This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Placebo Effect: Defendable Deception? Essay

2061 words - 9 pages

Buddha once said, “The mind is everything. What you think, you become.” The human brain possesses abilities and powers far beyond what one could ever imagine. Throughout the years, various studies have proven the brain’s capability to heal the body in a phenomenon known as the placebo effect. In short, this effect occurs when a doctor prescribes faux pills or gives fake operations to his patient, and the patient still recovers because of the immense power of the mind. Though employing the placebo effect means a doctor deceives his patient, this practice encounters much success; therefore, it should be allowed.
In the medical world, a stark difference between placebos and the term “placebo effect” exists. Substances, like sugar pills or fake injections, which have no medicinal effect, bear the name “pure placebos” (Saljoughian). “Impure placebos,” on the other hand, do elicit an effect for some illnesses, but not necessarily the illness for which the doctors prescribe them, for example: vitamins and antibiotics, which have a medicinal purpose (De Craen). When doctors use the terminology the placebo effect, they refer to “patient’s response to a treatment that is attributable to some reason other than the treatment’s pharmacologic effect,” (Niemi). In order to provoke the placebo effect, a doctor prescribes either a pure or impure placebo, without telling the patient. These different definitions hold significance because of the diversity of their meanings.
Widely used throughout history, placebos date as far back as Greek and Roman physicians (Saljoughian). The well-known Greek doctor Hippocrates stated that “many patients… have taken a turn for the worse…by the declaration… of what is present,” thus implying that placebos are acceptable ways to cure ailments (Saljoughian). In the year 1807, Thomas Jefferson spoke of the effect when he said that one of the greatest doctors he used “more bread pills, drops of colored water, and powders of hickory ashes, than all other medicines” (De Craen). Mr. Jefferson called the doctor who made this statement “one of the best physicians he knew,” showing that our former President and founding father supported this way of treatment as well (Waddington). Approximately one hundred years later, Dr. Richard Cabot, graduate of Harvard Medical School, told of his upbringing as a doctor, when learned “to use placebo, bread pills, water subcutaneously, and other devices,” (De Craen). In 1799, Dr. John Haygarth wrote the first documented recognition of the phenomenon now known as the placebo effect (Booth). Haygarth accidentally discovered the placebo effect when trying to make a profit by replacing a popular treatment of the time period, metal rods that supposedly relieved disease called “Perkins tractors,” with his own fake imitations (Waddington). Haygarth recorded astonishing results, which proved that the faux wooden tracts were just as effective as the metal ones (Saljoughian). In The Lanclet paper, T. C. Graves...

Find Another Essay On The Placebo Effect: Defendable Deception?

Mind over Matter Essay

2169 words - 9 pages since it involves deception on the part of the doctor. Besides some exceptions, deception is ethically wrong, in view of ethics from a Kantian, a Utilitarian or even a virtue ethicist viewpoint. The placebo effect has raised a question of magnitude: how can doctors be lying to their patients? How are they able to prescribe medicine to their patients without letting them know what they are taking

The Placebo Response and the Power of Unconscious Healing

1691 words - 7 pages evidence-based research use randomized placebo-controlled trials (RCTs) as the gold standard to test the efficacy of new treatments and clinical interventions. These clinical trials compare the effects of active treatment on a group of participants with that of a placebo group, whereby, neither the doctors nor the patients know what treatment is actually administered to a participant (‘double blinding’). The superior effect of a drug is often

Placebo Studies Should be Used in the Health Trials in Pharmacological Research

2350 words - 10 pages considered effective if statistically significant difference4 ,often called effect size, between two group is detected. Other way the medicine is regarded as ineffective and treatment based on this medicine is not better than treatment via placebo (Wampold 2005). As follows placebo controlled studies are important part of pharmacological research because it emphasizes real treatment effect of developing medicaments and prevents releasing ineffective


1107 words - 5 pages What if there was a new drug that’s making you high, but is just a sugar pill? What if you can get drunk with non-alcoholic drinks? What if there was a pill that can cure all your physical and emotional problems? This is known as the placebo effect. The placebo effect is a phenomenon in which some people experience a type of benefit after the use of a placebo. A placebo is any substance with no known medical effects; such as sterile water

Control in a Clinical Trial

1423 words - 6 pages The gold standard for a clinical trial design is the inclusion of a control. A control could be a placebo, active or no treatment. Clinicians use controls in order to give more power for their studies. A placebo control is a vehicle without the active ingredient. The main purpose of using a placebo in clinical trials is to differentiate the background noise from the actual effect of the treatment drug. Regulatory agencies prefer or favor trials

