This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Perfect Fit Essay

1119 words - 5 pages

Open adoption came into widespread practice in 1982 when the Independent Adoption Center opened its doors in California. However, it was extremely controversial, with several adoption professionals refusing to even share a panel stage with speakers on open adoption. (Independent Adoption Center) In April of the same year, Robert Borgman wrote an article titled “The Consequences of Open and Closed Adoption for Older Children”. As the title suggests, Borgman discusses the consequences of open and closed adoption for older children but he argues that open adoption is a more practical choice for children. Four years later, Patrick A. Curtis writes an article titled “ The Dialectics of Open ...view middle of the document...


The second article, written by Patrick A. Curtis, argues that closed and open adoption should be decided by the adoptive parents and biological parents together. He argues that infants cannot speak for themselves so the parents must make the decision. He includes information for all ends of the spectrum. When he includes all these perspectives, he shows that everybody is different intellectually, nevertheless supporting his thesis. His article effectively demonstrates the pathos key to persuasion. Even with the grand emotional appeal in this article, he also provides credibility and logic to his article. The article reads as an informative essay but his tone is persuasive. He is persuading the readers that open and closed adoption is dependent on the person, rather than research.
Both authors argue that permanence and continuity give the necessary foundation for adopted children. Borgman and Curtis both provide many references and expert opinions to solidify their case. Borgman’s argument is that permanence in the child’s life can be achieved by allowing the children to hold to their memories by keeping their past relationships and staying in touch with their biological family.
In Curtis’s article, his argument is more balanced and does not pick a side. He simply elaborates on both ends. It is as if his essay is informative but his word choice is persuasive. Curtis even wrote in the conclusion of his article, “results derived from future longitudinal research cannot be of help to is now.” This suggests that his evidence cannot be supported by research. The reader knows Borgman’s claim automatically. He presents closed adoption and the expert opinion on its success. Then, he passively refutes closed adoption. Following, he presents his case on why he believes open adoption is a more logical decision. He even provides insights into the adoption process to give the reader background information.
In both articles, they share a similar viewpoint; the child is the basis for making the decision between open or closed adoption. However, in Borgman’s argument is that if the child is still involved with the biological family, the process of being adopted by another family will not be as stressful and dramatic to the child. He recognizes the needs of the biological parents and the role of the adoptive parents. Curtis’s argument is that both adoptive parents and biological parents should decide which adoption is...

Find Another Essay On The Perfect Fit

hitler Essay

870 words - 4 pages Hitler wanted a “More Perfect Race”, But how was such a troubled man such as his-self, make such a “Perfect Race”, He went out his way of the mass murder of over six million Jewish people, and long with eleven million more who didn’t fit the perfect picture. Hitler’s idea of the “Perfect Race” was very simple, blonde hair and blue eyes. Hitler thought that blond hair and blue eyes meant power and leadership. Hitler thought people with blond

Fahrenheit 451 Essay

543 words - 2 pages that can fit into several different cultural archetypes.I think that Captain Beatty portrays the perfect villain archetype in the book, I will show you why with some quotes. "The whole house is going up."(38) This quote is when they go to the old woman's house to burn books. Captain Beatty decides they should burn the whole house down instead of just the books, he is also killing a woman. "Here we are."(110) This quote comes when they pull up to

Physically Fit

1540 words - 6 pages includes several testable factors of health which can be interpreted in various ways. Body or figure, resting heart rate, strength and endurance, and flexibility are each equally important aspects to consider when testing whether a person is physically fit. When it comes to one's body or figure, a lot of people believe that in order to be classified as physically fit, he or she must have the perfect body reminiscent of a model. This is not actually

The Secret Behind Cross-fit Professionals

1639 words - 7 pages stated are very important to one’s overall body health. About 73.5 % of people who participate in cross-fit end up with an injury that prevented them from going to work the next day or continuing their work out (Haley). Cross-fit workouts are always supposed to be supervised by a trained, certified professional. With that said, technique and form should be perfect at all times. Unfortunately, that is not always the case, which is why people

The Fine Art of Building the Perfect Sub Sandwich - Process Analysis Essay

960 words - 4 pages can be made, the bread must be cut to fit the proper servings. For a regular sized sub, which is around seven inches, one-half of a loaf of bread is required. The half cut loaf must then be cut horizontally, separating the loaf into a bottom and top layer. Now the sliced bread is ready to receive the proper amounts of cheese and meat.The next step in building the perfect sub is applying a layer of cheese. The cheese should be sliced into

