This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Role Of Feelings In Moral Reasoning

1023 words - 4 pages

The Role of Feelings in Moral Reasoning


The discussion of how feelings affect morality is quite prevalent in both David Hume and Immanuel Kant’s works. While each philosopher touches on the topic of feelings, both men differ in their outlook on the role feelings play in our moral lives. While David Hume, seemed to feel that the human mind was nothing more then a series of sensations and feelings, Immanuel Kant argued that there exists more to our minds than just these feelings.
David Hume based his whole ideology on a pleasure vs. pain scale. According to Hume, in order to make a moral decision, we must look at the given situation, and decide which solution would give us the highest level of pleasure. If the pleasure of said solution would outweigh the pain caused by it, then we would be achieving morality. He says that we need to do the greatest good for the greatest number of people.
Hume was an empiricist. He felt that knowledge began with the senses. Hume thought that a person could know nothing outside of experience. Experience is based on one’s subjective perceptions and never provides true knowledge of reality. For example, even the law of cause and effect was an unjustified belief. If a person drops an apple, he cannot be certain that it will fall to the ground. It is only possible, through past experience, that certain pairs of events, dropping an apple, and then the apple hitting the ground, have always accompanied one another.
Hume’s empiricism led him to the conclusion that we simply have feelings as to what is right and wrong. Reason would have nothing to do with morality, because we can not know what we have not experienced, and we can not reason what we do not know.
At first glance, we can see that Hume has a point. But his pleasure vs. pain scale is quite flawed in design. If we were to look at modern day examples of this pleasure vs. pain scale being utilized, we can easily see these flaws. Adolf Hitler is a prime example of this. When Hitler became dictator of Germany in 1933, he was aware that his country was in shambles. There was an economic depression resulting from World War I, and an absolute lack of national pride in his people. Hitler, and most of the German people, had a strong hatred of Jews. So in order to restore nationalism, Hitler decided that the pleasure of nationalism outweighed the pain of killing six million Jews, homosexuals, and gypsies. Even though his idea was able to bring back Germany’s economy and nationalism was stronger than ever; can we call this a moral decision? For years, Adolf Hitler has been regarded as an evil man, but on closer inspection, it seems that all he was doing was following David Hume’s ideology.
Immanuel Kant’s ideas completely and soundly dispute Hume’s thesis. Kant suggests that there exist three parts to the human mind,...

Find Another Essay On The Role of Feelings in Moral Reasoning

The Role of Scripture in Christian Moral Formation / Ethical Decision-Making Today

1440 words - 6 pages The question of what the place and role of Scripture is in Christian moral formation and ethical decision-making today is not one that I believe has a single answer. There is the perspective of what I might believe it should be versus what it actually is, as well as how in reality it plays out in different contexts. Those Christians who identify on the more liberal end of the spectrum may differ than those on the more conservative end, as well

The Reasoning for Shakespeare's Inclusion of the Witches in 'Macbeth'

1010 words - 4 pages The witches are vital elements in Shakespeare's 'Macbeth', not just to make it successful in Jacobean times, but also to add depth and atmosphere to the play. They are the root of disorder and are the trigger factor for the chaos that unfolds throughout the play. Shakespeare considered their role very carefully and included them for important reasons.In 1604, a year after he came to the English throne, James passed many laws on witchcraft

Reasoning In The Issues For The Costs Of Textbooks

746 words - 3 pages , the used low quality price of the same book would only be few dollars less than the actual text book, not even close to half of the price of the original. With the aim of reselling books, online book buyers buy textbooks and sometimes other types of books for a profit. Online book buyers operate year-round like online marketplaces to give students the opportunity to sell their books even when campus “buyback” periods are not in effect. Students

The Power of True Feelings in The King of Masks

1853 words - 8 pages " The world is a cold place but we can bring warmth to it". -- The quote from one the of characters Master Liang pinpoints a key theme in Wu Tianming 's movie The King of Masks, that is, the power of the true feelings in times of oppression and inequality. Wu Tianming is a representative of Chinese fourth generation filmmakers, who are known for a simple, natural and realistic way of storytelling as well as their thematic

Discuss Nationalism in the ERa of Good Feelings

546 words - 2 pages Nationalism, not sectionalism, was the driving force during the era of good feelings. Nationalism became the leading ideology of the American republic. While sectionalism proceeded in bringing the nation into turmoil and constant bickering among the politicians, as in the case with dealings leading to the Missouri compromise, nationalism was able to unite the nation into a headstrong body, led by an ever-increasing, more powerful central

