote is an old gentleman of noble lineage who becomes tired of the monotony and the lack of meaning in his life. Through his maddening and compulsive taste in books of chivalry, he concludes that the ideal life is that which is undertaken by a

Don Quixote and what type of charcter he portays.

629 words - 3 pages Don QuixoteIn Don Quixote there are many perceptive that it may be seen from. The one that I really was fond of because it is quite obvious in the book is Don Quixote being a comic character, created purely for your entertainment.Don Quixote is a very long novel, but the plot is really not that difficult. A man named Alonso Quixano has read so many romantic stories about the knights of the middle ages that he goes out of his mind and imagines he

Don Quixote: Which interpretation is the most correct?

2972 words - 12 pages Moore 1Nirmine P.A. MooreMr. John CabascangoIB English HL27 October 2014The Many Interpretations of Don Quixote: Which one is the most correct?Being an old book of over 400 years, Cervantes' Don Quixote has been read by many all over the world and has been translated into 60 different languages ( However, being available to such a global audience makes the novel susceptible to being interpreted in several different ways

The Ingenious Gentleman Don Quixote of La Mancha, by Miguel Cervantes

1079 words - 4 pages Through the use of tone, authors can appear objective, while in reality they use their attitude to influence their readers. The Ingenious Hidalgo Don Quixote de la Mancha is a novel written in episodic form, by Miguel Cervantes in 1615. By ridiculing Don Quixote, the protagonist, this novel parodies medieval romances and satirizes the hero knight. Joe Darion’s songs, “The Impossible Dream” and “Man of La Mancha”, are from the 1965 musical Man of

Sun Related Elements and The Existentialist Philosophy in The Outsider

1343 words - 5 pages references to the sun, the novel is able to assist the reader in appreciating existentialism by exhibiting the gradual development of Meursault’s philosophy and by evoking emotions which sensitize the reader to feel the beauty of existentialism. Within The Outsider, a parallel exists between the sun, which dictates Meursault’s actions, and societal constraints, which dictate mainstream society’s actions. The Arab’s death, caused by the sun’s pressure, is

The development of Rousseau and Raskolnikov in Dostoyevsky's "Crime and Punishment" and Camus' "The Outsider"

1718 words - 7 pages In every society, it is important for individuals to adhere to a set of principles inorder to maintain order. In Dostoyevsky's Crime and Punishment and Camus' TheOutsider , however, both protagonists ignored the values of their society. Raskolnikovand Meursault felt their own beliefs were significant, and through their actions they wereable to express them. As a result, one man was judged as a social deviant, while the otherman suffered

Similar Essays

The Satiric Subject, Its Practices And Purposes In Miguel De Cervantes' Don Quixote

1007 words - 4 pages or folly is censored". A satire should include entertainment, critical dimension, and a moral Reform. The novel can not be regarded as crude, slapstick humor (low comedy), but rather, as a warm, human tale, depicting the conflict between noble idealism and brute, unfeeling practicality. Don Quixote is a novel allegorizes high comedy, because it represents the life and the problems of an upper-class gentleman, in a funny and sardonic way. The novel

The Duality Of Truth In Don Quixote By Miguel Cervantes

3657 words - 15 pages "Everything we hear is an opinion, not a fact. Everything we see is a perspective, not the truth." -- Marcus Aurelius Don Quixote is considered as the first modern novel and one of the most important modernist elements available in the novel is the exploration of characters’ inner worlds, especially of Don Quixote’s. Through inner exploration of the main character, the readers observe that the real and the illusionary are interoperable

Compare And Contrast Hamlet And Don Quixote

1256 words - 5 pages In both Hamlet and Don Quixote we find many characters that fashion themselves in different ways in order to gain something from the situations they are put into. These characters include Rosencrantz and Guildenstern found in Hamlet and Sancho Panza and the Priest in Don Quixote. In Hamlet two characters tend to stand out as people who have become accustomed to self fashioning. These two characters are Rosencrantz and Guildenstern. When these

Imagination In Don Quixote By Miguel Cervantes

941 words - 4 pages "Life itself seems lunatic. Who knows where madness lies! To be too practical is madness, to seek treasure where there is only trash, to surrender dreams may be madness. Too much sanity may be madness, but maddest of all is to see life as it is and not as it should be." -Miguel Cervantes In his novel, Don Quixote, Miguel Cervantes proves that a strong imagination is necessary to lead a fulfilling life. The main character, Alonso Quejana