The Privilage By Journalists To Resist Criminal Process

1751 words - 8 pages

Both the first amendment and federal common law recognize a qualified privilege by journalists to resist criminal process. This brief first analyzes both the Supreme Court’s holding and reasoning in Branzburg v. Hayes, 408 U.S. 665 (1972), and its interpretation by lower circuits for the reporter’s privilege under the First Amendment. The brief then examines Fed. R. Evid. 501 and the evolution of federal common law related to the reporter’s privilege.
The Tenth Circuit reviews a district court’s order granting a motion to quash a grand jury subpoena for an abuse of discretion. See In re Grand Jury Proceedings, 616 F.3d 1186, 1201 (10th Cir. 2010). “A district court abuses its discretion when it commits an error of law.” United States v. Commanche, 577 F.3d 1261, 1266 (10th Cir. 2009). Whether the First Amendment or the federal common law recognizes a qualified privilege by journalists to resist criminal process is a pure question of law. The Tenth Circuit reviews purely legal questions de novo. See In re Grand Jury Subpoenas, 906 F.2d 1485, 1488 (10th Cir. 1990).
A. The District Court Correctly Recognized a Qualified Reporter’s Privilege Arising under the First Amendment That Protects Against Disclosure of Confidential Source Information in a Criminal Context.
The district court correctly held that, “based on Silkwood, . . . the Tenth Circuit would recognize a qualified privilege by journalists to resist criminal process.” R. at 3. This holding is consistent with both the Supreme Court’s reasoning in Branzburg and with the interpretation of Branzburg by a vast majority of circuits.
1. The Supreme Court, by way of Justice Powell’s concurring opinion in Branzburg, recognizes a constitutional, qualified reporter’s privilege for confidential sources in a criminal case.
The constitutional reporter’s privilege is rooted in Justice Powell’s decisive concurring opinion in Branzburg, 408 U.S. at 709 (Powell, J., concurring). In Branzburg, the Supreme Court upheld, in a 5-4 decision, contempt convictions for journalists based on their failure to testify before grand juries. As the fifth and deciding vote for the majority opinion, Justice Powell wrote a concurring opinion emphasizing the narrow basis of the majority holding. In so doing, Justice Powell clarified that the majority’s decision in Branzburg did not in any way preclude journalists from asserting in any case, civil or criminal, a “claim to privilege” that is rooted in “constitutional rights with respect to the gathering of news or in safeguarding [reporters’] sources.” Id. at 709. Justice Powell further stated that courts are required to judge such assertions of privilege “on [their] facts” and on “a case-by-case basis,” by balancing the “vital constitutional and societal interests” of freedom of the press, on the one hand, and the obligation of citizens...

Find Another Essay On The Privilage by Journalists to Resist Criminal Process

The Process to Heal Essay

1465 words - 6 pages writer, published her well known play “A Raisin in the Sun” in 1959. This play shares the challenges of racial segregation a family faces, but proves that in order to move past the judgment from society they must succeed to accept one another first. These stories relate because they both find a way in dealing with their grief by starting off in denial and resulting in acceptance. Everyone’s journey through grief is similar in many ways, but it is

Hard Rock Returns to Prison from the Hospital for the Criminal Insane by Etheridge Knight

728 words - 3 pages Hard Rock Returns to Prison from the Hospital for the Criminal Insane by Etheridge Knight In Etheridge Knight's poem "Hard Rock Returns to Prison from the Hospital for the Criminal Insane," he uses a fictional tale to describe the tyrannical elements of prisons while simultaneously conveying the oppression that those who defy authority face in society. Knight effectively utilizes imagery and analogies (implied or clearly stated) to

With regard to the role of bail in the criminal investigation process, evaluate how the 2013 NSW bail laws balance the rights of offenders, victims and society.

2070 words - 8 pages Legal StudiesThe role of bail laws Assessment Task 1 With regard to the role of bail in the criminal investigation process, evaluate how the 2013 NSW bail laws balance the rights of offenders, victims and society.In the criminal investigation process laws regarding the role of bail must balance the rights of offenders, victims and society. However, in the past the protection of society and the individual have often come into conflict with each

An Analysis of Various Hawthourne Short Stories. "Rapaccinni's Daughter, " "Young Goodman, " "The Birthmark,""Look up to heaven, and resist the wicked one"

796 words - 3 pages sexes equally.In Young Goodman Brown, Faith, the wife of Young Goodman Brown is a character who loses her faith and submits to the Devil. Hawthorne, in this case directly uses faith as the carrier of a flaw. That is, she does not contain enough self-control, or faith to refuse the calling of the Devil. Even with the emotional plea from her husband, "Look up to heaven, and resist the wicked one," (1590) Faith cannot resist the Devil's temptation

