This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Packed Lunch Debate Essay

2680 words - 11 pages

Racheal Milich
Mr. Lowe
American schools are under a pressure to serve the children of America now more than ever. On top of trying to create a learning curve to brighten our country’s future, while not leaving any children behind (with the 'No Child Left Behind Act'), the new stress of nutrition has been added to the undoubtedly long list of impossible tasks that United States public schools must accomplish. While there are several ways of implementing changes to the school-served lunches, changing the minds of parents who pack their children’s lunch can be a whole new daunting task. With the U.S. getting more and more parents working instead of staying home with children, it seems convenience and speed have put nutrition and health in the back seat. Even though the public is concerned with child obesity and children’s overall health and well-being, it is the same public that, when broken down into households, is the direct problem. Schools are now supposedly providing ‘healthier’ lunches at their institutes than parents are packing for their own children at home. Although schools are required to provide lunches that contribute one third of children’s daily nutritional value and offer options that include all five food groups, lunches from home have no guidelines to follow. Therefore, schools are now trying to rectify the problem by setting such requirements for packed lunches. However, a new debate has opened; how can a public school in a democratic nation require standards of any kind involving the freedom of being able to pack a lunch for your own child? Is this an attack on parent’s rights or an overdue slap across the face to American parents? Both sides of the debate are poised and ready to explain their side of the story. The argument at hand is, whether or not it is fair for schools to restrict packed lunches, or even ban them, for the nutritional well-being of the youth of our nation.
Public schools are being pressured to change their menus to suit the public’s view of healthy food because of the childhood obesity epidemic in the United States, and several other countries. While there are many changes, some of them are very minimal and some are simply erratic. Schools have even started counted pizza as a vegetable because of a provision in the healthier school meals bill that, “…allows one-eighth of a cup of tomato paste on a slice of pizza to count as one-half cup of vegetables, rather than one-eighth of a cup.” (Shah 11) American schools have several other new restrictions such as the guideline that, “…no more than 30 percent of calories may derive from fat, and less than 10 percent may come from saturated fat.” As well as being required to, “…provide one-third of the recommended daily allowances of protein, vitamins, and calories.” (Hellmich 2) While the public seems to support the healthy changes being made in schools there is one flaw in the plan: packed lunches. Parents who have their own busy and demanding...

Find Another Essay On The Packed Lunch Debate

School Cafeteria Food Essay

696 words - 3 pages life. In conclusion, there are various reasons why the schools should have an advanced lunch system and healthy, yummy lunches. There are more pros than cons to this! Although this topic would be debate-able, countless people would agree that there should be lunch systems and food superior to other junky ones. You wouldn’t like to eat undesirable food, so why should the students have to? Therefore, a more desirable lunch system and selection of foods would be an excellent idea that should be implemented in schools.

Off Campus Lunches Essay

979 words - 4 pages rest of their classes. Diana V. from Foothill High School claims, “When the school keeps students on campus it makes the students want to leave” (Should High Schools). Having an off-campus lunch period would allow for students to see their friends outside of class, especially friends they don’t get to see at all throughout the day. One may argue that this is not important because students get to see their friends during class, but class time is

Trip To Tennessee

1415 words - 6 pages packed into the cars when we drove up my Aunt's driveway. We started off for our two hour drive to the river. We were all relieved to finally arrive at our destination. We laid out all the blankets and ate our lunch. Then we spent the rest of the day swimming, and playing a game of baseball.By the end of the day we were all worn out. We loaded our car, said goodbye to our family, and headed back to the hotel to get some sleep.After a week long

Fishing with My Dad

1802 words - 7 pages father packed a deliciously enticing lunch, large enough to survive a couple of days in the wilderness.     We packed the fishing gear, maps, paddles, canoe seats, an anchor and rope, carefully placing our deliciously enticing lunch. Lifting the canoe up to the roof racks on the jeep was easy. After securing the canoe to the jeep with strong nylon rope, I checked the supply of bug dope. One of the major secrets of enjoying

Research Methodology: Qualitative Methods of Data Collection

2290 words - 9 pages in natural social settings (Patton, 2002). The researcher is able to note the participants’ body language as well as other situations and actions happening within the school cafeteria. The researcher will mainly focus on the lunch choices students are choosing and the comments they have regarding school lunch and packed lunch. The data can be recorded in several different ways such as audio, video, pictures, photos or field notes. As stated