The Role of Government on a Society's Moral Values

1189 words - 5 pages government, the idea of a government will simply fade, but in order to have this mutual relationship some moral values must be set up in between them. But who sets the baseline and standards for this moral values? Is the community a better source to create these values, or is it the government? There are some societies in which the government created this moral values, and there are others in which the community itself sets the moral values. In some

The Era of Good Feelings

851 words - 3 pages The Era of Good FeelingsThe time period between the year 1817 and 1824 is renown as the Era of Good Feelings. It is considered as a critical moment in American history, for it had improved the nation's feeling of nationalism and the transportation system that had existed. However, despite its name and the positive contributions that improved America, the Era of Good Feelings, overall, proved to be a time of major political, economic, and social

The Era of Good Feelings

851 words - 3 pages The Era of Good FeelingsThe time period between the year 1817 and 1824 is renown as the Era of Good Feelings. It is considered as a critical moment in American history, for it had improved the nation's feeling of nationalism and the transportation system that had existed. However, despite its name and the positive contributions that improved America, the Era of Good Feelings, overall, proved to be a time of major political, economic, and social

The Era of Good Feelings

1058 words - 5 pages this time was an “Era of Good Feelings”. Whereas Nationalism did emerge following the war of 1812, it was quickly squashed down and overshadowed by the growing sectionalism and tension in the United States. Tariffs, the National Bank, and slavery all played a role in further dividing the nation and securing that sectionalism would prevail. Even though the period was traditionally labeled as the “Era of Good Feelings”, it was anything but, thanks to the emergence of sectionalism and the division of the North and South.

The Era of Good Feelings - 1617 words

1617 words - 6 pages “The Era of Good Feelings”, is marked by the beginning of James Monroe’s first term as president and is said coincide with his presidency. With the end of the War of 1812, the people of America began to feel optimistic and for the first time unified as a nation. With America’s continued to growth and development, we see an increase in nationalism among the people that defines this time as “The Era of Good Feelings”. These years can also be seen

Evaluation of Feelings of Love in Relationships

1963 words - 8 pages . There are many complicated feelings they each have about this subject and to some degree it overshadows all of the aspects of their lives. In many ways they do not learn more about each other since the complications of race are all encompassing. It appears as if Raymond initially neglects considering other important qualities about Aurora. His first thoughts are about race, "Was she part Korean or Japanese? Maybe he was altogether wrong and

Similar Essays

Characters Of The Crucible In Relation To Kohlberg's Stages Of Moral Reasoning

1002 words - 4 pages Lawrence Kohlberg, a developmental psychologist, identified six developmental stages of human moral reasoning. The first stage that he recognized was the Punishment-Obedience Orientation, where the person’s concern is for avoiding punishment through obedience. The second stage was the Instrumental Relativist Orientation, where the person’s concern is to work in their self interest, and better their position. The third stage of moral

Kohlberg's Theory Of Moral Reasoning Essay

678 words - 3 pages . Joey will let Jay play with his ninja turtle only if Jay will let Joey ride his bike. It's basically looked upon as a win-win situation.Level II of Kohlberg's Moral reasoning process is know as the level of conventional morality. This level can be seen in a few of the older elementary students, some of the junior high students, and most of the high school students (Education and Psychology 89). Level II is divided into two stages; stage three, which

Moral Reasoning By The Great Philosophers

1642 words - 7 pages disequilibrium as playing a key role in pushing people into a higher stage of moral development ." On the contrary, Kohlberg's counterpart Carol Gilligan, took a different route about how she thinks moral reasoning in women is developed. According to Gilligan, who studied with Kohlberg, "women's moral development tends to follow a different path than men's." In that thought, Gilligan came up with her own vision of how women's development occurred. With that

The Feelings Of Greeks Essay

897 words - 4 pages anymore. As Joseph Bates says, “Emotion is one of the primary means to achieve this believability, this illusion of life, because it helps us know that characters really care about what happens in the world, that they truly have desires.” (Bates). Characters give humans something to hold and connect to in a lonely and harsh world. Works Cited Bates, Joseph. The Role of Emotion in Believable Agents. Pittsburgh: Carnegie Mellon University, 1994