The Pacific Oil Case: Conflict Management And Negotiation

1035 words - 5 pages

Pacific Oil Case
Conflict Management and Negotiation
Paul Gaudin and Jean Fontaine negotiated a favorable contract for Pacific Oil Company in 1982 with Reliant Chemical Company. Gaudin and Fontaine prepared well for this negotiation, but they assumed it that negotiations would be quick and easy. Gaudin and Fontaine believed that even with the current and future market condition, a positive outcome could be obtained by offering the best service possible and having an established positive relationship. However, their aspiration to gain a favorable “re-negotiated” contract was hamstrung by competition; market expansion for vinyl chloride monomer “VCM”, and a different style of negotiation by Reliant.

The first problem with the renegotiation of this contract was the projected demand for VCM creating a “buyers market”, according to the textbook, “the demand was high, but the supply was to increase exponentially” (Lewicki, Saunders, and Barry 2010) Reliant was already locked into a five year contract with Pacific Oil, but there would be stiff competition at the expiration of the that contract. Knowledge of this market situation put Reliant in a position of leverage and trapped Pacific Oil into a desperate sign at all costs scenario. Gaudin and Fontaine assumed that even with a fluctuation with price; Reliant would sign a new because of their established relationship Pacific Oil. Gaudin and Fontaine’s assumption opened themselves up to more concessions by not attaching conditions to the price adjustment. They could have countered with a reduction of the formula price on the condition of contract length.

Another problem that Pacific Oil Company faced was their own internal research and development of expanding the use of vinyl chloride monomers. Not that coming up with other ways of marketing and using a product is bad, but the timing was an issue, because if Pacific Oil were to go ahead with their internal plans. The demand and price for VCM could be affected, and maybe putting off plans to start negotiations till this information was solid could have been beneficial. Also, Fontaine and Gaudin had this internal knowledge that if Pacific Oil were to start their own line of products, there could be a conflict of interest (Lewicki et al., 2010). Since, it took the company so long to determine if this was a possibility, Gaudin and Fontaine and negotiate blindly. Had they known prior to the start of the negotiation, there could have been more certainty to their negotiation.

The last problem that Pacific Oil faced was a change in the negotiating team for Reliant. Frederich Hauptmann and Egon Zinsler were new to the company not part of previous negotiations. Therefore, they had a different style and perspective on how to carry out the negotiations. They were very assertive by demanding a price cut during the beginning of the negotiations. Then they were conservative throughout negotiation by keeping their demands “close...

Find Another Essay On The Pacific Oil Case: Conflict Management and Negotiation

Racism and the Pacific Essay

2306 words - 9 pages circumvention of the Alien Land Law.” Americans in California responded negatively insisting Harada violated the Alien Land Law, which eventually reached the press throughout the state and the eastern regions of the United States. Additionally, Oyama versus California guaranteed “equal access to property regardless of race” in 1948. This case supported the impact and the defeat of the California Alien Land Laws several years after the decision

Motivation and Conflict Management Essay

1052 words - 4 pages Motivation and Conflict Management Organizations strive for creative ways to enhance employee motivation and resolve conflicts with the desire to have employees perform better within the workplace. To motivate one has to be motivated. Motivation within the workplace has to be constant and requiring a goal. Motivation, if not repeated will not last. Therefore, learning to determine how different organizations apply motivation theories to

Hawaii And The Pacific In The Flesh

1150 words - 5 pages December 1, 2000 Hawaii and The Pacific In The Flesh Today when we go to watch a movie, nudity is something we have come to expect. Although society has come a long way in what we feel is exceptional to see on film or television, the exploitation of native people can still be found, as it was when it was prominent before the eighties. Throughout this course we have watched how the natives of the pacific were portrayed as highly

Adaptation, Motivation, and Conflict Management

1043 words - 4 pages . (2012). Adaptation, Motivation, and Conflict Management. In Management Principles for Health Professionals (6th ed. (pp. 321-347). Medes, F., & Stander, M. W. (2011, May 6). Positive organisation: the role of leader behaviour in work engagement and retention. SA Journal of Industrial Psychology/SA Tydskrif vir Bedryfsielkunde, 37, 29-41. Positive psychology center. (2007). Retrieved from