Open Supplier Network

1443 words - 6 pages in the future. Recommendations The Open Supplier Network appears to best fit companies that already have a well-established ERP and are simply looking to improve exposure to available suppliers. Other products offered by Perfect Commerce do not appear to have the same clout in the marketplace, so it would be advisable for a new company, or an existing one without a current system, to start of with a more trusted name, such as SAP or

Perfection (persuasive essay)

1009 words - 4 pages Queen felt that she had to be better than everyone else, or at least the best a person can possibly be. In society today, many of us are replicas of the Evil Queen, putting on ourselves a heavy burden in order to obtain perfection, yet kill ourselves in the process as she did. Instead of trying to be absolutely perfect, why not simply try our best and know our limits, rather than die striving to achieve an impossible goal?What do you see every time

Industrial and Organizational Psychology

1487 words - 6 pages toward a fit between the people employed in the organization at any one time and the needs and expectations of that organization. The process is a lessthan- perfect one in the sense that it does not create a perfect fit between all employees, their work, and those with whom they work, but it does create a force toward fit. An important component of ASA theory is the gravitational hypothesis; this hypothesis posits that over time, people will

The Secrets of Cross-Fit

1390 words - 6 pages next day or continuing their work out. Cross-fit workouts are always supposed to be supervised by a trained, certified professional. With that said, technique and form should be perfect at all times. Unfortunately, that is not always the case, which is why people end up getting hurt. There is also a very high safety concern connecting cross-fit to rhabdomylosis, which is a condition associated with your muscles breaking down, and possible death

How does Shaw appropriate aspects of earlier texts? Cinderella, Pygmalion, Frankenstein?

588 words - 2 pages Greek legend, the King of Cyprus who fell in love with a beautiful ivory statue, Galatea. The more he looked upon her, the more deeply he fell in love with her, until he wished that she were more than a statue. Taking pity on him, the goddess; Aphrodite blew life into the statue and made it come alive as a beautiful woman. Shaw's parody is clear in the way he adapted this myth to his play in integrating the concept of a 'perfect state' for a

The Vitruvian Man. This is the famous artwork done by Leonardo da Vinci with the perfectly propotional man who is able to fit in a circle and a square

715 words - 3 pages on architecture. In the third volume of this ten book series he is talking about the temples and says that the temples should be based on the proportions of man because the human body is the model of perfection. He continues saying that a man can fit in the perfect geometric forms, a circle and a square with the arms and legs of the body extended.There were many attempts by artists and others during the Renaissance to make a man or figure that

Similar Essays

History Of The Perfect Number Essay

865 words - 4 pages number given in the form of 2^n-1(2^n-1) is perfect when 2^n-1 is a prime number. A number in this form is called a Mersenne number. Every perfect number and even number has been found to fit this formula. Where “n” is located in the formula, a very short list of prime numbers can take the place and they make up Mersenne’s prime numbers. Euclid was the discoverer of this theorem. In the 18th century Leonhard Euler showed that any number must be

The Perfect Number Essay

1092 words - 5 pages is “perfect” it has to fit into specific criteria. All perfect numbers are even, positive numbers. There are not any odd, perfect numbers known to man. If there is an odd, perfect number it is out of the range of human computation. Most and almost all perfect numbers end in the number six or the number eight. No perfect number will end in the number five or zero because prime numbers do not end in five or zero. Perfect numbers and prime numbers

I Want To Be Essay

627 words - 3 pages about their culture or religion or just anything that makes them different from everybody else. Most of the times people think they have to be perfect and once they see that their differences do not fit with what society says to be perfect they do not want to share them. What people do not realize is that they are being judged anyway and that everyone is unique which makes everyone different.In some cases, people want to be accepted. Most people

The Mistakes In Searching For Perfection

820 words - 4 pages girl living in the ‘perfect world’. She has found out that she doesn’t fit the image of perfect and never will, whether she be too tall, oversized, blonde, or talk to high pitched. The ‘perfect’ kids laugh at her, tease her, and treat her as if she has no feelings. This goes on for weeks and weeks. In time, she becomes depressed and lonely. Eventually, she can’t take it anymore. She starts therapy, but nothing helps her get back to the state of