Placebos should be used on patients without their consent

651 words - 3 pages about that the use of placebos on patients without their consent was unethical, the placebo effect is due to two main mechanisms which are the expectancy and the conditioning. The expectancy is based on what patients are told about a certain product and thus telling patients that they are receiving an inert substance is ruining this aspect of the treatment and the effect of the placebo is therefore greatly reduced SOURCE PAGE 59. Also, the

Placebo effect

606 words - 2 pages The Placebo Effect The activity I chose to write about was on Dr. Walter A. Brown's article in Scientific American about placebos and their effect on the patients. His article described what a placebo is and if it is ethical for doctors to prescribe this "treatment" to their patients. Dr. Brown, who is a psychologist at Brown University, decided to do a study on the effects of a placebo. A placebo is any treatment or drug with no

Placebo Effect

1917 words - 8 pages chemical reactions in our body. The patient’s attitude, belief and understanding of the treatment is crucial for a positive outcome. This “altered perception” causes a “complex web of psychological effects surrounding medical treatment”.(Hall) So that this triggers analgesics in the body that occur naturally and cause a reduction in pain. It is called “placebo effect” when a real progress or pain relief is observed.(Kennedy institute) In terms of

Irritable Bowel Syndrome

900 words - 4 pages and more frequent need to go to toilet. Ondansetron showed a significant improvement comparing to placebo with −0.9, 95% CI −1.1 to −0.6, p<0.001 difference in the stool form. The worse the diarrhea at baseline the lower the effect of ondansetron (every 1 point baseline average stool form increase reduced effectiveness by 0.4 points, 95% CI 0.00 to 0.8, p=0.032). PPA showed average −0.9, 95% CI −1.2 to −0.6 stool form difference between

Antidepressant vs Placebo

1883 words - 8 pages Depression has grasped the lives of millions of Americans. There are those who claim these new cures, known as antidepressants, have helped many Americans escape from depression. The mind is what determines the outcome, the placebo effect is a way the mind heals itself without any medication. Placebo is a better and safer route to take for multiple reasons. First off, drugs can cause unpredictable symptoms. Secondly, there is the negative

Garcinia Cambogia Extract

1238 words - 5 pages the conclusion of the trial, both groups had lost weight but those taking the supplement achieved greater weight loss than those taking the placebo. Garcinia Cambogia did not have a notable effect on appetite. Trial 5 [5] – 54 overweight subjects • Dosage – 500mg GCE three times per day, low fat diet and at least 64oz water per day • Trial type – Randomized with placebo for eight weeks • Outcome – The placebo group lost an average of 4.2lb/person

Similar Essays

The Anti Placebo Effect? Essay

850 words - 3 pages The Anti-Placebo Effect? In my last web paper I struggled with the idea that Melatonin is supposed to make people sleepy. If anything I became more restless. Well, what is that all about? So, in this paper, I decided that I wanted to find out, what that was "about". If you pull it apart, you can tell that it has something to do with the preconceived ideas that we have running around in our heads. So then, I thought, well, that is the

The Placebo Effect: Ethical Or Unethical

874 words - 4 pages The use of placebo has been a breakthrough that has been used to advance pharmaceutical understanding for many physicians. A placebo is a sugar pill that is used to heal a person’s sickness by tricking the brain into thinking that the pill the person is taking is the medication that is healing the sickness. The physiological change that takes place in that person’s body is the effect of the placebo; It is called the placebo effect. If a person

Does The Placebo Effect Really Work?

2931 words - 12 pages “Does the placebo effect really work?” We’ve all been there, sitting in the waiting room surrounded by people coughing a spluttering all over you, surely making you worse rather than better. Then, half an hour after your appointment time, your name is called and you reach the safe (sanitary) haven of the doctor’s office. After a poke and a prod, and a rather uncomfortable “Aaaaahh!” with an ice-lolly stick half way down your throat and a light

Placebos Are A Valid Choice Essay

1440 words - 6 pages Placebos, (Latin for “I shall please”), have been around since medieval times to treat a variety of ailments. Currently, researchers are using them to examine what effects they will have on the general population, and physicians are prescribing them. Any alteration in a person’s condition derived after receiving a placebo is labeled a placebo effect. There is no debate as to whether the placebo effect is genuine; the dispute lies in what