This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Pains Of Catastrophe In The Flooding Of Buffalo Creek, Virginia

2518 words - 11 pages

Pain in the wake of catastrophe can be as elusive as pain in illness. Kai Erikson argues that the events of catastrophe such as the flooding of Buffalo Creek Virginia cause a syndrome which includes pains such as numbness, reliving of the event, familial loss, loss of community as well as many others. The problem that arises from such a catastrophe is how to handle the pain suffered by its victims. Veena Das and Elaine Scarry argue that pain is unshareable but it also calls for attention. Through an extensive look into Kai Erikson’s piece on the events that took place in Buffalo Creek and the leading literature on pain it becomes clear that recognition and generalizability of victims pain and suffering is impossible to validate and because of this disaster relief efforts are greatly impaired.
Buffalo Creek is a coal mining town in the Appalachia of Virginia. The town revolves around coal mining. Generations upon generations have benefitted from the plethora of coal the mountains provided. However, along with the plethora of coal came an immense amount of coal by-products one of which being coal slurry. Coal companies had for years dumped the massive amounts of toxin filled water-coal slush down the sides of the mountains into nearby streams and mountainsides. In Buffalo Creek, the Buffalo Mining Company “used more than a half million gallons of water a day to clean the four thousand tons of coal it loaded onto railroads (Erikson, 25).” The company used the landscape of the mountains and the left over debris which was compacted together by bulldozers to create a man-made impoundment, or “dam,” as the town-people called it. This man-made structure held back a whopping 132 million gallons of toxic coal sludge. By creating a lake of this sludge, the company was able to reuse the water which had been somewhat filtered as the particles of debris settled to the bottom of the impoundment.
On the night of February 26, 1972 the coal mining community of Buffalo Creek would be drastically changed. Just before 8pm the heavy downpour of rain and the sheer amount of sludge being contained proved too much for the man-made wall of the impoundment. The dam wall gave way releasing the 132 million gallons of black coal water. On its way down the banks below the sludge picked up even more refuse and solids as it traveled. As the sludge hit the towns below it added cars, houses, and any other materials in its mighty wake. Entire families were swept under the immense black waves and many lives were taken in the flood. This disaster left behind only suffering for the people of Buffalo Creek.
Elaine Scarry argues that the main difficulty with pain is that it is nearly impossible to express. Scarry argues that the language of pain is that of analogies, “it is as if…” or “it is like.” She states that it has no referential content, and that it is because it takes no form that it is so hard to describe through language. In one testimonial that...

Find Another Essay On The Pains of Catastrophe in the Flooding of Buffalo Creek, Virginia

Construction of The Peace Bridge in Buffalo New York

1707 words - 7 pages Construction of The Peace Bridge in Buffalo New York What can construction do for an area? The construction of an office building may bring in a firm, corporation, or company. The construction of a sporting arena may keep a team where it currently is, or bring a new team to that area. For example, the construction of the HSBC Arena kept the Sabres in Buffalo. The construction of a casino may bring in tourists, or people who live in the

Buffalo The Great Animal Of The Plains

871 words - 3 pages Buffalo The Great Animal Of The PlainsBuffalos or bison are one of the beasts that used to freely roam the Wild West. They are one of the strongest and most powerful animals in North America. Millions once roamed the United States, Canada, and Mexico. Today they're far fewer and less common. Most buffaloes live in national parks and protected areas.What Do Buffaloes Look Like?Buffaloes are very large animals that sort of resemble a bull. They

The Expansion of Buffalo Wild Wings

1046 words - 4 pages Country Study This study will focus on the casual dining restaurant and sports bar Buffalo Wild Wings which primarily sells buffalo wings, and its potential international expansion into China, one of the worlds fastest growing major economies. In order to gain a better understanding of China, it is important to understand the environmental factors associated with the country. I will begin by discussing economic, geographic, and political-legal

The Joy and Pains of Dog Ownership

1177 words - 5 pages The Joy and Pains of Dog OwnershipThis essay will document the joy and love of dog ownership. Pets can be a great addition to your family. I have two beautiful American Pit Bull Terriers (Honey and Spot) and they are the joy of my life. When you ask the question should I get a dog? there are important things to consider before making the decision.The purchase price of a dog can vary greatly. It can range from free (from a friends litter), to

The Battle of Antietam Creek

772 words - 4 pages The Battle of Antietam Creek The Battle of Antietam Creek was a very bloody and important battle in the Civil war. The battle was fought by two different armies within the Union and the Confederacy, The Army of the Potomac (Union) and The Army of Northern Virginia (Confederate). Antietam Creek is located just to the east of the Potomac River in Maryland. The battle was fought on a hill just above the west bank of Antietam Creek. The Army of

