This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Overlooked Richness Of The Recitatives Of Bach's Cantata 78

3000 words - 12 pages

The Overlooked Richness of the Recitatives of Bach's Cantata 78

In "Expressivity in the Accompanied Recitatives of Bach's Cantatas," George J. Buelow writes that although many of the distinguishing properties of Bach's music have been studied over the years, few scholars have examined Bach's recitatives or have given them proper credit. He notes that these recitatives generally either are ignored by musical scholarship or are briefly discussed with "general errors" or "confusion." 1 For example, he cites Jack Westrup as stating that Bach's recitatives are "basically an adaptation of the idioms of Italian opera" (19), and he mentions others who term them "improvisatory" or unrelated to the text. Buelow asserts that "informed observations" about Bach's recitatives would lead to different answers; he agrees with Martin Ruhnke who writes that Bach's recitative style is "original," its melody not "subservient to the texts as practiced by Italian composers" or as "promulgated by German theorists" but "independent and richer" and also "more excited and dramatic" (19). Indeed, a closer look at Bach's recitatives discloses fascinating devices of text and narrative illustration.

In his article, Buelow explores these neglected recitatives of Bach's cantatas and discusses aspects of their originality, including their relationships between music and text. He notes how Bach chose for some of his recitatives to be accompanied and for others to remain "simple." Buelow writes that it seems likely that Bach often employed the accompaniment style because it required the singer to remain slightly more measured. He quotes Scheibe who writes in his Critischer Musikus that accompanied recitative "is more suited to rousing and increasing devotion" in church, moving the listener more and "penetrat[ing] deeper into the heart" (21). This form does seem more fitting to devotion, "guided more by the beat of the measure" (21) just as churchgoers wish to be guided by God and not left to stray about like free improvisatory gestures! Some of these instrumentally guided recitatives even contain arioso segments, melodious passages that may seem out of place in a standard recitative. Two such recitatives that Buelow does not mention are the intriguing movements 3 and 5 of Cantata No. 78. In the first of these two examples, the arioso section lasts for the last four and a half bars of the piece and helps show the shift from the sinner's inner monologue to an outward presentation of his grief to Christ. In the second, the arioso spans the last dozen "andante" bars of the piece and illustrates a similar shift from the text's discussion of Christ's strengthening of mankind through his suffering to an individual's placement of his own suffering heart before Christ.

To most Baroque theorists, recitatives were simply a form of sung speech, an "oration in tones" (25). Buelow points out that while Bach is a skilled rhetorician, he is also unusually sensitive to words in his...

Find Another Essay On The Overlooked Richness of the Recitatives of Bach's Cantata 78

Section 78 of the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984

2192 words - 9 pages To a man with a hammer everything looks like a nail. I would submit this is the case in regards to Section 78 of the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984. The courts have been granted a tool and since its introduction have been wantonly applying it case after case. I will endeavour to argue that s.78 has been developed into the tool the courts sought as oppose to the tool they have been granted and the wording of the statute ignored. The point

The Model Minority Theory: The Cause of an Overlooked Culture?

2401 words - 10 pages would better the life of all Asian Americans because it would uncover the great number of Asians that are overlooked by the theory. The Model Minority theory might have formed based off of the post-1965 Asian immigrants who came to the United States. Many of these immigrants were well educated, could speak English, and held white-collar jobs. It also might have formed from Confucianism and their cultural values of always working hard and

Close but not Deep: The Use of Richness in Love’s Literary Ethics and the Descriptive Turn

1602 words - 7 pages Heather Love starts her essay, “That there is perhaps no term that carries more value in the humanities than ‘rich’. In literary studies, especially, richness is an undisputed - if largely uninterrogated good…” (371). She uses the word rich and richness multiple times since it is connected with interpreting and deep reading, but the critic loses richness, when he practices surface reading. Love asserts at the beginning of her essay, “richness

The Richness of Old Age: a New Critical Reading of "to Autumn"

1431 words - 6 pages "Where are the songs of Spring? Ay, where are they? Think not of them, thou hast thy music too." So often, people look back upon their youth and wish that they still had it before them. Our natural tendency is to fear old age, to see it as the precursor to death, rather than a time of life, desirable in its own right. However, in John Keats' poem, To Autumn, he urges us not to take this view, but to see old age as a beautiful and enviable state

Analysis of Bach's E Minor

811 words - 4 pages An invention in this context is really a short two- little bit of music, customarily instrumental, which shows off the composer's inventiveness in inditing polyphonic (multiple independent voice) music. Bach's inventions are the absolute most often played pieces in this genre. His two-part inventions were composed in Cothen around 1720. They certainly were intended not just as pieces for edifying "unsullied" playing of two (or three) part