Direct Marketing Plan for Campbell's Easy Heat Soup

1229 words - 5 pages quickly feeds and kisses him off to work. Hurriedly, she helps her children, Max and Betty, get ready for school and prepares their packed lunch: peanut butter sandwiches and chips. She races them to the local school. She rushes to her office at 8:55 am, which gives her barely 5 minutes to collect her thoughts before starting work.A half hour lunch break at 1:00 is a huge respite for her. She normally grabs a sandwich from the expensive cafeteria down

The Ineffective Priory Food Program

955 words - 4 pages face to face with food filled with grease and cheese, which led some students to skip lunch. Many of them even dumped their plates without bothering to taste the food. The meal program has to change and become healthier and more appealing. Priory food has changed over a period of four years. In sixth grade, hot food was the best part of my meal. Appetizing tortellini and ravioli was cooked fresh on Mondays with a warm white sauce that melted

Violence in Schools

1550 words - 6 pages contact the police immediately (Simmson, B. 1994 P. 239). It is important that authority figures take this seriously, but there is a chance that it can be taken too far. In a South Carolina school, an elementary school student was suspended after a faculty member found a butter knife packed with his lunch (his mother had actually packed the knife so the boy could slice his banana). Teachers and staff are becoming more aware, but should focus on

school policies

1015 words - 5 pages to the entire curriculum. The changes to the school under the policy could include, wheelchair access or ramps to be built or desks that can be altered to height, also disabled toilets would be installed. Also displays could be lowered. A pupil has a cake and chocolate bar with a bag of crisps in their lunchbox. The Packed lunch Policy outlines what is expected to be supplied for a pupil’s lunch. Pupils will be educated in healthy eating and

Mountain Dew

1154 words - 5 pages students say they like it because it tastes good and keeps them awake. They find this extremely sweet and caffeine-packed solution appealing and refreshing to taste. Senior Zach Bougner said he likes the citrus taste of Mountain Dew. "I used to drink a can every day before school in high school," said Bougner. "I drove with my left hand and drank with my right." Mountain Dew has the highest caffeine content of all the other pops. While Coca

Review of Free For All: Fixing School Food in America by Janet Poppendieck

1992 words - 8 pages showing the unintended consequences. One of my favorite parts of the book was getting to hear the stories her college students had to say about their school food. I was really able to relate to all of these stories, and often times felt as though they were talking about my school’s cafeteria. I’ll be honest, I was not a student who bought school lunch instead I always packed a lunch. I knew that the school lunches were not healthy, balanced, or

Similar Essays

Problem Solution Essay

775 words - 4 pages danger of theft in school. “Sometimes in a packed lunch line students try to steal other students stuff from their back pack,” said Dylan Robbins (from Central Valley High School). This quote describes that if the student has something really expensive in their backpack for example an iPhone and some other student ( steal) takes it. It would rally upset that student because he or she they might get in trouble from his or her their parents. This

Kids Across America Forced To Eat School Lunch

1749 words - 7 pages packed, they should not have to inhibit to these actions. ​Many parents of the students at these schools were outraged to find out that their healthy, homemade lunches were being replaced by the schools gluten-filled meals. According to James Joyner of Outside The Beltway a preschooler had gotten her bagged lunch taken away because an official at her school labeled it as “unhealthy”. The young girls lunch consisted of a turkey & cheese sandwich

The Case Against The Case Against Burger

1030 words - 5 pages beverage can be drunk as much as I want without paying more. I found that American eat raw veggies, together with different kinds of sauces. I found that American eat burger as staple food, for breakfast, lunch, dinner. Sharing little similarity with those in China, burger here is not delicate. Also, there is no debate on whether burger can be eaten or not. I start to observe and try to figure out why. It seems that burger is like the sidewalk in

Argument Against Open Campus Lunch Policy

1459 words - 6 pages One day, Jennifer and her two best friends, all of whom were juniors, took advantage of the open lunch policy and went out to lunch in her Toyota Camry. Since all of them loved Japanese food, they decided to go to Tempura House, which was only two minutes away from their school, Loyal High School. When the students ordered their meal, Jennifer, pretending to be over twenty-one, used her sister's driver's license to get Japanese beer, or sake