This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Power Of Words: Lawrence Summers' 2005 Speech On Inequality

1287 words - 5 pages

Words can be powerful, especially when those words are spoken by the president of a top university. In a 2005 speech by Lawrence Summers, he put forth the hypothesis that there are more men than women in the most high end positions due to a different set of measurable attributes, rather than it being caused by pervasive sexism or discrimination. To make it to the top of highly demanding fields, one has to be of exceptional quality and these are “people who are three and a half, four standard deviations above the mean in the one in 5,000, one in 10,000 class” (Summers, 2005). Summers is making the point that we should analyze the dataset that produces this type of result, rather than saying it’s all because of discrimination. Summers does not deny that discrimination exists, but he argues it cannot explain every difference. While there are more women in science and math based majors than ever before, fewer of them are in the top research positions that require the most demanding work and longest hours. Summers was strongly criticized and forced to resign as president of Harvard.
The forced resignation of Summers was unjust. It’s easy to say that Summers is being sexist in his remarks, because his comments can be construed as promoting inequality among the sexes. But he prefaced his marks by saying that he was making observations based on data and not trying to be political. Summers points to other examples, such as white men being underrepresented in the National Basketball Association (NBA) and Jews not having enough representation in farming and agriculture. Does that mean those groups are discriminated against, or is it that they don’t possess the characteristics, or even a natural desire, to excel in those fields?
Summers hypothesized there was a diverse dataset that could explain the reason for the disparity between men and women in the highest positions. First, the demands and rigor of long hours is not necessarily well suited to women who want to raise a family. Summers noted that the women in the highest positions are either unmarried or without children. Rising to the top of one’s field requires long hours and “near total commitments” in work. How many women are willing to sacrifice raising a family for a career? Historically, married men have been more likely to make that sacrifice. Summers acknowledges that that’s not how it should be, but that’s what it is. He also asks the question if it’s right that society should ask married women to choose family over career.
There is nothing in Summers remarks that appear sexist, and in fact, he appears sensitive to the difficulties of women. But he does indicate data that supports his hypothesis. The resignation of Summers was a result of a reaction in our society. The kind of reaction where politics and ideology win out over reason and data. Summers, at least, is willing to start a conversation about the role of women in high end positions.
A data point cited by Summers is the pattern in...

Find Another Essay On The Power of Words: Lawrence Summers' 2005 Speech on Inequality

The Power of Words Essay

944 words - 4 pages , or how are lives are controlled by fate, things happen for a reason and that just how things are meant to be. The concepts of good and evil are always unclear. This play is a perfect example of the great things Shakespeare accomplished, a dramatic yet tragic story line. This play gave me a better perspective not only of William Shakespeare, but the true power of words.

The Power of Words Essay

1212 words - 5 pages Joseph Addison once said, “Words, when well chosen, have so great a force in them that a description often gives us more lively ideas than the sight of things themselves (416).” I like this quote because it shows the importance of words and how powerful and influential they can be. Illustrations are used the same way, they hold the attention of readers, communicate content of information, and give insight of a particular event. There are eight

Through the Power of Words

2062 words - 9 pages In a small town of Holly Springs, Mississippi lives a young woman, Ida B. Wells, who uses the power of her words to make a change. Her parents, James and Elizabeth Wells, emphasized the importance of education and her father was involved in politics by becoming a member of Loyal League. Through these teachings an interest in politics and ambitious goals were born. Following the footsteps of her parents, Ida B. Wells, born as a slave, devoted

The Power of Words (based on great philosophers) - wright college humanities class - paper

658 words - 3 pages 1 Oksana Vnuk Humanities 123 Malgorzata Dzwonowski 02/07/2017 THE POWER OF WORDS Yehuda Berg said: “Words are singularly the most powerful force available to humanity. We can choose to use this force constructively with words of encouragement, or destructively using words of despair. Words have energy and power with the ability to help, to heal, to hinder, to hurt, to harm, to humiliate and to humble.” I absolutely believe that words are the

Analysis of Steve Job´s Commencement Speech on June 12th, 2005 at Stanford University

1476 words - 6 pages Executive speechwriter Anthony Trendl once wrote “A commencement speech, simply, is an opportunity to share your experience, values and advice. The precise form is up to you. This affords the speaker a platform to say amazing, unlimited things.” Steve Jobs’ Commencement address to the graduates at Stanford University was delivered on June 12th, 2005. Jobs is well known for being the CEO of Apple Computer, Pixar Animation Studios, and the

