The Politics Of Democracy Essay

929 words - 4 pages

A perfect government, as history has shown us, is next to impossible. While the degree of histories’ many governments is quantifiable, none can be defined as perfect. Whether it’s the size of the state, complexity of the time and issues, the rulers, the people, or unforeseeable matter-whatever it is-the human race has yet to find a perfect form of government. Consequently, while approaching this issue, the question is not which group is “right”? Rather which system more benevolently serves the people, since “democracy is the government of the people, by the people, for the people”. Despite participatory democracy being the most democratic of the two systems of government, representative democracy feasibility and efficiency, makes it the most formidable for Mars.
Participatory democracy, in its true form, is dismissed simply for its practicality of use. With a population of 11 million it would be impossible for everyone to join in on every legislation and law. However impossible it may be, representative democracy is true democracy. People have absolute equality and freedom. Furthermore, considering Marquis de Condorcet theory-which could be manifested into implying that the majority will be correct-participatory should lead to more utilitarian laws and legislations (pp 213). However, this argument faults in its application, because it assumes voting to be as simple as right or wrong. Yes we could use technology to help us vote and learn about politics but technology and moreover the media is the biggest problem for this system. The media would surpass the government as they could manipulate the people through information and advertising (not to say that this is not currently happening). In addition, who would set the agenda? This group could as well control the state in similar technics, worse if the public controlled the agenda it would take months for laws to be passed(IPT 92)
Participatory democracy is unattainable in the modern world; nevertheless representative democracy still retains many of the positive attributes participatory democracy. The representatives diminish the absolute equality, freedom and commitment by and for the people, but it ‘s efficiency and functionality makes it accessible. Like all forms of government it is not perfect but it works. Similar to participatory democracy, it can easily be tainted by the media and technology, but even worse, by one of the representatives. Yet, regardless what form of government is implemented, a leader or representative is necessary for efficiency and thus runs the risk of corrupting the system or the state. Even the most extreme form of participatory government would need some representative to exist in anything other than a small town.
Representative democracy is the winner due to practicality, but it can be improved, maybe by creating a hybrid of the two. For example, representatives would still be the backbone of the government, together with weekly or biweekly votes on...

Find Another Essay On The Politics of Democracy

The History of Democracy Essay

2152 words - 9 pages Democracy is a large component within governmental politics in the modern world we live in; some would argue that it is the only true form of “practiced politics” because democracy keeps in mind the interests of other individuals. The realm of democracy is where ideas are shared because not one being will ever possess the notion of an absolute truth. Democracy sanctioned for multiple ideas to be presented which diversified perspectives on a

Politics of the people Essay

1066 words - 4 pages Politics of the People touches on a multitude of topics discussed this term. The article brings to light the issues in South America. Specifically in the Amazon, surrounding big oil companies, the destruction of land and environment, and the destitution of the people of Ecuador and how the people and NGO's have taken action to fight it. In this territory of the Amazon according to Judith Kimerling, “the oil spills and contamination of this

the politics of spying

1537 words - 7 pages Introduction This essay will consider the politics of spying. It will discuss examples of espionage as well as its necessity. The paper will also debate upon whether spying is an invasion of privacy and there for rights, or not. The essay begins by defining espionage. It offers examples of espionage and how it has been used by different countries in the past as well as how it is increasingly used today on a global scale. The paper concludes by

The Politics of Obesity

1312 words - 5 pages The Politics of Obesity A March, 2005 headline on brought deeply disturbing news to the American public: “Report: Obesity will reverse life expectancy gains.” For the past 200 years, life expectancy steadily increased thanks to medical advances such as the discovery of antibiotics and vaccines, but this upward trend is no longer guaranteed. Childhood obesity has already reduced the average life expectancy between four and nine

Plato: The Grandfather of Democracy

1484 words - 6 pages Plato: The Grandfather of Democracy The history and the evolution of what we know as law, has developed out of many different viewpoints and philosophies. It has been the result of the operational and manipulative aspects of public affairs, and also seems to be the creation of different philosophical systems. There have been many that have been innovators in this area of thought from political leaders and dictators, to others who were

