This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Issue Of Ethical Torture Essay

2102 words - 8 pages

Given the choice, would you sacrifice one life to save two lives, ten, or would it have to be one hundred? What would you give to save your nation? These are questions that our government deals with every day. Many American citizens believe that government should be able to use every means possible to protect its citizens, yet their brothers disagree. “Every means possible” they believe to be too strong, too all-inclusive. These people recognize an ethical problem with this statement. The destruction and violation of human rights is exactly what we should stand against. Both views are well thought out. Both have weighed the costs. Therefore they both may lie partially in the right. However, it is the government’s job to protect and preserve its people and their values. Torture, in its base form, is unethical, but the use of humane methods of enhanced interrogation in the most dire circumstances protects the people and, through preserving a country’s people, their values.
Torture, unfortunately, has left its bloody fingerprints all over the past of mankind. Torture was used long before even the Inquisition of the Middle Ages used it in an attempt to squash the Reformation. Adolph Hitler took torture to a whole new level with his Holocaust, and still mankind faces this issue (ProQuest Staff). David Masci, author of Torture, states that the United Nations outlawed torture in multiple documents including the UN Convention Against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment. He also records that 2001’s State Department report recognized 100 countries on 5 continents that practiced state sanctioned torture. Stereotypically these countries have been African, Middle Eastern and Latin American, yet America is known to be one of them (ProQuest Staff). Although the U.S. does not use extensive methods such as tongue screws or electric shocks from head to groin, Masci states that the U.S. does use means such as sleep deprivation and verbal threats regarding the convict’s families. Masci goes on to quote an unnamed counterterrorism official as saying, “If you don't violate someone's human rights some of the time, you're probably not doing your job.” Torture is clearly a method of counterterrorism efforts that is frowned upon, but, even though we might wish that mankind was above such things, this issue of necessity should still be debated.
The United States government has had to deal with this issue constantly throughout the nation’s history and, more recently, since nine-eleven. There were some officials who believed that the use of torture in this instance was necessary to protect the lives of the American people and the name of the nation. Others clung to the virtues of humanity’s rights believing that torture was ineffective, immoral and inhumane (Masci). After the Death of Osama Bin Laden, many, including Brian Dickerson author of Bin Laden’s Death Doesn’t Validate Torture, were wondering by what means was such vital...

Find Another Essay On The Issue of Ethical Torture

The Benefits of Torture Essay

2220 words - 9 pages touches on the argument of one life versus hundreds or thousands, but he adds a new dimension to the equation with the idea of torture warrants. He argues that human nature can lead to unregulated abuse if not monitored meticulously. Thus it would be beneficial to the people and the government if there is some form of regulation or procedure involved through which the government might issue torture warrants to establish accountability. This would allow

The Art Of Torture Essay

1698 words - 7 pages The Art of Torture Going by the title of this paper you are probably asking yourself “How in God’s name can torture be seen as an art, were these people mentally ill?” well it was, but I talk about that later, let me tell you a little about the history of torture. Torture has been around since the times of Ancient Greece and is still around today, usually in the Mafia. Other than the mob, torture isn’t very common in our society

The Art Of Torture

1838 words - 7 pages Going by the title of this paper you are probably asking yourself "How in God's name can torture be seen as an art, were these people mentally ill?" well it was, but I talk about that later, let me tell you a little about the history of torture. Torture has been around since the times of Ancient Greece and is still around today, usually in the Mafia. Other than the mob, torture isn't very common in our society. Punishments aren't near as harsh

The Definition of Death: An Ethical Issue in Organ Donation

644 words - 3 pages According to The President’s Council on Bioethics, a group of individuals appointed by President George W. Bush to advise his administration on ethical issues related to advances in biomedical science and technology, the need for criteria to define death became important after the invention of the mechanical ventilator, an artificial support for patients who cannot breathe on their own due to injury or infirmity ( The President’s Council 2

Torture: The Abuse of Violence

985 words - 4 pages The legality of using torture as punishment has been historically controversial. Today, some people see torture as an efficient form of punishment; they believe it is especially necessary in the treatment of terrorist captives or prisoners for the purpose of extracting information. Some writers such as Michael Levin even intentionally make up fake scenarios to exaggerate the advantages of torture, claiming that it is danger free, low cost and