The Power of Words in Shakespeare's The Merchant of Venice

4097 words - 16 pages , metatheatricality imbues the story with tragic thematic undertones, and consequently a comic structure gives way to the tragic . It is in considering the play as a written work that such undertones seem to emerge most strongly. Ironically, the accumulation of words—the physical construction of lines within scenes—reveals a pattern in which words themselves emerge as the tragic threat. Speech and language become a precarious foundation upon which the very

The Power of Words in the Book Thief

1509 words - 6 pages an example of a character that is negatively impacted by the power of words. Body Paragraph 1 Topic Sentence 1 Liesel’s slow development of the power of words causes her to experience the negative effects of words and misery on many occasions throughout her lifetime. Point 1a Liesel is abandoned by her mother at a young age. Proof 1a “’Is my mother a communist?’ Staring. Straight ahead. ‘They were always asking her things, before I came

The Book Theif, and the Power of Words: A Review

991 words - 4 pages consequences or futile actions of each character during the all-consuming war. The Book Thief was also mesmerizing because of Zusak's powerful use of language throughout the story. This is a story about the heartbreaking or uplifting power of words during World War II, and this was effectively demonstrated by the author. In telling of Liesel's ability as a "Word Shaker", or one who understands the potential of words, he says "The words were on their

The Power of Sixteen Words Exposed in The Red Wheelbarrow

1045 words - 4 pages The Power of Sixteen Words Exposed in The Red Wheelbarrow            William Carlos Williams's poem "The Red Wheelbarrow" is extraordinary for what it accomplishes within its eight short lines. It is exactly one sentence long, sixteen words. Numbers like that wouldn't normally be important in the consideration of a poem's merit, but "The Red Wheelbarrow" begs to be noticed for its

The Power of Speech: Sir William Wallace

707 words - 3 pages of Scottish Independence against King Edward I of England. This speech uses a variety of different techniques and methods to motivate his viewers into accepting and believing that freedom is precious. Freedom in the 13th century was cherished greatly as it’s “the state of not being imprisoned or enslaved”. The power of this speech integrates from a mixture of his movement upon his horse. Instead of just standing in one spot, speaking to the

The Power of Words When Being Laid Off

755 words - 3 pages Life can be enjoyed or destroyed by the power of your tongue. There are heartfelt words of encouragement that brings hope and joy, or cruel offensive words that cut like a knife and destroy lives instantly. Words have been known to create peace, or cause wars. In fact, the choice of words one uses can mean the difference of generating serenity or anger. Take, for instance, the synonyms “be quiet” and “shut-up.” Even though both statements

Similar Essays

The Power Of Words Essay

739 words - 3 pages this in order to get on a personal level with the citizens. The way he embarks his speech contributes to the power of words by demonstrating that Antony can manipulate the Roman citizens into thinking he is one of them, affected, distressed by the idea that they have lost a friend. Antony finishes his speech by stating, “My heart,” is in the coffin beside Caesar, “and I must pause until,” I am there with him (III, II, 104-105). Antony speaks

The Power Of Words Essay

2217 words - 9 pages "The picture he had of the city was reduced to what she said of it, and finally it was her speech alone that could call up and protect that picture. 
 ruins.” — Abdekelkebir 
 Languages Words are very powerful things, they are not simply just letters written on a sheet of paper; they can inspire, motivate, and evoke

The Power Of Words Essay

2008 words - 8 pages The Power of Words Language has an irreplaceable role in our lives as mankind has grown to depend on it as an important way of acquiring Knowledge. But how valid is language as a way of knowing? French philosopher Jean-Paul Sartre answered this question with the quote: "Words are more treacherous and powerful than we think." Words do indeed lie. It is precisely because of its role as an indispensable tool of

The Power Of Words Essay 627 Words

627 words - 3 pages how they say it, instead of playing on the computer, checking my myspace I would study the thesaurus by putting random words and finding other uses for it, and other routes for the word. Having an extinctive vocabulary makes you experience more things that life has to offer, like being able to have a conversation with out anyone ridiculing you, and being able to converse to someone and actually understand them. To walk out side and not be