Anxiety, the Overlooked Disease

1221 words - 5 pages Feeling anxious is common for everybody, especially when faced with an important life event, but it is when someone has that anxious feeling for long periods of time for unwarranted reasons, that it can be determined that they have an anxiety disorder (Rector, Bourdeau and Kitchen 2). Anxiety will never appear on it’s own, it is usually paired with depression, this is why Patricia Farrell refers to anxiety and depression as the “ugly twins

The Orangutan: The Overlooked Ape

1826 words - 7 pages Study of the orangutan began in earnest in the 70s, when Louis Leakey dispatched Birutė Galdikas to join Jane Goodall and Diane Fossey in their study of the great apes (de Waal, 1995). While Goodall’s work with chimpanzees brought extensive public awareness to the animal (Quammen, 2003) and Fossey’s groundbreaking study of gorillas was so prominent a Hollywood film was based on her work (“The Gorilla King,” 2008), Birutė Galdikas and her

The Overlooked War: Kosoco War

711 words - 3 pages The history of technology is the cases of human beings’ ability to manipulate nature. The stories tell of ancient cavemen using axes and lead up to the creation of nuclear bombs. These inventions and innovations are incredible to think about what humans can create and use over nature and other people. The advances in technology come with a price though. It creates the idea of being in control, of not only one’s self, but of others as well. It

The Most Overlooked Crime: Piracy

1158 words - 5 pages Internet piracy is not a victimless crime. Piracy is a term used to describe the illegal downloading of music, movies, games, and even software online. Although many people don’t feel that piracy is a crime that affects anybody, it really does. People pirate stuff online because it is free and does not require one to run to a store to get their product. People that pirate these things don’t think of the repercussions that go along with it. You

An analysis of Bach's prelude and fugue no.6 book 1 and brief biography of bach

3399 words - 14 pages the rest of his life, often in conflict with the authorities, but a happy family man and a proud and caring parent. His duties centred on the Sunday and feastday services at the city's two main churches, and during his early years in Leipzig he composed prodigious quantities of church music, including four or five cantata cycles, the Magnificat and the St. John and St. Matthew Passions. He was by this time renowned as a virtuoso organist and in

A Beautiful Mistreated Mind This essay concerns an often overlooked aspect of the lives of people with mental health issues: their treatment. It looks into the reasons why these people were neglected...

1647 words - 7 pages A Beautiful, Mistreated MindMany people consider the movie "One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest" one of the greatest movies ever made. This is not without reason, as the shocking subject matter and brilliant acting truly personify the horror of the situation as a group of supposedly mentally ill people fight to keep what is left of their sanity under the twisted care of the fiendish Nurse Ratchet. As they hear the native American drums beet while

Similar Essays

Unity In Bach's Cantata No.78 Essay

1282 words - 5 pages Unity in Bach's Cantata No.78 According to Rowell, "Musical composition became much longer, and composer were forced to evolve new means of maintaining unity and continuity over long time spans" during the Baroque period. Therefore, the texture of music became very important. When I look at the musical texutre of the Cantata No. 78 by J. S. Bach, I realized that this piece was unified very well within a movement and as a whole piece by many

The Richness Of Olive Oil Essay

2208 words - 9 pages The Richness of Olive Oil When I think of olive oil, a picture suitable for a postcard comes to mind: rows of olive groves, pasta figgoli, Pavarotti singing, and Grandma Garone rubbing olive oil on the heads of my father, Vincenzo, and his brother, Francisco. Their hair would take on the Italian look: dark and sheen, slicked back, reminiscent of John Travolta in Saturday Night Fever. Grandpa Garone owned acres of olive groves in a small

The Overlooked Gift Of Knowledge Essay

1019 words - 5 pages In 399 BCE, one of the wisest men in history was put to death. This man was not only extremely wise, but also highly influential. He was a leader of the highest caliber. This is Socrates, arguably one of the most prominent men in philosophical history. Socrates is a figure of evolution, when referring to the way people think. He was sentenced to death by the Athenians for corrupting the youth, not believing in the gods recognized by the state

The Overlooked Rights Of Men In Abortion

1108 words - 5 pages Abortion is a controversial topic regarding the rights mainly of the fetus and the mother. Men’s rights and involvement are generally overlooked in the abortion process. Since females are the carriers of the embryo, most of the time male’s decisions are not incorporated into the final conclusion. There are several debates regarding abortion and whose choice it should be to decide in terminating the fetus. Every father has different outcomes in a