Ethical issue of Employer and Employee Rights

1222 words - 5 pages uncooperative with marketing. And then Nancy Smith resigned.From above review, we could know that it is an issue of Employer and Employee Rights. The key facts are the terms of Nancy Smith's employment and the ethical aspects of company's human resource. Right to work is right to freedom. Some questions are raised;1. Should the company have the right to terminate Nancy only if she refused to take the drug test?2. Should Nancy Smith have the

Ethical Issue Analysis - The Sandy Berger Scandal

1420 words - 6 pages During the past five years, the United States has experienced an abnormal number of business and engineering catastrophes and disasters. The causes have too often involved the lack of ethics, the violation of a code of ethics, or the violation of procedures. One seldom misses a day when a new or ongoing ethical problem is not being discussed in the news. One could wager that over fifty percent of the hard working Americans have been affected

The Ethical Issue of Foregoing Nutrition and Hydration in End-of-Life Care

2097 words - 8 pages The Ethical Issue of Foregoing Nutrition and Hydration in End-of-Life CareEnd-of-life care comprises a major aspect of the modern health care system, serving those who suffer from terminal illness, a medical condition that is irreversible, or imminent death. As the aging population in the United States continues to grow at a rapid pace, along with a rising awareness of better care for the seniors in the general public over the years, end-of-life

Limiting the Use of Torture in America

618 words - 2 pages Many social groups as well political groups have discussed the issue of torture. The elements and basic working of torture have many against it saying it is too cruel and violates America’s 8th amendment. But the question does arise what do we do if there is a suspect found hours before the crime is committed? Or what do we do to those that are known to have committed the severe crime (ie. a serial killer that has three victims hidden away

The Misuse of Torture in Rendition

1371 words - 5 pages ... and you're not. We can torture one, and save 7000. Those are ‘good’ statistics.” Under these circumstances where torturing one man can result in saving 7,000 people, this seems really good, but how can one be sure that the information told to us is 100% accurate? What if hostages learn to say anything in order to save their own life? In the movie, Rendition, it raises the issue of ends justifying the means, but it does not develop it

History of Torture and the Organizations that Attempt to End Torture Practices

663 words - 3 pages Torture is defined as the use of physical or mental pain, often to obtain information, to punish a person, or to control members of a group. Torture has been ongoing since the early ages of man. Many organizations attempt to stop the use of torture for any of the above mentioned reasons through conventions, protests and lobbying government officials to change laws. Such organizations as the Geneva Convention, the United Nations and Amnesty

Similar Essays

The Ethics Of Torture Essay

1439 words - 6 pages during the Spanish Inquisition, this notion of torture evolved to a means to extract withheld information. Today torture is unofficially used to extract information; however, it is officially illegal according to the United Nations and the Geneva Conventions. Nonetheless, the issue of legality and morality are different and separate issues; therefore, is the institution of torture ethical? In short, torture is not ethical in any circumstance

The Morality Of Torture Essay

1710 words - 7 pages regarding the legal basis of torture being justified. However, in my opinion looking at torture through a legal stance creates a skeptical outlook through a moral and financial standpoint. In my opinion, using the torture warrant method may present financial barriers. The cost of each warrant has to be a considerable factor when using a warrant to brutalize an individual. “Judges should have to issue a "torture warrant" in each case. Thus we

The Morality Of Torture Essay

1348 words - 5 pages The Morality of Torture The moral issue of torture is one that has come under scrutiny by many national and international organizations as of late. To talk about torture one must really understand what torture is. As taken from “1.a. Infliction or severe physical pain as a means of punishment or coercion. b. An instrument or a method for inflicting such pain. 2. Excruciating physical or mental pain; agony. 3. Something

The Ethics Of Torture Essay

1607 words - 6 pages seemingly black and white definition, the conditional “…other than pain or suffering incidental to lawful sanctions…” have led many to question what precisely this entails. In other words, what are the lawful sanctions that permit such acts? Are they ethically right? Where is the line drawn as torture in this respect? Several arguments are offered. To test what each ethical theory would say regarding the justification of such acts, I am