Improvements to the Selection Process

1185 words - 5 pages the guidelines as it lessens the probability of having adverse impact as with other evaluation tools which require ranking of scores or individuals independently of a standard. I selected this as my second behavior because the clerical test is required and it modifies the procedure to one that is formal and scored. It is also a good practice as it aids in the selection process by ruling out applicants who do not meet the standard score. The

The Process by Which Elders Give Advice to Minors About Dating

1200 words - 5 pages The Process by Which Elders Give Advice to Minors About Dating The concept of courtship and dating has been transformed in the face of youth culture and the generation gap that exists between the young people of today and their parents. With this change, there is also a shift with regard to the advice that elders give the youth on the topic of dating. Not only does the advice vary from generation to generation, but it also varies from

Essay regarding the public's Misperception of the criminal court system and due process of the law

1916 words - 8 pages coverage for the unwarranted increase of the public's awareness of crime versus actual crime. Politicians exploit the sensationalized crime as a way to relate to the public's perception that the increased crime needs special attention, so they manipulate the reports by the media. Although the television has been harmful in its' distortion of reality, it is useful in keeping people informed on criminal information and warnings when there is a


3320 words - 13 pages are funded by the government represent the people, and defence lawyers who are privately paid or paid by the government represent the accused. In his book, Ericson argues that through time in Canada the accused has played very little to no role in his own defence and depends entirely on his lawyer who makes his living in the criminal justice system. Because of this, he argues that the accused is more of a dependant than a defendant. For Ericson

Bind Touture Kill Killer: Serial Murder - Criminal justice: investigated the process of a case - Research Paper

1828 words - 8 pages , torturing and killing other human beings” (Criminal investigation, 2011) The way he carried out his crime would lead him to the name the BTK killer. According to an exclusive interview done by dateline NBC, Rader had a process for when he selected his victims, and the way he carried it out was to hi fulfilling a fantasy. Rader described his victims as “projects”, he would start by stalking them, saying he would “research them, call them, and find out

The process of admittance to the Trappists

878 words - 4 pages throughout the world. The process of admittance to the Trappists is a long, challenging journey.  A candidate begins the process by visiting the monastery for several months before entering the Observership period  The next step is to enter the Postulancy and later the Novitiate before taking temporary vows for three years as a Junior.  Finally, an individual takes permanent solemn vows to officially become a Trappist for life.  In all, this entire

Forensic Neuropsychology & The Criminal Law, by Martell Daniel

3583 words - 15 pages Before proceeding with the review of this article we should first be clear with the meaning of the term forensic neuropsychology. Forensic neuropsychology involves the evaluation of subjects by application of clinical neuropsychological assessment methods. This particular branch of forensic science plays a key role when it comes to evaluating the criminal competency of an individual to stand trial, insanity defences, diminished criminal

Similar Essays

De Skilling Effects On Journalists: Ic Ts And The Labour Process Of Taiwanese Newspaper Reporters

1087 words - 5 pages sector. (Campbell) Technology is also a growing field. The technological change has created a standard in which employees must be knowledgeable to adapt and keep up with new technology. With the increase in change there is a greater demand for more highly skilled workers thus they have to "keep learning new skills along with the development of technology" (Block).In the article "De-skilling Effects on Journalists: ICTs and the Labour Process of

Two Models Of The Criminal Process

545 words - 2 pages Individual rights are the rights guaranteed to citizens by due process. Due process is when life, liberty, or property cannot be deprived without due process of the law. Public order is crime control, where the rights of the victim surpass the due process laws. The two theories of due process and crime control have different views on enforcing the law. Due process deals with all people are innocent until proven guilty, and crime control is a

Why Is Privacy Probably One Of The Most Difficult Ethical Area For Journalists To Define?

2519 words - 10 pages journalists are recommended to seek legal advice when faced with an application under the legislation.The Freedom of Information Act was passed on November 30 2000.Anyone processing personal data must comply with the eight principles of good practice enforceable by an Information Commissioner.The Act stresses that "data must be:· fairly and lawfully processed;· processed for limited purposes;· adequate, relevant and not excessive

To Kill A Criminal: The Morals Behind The Classic To Kill A Mockingbird By Harper Lee

693 words - 3 pages my essay: To Kill a Criminal: The Morals Behind a Classic The problem: A disgusting creature by the name of Bob Ewell claimed that a colored man assaulted and raped his 19 year old daughter, bruising and hurting her badly. He demanded justice for this crime, which he pronounced was a hanging. The father of our main character, Atticus, was the defending lawyer in the case. He proved well and thoroughly that the young