This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Partition Of Indian Subcontinent: Crisis Of Identity And Uprooted Nationalities Resulting In Double Disaster For Pakistan

2127 words - 9 pages

The theory that Hindus and Muslims of the Indian subcontinent constituted two distinct nations and therefore needed separate states to pursue their respective destinies has proved to be wrong; supporting the view that ‘they (India and Pakistan) will bitterly regret the decision they are about to make’. 1
The problem with the ‘two-nation theory’ was that it treated the people of south Asia as two homogenous groups of Hindus and Muslims, making no allowances for the vast cultural, ethnic and linguistic differences that contribute to the colourful and vibrant mosaic that is the subcontinent. This theory sought to bind a Muslim in Karachi with one in Kolkata, and a Hindu in Lahore with one in Lucknow. The reality is very different. A Muslim Bengali had far more in common with a Hindu from Kolkata than a Punjabi Muslim, while a Pushtun from Durra is closer culturally and ethnically to his cousin in Jalalabad in Afganistan than he is to a Muslim in Chittagaon. The very real differences were glossed over by the over simplification on which the two-nation theory is based.
‘Leaving behind scores of thousands of dead and dying sacrificial offerings to freedom,’ 2 millions of Muslims and Hindus migrated in both directions in 1947. Millions of others choose to stay where they were, unable to leave whatever they have collected, ‘bit by bit through their own efforts.’3 The fact that even after partition India continued to have a significant Muslim population, weakened the concept on which Pakistan had been created. The creation of Pakistan has created a permanent problem for India. ‘Partition would not solve the communal problem but would make it a permanent feature of country.’4 The questionable premise was further eroded by the separation of East Pakistan in 1971, creating third state in the subcontinent, each with roughly 150 million Muslims. Detractors of the two-nation-theory point out that had India not been partitioned there would have been around 450 million Muslims living there, such a large population can hardly be termed a persecuted minority. Though emergence of Pakistan would not eliminate the problem of minorities, it would reduce the area of conflict between Hindus and Muslims and give each country an equal interest in the protection of the minorities within its borders.
The damning argument against Pakistan is that it took a community spread throughout the subcontinent, chopped it into several communities, gave it first one country and then two, and left the other dangling in mid air. People who once possessed the culture were left with neither a nation nor an idea of themselves as community. Pakistan was a double disaster for the Muslims in India: first they list their sense of the coherence and political strength in the Indian union along with their leadership and middle classes which migrated to Pakistan by thousands; secondly, they were forever damned in India for having voted for Pakistan and broken...

Find Another Essay On The Partition of Indian Subcontinent: Crisis of Identity and Uprooted Nationalities Resulting in Double Disaster for Pakistan

The partition of Africa Essay

860 words - 4 pages to meet the high demand for valuables such as gold and diamonds. They also desired a place to send criminals and the mentally challenged. Military and Naval bases were needed as well. As a result of various countries trying to colonize Africa many benefits followed suit, however, many problems arose as well. Along with the partition of Africa, came many complications. For example, weather patterns were different than they were in Europe so

Partition Between India and Pakistan Essay

1234 words - 5 pages to maintain its over-extended empire. If the sole purpose for creating Pakistan was truly to create a home for Muslims, it is confusing at to why so many stayed in India, rather than migrating to Pakistan. It should be noted that Pakistan, at the time of its independence, was a country created in two halves: one to the east of Indian, formerly known as East Bengal (now Bangladesh), and one to the west, known as Western Pakistan. These two halves

Identity of Indian Emigrants

1499 words - 6 pages Identity of Indian EmigrantsHugh Tinker's The Banyan Tree is an intensely researched study of the enormous complexities behind the emigration of the citizens of India, Pakistan and Bangladesh. It is a survey of the Indian communities in foreign countries, in a broader scope, mainly relying on the author's knowledge of the Indian diaspora, supported by secondary sources for data. Tinker describes two distinct impressions about the status of

Spain's Pre-War Years, speaks of why the years before the Spanish Civil War of 1936 so confusing and unstable, resulting in the need for a totalitarian leader?