Summarise the differences in impact between the flooding in Boscastle on the 16th August 2004 and the flooding in Bangladesh in the summer of 1998

728 words - 3 pages The impacts of the flooding in Bangladesh were much more severe than those in Boscastle due to scale and economic development. For the lower income country we use the example of Bangladesh. For a higher income area we use the example of Boscastle. One of the social differences between the impacts of the flooding in Boscastle and Bangladesh was the scale. An example of this is the difference in the death tolls. In Bangladesh 1,300 people died

The Pains of Withdrawal: An Analysis and Explanation of S.T. Coleridge's "The Pains of Sleep"

990 words - 4 pages The Pains of Withdrawal:An Analysis andExplication ofS.T. Coleridge's"The Pains of Sleep"In this poem, Coleridge reveals his reluctance to sleep and the reasons behind the reluctance. What he doesn't happen upon in his lyrical exploration of his guilt ridden dreams, is that the, what we would refer to as the depression he is experiencing, is most likely caused by his withdrawal from Opiates. Also exacerbating the symptoms is the fact that his is

The Carnage and the Catastrophe: The Japanese Militarization of Zen

1997 words - 8 pages In the modern day, a general Westerner usually pictures Buddhism as an idyllic peaceful religion that is withdrawn from society, but like all other religions Buddhism is interconnected within its own society. Buddhism also like many other religions, has an element of violence within itself and within different sects. Zen Buddhism specifically developed into a very violent religion during World War II and the wars that preceded it. Brian Daizen

The Pains of Anarchy in Lord of the Flies by William Golding

802 words - 4 pages Earlier this year, I became the government. Everyday, for the next few days, I woke up before the sun rose and filled my hotel room with light. In business professional attire, I would walk down the halls of the California State Capitol and into the Assembly Chambers. I experienced firsthand how the administration of our society works. There came a day, a cloudy day with rain falling momentarily, in which a protest was gathered in the streets

The Reason Behind the Flooding of Great Salt Lake

1374 words - 5 pages The Reason Behind the Flooding of Great Salt Lake In Refuge, Terry Tempest Williams blames a natural disaster—the overflowing of the Great Salt Lake in Utah--for the destruction of the place she loved most in the world, the Bear River Migratory Bird Refuge. What Williams attempts to explain, however, is that this disaster wasn’t really “natural” at all. Refuge is critiqued by some for being over-dramatized, and Terry Tempest Williams is

Urban Renewal: The History of City of Buffalo

2474 words - 10 pages After his completion of the Delaware Park and Parkway system with Calvert Vaux throughout Buffalo, New York, Frederick Law Olmsted declared Buffalo as “the best planned city, as to its streets, public places and grounds, in the United States, if not the world.” Inspired largely by the baroque styling of Paris, France, Olmstead wished to create a park within urban Buffalo but rather put the city of Buffalo in a park system. The parks were non

Similar Essays

Buffalo Creek And The Question Of Punitive Vs. Compensatory Damages

1695 words - 7 pages to pay punitive damages to Buffalo Creek disaster survivors. We will then look at current trends in American and French law on punitive damages. I-The example of the Buffalo Creek Disaster In February 1972, a dam which had been built in 1968 and which belonged to the Pittston Coal Company collapsed in Middle Fork Hollow, West Virginia. The dam was a coal-waste refuse pile which, along with two others, was intended to filter black waste water from

The Pains Of Gravity Essay

1159 words - 5 pages Gravity is a neutral force that causes things to fall toward the Earth and keeps structure in the universe. Many people think that the appealing experience of weightlessness or zero gravity comes at no price and are unaware of the many effects behind the pleasant sensation of floating. An astronaut’s job is to be in outer space and examine celestial bodies and extraterrestrial planets, but there are many health hazards that come with the job. An

The Pains Of Bullying In Adolescence

1216 words - 5 pages went to school in a new sweater my parents give me one day after Christmas break, which I wore it pretty much every day from the point I got it. It was probably was my one of my most favorite sweaters. It was comfortable, cosy, and actually, really not all that itchy as they are told to be. So I thought to myself, why not wear it to school? It doesn’t look that bad, maybe they’ll like it. So I decided to go with it on to school, granted this was

Engineering Processes In The Wake Of A Catastrophe

1407 words - 6 pages to change at their core in order to survive in this new environment.By any measure, the scope of the attacks was massive: thousands dead; thousands injured; the cost of destruction in the tens of billions of dollars; millions of square feet of office space destroyed; air travel disrupted around the world; an undetermined impact on the international economy; global political turmoil. Though the immediate effect was upon those in New York and