The Future of Global Democracy

3300 words - 13 pages monolithic group with the same values, outlooks and policy preferences. The Chinese political landscape becomes bipartisanship for the first time which leads to the development of democracy in the world’s largest country (Li, 2007). The growth of information technology inevitably makes the political process focased for the people. Political lobbying becomes transparent, factional politics become legitimate, and elections become more regular and

The Ambivalence of Direct Democracy

1044 words - 4 pages The California Constitution states, “All political power is inherent in the people. Government is instituted for their protection, security, and benefit, and they have the right to alter or reform it when the public good may require.” (CA Const. art. 2, sect. 1) Indeed, the age-old maxim that the government is for the people is evident in California’s Constitution, and the inception of direct democracy by the early 20th century Progressive

The cure for ills of Democracy is More Democracy

2850 words - 11 pages uses the democratic process for its own good.Works Cited:Capitalism Socialism and Democracy. Jaseph A. Schumpeter. Harper & Row Publishers. New York, Third EditionEduardo Galeano. Open Veins of Latin America. America Latina, Sixth EditionMark O. Dickerson and Thomas Flanagan. An introduction to Government and Politics. Thomson Nelson, Seventh EditionNorberto Bobbio. Which Socialism?; University of Minnesota PressRobert A. Dahl. Democracy and its Critics. Yale University Press,1989

Direct democracy -vs- representitive democracy. Contains the ideas of Rousseau

942 words - 4 pages The term Democracy is derived from two Greek words, demos, meaning people, and kratos, meaning rule. These two words form the word democracy which means rule by the people. Aristotle, and other ancient Greek political philosophers, used the phrase, `the governors are to be the governed', or as we have come to know it, `rule and be ruled in turn'.The two major types of democracy are Representative Democracy and Direct Democracy. Clearly the

The New Science of Politics

1039 words - 4 pages The New Science of Politics When discussing the new science of politics laid out in the Federalist papers, it is imperative to understand that proponents of the Constitution had various reasons for writing these papers, not the least of which was convincing critics that a strong central government that would not oppress but actually protect individual freedoms as well as encouraging the state of New York to agree to ratify the Constitution

Politics of the Cuban Embargo

1582 words - 7 pages foreign policy once dominated by the president. In American politics this is done by donating money to political candidates, contributing over $100,000 a year, on average, over ten years. The enactment of the Cuban Democracy Act is used an example to show how congress at the urging of the pro-embargo forces creates a policy initiative that is not in keeping with the presidents desire to back-burner Cuba policy. Further in this case, the

Similar Essays

Analysis Of Modern Greece's Politics: From Dictatorships To Democracy To The Eu

1735 words - 7 pages For centuries Greece has been seen as the birthplace of democracy. But until 1974, it was a country whose government had been instable for years. The definition of democracy has evolved over the years and now contains many components. Before democratization, Greece was being run by the Greek Colonel’s dictatorship. Due to lack of legitimacy, internal disagreements, high inflation and Turkish invasions, the dictatorship rule would come to an end

Canadian Democracy: A Lack Of Transparency And Accountability In Canadian Politics

1384 words - 6 pages , media, and opposition members in order to fulfill a personal or hidden agenda. The sheer manipulation that is possible by a Prime Minister completely undermines the transparency and accountability of true democracy. References Jackson, D., & Jackson, R.J. (2002). Canadian government in transition (3rd ed.). Toronto: Pearson Education Canada Inc. Kendall, D., Linden, R., & Murray, J. L. (2008). Sociology in our times: The essentials (4th Cdn ed.). Toronto: Nelson Education Inc. Martin, L. (2010). Harperland: The politics of control. Toronto, ON: Penguin Group.

The Art Of Democracy Essay

596 words - 3 pages Democracy was founded in the ancient Greece city-state of Athens. Athens went through a couple of systems of government before coming upon democracy. Democracy was created in order to satisfy the citizens of Athens and helped to revolutionalize politics in ancient Greece and, a couple of centuries later, the rest of the world. Because the revolutionary ideas of the Athenians had more solutions than problems, I believe that the government

The Government Of Democracy Essay

1635 words - 7 pages and religion. Often throughout history these civilizations and their ideologies have caused great wars that have created ripples that are still felt today. Democracy is the most common form of government today and is considered to be the best functioning government. Yet in the Middle East only Israel, Turkey, and Cyprus have a democratic government. The Arab world is lagging behind the majority of the countries in the world by not adopting