2811 words - 11 pages generals against any of the governments in power, wether it be liberal or conservative.1The rise and quick fall of the first Spanish Republic signified the inability for liberals and conservatives to work together, and shortly after the monarchy was ejected from Spain, it was called back to rule again in 1875. Unfortunately, the collapse of Spain continued. Anarchism was flourishing at home, resulting in strikes, riots, and general terrorism


1735 words - 7 pages and every writer makes it his particular genre. World literature is that which is accepted and read in the whole world which deals with diversified issues and identity dilemma is one of them. Khair’s poems reveal his nostalgic feelings for his homeland and dilemaic feeling for his identity. Being an Indian Muslim who has migrated to a European country his whole identity has changed but his feelings and memories for his own identity and home are

Partition of India

2384 words - 10 pages uncompromising in his demand for a separate Muslim home land (12orjinnah). Lord Mountbatten convinced the Indian National Congress leader that achieving a united independent India was impossible and that the partition of India was necessary (12). Thus, on August 14th 1947 Pakistan was created and on August 15th 1947 India became independent. Despite Mountbatten’s skillful handling of the partition, he failed miserably in handling the issues surrounding

Could Violence Have Been Avoided in India's Rebellion of 1857 and Its Partition in 1947

999 words - 4 pages Alexa Montgomery History 104.05 4/11/2014 Reflection Paper #3 After watching Freedom from the documentary The Story of India, I learned a lot more about what India went through as a country in the 19th century. During this time period India was going through a lot of changes while they pushed for their freedom. The rebellion of 1857, gaining their independence, and the Partition of the South Asian subcontinent in 1947 all made up the story of

Gandhian Politics: The role of Khadi in shaping Indian national identity

3040 words - 12 pages poor.” It was hence a “nostalgic throw-back to a primitive and ‘back to nature’ philosophy.” As such, these views highlight that the negative economic meanings attached to khadi hindered the fostering of an Indian national identity because it seemed to justify British existence in India.Although from a purely economic perspective khadi indeed seems to have had a detrimental effect for the future of the Indian economy, one

The Double Minority in Song of Solomon

829 words - 3 pages Morrison's Song of Solomon, the African American female characters demonstrate the impact of having a double minority status. The female characters in Song of Solomon exhibit the difficulties for double minorities. Macon Dead and his family are a prominent, middle-class African American family. Although slavery has been over for a long time, the Dead's house has a feel of a prison. Macon seems to be the master of his house, and the women in his

Methodology for Evaluation of Mergers in the Indian Banking Sector

1463 words - 6 pages Pattern The share holding pattern that might be influenced in a merger deal has also been closely analyzed. Item Pre Merger Post Merger HDFC Group 28.78 25.74 Indian private equity fund 10 8.95 Indocean Financial holdings 4.99 4.46 Bennet, Coleman and company and NIL 7.78 group (times bank promoter) Public 56.23 53.07 Table 4 : Shareholding Pattern for HDFC- Times Bank . Itcan be noted that there has not been much of a dilution of ownership

The Polemics Of Identity And Crisis: Rabindranath Tagore’s Ideas Of Civilisation And Modernism

3427 words - 14 pages of his seminal works and will try to understand Tagore’s ideas of the notion of identity and how this identity formation leads to the development of a society based on mutual trust and brotherhood. His ideas of identity formation also deal with his study of gendered spaces that is vital for the status of equality to be maintained in society. 2 The novel The Home and the World (1919) opens up enormous possibilities to understand nationalism on

Similar Essays

Nationhood And Nationalities In Pakistan Essay

1994 words - 8 pages Nationhood and Nationalities in Pakistan Pakistan is a country inhabited by people belonging to many different nationalities. Hamza Alavi’s article focuses on the rising sub-national demands in the country and how the dominant factions have tried their best to suppress these movements. Official Nationalism: Benedict Anderson describes official nationalism as “A national identity that is not spontaneously generated from below, but is imposed

The Subcontinent Of India Essay

1316 words - 6 pages honor the birth of Mohandas Karamchand Ghandi, referred to as the Father of India for doing a great deal of peaceful protesting in order to gain India liberty from Britain. Since Ghandi was born on October 2nd, 1869, all of India celebrates Mahatma Gandhi Jayanti on the same day. It is lionized in every Indian state or Union territory as one of the nation’s official three Nation Holidays. Ghandi had a love for ‘truth’ and ‘duty’, which most

Gravity From Goce Over Indian Subcontinent: Understanding Its Potential For Identification Of Regional Tectono Geomorphic Structures

2387 words - 10 pages and filtering for regional-residual separation. For this, the generated netCDF database can be converted to standard MS Excel© worksheet via a netCDF-Excel module. This facilitates better transparency and flexibility to the data. The algorithms and commands to be used in GUT are mentioned in GUT tutorial (ESA, 2012) and Algorithm descriptions (ESA, 2011). 4. Regional Interpretations over Indian Subcontinent The free air anomaly map generated

The Crisis Of Identity Essay

1553 words - 6 pages desired identity further affect this rebellion. The more one is pressured to yield to a specific identity, as well as the degree of variation will determine the force of the rebellion. Specifically for Malcolm X, who grew up in a time when the expected social and desired self-identities of African Americans was at a maximum, rebellion could have only been expected. In actuality, Malcolm X’s rebellion continued further as he eventually rejected