Australia and the Trans-Pacific Partnership Agreement

2613 words - 11 pages and ineffective for nations wishing to get faster results (Schott). One of these RTAs is the Trans Pacific Partnership (TPP) Agreement which is currently under negotiation with twelve different countries located in the Asia-Pacific Region. The goal of the TPP is to increase trade and investment, encourage innovation, and promote economic growth and development which will help boost long term sustainable job creation (Leaders of the 9 TPP

The Importance of Conflict Management

2731 words - 11 pages model for conflict resolution is listed in Appendix B) CASE STUDY The following case study provides an insight into the dynamics of conflict in international trade. The difficulties arise due to powerful lobby groups and vested interests. Successful cross-cultural trade provides a perfect illustration of the dynamics of conflict management and the following example is an instance where this succeeded. The Otis Elevator Company¡¦s entry into

Conflict Management in the Workplace

961 words - 4 pages management strategy is called `compromising'. This strategy can be defined as attempting to resolve a conflict by identifying a solution that is partially satisfactory to both parties, but completely satisfactory to neither. This type of management strategy requires the individual to be both partly assertive and partly cooperative in their actions and overall message. One's main goal with this particular strategy is to reach an advantageous

Water management in unconventional oil and gas development – The issues and their optimization

789 words - 4 pages stimulated, owing to very low rock matrix permeability [1]. Hydraulic fracturing of these formations results in a significant enhancement in well productivity, and today it is a ubiquitous reservoir stimulation technique across shale and other low and not so low permeability formations. Although certainly synonymous with shale gas development, the process of hydraulic fracturing has a much wider utility. Its use is widespread across the oil and gas

The principles of conflict management: The reasons why conflict occur in the workplace and tips on how to resolve them

1472 words - 6 pages other note, destructive conflict is the negative behavior applied to the conflict and it usually result of a negative outcome, e.g. damaged relationships, diminished productivity and low morale.Conflict can occur for many reasons in the workplace. Some of the reasons are: poor communication between management and employees, the alignment or the amount of resources is insufficient, conflicting values or actions among managers and employees and poor

The Oil and Gas Industry

677 words - 3 pages Mary Paige Linder The oil and natural gas industry is a part of an oligopolistic market structure with an undeniable competitive fringe. It is very clear to society that the oil and natural gas industry's past, present, and future production is somewhat controlled and relied upon by OPEC "cartel" decisions. There are few countries that dominate global oil and natural gas production that are outside of the OPEC organization. OPEC, The

The United States and Oil

1346 words - 6 pages later. Every single day we drive our cars to work, turn on the lights, and use our computers. All of these things use oil; the gas to drive, plastic in the cars and computers. Almost everything we use has something to do with oil. “The United states uses nearly 400 million gallons of oil every day moving people in automobiles, goods on freight trucks, air travel, rail and transit.”(Sierra Club 1) Many people don’t thing about all the things that we

Similar Essays

The Pacific Oil Company Case Study

1097 words - 5 pages Introduction This paper will describe the problem that Pacific Oil Company faced as it reopened negotiations with Reliant Chemical Company in early 1985. Secondly I will identify and evaluate the styles and effectiveness of Messrs, Fonatine, Guadin, Hauptmann, and Zinnser as negotiations in this case. Finally I will outline what Frank Kelsey recommend to Jean Fontaine at the end of the case? Why? Managing Conflict in Negotiation The Pacific

Case Study Human Resources Management In The Asia Pacific

3008 words - 12 pages labour markets and local education system, have the communication, culture, and language problems, they are familiar with the corporate culture, have advanced management skills, and also have stronger informal linkages with decision makers in the parent company. Many companies send their home country employees to foreign subsidiaries (Hutchings 2002). In the GM case, it is indicated that there isn't a modern management system in the JV and the JV

Conflict Management Case Study

4095 words - 16 pages personality, character or motives. When conflict is personalized and extreme each party acts as if the other is suspect as a person. In this case problem solving never works, because it is about emotion and not issues. These kind of conflicts almost always get worse over time, if they cannot be converted to substantive conflict.b.Destructive vs. Constructive ConflictAn other useful differentation is the categorisation of conflicts according to its impact

Ethics And Negotiation Case Study

2376 words - 10 pages Case Study: BP Texas RefineryIntroductionAccording to Lewicki, Saunders & Minton (2003), adopting an unethical approach to negotiation in business can have serious consequences. A recent explosion at the British Petroleum (BP) Texas refinery on 24 March, 2005 reiterated this and demonstrated the effect of an unethical approach to negotiation with the death of 15 contract workers.Ethical behaviour refers to the standards of conduct such as